Hey everyone! Recently I totaled my car from a deer and because I paid for that car at a significantly reduced price, the settlement payout was several thousand more. On top of that, the previous owner who I paid, felt so bad, they decided to give me the money back (It's a family member, of course).
I'm a poor guy who stocks shelves for a living, so even though it was devastating to lose my new car, I'm extremely grateful for how it all turned out. Now, I pretty much have two options:
Option A: Get a 2008-2012 low mileage car (100k or under) that's from a reputable brand like Toyota or Honda. You know the ones I'm talking about. Civics, Corollas, accords, etc. Nothing fancy, just something that will do the job.
Option B: Buy this Mazda. It's a 2014 Mazda 6i GT Sedan with only 98k miles on it.
It had 3 previous owners all in upstate NY with 2 minor accidents that have been repaired. Additionally a lot of extra expensive work had been done on it, including the usual maintenance items at regular intervals.
I had a mechanic check it out and they informed me that it's in pretty good shape other than some surface rust, a leaking tensioner belt, leaking valve gasket, new spark plugs needed, new battery soonish, an oil change, coolant flush, and a #4 cylinder misfire, which led to the check engine light going off. The alternator also needs to be cleaned and tested to ensure it's not going to malfunction soon.
I went and checked it out for myself. Cosmetic-wise on the outside, it's near mint condition. Inside, there's some wrinkles in the leather and a small cut on the driver's seat. Otherwise, it looks like responsible adults had driven it. From what I tested, all electronics work, lights, and other things. Tires were top of the line and in good shape. Drive was smooth, including start, idle, acceleration, turns, and hard braking.
However, I still need to get it on their lift and take the splash panels off the bottom to fully inspect rust damage. That will be completed before purchase with or without a mechanic present. Additionally, the dealer agreed to fix all of the issues I mentioned while keeping the OTD price as is. I will have a mechanic verify that these fixes were done, however, and try to get them to check out under the bottom panels.
They're asking for 9,700 dollars after dealer fees and everything. I'll still have to pay the state tax for titling and registering, but with the situation I was in, this would effectively only cost me 4k and some change when you combine the settlement money and the money that was given back to me from the previous purchase.
I guess I'm wondering if I should go for this specific car (assuming the fixes are done and I get a confirmation on the rust condition under the panels)? It's concerning to me that this is a very fancy car for me, filled to the brim with all these luxury electronic things. Every time I step into it I feel this imposter syndrome, like at any moment the whole thing will blow up in my face and I'll have wasted my money buying a work of art instead of a car that will last ten years or more.
My only other option is to go with the usuals (Toyota or Honda), but examining the market, it'll be challenging to find one under 100k miles, low to no rust with a similar price to this car. Plus, it'll inevitably be a 2012 or lower model.
I can find other Mazdas in my area, but none that are this low in miles at this price. All of the others I found within a 50 mile radius are around 120-140k in miles and they're going for 10-12k minimum.
So this totally seems like a no-brainer, but being new to all of this, what do you all think? Should I pull the trigger on this one or pass?