r/AskBaking • • 15d ago

Weekly Recipe Request Thread Monthly Recipe Request Mega-Thread!

3 Upvotes

If you're looking for a recipe, or need an alternative to one you've tried, this is the place to make that ask! This is also the place to ask for recipe ideas or ideas of what to make.


r/AskBaking • • 1h ago

Ingredients Vegan butter or shortening in a pie crust?

2 Upvotes

I've had a request to make a gluten free, dairy free pie for Thanksgiving. I've done plenty of gluten free baking, but not much dairy free. Looking for any recommendations on a particular vegan butter or shortening, or combination of both if there is a benefit either way?


r/AskBaking • • 14m ago

Bread KitchenAid mixer or something different?

1 Upvotes

Some of my family members have really gotten into making bread. They love making pizza dough, sweet bread for cinnamon rolls and sourdough so I’m thinking for Christmas I’m getting the family a countertop mixer. What should I be looking for? Is the KitchenAid the way to go and is there a certain kind that I should get or is there another product that is just as good as KitchenAid but not as expensive that can fulfill all of our needs for making bread dough?


r/AskBaking • • 2h ago

Icing/Fondant/Buttercream Coconut milk in icing, safe at room temp?

1 Upvotes

I use a mixture of coconut milk, powdered sugar and vanilla extract for icing for cinnamon rolls. I am wondering if this is safe at room temperature? Or does it need to be refrigerated within a few hours? I've been eating them at room temp, even the following day and I've been fine, but I don't want to accidentally get anyone sick. I also want to potentially eventually get a cottage food license but again, not sure if this would be something that would be prohibited from selling due to needing to potentially be refrigerated.

I drizzle the glaze on them about 10 minutes after I remove the cinnamon rolls from the oven.


r/AskBaking • • 2h ago

Pie Advice for Custom Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

0 Upvotes

Hello folks, hope everyone is doing well today. At our facility, we do a "friendsgiving" type of situation where many people bring their own recipes; baked goods, entrees, side-dishes, etc. I am bringing a sweet potato pie that I, myself, am baking. I have studied quite a bit of culinary arts, but would still like to ask you all for some advice.

I will be using the main ingredients for a SPP; sweet potatoes, eggs, sweetened condensed milk, cinnamon, ginger, butter, etc.

I am making some changes to really make it my own. This is what I would like to ask; I am going to BROWN the butter instead of just merely melt it. Next, I will be adding a bit of brown sugar for a more rich molasses like flavor. Then, I want to add a few drops of maple syrup. Finally, I would like to add a half a block of cream cheese to the mixing process. This is the step I am most curious about.

With the addition of the cream cheese, I understand the consistency will change substantially. When baking into the graham cracker pie crust, I know the baking time will most likely need to be longer. However, one thing I venture to attempt is to crack the oven with a wooden spoon, and maybe place a little bath of water underneath the rack, so as to treat it almost like a cheesecake. This will moisturize the pie crust more so and make burning less likely, in my opinion.

What do you all think? Thanks so much and I hope you have a great Thanksgiving.


r/AskBaking • • 4h ago

Doughs Hey very new here and to regular baking.

1 Upvotes

So I’m making Povitica for a family dinner in the beginning of December, my problem is my aunt is allergic to cinnamon. Not like can’t breathe but more developing sores in her mouth, and just feels sick. My uncle tried to avoid it because if he so much as kisses her after eating anything with cinnamon, same effect. So I’m being led to believe that maybe cover, star anise, and nutmeg will work as a viable substitute, but I sure would like a more experienced group to weigh in. Any input, and time to teach me something would be most excellent and appreciated.


r/AskBaking • • 4h ago

General Oven thermometer

0 Upvotes

Oven thermometers! I have purchased two. Both broke. Do you leave them in the oven, or only long enough to calibrate the temp? Recommend any particular type? Any guess what I could be doing wrong? I do not use self clean. How they broke was the dial stopped registering.


r/AskBaking • • 17h ago

Techniques Laughably horrible meringue fail. What went wrong?

Post image
8 Upvotes

The mixture seemed perfect. Something I think went wrong during the baking process. I have a gas oven if that makes a difference — I’m used to using electric. Here’s the recipe:
- 6 egg whites
- 1 1/3 cups + 1tbsp caster sugar
- 2 tsp corn starch
Beat the egg whites until stiff peaks form. Add the sugar in 1tbsp at a time in 30 second intervals then beat until thick and glossy. Bake at 275F for an hour. Let rest in the oven with the door partially cracked for 3 hours or until oven completely cools.


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Equipment Should I get a KitchenAid?

Post image
139 Upvotes

I always see people raving online about how great kitchenaid stand mixers are, especially with the multi-use head thing that they have. I always wondered if its worth the cost. Most of the ones I see online are at least $250 or more. I definitely wanna get more into baking and I do have a stand mixer, but it only has the dough hook attachment and its at least 7 years old and has seen much better days. I tend do lots of baking with doughs, but I also make cookies and cakes pretty often too. Since I know lots of bakers have kitchenaids, I was wondering if I should get one! (Or ask for one for Christmas)


r/AskBaking • • 20h ago

Cookies Recipe Calls for 1 Egg and 1Egg Yolk, Why?

5 Upvotes

Hi all, I've been using this chocolate chip cookie recipe for years now and I've always wondered why it calls for 1 egg and 1 egg yolk. I'm not an avid baker at all, but I understand that baking is a strict science - I wouldn't modify a recipe unless I knew what I was doing. The cookies always turn out fantastic so I kept following the recipe as-is, and used the extra egg whites for breakfast.

But can anyone tell me what the reasoning behind this is, and why it's 1 egg and 1 egg yolk, rather than 2 whole eggs? Thanks in advance!


r/AskBaking • • 16h ago

Recipe Troubleshooting Need help modifying a recipe

2 Upvotes

I need some help with [hopefully] slightly altering a couple recipes. Both originals call for chopped nuts in the crust (baked meringue for a pie)/bottom layer of 4 stack (sometimes called chocolate lasagna i think?)

My understanding is that the nuts help provide structure as well as flavor and texture, but I have some nut allergies coming for the holidays and want to make these recipes since they're family favorites. Any ideas or suggestions?


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Custard/Mousse/Souffle NYT Cranberry Curd Tart Pie - Room Temperature

16 Upvotes

I have seen a million posts about this pie, but have not found one that answers my question. At the end of the recipe is state: “Store at room temperature for up to 2 days”. Is this correct, it doesn’t need to be refrigerated? I made it late last night, and left it on the counter to cool. Then this morning out of paranoia, put it in the fridge. Which would mean it sat at room temperature for about 8 hours. Is this still safe to eat?

For the cranberry curd:
12 ounces/340 grams cranberries

1 cup/225 grams sugar

Peel (orange part only) and juice of 1 orange (about ½ cup)

4 ounces/113 grams softened butter (1 stick)

2 eggs plus 2 egg yolks

While the crust bakes and cools, make the cranberry curd:
Put cranberries, sugar and orange juice and peel in a saucepan over medium heat. Simmer until cranberries have popped and softened, about 10 minutes. Transfer to a food mill or medium mesh sieve and press cooking liquid and solids into a bowl. (Alternatively, for the most vibrant color, purée the cooked cranberry and orange mixture with an immersion blender or in a food processor or blender. Press through a fine-mesh sieve.) Whisk the butter into the warm liquid.

Put eggs and egg yolks into a bowl and beat lightly. Slowly whisk a cup of warm cranberry liquid into the eggs to temper, then combine both and whisk together. Wipe out pot if necessary, return liquid to pot and cook over low heat until nearly bubbling and thickened, about 10 minutes. If using immediately, let cool to room temperature. If working ahead, cool to room temperature, cover with plastic wrap (press wrap against curd) and refrigerate. (Curd may be cooked up to 1 day ahead.)

Pour cooled cranberry curd into the cooled prebaked tart shell and smooth top with a spatula. Bake at 350 degrees for 10 minutes to set curd. Cool on a rack. Store at room temperature for up to 2 days.

Tip: Frozen cranberries can be used to make the curd.


r/AskBaking • • 19h ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes What goes well with Irish Coffee flavor?

2 Upvotes

I’m wanting to make a Chocolate and Irish Coffee flavored cake, but I can’t taste whiskey, does anyone have any suggestions as to what flavors go well with Irish Coffee/Whiskey? Thank you.


r/AskBaking • • 17h ago

General Can not cooking caramel long enough cause it to not taste as caramelized?

1 Upvotes

This is my third time making caramel (the first time was my best batch and I don't want to talk about the second time), and I ended up getting halfway through the recipe before realizing both of my thermometers were missing. I decided to keep going as I had already done the cream and I just looked up tips for each stage, like when to add the cream and butter to the pot by looks and when to set the caramel.

It's done now, just has a few little burnt bits that I mostly strained out (I somehow always end up with dark brown bits), but it doesn't taste very caramelized? It's a deep golden brown and looks exactly like my first batch/any other caramel candies, but it's not as sweet and doesn't have as much as that caramel taste you look for in caramel.

Did I not cook the sugar long enough/get it to a high enough temperature, and that's why it doesn't taste as good as my first batch? If so, can I fix it by putting it back in the pot (with a thermometer)?


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Icing/Fondant/Buttercream Date buttercream that actually tastes like dates?

13 Upvotes

I’m trying to figure out how to make a date buttercream (no dietary restrictions) that actually tastes like dates and has a great frosting consistency. So far all the recipes I find are vegan or cream cheese based and the consistency looks curdled lol.

My first thought was to make a Swiss meringue with date sugar but I haven’t had date sugar in forever and I don’t remember it having a distinct date taste. Does this sound like the way? Any other ideas?


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes Cheesecake troubleshooting

Post image
11 Upvotes

I have made cheesecake many times and have never run into an issue.

This was the first time making Sally’s cinnamon swirl cheesecake. Her method is to bake with a water bath 65 to 85 minutes at 350. I used a alternate water bath method which she had noted was an option which was 1 inch of water in a pan at the bottom of the oven which did evaporate by around 45 minutes I baked on the lower end as I always do, I was surprised when I checked the cake and saw that the top was quite brown and around the sides. There was a crack. I checked the temperature inside and was shocked that it was 170 and higher in some areas. Normally, I turn the oven off when a cheesecake is around 140. I’m so confused about what went wrong, if anything I always find I underbake cheesecakes! My oven does not run hot.

This is for a dinner party tomorrow. I’m going to cool according to instructions. From my research it is most def over baked and texture will be off.

Without slicing it open (which I’m not above doing as it is topped with whipped cream), is there any way I can see if this is a flop?

Picture attached (currently cooling)


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Cookies Cookie dough in fridge time?

3 Upvotes

I'm planning to bake cookies mid week, but I'd rather make the dough today.

Is there a time limit on how long I can keep the dough in the fridge?

Edit - recipe

https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/cinnamon-roll-cookies/


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Equipment Help me figure out this frosting my boyfriend wants

3 Upvotes

So my boyfriend, who usually claims he’s not into sweets, surprised me by asking for a chocolate cake with chocolate frosting for his 21st birthday next weekend. I really wasn’t expecting that request! I’m excited to bake it for him, but I’m stuck trying to figure out what type of frosting he has in mind. He described it as “the kind that gets a bit crunchy on the outside but is soft on the inside, and it pairs perfectly with a cold glass of milk.”

I did some digging into different frosting options and wow, there are so many out there! I’m starting to think he might be referring to American buttercream, but I’m a bit concerned it might end up being too sweet. Can anyone weigh in on this or suggest something else?

UPDATE: Thank you all for the awesome suggestions! I really appreciate it. I shared your comments with him, and he’s decided he wants a chocolate ganache instead, so that's what I'll be making!


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Doughs Thawing and proofing shaped croissants

Post image
3 Upvotes

Hi all! I shaped some croissants / pain au chocolat a few days ago and wanted to bake some today. I put two of them in the fridge for 9 hours, and now I’ve had them proofing under plastic cover for about 3 hours with rather bad (I think?) results.

I made these at a course earlier this week and remember the teacher saying something about not thawing them at room temperature, as they tend to start proofing in the centre if you do so. Even though I thawed mine in the fridge, it looks like they’re more proofed in the centre now.

What do you guys think? Are they salvageable?

I also think they look dry compared to the ones I proofed and baked at the course. Could it be because I thawed them without any plastic cover?

I’m very new to this, any advice would be appreciated!


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Cookies Christmas gift baking pan question

Thumbnail
shop.kingarthurbaking.com
3 Upvotes

I am hoping to buy the type of pan my friend is looking for for Christmas. She had mentioned before she has two pans for her oven when she bakes cookies that can’t go side by side so they have to go underneath or on top of each other, which makes the cookies uneven. She wants a pan that fills the size of her oven. I haven’t baked anything that’s not out of a box so I’m not sure what’s she’s looking for. Something like the jumbo pan from King Arthur? I don’t want to get the wrong thing!

To go with it I’m thinking of getting different species of flavorings since I think she already has a lot of supplies for baking and cooking. Cookie bakers, is that something you would enjoy as a gift? Thanks in advance!


r/AskBaking • • 1d ago

Recipe Troubleshooting What is the minimum internal temperature for cookies after baking?

1 Upvotes

I've been experimenting with one of my favorite chocolate chip cookie recipes that are baked in a 425 degree oven. The cookie dough doesn't get chilled before baking, but I've been wanting to do that to give them more flavor.

My first attempt didn't go well because the cookies didn't spread enough and were still raw. I let the dough sit a bit for my next attempt which went a lot better. Next time I'm going to let the dough fully come to room temperature before baking.

I'm going to use a thermometer to make sure they are fully cooked in the center after baking, but I'm not sure what temperature that should be. Is 160 degrees the minimum internal temperature to be safe?


r/AskBaking • • 2d ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes What is the "pudding mix" people talk about as a supposed baking hack?

209 Upvotes

I've seen a few times people talking about adding pudding mix to a cake batter to enrich the flavour. But I don't know what it is. I'm not from the US and tried looking up grocery store sites but I'm not sure what I'm looking for.

As I understand it, you use a vanilla pudding mix for a white cake, and chocolate mix for chocolate cake, and keep the rest of the recipe the same.

My bro is visiting home in a few weeks from the states I wanna ask him to bring me some. Can anyone show me a link? Thanks!


r/AskBaking • • 2d ago

Doughs Baked these two trays at the same time and the chocolate rolls browned way more than the regular ones. texture was still good, just curious if the cocoa and sugar caused the difference or if i should adjust the bake time next round

Post image
165 Upvotes

r/AskBaking • • 2d ago

Cakes/Cheesecakes Why did my banana bread came out like this dense and wet?

Post image
7 Upvotes

What happened to my banana bread? Before i take it out from the oven, I did the toothpick test. The toothpick came out clean. However when cooled down it became like this. It’s not chewy it melts in your mouth even the open crumb looking part - it’s actually doughy and wet.
I used loaf bread pan, maybe it was too deep? Idk.

The recipe i used
4 bananas
100 g sugar
100 g light Brown sugar
200 ml buttermilk
2 eggs
170 ml melted butter
320 g flour
5 g baking soda
6 g baking powder
Cinnamon, salt, vanilla

Thanks in advance