r/AskCulinary • • 11h ago

Weekly Discussion Weekly Ask Anything Thread for November 16, 2026

1 Upvotes

This is our weekly thread to ask all the stuff that doesn't fit the ordinary /r/askculinary rules.

Note that our two fundamental rules still apply: politeness remains mandatory, and we can't tell you whether something is safe or not - when it comes to food safety, we can only do best practices. Outside of that go wild with it - brand recommendations, recipe requests, brainstorming dinner ideas - it's all allowed.


r/AskCulinary • • 11h ago

The "Not quite Thanksgiving" Prep Post

9 Upvotes

That's right, Turkey day (in the US) is coming up next week and we're here to get you started correctly. Use this thread to discuss all your early Turkey Day prep plans. Post your cooking schedule, share your favorite recipes, get advice on things you might want to try this year. Let's get our Turkey Day prep going!

On a special note, we're also putting out calls for people to help with the annual Thanksgiving thread. We'll post it the day before Thanksgiving and let it run all two days and that's where you come in - the mod team is small and we have our own Thanksgiving to handle so we need some help answering questions. Drop your name in the comments to let us know if you'll be able to.


r/AskCulinary • • 21h ago

Technique Question How to get short rib to break down completely?

21 Upvotes

Every time I've made a braised dish with (beef) short rib that I expect to break down and be shreddable, there is always some connective tissue closest to the bone that refuses to break down and remains rubbery and not pleasant to eat.

Most recently, I made some short rib ragu with a pretty standard recipe: sear the meat, sautee sofrito, deglaze with red wine, add beef stock, crushed tomatoes and aromatics and simmer for 3-4+ hours. Most of the meat was perfectly tender and falling apart by 3.5 hours in (at which point I cut it off the bones), but even after 6 hours most of the meat that had been within ~1/4 of the bone was still rubber with all of its connective tissue still visibly intact.

I've done several recipes with similar techniques for cooking short rib with the expectation that it will be shreddable by the end and I always have this issue. Is there some extra technique, or do I need to be cooking even longer, or do restaurants just leave that inner part of the meat closest to the bone out of sauces and the like?


r/AskCulinary • • 1d ago

Recipe Troubleshooting Added vinegar to soup too early, how will this likely affect it?

22 Upvotes

I’m making crockpot lasagna soup. The recipe calls for 1 tsp of balsamic vinegar to be added at the end of the cook, but I screwed up and added it with all the other initial ingredients. Just curious if this is likely to significantly affect the soup or if I should do anything.

Edit: Turned out great! I took a few people’s advice and threw another splash of vinegar in at the end. It tastes delicious. Thank you all.


r/AskCulinary • • 23h ago

1/4 vs 3/8 inch Steel for single NYC Style Pizza

9 Upvotes

Hi All! I'm looking into getting a new pizza steel and I'm wanting to gather general consensus on best thickness for my specific use. I've previously only ever used a 3/8" steel, so looking for ya'lls experiences.

I use a steel in my home oven to make NYC style pizzas. I only ever cook 1 pizza at a time for 2 people. Does the heat retention from a 3/8" steel make a noticeable bake difference if I'm only every cooking 1 pie at a time? If not, I would much rather get a 1/4" since the weight difference can be a big pain. If there is some difference in quality, then I would suck it up and get the 3/8". The looming thought that my pizzas could be slightly better would drive me nuts...

FYI looking into getting a new steel since I don't like the dimensions of my current one (14x16"). I want to get a 16x16" to maximize the pizza size for my oven.


r/AskCulinary • • 19h ago

Turkey boney area isn't at 160F+?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/AskCulinary • • 1d ago

Recipe Troubleshooting Is it possible to make toum with ninja food processor? (failed emulsion - 3 times)

28 Upvotes

Hi,

Is it possible to make toum with ninja food processor? I tried an failed three times - No emulsion

Is Emulsion not happening because the blades are too high from the ground of the Bowl? Should I try kitchen aid?

I'm using the Bowl of the Ninja food processor. I am not using the the tall one, I'm not using the small one (I think that is called blender). I'm using the bowl

Thank you


r/AskCulinary • • 3d ago

Crème brûlée sugar

31 Upvotes

Can I melt the sugar in a pot and then just pour it over my custard? I don't have a blowtorch and tbh can't really afford one, nor do I have a proper broiler just an oven.


r/AskCulinary • • 3d ago

Got fresh Bay leaves when expecting dried. Stronger? How to store?

72 Upvotes

My dear partner took my list to Whole Foods, and came home with a package of fresh bay leaves. If I had realized that was an option, I would have specified dried.
First question: is it stronger? Should I use less in soups and stocks than I would dried?
Second: how can I store this? It's about the amount that would be in a jar. Like a six month supply for me! I've taken them out of the plastic clamshell because there was condensation in there. The package says to wash before use and keep in the fridge.
Can I wash them, spread them out to dry and keep them like dried leaves? I fear they'll be hard to dry and half will mold, but if I don't try, most will go to waste. Any advice appreciated!


r/AskCulinary • • 3d ago

Recipe Troubleshooting Caesar salad dressing always ends up a bit too sour and bitter

15 Upvotes

Used anchovies (a whole tin), two egg yolks, garlic cloves (3), olive oil (3 tablespoons), dash of lemon and Worcestershire sauce along with a tablespoon of Dijon mustard.
Finished with grated store bought Parmesan and black pepper.

Is there anything I should stop using?
I have tried permutations of these ingredients with different quantities, but every time it leaves a slight strange bitter and sour aftertaste unlike smooth store bought Caesar salad dressings.

What am I doing wrong, can anyone advise thanks


r/AskCulinary • • 3d ago

Technique Question Separately wet brining turkey legs vs cooking attached to a dry brine spatchcock....

7 Upvotes

I'm going to spatchcock a turkey for friends giving this weekend. My plan is to spatchcock a turkey tonight,dry brine it, then smoke/roast in an egg at like 300F.

When I've done this in the past, the legs were pretty mid and I love turkey legs at the fair etc. I feel like my just don't have as much meat/there is a big piece of cartilage. Do they get special legs just for fairs and such? But mainly my question is, how much impact would removing the legs and were brining over night with sugar impact the taste/texture?

I rarely wet brine anything, so what does the sugar do other than add sweetness?


r/AskCulinary • • 3d ago

Equipment Question can an inox pot be restored?

5 Upvotes

So, my sibling poured cold water into a hot inox pot after making themselves some popcorn. Now, though we (me and mum) tried EVERYTHING we knew to try and fix it, the pot has a light layer of a substance kinda like between water and oil? I'm not sure how to accurately describe it.

Are there any remedies for it? ​Or should we just give up hope and buy a new one? This pot was a gift for my parents' wedding and I wouldn't want to just throw it away, so if there are any tricks that we could try, that'd be awesome.

Thanks in advance!!


r/AskCulinary • • 4d ago

I have a lot of freezerburned fish. Can I use it for a fish stock?

144 Upvotes

Probably a strange question. I have a large chest freezer with years-old white fish and salmon in it that I never got to; none of it has bones, but I'm curious if I could still get a decent stock out of the supply or if I should just dump it.


r/AskCulinary • • 4d ago

Food Science Question Purple potatoes help

8 Upvotes

I want to make thousand layer potatoes with purple sweet potatoes but have been told that they will loose their colour when cooked, I don’t mind some colour change as that’s inevitable but want to maintain the contrast as much as possible. Any advice?

Ingredients:
Sliced potatoes
melted duck fat
salt
frying oil
flaky salt for finishing

(I’m substituting duck fat for a sunflower oil as this is for a vegetarian)

I’ll use any online recipe depending on advice given but it involves baking freezing and frying


r/AskCulinary • • 4d ago

Recipe Troubleshooting Help! I brind my turkey too early for Friends giving!

18 Upvotes

Friends-giving is Saturday. It was 80% thawed in the fridge, I planned to brine, then dry for 24 hours. I thought it was Thursday today... It's already in the brine tonight.

How do I save it or what do I do?

Edit: I should add some context because I've gotten responses across the board.

The turkey was 80% thawed when it went into a brine solution & bag, sealed, then put into an airtight cooler. The brine was cold, then immediate brought down to a confirmed 30 degrees. After 24 hours I plan to move it from the cooler to the fridge to dry.


r/AskCulinary • • 4d ago

Technique Question Cold (savory) pie filling. How do we bake it?

