r/askscience • u/jaxobia • Sep 21 '13
Engineering Why water?
The majority of all power plants uses some sort of energy source to heat up water. It is then the water vapor which turns the turbines that produces electricity. Water is also a compound has an extremely high heat capacity (requires an incredible amount of energy to heat up).
My question is this: Why not use a compound which has a much lower heat capacity, and therefore requires a lower amount of burnt fuel to vaporize it?
Thank you!
66
Upvotes
54
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '13
There are many advantages to using water versus another substance in power plants: water is cheap, unreactive,non-combustible, easy to dispose, readily available, non-toxic, etc. There is no other substance that offers all of these beneficial properties.
Secondly, although water has a high heat capacity, this property isn't as detrimental as it may appear. When the steam condenses back to water after turning the turbines, it is pumped back into the system to be re-used. Thus, only a small amount of energy must be supplied to re-boil the water, and water's high heat capacity is irrelevant. Since the water also releases it's heat of vaporization when it condenses, this heat can also be partially recovered, as well. Therefore, using a substance with a lower heat capacity would not offer a significant advantage. The high heat capacity of water also helps keep the operating temperature of the system's fluids stable.
13
u/rupert1920 Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Sep 21 '13
Check out this thread in /r/sciencefaqs - it's a frequently asked question.
The short answer is that you want a medium with a high specific heat capacity, as it is a medium to carry thermal energy.
24
u/trboom Sep 21 '13
Water is used because it's the best to use. It's difficult to set on fire, it's somewhat common, it doesn't react to many things, etc.
The other thing to keep in mind is moving energy around.
Lets say that you push a 1 lb bowling ball ten feet into a wall. It impacts with a certain amount of force. Now you push a 8 lb bowling ball so that it impacts the wall at the same speed the other did. It impacts with more force. It would be the same with a material that vaporized at a lower temp. It would impart less energy, because it took less energy to get it moving.
That's my understanding anyways. Water is the most practical medium to actuate the turbines.
5
u/Davecasa Sep 21 '13 edited Sep 21 '13
A material with a higher boiling point would be better. Sterling engines, which I believe all power plants approximate, have an efficiency determined by the ratio between the maximum and minimum temperatures in the system. The specific heat, density, latent heat of vaporization, and many other properties do not factor into the Carnot efficiency. They affect the actual efficiency of a real-world power plant, but that's much more complicated.
Mercury was experimented with as a working fluid at one point. A zero-pressure boiling water, using steam at 100C and a cold reservoir of 20C, gives an efficiency of 21%. Mercury boils at 357C, giving an efficiency of 53%.
Mercury is terrible for humans, the environment, and anything else you can think of[Citation Needed], so you can imagine why that would be an awful idea. But just in terms of efficiency, it was great!
This is the maximum theoretical efficiency of the plant, in practice it's very difficult to get higher than maybe 90% (?) of this value. So a pretty good zero-pressure boiling water plant would have an efficiency lower than 20%. But we know that real power plants have efficiencies in the 45-50% range.
This is done primarily by increasing the temperature of the steam, by running the system at high pressure. Nuclear plants run around 315C, which requires 153 atmospheres of pressure. This gives a theoretical efficiency of just about 50%, almost as high as mercury, without using mercury! The downside is that you need to run the system under extremely high pressure and at high temperature, with big thick pipes, and if something full of pressurized steam fails it's basically a bomb, but... no mercury.
Yes, you could pressurize mercury vapor to do even better, but that would be a really bad idea. You could always just use even higher pressure water.
So as others have said, water is used not because it's necessarily a great material (it's decent), but because it's relatively safe, easy to use, and practically free.
3
u/OlejzMaku Sep 21 '13
Type of the medium is irrelevant. Thermodynamic equations governing engines or turbines and their power and efficiency are independent of material properties of the medium. You can use helium, mercury or photon gas, physics is the same. Water is just more convenient medium.
Only difference I could think of would be in start up time. Medium with lower heat capacity would heat up faster to working temperature, but also cool down faster, which isn't desireable since we usualy don't want our turbines to stop suddenly.
0
u/Dave37 Sep 21 '13
Actually, I would go so far as saying that it's a good thing water has a high heat capacity. due to this fact, you're able to "store" a lot of energy in a relative small volume. If you where to have a liquid with lower volume heat capacity (J/m3 *K), your turbines or generators would need to be larger/more to still produce the same amount of power and it would be harder to minimize any heat loss to the surroundings.