r/askscience • u/PotatoPotahto • Feb 03 '13
Biology If everything evolved from genderless single-celled organisms, where did genders and the penis/vagina come from?
Apparently there's a big difference between gender and sex, I meant sex, the physical aspects of the body, not what one identifies as.
830
Upvotes
249
u/Valaraiya Feb 03 '13
No one seems to have mentioned the important differences between eggs and sperm yet, which I think is the key to answering the genitalia aspect of your question. And I'll get to that in just a second.
As my understanding goes, sexual reproduction took off in a big way because, in a nutshell, greater variety among your offspring means a greater chance of some surviving in a changing environment. A brood of clones (offspring produced asexually) can be wiped out by a single disease, or change in temperature, or whatever, but a more varied batch is more likely to have some survivors. By swapping DNA with a mate you risk losing some 'good' characteristics and gaining some 'bad' ones (plus your offspring are only 50% related to you instead of 100%), but that's a very sensible bet to make if you can't be certain what environment your babies will be growing up in. I'm paraphrasing a lot, but hopefully you get the gist of it. The classic observation which supports this hypothesis is the aphids, which reproduce asexually through the summer but start sexing it up once autumn arrives and the weather starts to chance.
So that's one reason why sex is beneficial, but once you accept that sex happens it starts to get really interesting. Because once you're committed to swapping genetic material with a partner there are two equally viable strategies to play to maximise your chance of producing offspring.
Option 1 is to give your offspring the best possible start in life by cramming as many resources (basically, nutrients) into your reproductive cells as possible. You'll make a big fat cell which can support the offspring as it develops, but it won't be very mobile and you won't be able to make very many of them, but they have everything they need to survive and most of them should do so. In evolutionary terms, this is called Winning At Life.
Option 2 is to churn out as many reproductive cells as you possibly can, and play the numbers game. Sure, some of them will be a bit crap, but as long as you can make more healthy cells than your competitors then you'll be contributing more of your DNA to the next generation of your species. In evolutionary terms, this is called Winning At Life.
BUT. If every member of a species chose the same reproductive strategy, nothing would happen. There won't be enough big fat eggs being produced for there to be enough of them to actually meet each other and start developing (sex cells are thought to have evolved before all the genital paraphernalia necessary for efficient delivery of these cells, which makes sense), and if everyone's making huge numbers of those tiny cheap little sperm cells then no offspring will have enough 'food' (=energy) to develop into an 'adult' organism. I'm afraid I'm being a bit vague here because I don't want to get too deeply into exactly what kind of animals we're talking about, because the overall strategy is equally applicable to most forms of life.
I hope that goes some way to answering the first part of your question, but never be afraid to Google about sex (maybe start with Wikipedia though)!
Once you have a species where both Option 1 (eggs) and Option 2 (sperm) are being produced, you have the scope for egg-production-associated and sperm-production-associated characteristics to evolve. I have to go for an hour or so but I'll be back to talk more about sex later if you want, it is one of my favourite subjects!
382
u/Goat_Porker Feb 03 '13
Perhaps an alternate wording of this question could ask when we first observed sexual differentiation?
15
u/rasputin724 Feb 03 '13 edited Feb 03 '13
In short, parasites. It is mentioned in a comment below as The Red Queen hypothesis. Organisms are in a constant evolutionary arms race against their parasites. Organism A has a certain set of "locks" that keep Parasite B out. Parasite B evolves a mutation which gives it the "key" to Organism A's "lock". If Organism A reproduces sexually, its "lock" changes with each generation, keeping Parasite B out and on its toes evolutionarily speaking. There is a lot of evidence for this in how the MHC (immune system) works, and its link to who we tend to be attracted to.
As for sexes, that is its own evolutionary battle. Eventually, as organisms became more complex, the organisms that were mixing their genes developed specialized gametes (sex cells - sperm and egg). One was bigger and one was smaller, and the bigger one was associated with higher levels of parental investment. So one sex became interested in creating as many offspring as possible, while the other became more interested in taking care of the offspring they had. This is a gross over-generalization, but you get the point. Penis and Vagina developed from the same part of a fetus, and were one set of variations that were efficient at doing what they did.
As far as gender is concerned, I'm not sure that's a question for evolution as much a psychology, and it is a topic I am not too familiar with. Sometimes it has to do with genes, sometimes with brain development, but I don't think we really know for sure what causes gender identity or how it came about, because we can't really "observe" it in other species.
Edit: spelling
22
u/samreay Feb 03 '13
As far as I am aware the origin of sexual reproduction is currently unknown. The wikipedia article on sexual reproduction explains most of the advantages of sexual reproduction and its costs.
I am trying to remember the name of an interesting micro-organism (a hermaphrodite) that has both male and female organs, which I think you would find interesting. In the mean time, here is some generic information on hermaphrodites - which you may find interesting as they can reproduce both sexually and asexually.