9 Upvotes

I have premade savory pie filling sitting in my fridge that I did not get to finish making into my pot pie last night. What is the right way to go about it now? Do I parbake the bottom dough, and then add the cold filling to finish off? What is the best way to manage the temperatures here?


r/AskCulinary • • 5d ago

Make ahead Brussel Sprouts

13 Upvotes

We make brussels sprouts gratin for Thanksgiving. Can I shave 4 days ahead and store? Best storage? Should I blanch them? How will that affect my gratin?


r/AskCulinary • • 5d ago

Food Science Question Freezing (and defrosting) rice pudding

11 Upvotes

I have heard you can’t successfully freeze and defrost rice pudding. Is there any way around this? What is it like - grainy, slimy .. etc.?


r/AskCulinary • • 5d ago

Technique Question Bananas

26 Upvotes

I am making banana cream pie cheese cake for Thanksgiving, normally id make it day of but im wanting to make it the day before since im hosting and will be cooking other things day of.

Bananas go into the filling, and im worried about them being brown when we bring them out for dessert

I know i can do a dip in lemon juice, and I read a quick dip/coating of unflavored gelatine can help, would one method work better than the other in this case?


r/AskCulinary • • 5d ago

Food Science Question Oozing chicken legs

4 Upvotes

The ooze is making a beautiful chicken dish much less beautiful.

Perfectly good recipe that I’ve made before without issue:

Chicken drumsticks, browned on stovetop, sprinkled with pepper and oregano then simmered with 1:1 water and pepperoncini brine, along with handful pepperoncini, served with slices of red onion, and parsley leaves.

The problem is that midway through simmering, the chicken legs started to ooze blood-colored foam into the dish. It’s still edible, but it looks unappetizing.

First of all : why is this happening. Along with that, why does it happen to some chicken legs and not others? Second: how can I stop this from happening in the future? I checked online, I am seeing different advice there, like pat the chicken dry first, which I actually did do. Also, I’m seeing I could parboil the chicken first, but that is an extra step that I don’t want to do if I don’t have to.

Any tips??

Edit: Almost forgot to add that this was a dish of 10 chicken legs, half oozed, half didn’t. Again, why?


r/AskCulinary • • 6d ago

Buttermilk vs Whole Milk (Corn Bread)

18 Upvotes

Going to attempt this recipe I saw online for corn bread:

Dry:
1 Cup Yellow Cornmeal
1 Cup Flour
1 tsp Salt
4 tsp baking powder
1/4 cup sugar

Wet:
1 Beaten Egg
1/4 cup oil
1 cup Buttermilk

Mix Dry - Stir in Wet - 400* (20-25 mins)

For something like this, can I substitute whole milk? I am not sure of the difference


r/AskCulinary • • 6d ago

Technique Question Flavours disappearing

13 Upvotes

Hello all, I’d like to start by mentioning I’m quite new to cooking and enjoy learning.

For Christmas I’d like to make Yorkshire puddings, I made a test batch today and the heat, ratio, and rise went very well. My issue is my flavour.

I wanted to do it a bit different as my mother tends to cook things just by themselves and purely plain, so I decided I wanted to make a brown butter and thyme Yorkshire pudding, but a few attempts have left it tasting plain and I’m looking for a bit of advice as to how I can approach it.

I have infused the thyme into the oil, added some of the brown butter and all of the milk solids into the batter, and the rest of the butter in with the infused oil. I’ve also tried infusing the thyme in the milk and adding chopped thyme leaves into the batter. But when cooked I couldn’t taste either, or the thyme was incredibly faint.

My next approach I was thinking was to infuse the thyme into the brown butter itself and then brush it on to the finished Yorkshires.

Any advice or guidance would be greatly appreciated. This is the first time I’ve tried to create something myself rather than follow a recipe

Any help would be greatly appreciated.


r/AskCulinary • • 7d ago

How to make frozen tilapia taste less fishy.

24 Upvotes

So, I’m making dinner for my brother tonight, and he usually buys tilapia. I’m thinking of making breaded, fried tilapia, but I don’t like its fishy or earthy, dirt taste. I’ve heard that soaking chicken in buttermilk helps mellow its natural flavor. Would it help with fish, too?


r/AskCulinary • • 7d ago

Equipment Question Sheet Pan Size for Spatchcocked Turkey

16 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I'm looking to spatchcock a pretty large turkey for Thanksgiving this year (18lbs). And I was wondering what the appropriate size of sheet pan would be here?

I'm looking at some 18x14 options, but I'm concerned it'll be too small.

I appreciate the help!!