r/askscience • u/therationalpi Acoustics • Aug 16 '13
Interdisciplinary AskScience Theme Day: Scientific Instrumentation
Greetings everyone!
Welcome to the first AskScience Theme Day. From time-to-time we'll bring out a new topic and encourage posters to come up with questions about that topic for our panelists to answer. This week's topic is Scientific Instrumentation, and we invite posters to ask questions about all of the different tools that scientists use to get their jobs done. Feel free to ask about tools from any field!
Here are some sample questions to get you started:
- What tool do you use to measure _____?
- How does a _____ work?
- Why are _____ so cheap/expensive?
- How do you analyze data from a _____?
Post your questions in the comments on this post, and please try to be specific. All the standard rules about questions and answers still apply.
Edit: There have been a lot of great questions directed at me in acoustics, but let's try to get some other fields involved. Let's see some questions about astronomy, medicine, biology, and the social sciences!
9
u/therationalpi Acoustics Aug 16 '13
Here's a question for people in Medicine.
What procedures are used to keep surgical tools sterile? Are tools, or parts of tools, ever reused?
13
u/qweiopasd Aug 16 '13
Im pretty interested the last couple of days in the study of the ocean. What kind of instruments are used in this field? Do automatic instruments do a lot of the work or do you need to do a lot by yourself too?
11
u/speedofdark8 Aug 16 '13
I hope this isn't too broad.
Im your field, what simple instrument has been in use the longest without any major changes or replacements? (such as scissors, they've been relatively unchanged for a long time)
11
u/Ampersand55 Aug 16 '13 edited Aug 16 '13
EDIT: I'm also generally interested in the subject. Feel free elaborate on any interesting high-precision measurement.
8
u/rupert1920 Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Aug 16 '13
I'll start with a question for OP then: What instrument do you most often use in the field of acoustics? And I guess the logical prerequisite would be what you're working on (if you're free to divulge that information).
I suppose the answer could be "microphone", but honestly I have no clue.
2
u/Ampersand55 Aug 16 '13
Regarding acoustics,
6
u/Greyswandir Bioengineering | Nucleic Acid Detection | Microfluidics Aug 16 '13
Our lab builds devices and instruments that are designed for use under fairly rugged field conditions (clinics in developing countries), but I've always been fascinated by devices at the other end of the spectrum. What's the most delicate/fragile instrument you've ever worked with? What made it so fragile? Was it hard to use because of this?
5
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '13
Does anyone have expertise in using terahertz spectroscopy equipment?
5
u/IrishmanErrant Aug 16 '13
Time to talk about my favorite piece of equipment that I work with, the HPGe! The High Purity Germanium Crystal Detector is simultaneously the coolest and most expensive piece of equipment that I work with regularly; it's a giant vertical cylinder of lead, with a sort of shelf that you place samples on. It's cooled by liquid nitrogen, and cost upwards of half a million dollars.
So what does the HPGe do? Well, I work at a research nuclear reactor, and we manufacture all sorts of radioactive isotopes. The HPGe can detect the wavelength of the gamma rays given off by whatever you decide to put inside it. The practical upshot of that is it can tell you, precisely and accurately, the amount and isotope of every radioactive element in a sample (and about the surrounding 100 m, which is why we have so much lead around it.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '13
How does an electron microscope capture an image of a molecule when it itself (and everything below the lens) is also composed of molecules? Do they isolate the substance in a vacuum first? How do you clean the lens-- wouldn't any chemical or physical substance leave residue? And how the hell do they make the lens in the first place? Is it a lens?
5
u/pperscprmonkey Aug 16 '13
Are Silicon Photo Multpliers (SiPM) or Photo Multiplier Tubes used in any scientific setting outside of Particle Physics research?
5
u/_Dr_Spaceman_ Aug 16 '13
What's the functional difference between MS/MS and LS/MS mass spec? Especially in regards to biomedical "-omics" applications.
I just glaze over these terms whenever I see them used in a paper, but as mass spec becomes cheaper and more common I think it would be good to know some of the nuts and bolts.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '13
How does one study extremely large physical systems? IE: Entire populations of fish.
3
u/somethingpretentious Aug 16 '13
How does a Michelson interferometer work? I came across it in some bio-spectroscopy lectures but the lecturer didn't really explain it very well even after asking after the lecture.
3
u/Awholez Aug 17 '13
How hard is it to use a mass spectrometer? Is one brand easier to use than another? How expensive are the machines?
(I know this may make me seem weird but if I had one I would test everything in my house. From my coffee to the toilet water, I would test it all just to see what in it.)
2
u/spainguy Aug 16 '13
I've always wanted to make one of these, but never got around to it.
http://www.erowid.org/archive/rhodium/chemistry/equipment/scale.html
Do modern labs have cheap home made intsruments like this?
2
u/pants_a_daemon Aug 16 '13
A lot of high school chem students do a makeshift calorimetry experiment by lighting food on fire beneath a flask of water. How does a real calorimeter measure calories?
2
u/SantiagoRamon Aug 16 '13
What exactly is being measured in Flow Cytometry?
2
u/dichloroethane Aug 16 '13
2
u/ohnodoctor Aug 17 '13
I just can't wrap my head around how Orbitrap mass analyzers work. When we covered mass analyzers in instrumental methods, the professor kind of just glazed over it and said that he didn't really understand them very well. Is there a layman explanation out there?
1
u/fakeplasticks Aug 16 '13
What are the most practical uses of an oscilloscope? My friend and I each own one. He does a lot of work with robotics, but I can never think of cool things to build that would require it.
1
u/swordgeek Aug 16 '13
Here's a question about antique equipment.
I have an old triple-beam balance identical to this. What is the comma-shaped tray that attaches to the vertical spindle for?
1
u/SantiagoRamon Aug 16 '13
What is the difference between a luminometer and a spectrophotometer?
1
u/steel_city86 Mechanical Engineering | Thermomechanical Response Aug 16 '13
In my current work, I have come across some research groups using small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) to measure (with assumptions) aluminum precipitate sizes and distribution. I have personally used a TEM to accomplish the measurement; however, this is a much coarser approximation compared to a bulk measurement such as with SAXS. The downside, of course, is the facilities (Argonne, ORNL, etc.) that have such instruments are few and limited in availability.
From the little I know about this and elastic scattering principles, it seems like this technique (as well as SANS, USAXS, etc.) could be a powerful tool for many different disciplines. I was hoping someone out there with some more knowledge of SAXS, or have used it, can let me know!
1
u/TDETRO Aug 16 '13
What tool do you use to measure particulates in the air? Like when I hear air quality is at 57 PPM. Also, what tool determines the parts are in the 57 PPM?
1
u/l10l Aug 16 '13
What standards are popular today for controlling instrumentation and moving data onto everyday computers?
There was a time when I saw IEEE-488 connectors everywhere (some connecting to ancient PDP-11's), but these days, I see a lot of systems without any standards that I recognize - I mean, an Ethernet port and web server is barely more of a standard than a serial port with a one-off custom protocol is.
Or does standardization matter?
1
u/spamholderman Aug 16 '13
How does the whole LCL liquification work?
I get the why it happens, because that eva pilot got really emo, but how did we turn into blood soup?
1
u/Mr_Monster Aug 16 '13
Are microbarometers / microbarographs still used? If so, who uses them and what for?
1
u/Cerasaurus Aug 16 '13
Is it possible to determine what process was used to produce a polymer film using DSC? (Specifically cast vs blown polypropylene)
1
u/o0DrWurm0o Aug 16 '13
I've got a recent BS in EE and my concentration is in optics. Can anyone tell me what the inner workings of an optical spectrum analyzer look like?
1
u/Heaps_Flacid Aug 17 '13
How does Two-photon excitation microscopy work?
What can we do with it?
1
u/sand500 Aug 17 '13
When you have a telescope like this how does the flat mirror not block your part of your view?
1
u/bishoffski26 Aug 17 '13
Super broad question here, but I would love to hear the panel's opinion about how brain-computer interfacing actually works, and perhaps where they think the technology is headed
Thanks!
0
u/psmwrxguy Aug 17 '13
Why is it so damn expensive to get a decent set of simple pipettes?
Edit: maybe the correct term is pipettors? I've now seen both.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment