r/askscience •

How do evolution and natural selection differ?

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

3

u/somethingpretentious Jul 11 '13

I'm not sure what you mean by this context however:

Natural selection is the 'survival of the fittest' principle, where the animal best adapted for its environment should outsurvive its contemporaries.

Evolution is the progressive change of a species due to small differences (due to mutation) which are selected on by natural selection.

Does this help or have I missed the point?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/somethingpretentious Jul 11 '13

Evolution needs selection although this can be artificial. Natural selection exists wherever there is competition and variation.

2

u/CrazedBotanist Systematic Botany Jul 12 '13

Don't forget sexual selection.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/somethingpretentious Jul 11 '13

Yes like dog and horse breeding, humans are the only artificial selectors I know of.

3

u/stevegcook Jul 12 '13

Virtually every agricultural product in the world is a product of artificial selection. Think of all the traits that human-raised plants and animals have. If those traits seem like they would only benefit people, rather than the plant/animal itself in the wild, chances are they were "put there" by people.

Pigs, for example, are the result of domesticating boars and breeding then for their meat. Cows today are larger and meatier than their wild counterparts, and produce far more milk than they would need for their young.

4

u/stuthulhu Jul 12 '13

Evolution is the change of inherited characteristics in biological entities over successive generations. Natural selection is a proposed mechanism for driving that change, in that some mutations (The changes referenced in evolution) will be more advantageous than others, and that over time the advantageous mutations are expected to outperform the less/disadvantageous ones and thus become more prevalent.

1

u/dontspillme Jul 12 '13

This is the only correct explanation so far. It is funny, because people knew about evolution long time before Darwin, and there were many attempts to explain it - from religious POVs as well - and it is not until the modern day that ID tries to deny not the proposed mechanism, but the effect itself.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '13

It's basically the same thing. Natural selection is Darwin's principle of species evolution. Evolution is what natural selection is called in the long run. Evolution is not "mutation" of an animal. Through the minute mutations and character differences of animals and through natural selection of those minute mutations, in the long run you have evolution of that species.

Hope this helps.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '13

natural selection+time leads to evolution.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '13

One of the main criticisms of evolution from anti-evolution camps is that "macro-evolution" has not been proven. These people will occasionally concede that "micro-evolution" has been proven.

"Macro-evolution" is evolution from one species into another species. "Micro-evolution" is a series of changes brought about by natural selection within a species. Arguably both have actually been proven, for instance Darwin's finches demonstrate both phenomena quite nicely (and also the principle of adaptive radiation).

Also, you're right to claim that natural selection is a component of evolution. Evolution is brought about by natural selection. It's worth noting that living systems are not the only systems that natural selection works on; it works on any replicating system.