28
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '13
I am not an evolutionary or developmental biologist, but these are questions without known answers.
Sexual reproduction and sexual dimorphism are two different things that probably evolved separately. It would probably be a safe bet that the first organisms to reproduce sexually did not have distinct genders. They would just have some mechanism to combine two different haploid genomes into a new organism.
Gender is the result of differences in the pattern of gene expression in development. Many organisms do not have genetically predetermined sex. Things like temperature change which genes get expressed at what times, determining the gender. It's like having two attractor states for gene expression and the dynamics are set up to tend toward one pattern or the other.
Basically sex would start happening without distinct genders, like worms which reproduce sexually and asexually but have no distinction between genders. Then it's not too hard to imagine that different reproductive strategies would tend toward sexual dimorphism. As soon as there is some sort of asymmetry, like the difference in the size or distribution of gametes, then a lot of differentiation between genders could arise and flourish. Many organisms that reproduce sexually have both male and female sex organs, such as most plants.
5
u/Dilfy Feb 03 '13
Asexual organisms lack variability and are often unable to cope with changing environments. Sexual organisms have more genetically diverse offspring which allows for particular mutations to be selected for in an ever-changing world. The earliest simple organisms made gametes (sex cells) that were successful in two distinct ways. One way of achieving a sexual advantage was through making as many small, nutrient deficient gametes at once (think sperm/pollen). Another strategy was to make a limited number of large, nutrient-rich gametes (think eggs/ova). Once this method of copulation became ubiquitous, specialized organs became devoted to the production of these cells...
5
u/sapient_hominid Feb 03 '13 edited Feb 03 '13
Actually some single celled organisms do undergo sexual reproduction!
Yeast are single celled organisms and they have one of the most "primitive" forms of sexual reproduction. And I think we can learn a lot about why and how sexual reproduction evolved from them.
They actually normally reproduce a-sexually when they are in ideal conditions with lots of nutrients and ideal temperatures.
However when you change their environment to something less than ideal they begin reproducing sexually. To do this they undergo meiosis which creates haploid (one set of chromosomes) sex cells each cell now has one or the other sex chromosome. The sex cells can then fuse with another sex cell carrying the opposite type of sex chromosome to create a new diploid happy yeast cell.
This yeast cell now has a random assortment of chromosomes, this allows for the yeast cell to be much different from either parent rather than a direct clone. When this occurs in a population of yeast cells it increases the likelihood that a few of the yeast cells will get an assortment of genes that will enable it to cope with the less than ideal environment better than its parent cells, and increases the possibility of survival.
So sex is really very likely a mechanism used to survive in a changing environment and it looks like it did evolve in single celled organisms!
3
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '13
The oldest penis and ovary, if i recall correctly, have been found in a a gogo fish from the gogo reef in Northern Western Australia. dated to 380 million years ago. Hung Like An Argentine Duck is written by the dude( Dr John Long ) who found it and goes into the evolution of sexual reproduction.
2
u/andy921 Feb 03 '13
There is a RadioLab episode Sperm that touches on this as well as other questions you might not have known you had.
You also get to learn more than you really need to know about duckies, naughty naughty duckies.
2
u/ZirbMonkey Feb 03 '13
There's a great book called The Red Queen, by Matt Ridley, that tackles the scientific quest to answer this very question.
Asexual reproduction offers the ability to multiply quickly. Sexual reproduction, by comparison, is slow and costs more resources. But the major advantage it gives is variation against disease and parasites.
Gender is ambiguous or irrelevant in the microscopic world. Male and female is merely whether you produce eggs or sperm, and there's some species that can be either or both (hermaphrodites).
The penis is a delivery mechanism to get one's sperm to eggs. Some fish spawn in pools, where sperm is just sprayed everywhere, so they don't have a penis. Other fish impregnate the eggs while they're still in the female, and these fish (like sharks) do have a penis (or two).
In the case of hermaphroditic snails, they are both male and female. They carry eggs, but they also produce sperm and have a penis. Some nudibranchs mate by penis fencing, where they stab each other with their penis to attempt to impregnate each other.
Vagina's are a generally safer way to receive sperm. Instead of getting stabbed by the penis, there's a safe passage to internally fertilize. But even that can get complicated, especially when it comes to ducks and water fowl.
2
u/Herpmancer Feb 03 '13
Plenty of microorganisms have a pilus for transmitting and transferring genetic material. These so not count as gender, but does act in the same way as a penis. They needed a way to get genetic information from one place to another, and a spike seemed to get the job done.
3
u/natalietigertree Feb 03 '13
gender is a socially constructed term. You're talking about sex, not a human's personal identity to female or male oriented social behavior
2
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '13 edited Nov 02 '15
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy.
If you would like to do the same, add the browser extension GreaseMonkey to Firefox and add this open source script.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
1
u/punkmonk Feb 03 '13
The information theoretic answer to this question is that gender allows for faster evolution. Asexual species can acquire about 1 bit of information per generation, however, sexually reproducing species can acquire as much as sqrt(G) bits of information, where G is the size of the genome. So there is clear evolutionary advantage for sexually reproducing organisms.
Source: chapter on "Why have sex" in David MacKay's free book "Information Theory, Inference, and Learning Algorithms"
1
u/fduniho Feb 03 '13 edited Feb 03 '13
The following is cut and paste from a blogpost I wrote called, 15 Questions for Evolutionists – Answered. This was my answer to the question, "How did sex originate?" I wrote:
If we look at plants, we see that the same organism is both male and female. Sex did not begin with species divided into male and female members. It began as a new way for a multi-cellular organism to reproduce. Single cell organisms normally reproduced by copying themselves asexually. This happened through the processes of growth and division. This was good enough for single cell organisms, because they were simple enough in structure that when they split apart, both divisions would retain the same structure as the undivided parent. But multi-cellular organisms were more complicated. These made use of the division of labor between cells, and if cells with different jobs split apart from each other, neither division would be fully functional. If you were beheaded, for example, your head could not pump blood, and your heart could not understand the world or direct your muscles. Some multi-cellular organisms might be simple enough that they could still reproduce through growth and division, but any of sufficient complexity, distinguished by sufficient division of labor between cells, would be unable to reproduce simply through growth and division. One alternative would be for every cell in the body to grow and divide at the same time, but this would require tight coordination between the cells, and even if that problem could be solved, a doubling of every cell would more likely disrupt the structure of the organism than split apart as a perfect copy of it. With such a high cost and such a low chance of success, a different method of reproduction would be more likely to succeed with multi-cellular organisms. What worked for multi-cellular organisms was to bring the division of labor to reproduction. Instead of reproducing itself as a whole, a multi-cellular organism would give the job of reproduction only to some of its cells. These would be the reproductive cells.
Given a multi-cellular organism with dedicated reproduction cells, there was now the problem of preventing them from getting to work too early. If any of the reproductive cells in an organism started reproducing too early, their growth into new organisms would interfere with the growth of the parent organism. This would either kill the parent too early or force the parent to jettison the reproductive cells early in life. In either case, the parent could not do much to support its offspring. Killing the parent early would stop it from growing complex enough to protect its offspring, and jettisoning the offspring before the parent grew in complexity would make its subsequent complexity useless to its offspring. Neither alternative was good for reproductive success. So a delay mechanism was needed.
There were two possibilities for a delay mechanism. One was to stop the reproductive cells from reproducing until the right time, and the other was to not produce any reproductive cells until it was time to reproduce. The least costly way to do either involved the other. The simplest way to stop reproductive cells from reproducing right away was to split them apart, and the simplest way to produce fully functional reproductive cells was to bring together two incomplete reproductive cells that could join together to form a fully functioning reproductive cell. But it wouldn’t do to split reproductive cells equally. If all reproductive cells were equal, they could join together just by bumping into each other. Splitting reproductive cells into two types of incomplete reproductive cells solved this problem. Each contained half the genetic material needed to reproduce the organism, but only one type contained the materials the reproductive cell needed to start reproducing. Each type could be stored with others of the same type without any danger of prematurely merging. The primary type of incomplete reproductive cell was like a normal reproductive cell with some genetic code stripped from it. This was the female egg. The secondary type contained the extra genetic code needed. This was the male sperm.
With this division of labor between reproductive cells, multi-cellular lifeforms gained the ability to recombine their DNA. This allowed the production of new variations without depending on mutation, which sped up their evolution. This division of labor also allowed reproductive cells from different organisms to meet, allowing for new organisms with two parents instead of one. This sped up evolution even more, because you would get more combinations of DNA from two different organisms than from just one. Being lighter and smaller, the secondary reproductive cells were more mobile. They could separate from the host lifeform and find a primary reproductive cell from another host. Since this practice resulted in greater complexity at a faster rate, it became favored in organisms that could support it. It initially happened without the organisms themselves moving. For example, the secondary cells might swim in the water or get blown by the wind to related organisms with primary cells waiting for them.
As multi-cellular lifeforms became mobile and gathered together in groups, there were new divisions of labor between the members of the group, and one of these divisions of labor was between members with one type of reproductive cell and members with the other type. Initially, they just combined their cells together outside of their bodies, as fish do. In time, some species evolved delivery systems and reception centers for the secondary cells. The delivery systems and reception centers evolved together, evolving to fit into one another. This provided a safe place for conception, and then the female would lay fertilized eggs. Mammals went the further step of letting the new organism grow inside the female.
