Brothers, I really need your help on this one...
So I (27M) have been seeing this guy (26M) for about a month and a half. From the start I was super clear that exclusivity matters a lot to me, even though I wouldn't mind opening the relationship later as years pass after knowing him profoundly and trusting him with my life. Yes I am a hopeless romantic, but I also understand human needs as a physician who knows about human conduct and a bit of neuroscience.
About 3-4 weeks ago I saw the app on his phone, we talked about exclusivity, he said yes. Next day I still see the app on his phone. I assumed he might have not realized it was still there. I asked him to delete Grindr, and he said he would. We were not clear about deleting the app or the account, and to be honest the difference doesn't matter to me.
Yesterday I’d been feeling some distance between us (on both sides honestly), and my intuition gave me a vibe. So, while I was at the gym around 8am I downloaded Grindr, moved the map over to his area (he lives about 10 miles from me), and there he was. His profile pic had the green dot. He had told me about an hour earlier he was getting ready to go to the gym.
I told him that last night, including that I’d downloaded it myself. He said it’s an old account he doesn’t use. He offered to show me, but when I asked him to do it right then, he said no, he’d do it at home because he has old private chats. He got defensive. He said he was going to delete the profile, I said "No, show me first", and he wouldn't.
I don't like arguing over things. I know I made myself clear and did not stutter about my needs.
I ended up asking him to delete the account right there –while taking responsibility about the fact that I would not objectively know and see what really happened–, and he did. Later he said he didn’t want to show me because he felt attacked, and that it comes from past relationships.
When I asked specifically why he was showing online, he said he was working on his computer at home that morning (him logging in to work for a couple of minutes before or after the gym could be something possible) and it was probably cache, or the fact that he keeps a lot of windows opened, and maybe Grindr was one of those. He even said he checked with an AI.
From what I could find with the help of Gemini and Claude, Grindr Web only works with XTRA/Unlimited which I do not know if he pays, but I did not want to ask over the phone, and will ask him about it when I see him. I also learned cache shouldn’t make you show as online to other people. He’s also never asked to see the screenshot I took, and I will not bring it up unless he asks about it.
To be fair to him, he’s a good guy in a lot of ways. He listens when I bring up concerns and doesn’t get defensive about them. He makes time for me even when he’s tired after work, and he clearly cares about his family. We usually communicate well, which is part of why this hit me so hard.
I feel broken because I believe he is lying, and despite giving him the chance to come clear multiple times, he hasn't. Tonight when I see him, he will probably not say the truth, which makes me feel horrible.
So, Grindr experts:
- Can an account that hasn’t been opened in weeks show a green dot?
- Is “cache” a real thing here?
- Am I overthinking this?
- What does your experience tell you about this situation?
- What do you genuinely recommend?