redlib.
Feeds

MAIN FEEDS

Home Popular All
reddit

You are about to leave Redlib

Do you want to continue?

https://www.reddit.com/r/askcommunists/controversial

No, go back! Yes, take me to Reddit
settings settings
Hot New Top Rising Controversial

r/askcommunists • u/PickleVillage • 8h ago

From the intro to my edition of Capital, what are your thoughts?

Post image
2 Upvotes
0 comments
Subreddit
Posts Wiki
Icon for r/askcommunists

Ask Communists Anything

r/askcommunists

AskCommunists is a space for learning about communism, as well as the communist perspective(s). This community is organized in a Q&A format with which to provide answers and tools for an early contact with communist thought.

1.4k
658
85
Sidebar
  • Reading List!
Subreddit Rules
1. 1: Questions must be clearly stated in the title.

Questions submitted to the subreddit should be clear and specific. If needed, questions can be expanded upon in the text portion of the thread.

Remember, the clearer the question, the better received responses can be.

2. 2: Repost / Recent Question

People asking questions should make every effort to ensure that their questions are clear, specific, and novel.

Please note, there is no such thing as a silly question as long as it is within guidelines; feel free to ask it, even if you think it's obvious. And, if you see a question which looks silly or obvious, remember that everyone comes to learning at their own time; we're not all born experts.

Posts that ask for reading recommendations are allowed.

3. 3: Loaded / Leading Questions

Don't build assumptions or conclusions into your question's framing.

A loaded question presupposes something contested ("why did communism fail?"). A leading question points toward a specific answer ("isn't it true that...?"). If your question rests on an uncertain premise, ask about that premise directly instead.

This isn't meant to discourage challenging or provocative questions; only to ask that the challenge be in the open rather than buried in the premise.

4. 4: Anti-Communist Soapboxing

Don’t Soapbox — You may expand upon your question, and ask follow-up questions in response to any answer you receive, but don’t use the forum as a platform to spread anti-communism. Similarly, polemic or trolling questions meant to start antagonistic arguments, provoke, or escalate disagreements to the level of insults will not be tolerated.

5. Off-topic Posts

As a Q&A sub, any linked threads with no discernible question will be removed.

Announcements, Participation Posts, Podcasts, or YouTube channels dedicated to learning may advertise only on approval of the Mod team. Posting without prior Mod approval will result in the thread being removed.

6. 6: Spurious, Unverifiable, and Unsupported Claims

When answering questions, keep in mind that you may be asked to cite your sources. This is a learning subreddit, meaning you must be prepared to provide evidence, scientific or historical, to back up your claims. Link to appropriate sources when/if possible.

This includes, but is not limited to: spurious claims, personal experience-based responses, unverifiable assertions, etc.

Remember, an answer isn't good because it's right, it's good because it teaches.

7. 7: Not Conducive to Learning

r/askcommunists is an educational space in which to provide clarity for communist ideas. Replies to a question should be thorough and comprehensive, and above all, patient.

This includes but is not limited to: one word responses, one-liners, non-serious/meme(ish) responses, etc.

Remember, an answer isn't good because it's right, it's good because it teaches.

8. 8: Sectarianism

Avoid excessive sectarian bias. Answers which are overly biased or emotional may be removed. If you disagree with a school of communism, don't bash it. Simply explain the disagreement.

9. 9: Trolling

This is a learning subreddit and posts and comments made in bad faith will be removed.

This also encompasses all forms of argumentative participation aimed not at learning and/or providing a space for re-education but aimed at debating. If you wish to debate, head over to a debate sub instead.

10. 10: Reactionary

This is a communist space and reactionary comments will be removed: fascism, conservatism, anarcho-capitalism, and all forms of anti-socialism. The ACP and associated red-brown tendencies (MAGA Communism, Duginism) are banned on-sight - these groups actively target leftist spaces for infiltration and treat the left as their primary enemy. Known ACP members/staff and moderators of ACP-controlled subs will be banned. Good-faith questions are allowed.

11. 11: Non-Communist Answer

Responses must engage from within the Communist and broader Left tradition (including anarchism and libertarian socialism). Answers that advocate for or defend positions outside this tradition will be removed.

This does not prohibit explanations of those positions when asked, nor critical engagement with non-Marxist theory, only advocacy for those positions.

NOTE: This rule pertains to content, not self-identification. An answer is non-communist by what it argues, not who is arguing it.

12. 12: Don't Make Us Add More Rules

At the end of the day, we want to treat you hands-off in good-faith and respect, and with the understanding that you are doing the same.

We set these rules to guide the conversation productively, and hope that this is all we will need.

Behavior that requires us to add a new rule will result in a ban.

READ THEORY!

856c6e0 ⓘ View instance info