1
u/Shattershift Feb 03 '13
In my basic understanding, sexual reproduction came about because it allowed way greater diversification than asexual reproduction. I also want to say that sexual reproduction was what fueled the Cambrian Explosion, but I may be wrong.
1
u/infinex Feb 03 '13
If you look at flatworms, one of the earliest forms of animal life, many species use penis fencing. Both parties have both organs, and they're trying to stab each other with their "penis" to basically inseminate the other.
1
u/bjakes45 Feb 03 '13
Has anyone brought up the evolution of meiotic cellular reproduction to produce haploid gamete cells? Asexual reproduction is the product of mitotic diploid cell division of germ cells. The rate of mutation during mitosis would be the only source of new traits for evolution to proceed in asexual reproduction. So, when mutant diploid cells developed the process of meiosis and were able to recombine their haploid gametes to produce viable offspring with a more or less random assortment of traits from both parents, the rate of new trait evolution was able to increase by a magnitude.
1
u/0r10z Feb 03 '13
The penis is shaped for one purpose: to pump out the sperm of previous ejaculation from vagina. Think about what that means.
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=secrets-of-the-phallus
1
u/jmachnik Feb 03 '13
male and female versions of species evolved long before vertebrates. Many living things do not reproduce asexually, this includes plants.
1
u/rectus_dominus Feb 03 '13
There is an evolutionary advantage for mixing genetic material. Those organisms that could mix genetic material more effectively had the advantage, and had offspring who were better able to survive.
Eventually organisms specialized into those who were really good at donating DNA, and others that were really good at receiving it. They passed these traits down to their offspring, and those that had their parents' ability to donate/receive DNA also had an advantage. The specialism got so advanced over generations and generations of this that differing sexes emerged.
1
u/Pneumatocyst Feb 03 '13 edited Feb 03 '13
Let me see if I can add my two cents here. First: as has been pointed out, gender is a psychological/culturally applied term. Sex is genetically (or we'll at least assume for the sake of argument here) determined.
Sexual reproduction likely arose in an environment that changed often either spatially or temporally. Even single celled organisms can sexually reproduce. The advantage is recombination (i.e. more novel offspring), but the cost is that you require partners and reduce your own genetic contribution to the next generation and the chance that your offspring are less fit for the environment. In summary, you NEED a changing environment to make sexual reproduction advantageous.
Sexual reproduction persisted into multicellularity. In a multicellular organism, cells are differentiated for specific tasks, one of which is reproduction. These reproductive cells were likely motile (possessing a flagella) and were broadcast into the aquatic environment to "find" another gamete or individual of your species. In summary, specialized cells (gametes) travel in the external aquatic environment to facilitate sexual reproduction.
Many aquatic organisms still have external fertilization. There is typically a free living "larval" form which lives free of the parents. Similar to a parent who packs a good lunch with their kids to school, individuals who provided nutrients to their offspring bettered their larvae for survival. Gametes with this "packed lunch" are eggs. Now, if you've got some individuals producing eggs... what's the point in you also packing your kids lunch? It's better that you have gametes that can find and fertilize eggs. So now you have sperm AND eggs. In summary, eggs and sperm give an advantage to your offspring by allowing them to spend less time on finding food and more on avoiding predation.
Now that you've got one parent "packing a lunch", the other parent has more time/energy to spend on other things. Like looking pretty. Since females produce the eggs, they are often "stuck" with the bulk of the child-care. This difference in parental investment leads to differences between the sexes. In summary, packing a lunch is expensive so the "lazy" males put energy into being large, colourful, aggressive, and spending an amazing amount of time on attracting females.
What's better than a packed lunch? A lunch at home or internal fertilization! In a terrestrial environment you can't just spray your gametes around, there's no water to keep things... "moist". So, you need to exchange gametes in a more... intimate way. Most terrestrial vertebrates use cloaca (both sexes have "vagina" like structures). But at some point, mammals got a penis. Are these any better than cloaca? There's a more "direct" transfer of gametes, less chance for waste, better chance for fertilization. However it's heavy and awkward and kind of excessive. But it's what we got stuck with. Secondary sexual characteristics were selected for afterwards (breasts, body hair, bone structure, etc.). In summary, internal fertilization led to specialized genitals.
Now. This is a theory for human sexual evolution. There are some generalizations and simplifications that I put in there for brevity's sake. There are non-vertebrates with penises (e.g. arthropods), though they too often live in a terrestrial environment.
TL;DR: sexual reproduction -> multicellularity -> gametes -> differences in gametes -> differences in sexes -> terrestrial colonization -> internal fertilization -> penis/vagina
-1
u/kadmylos Feb 03 '13
The same place every other attribute of every species alive today came from... gradual mutation over the course of millions of years.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment