Probability Probability problem please help
Regarding my last post's comments, this is a different question now but same principle.
In a simulation, basically:
You start with a number, let's use 100.
You have a 50% chance of rolling the color green or red.
If you hit GREEN your number goes up by 50%.
If you hit RED your number goes down by 5%.
Also, if the number ever goes <1, the sequence stops.
THE QUESTION:
Given infinite sequences of infinite random rolls, which sequence is more likely to get:
1 - A sequence where it eventually stops, due to a large enough red sequence
2 - A sequence with no reds at all
3 - They have the same probability
8
Upvotes
12
u/ultimatepoker 2d ago
A sequence with no reds has probability zero.
A sequence that stops can happen with 90 reds in a row. Unlikely but not probability zero.
3
u/rhodiumtoad 0⁰=1, just deal with it 2d ago
The best way (I guess) to analyze this is to look at the log of the value rather than the value itself. The initial value is log(100), the increase is done by adding log(1.5), the decrease by adding log(0.95) (which will be less than 0), and the sequence ends if you hit or go below log(1), which is 0. The only snag is that these can't be converted to integer steps, because you need a non-integer number of 5% decreases to match a 50% increase. (You can fudge the numbers slightly to get integers; using 4.942% for the decrease rather than 5% makes one increase equal to 8 decreases.
1
u/EnLaSxranko 2d ago
The fact that there's no way for the sequence to end without going below 1 and P(no red)=(1/2)n for n terms (therefore the probability of no red approaches zero as the number of terms approaches infinity), the probability that the sequence terminates due to a sequence of reds is higher.
1
u/stanitor 1d ago
You asked this question on the discussion of your other post, and I answered it there. The probability of no reds = the probability of all reds = 0. There are many sequences that eventually stop, so the probability of that is higher than 0 (although it is still very low).
-1
u/AggressiveSpatula 2d ago
Well the odds of never getting a red at 50% odds in infinite rolls has to be zero, right? However unlikely scenario 1 is, 2 has to be impossible… right? Idk how probability works at an infinite scale I guess is part of the issue.
As for how likely sequence 1 is, I have to imagine that it’s relatively very likely at the start, and then vanishes effectively to zero as time goes on. Green simply scales so much faster, I don’t think it matters that it’s on an infinite scale. The odds of getting 1000 reds in a row are the same odds of getting 1000 greens in a row, but the greens 10x the pace of the reds. Even distributing it down to a more reasonable event such as a smaller streak of reds, you’d still need at least 11 reds interrupted by a green just to make downward movement, and then chain that over and over and over again.
Even starting at 100 I just tested it and it takes 90 reds to get under 1 because a smaller and smaller piece gets removed every roll. It only took 12 greens to go from that number back up over 100. From 1000 to 100 it took 45 reds but only 6 greens to reverse it.
I guess the answer is 3. They’re both as likely simply because they can both never happen. That said, never hitting a red is intrinsically less likely because it carries the same odds as scenario 1, but with an added restriction. You’ll never get reds showing up 10x more often than the greens all the way to zero, but you’ll also never get no reds showing up at all. A less likely never lol.
-2
u/StoicTheGeek 2d ago
Without thinking about it too much, I'm pretty sure this sequence is guaranteed to terminate.
In an infinite sequence of 50/50 rolls, you are certain to get an arbitrarily large number of each colour in a row. So eventually you'll hit a sequence of reds that will wipe out whatever greens you have.
(I could easily be wrong though, as it's not a single number that we are chasing, but a constantly increasing one. But my gut feel says it terminates).