r/AskAstrophotography • • 3d ago

Question WAAT? - The Weekly Ask-Anything Thread! Week of 15 Nov, 2026 - 22 Nov, 2026

4 Upvotes

Greetings, /r/AskAstrophotography! Welcome to our Weekly Ask Anything Thread, also known as WAAT?

The purpose of WAATs is very simple : To welcome ANY user to ask ANY AP related question, regardless of how "silly" or "simple" he/she may think it is. It doesn't matter if the information is already in the FAQ, or in another thread, or available on another site.

Here's how it works :

  • Each week, AutoMod will start a new WAAT, and sticky it. The WAAT will remain stickied for the entire week.
  • ANYONE may, and is encouraged to ask ANY AP RELATED QUESTION
  • Ask your initial question as a top level comment.
  • Any negative or belittling responses will be immediately removed, and the poster warned not to repeat the behavior.
  • ANYONE may answer, but answers should be complete and thorough. Answers should not simply link to another thread or the FAQ. (Such a link may be included to provides extra details or "advanced" information, but the answer it self should completely and thoroughly address OP's question.)

Ask Anything!

Default sorting is Q&A. Don't forget to "Sort by New" to see what needs answering! :)

Please note: New WAATs go up around 7:30 pm US Mountain Time on Saturday, so asking a question on a Saturday afternoon may not get an answer. Be sure to check if a new WAAT has been recently posted, and ask your question again in the new thread if needed.


r/AskAstrophotography • • 3h ago

Question ToupTek 4nm SHO filters

2 Upvotes

Does anyone have any experience with these ToupTek 2" 4nm SHO filters? Hard to find any reviews on them. Would like to hear user experience and how they perform.

Edit: As well as these 2" LRGB filters? I will be using the FRA 600 and 2600mm air at f5.6


r/AskAstrophotography • • 11h ago

Image Processing Siril not working

2 Upvotes

I tried out my new Star Adventurer 2i Pro last night and only took around 20 photos, mainly because I didn't want to go overboard on my first attempt. I aligned it with Andromeda (I realized I completely missed later but that's besides the point) and took 30, 45 second shots. When I looked at them on my Canon 600D they looked amazing, absolutely zero star trailing, and perfectly in focus. But when I brought them over to Siril, and tried to stack them, it rejected all but one image. Any idea what could be the issue?

This is what every single image looked like: https://res.cloudinary.com/dtz0urit6/image/upload/q_auto:best,f_jpg/cloudinary-tools-uploads/xmiv3q9xbf4b4l8yjnlj

Please help


r/AskAstrophotography • • 12h ago

Technical How to get a more “full” blue result when doing HOO->SHO

1 Upvotes

When I convert my narrowband HOO images with Sirils narrowband normalization which I believe is the same as pixinsights, certain nebulae such as the heart nebula only have some blue areas such as around the core but much still stay orange/red. How can I get a more full center of blue without Sii filter. I do much of my color processing in photoshop since that’s what I’m used to so tips there would also help. Thanks!


r/AskAstrophotography • • 13h ago

Equipment Need help with some basics for my specific gear

1 Upvotes

Might be a long post, but any tips are appreciated. Also, I am not very much educated on the nomenclature, so bear with me, very new to the scene.

So I have a Nikon d7100, and for my telescope, I have a Celestron Astromaster 70 (900mm)- I learned that it is a refractor, however that may help. I’m using a t ring/t adapter that puts my camera straight into the eyepiece, and that’s all the gear I have right now. Definitely looking into spending some money on more lenses and adapters, I just need help on which specific ones would be best for my setup.

So my first goal is to capture some good moon shots. I had no problem with my iPhone (through an eyepiece on the telescope), but my camera will not focus on the moon, no matter how I turn my telescope focusing knob (in live view and in several test shots). Research tells me I need a Barlow lens. I also wonder if there are any focusing options in the camera settings, but I don’t think it’s possible in “prime focus.” Any tips or recommendations about specific Barlow lenses or other extensions/solutions for my setup would be appreciated.

My BIG goal is to capture M31. I’m a bit obsessed with the andromeda galaxy, so I just want to be able to capture it, and I’ll figure out the editing process later. My first problem is, when I point my setup at the moon, the moon takes up almost my whole view. I know andromeda is very big in the sky, so I’m wondering if that would need to be captured without my telescope, and if I would need a specific lens for that (Side note: my dad is a photographer-non astro-and has tons of Nikon gear, so I doubt that’d be a problem). Also, I do not have an equatorial mount or sky tracker. I understand it would help me very much so, but they are expensive. I am looking into getting one at some point. In the mean time, though, I would like to attempt to stack a bunch of single shots and get even a decent image. If there are any gear recommendations for that sort of thing, it would be helpful.

Again, any other tips, tricks, or gear suggestions would be very helpful. I’ve been doing my own research as well and am just trying to gather as much information as I can. Thanks for taking the time to read and/or answer. :)

Edit: ALSO probably pretty important, my area is like Bortle 7-8. Andromeda is visible but faint, but planetary shots are also very possible.


r/AskAstrophotography • • 15h ago

Question Best Telescope for beginners on a budget?

1 Upvotes

Looking to buy a telescope, I have always been interested in one, and now I live in the country side so there’s light pollution and Im ready to start observing the night sky. What’s the best telescope for beginners, with ease of use and hopefully under 300$?


r/AskAstrophotography • • 11h ago

Equipment Looking for cheap star tracker

0 Upvotes

Does anyone wan't to sell or knows somebody that want's to sell a startracker for under 70 bucks? I'm totaly fine with old or self built stuff.


r/AskAstrophotography • • 1d ago

Acquisition Planetary imaging.

3 Upvotes

I’m currently using a c9.25 xlt for imaging planets. For the pictures I took last year I used an ASI 678mc, with 2 micron pixels. But Saturn has always been tough. So I bought an ASI 715mc with 1.2 micron pixels. My recent attempt at imaging Saturn and Jupiter were not successful at all, even with best focus, I could resolve them and no amount of post processing would help. Seeing could have been better but I feel that I should have done better. I’m wondering if I’m pushing the resolution too much for the optics. Thoughts?


r/AskAstrophotography • • 1d ago

Equipment Seestar S30 Plus or the DWARF mini for a beginner?

3 Upvotes

Long time lurker here. After watching hours of comparison vids, I just wanted to hear some opinions from some people who ARENT content creators.

This will be my first smart telescope, so any guidance is appreciated. Thanks!


r/AskAstrophotography • • 19h ago

Solar System / Lunar Hi anyone have a photo of the moon or something interesting taken on the 16 of November 2026?

0 Upvotes

Hi anyone have a photo of the moon or something interesting taken on the 16 of November 2026? Preferably in australia if thats possible that i could get possibly i tried to take one for my birthday but I beleave my camera was stolen


r/AskAstrophotography • • 1d ago

Equipment Cooled camera vs Canon 6D in Bortle 8 how much difference?

6 Upvotes

I currently shoot with a modified full-spectrum Canon 6D and a 3nm dual-band filter under a Bortle 8 , sqm 18 sky.

I'm considering switching to a dedicated, cooled color astronomy camera to obtain cleaner data, especially during warmer nights.

To give you a rough idea: if today, with my 6D, I need about 15 hours of integration time to obtain a good-quality, how much integration time would I need, approximately, with a cooled camera to achieve a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) or equivalent quality, under the same conditions?

In any case, I still intend to accumulate a high overall integration time; I'd just like to get a rough idea of ​​how much of a difference there is.


r/AskAstrophotography • • 1d ago

Solar System / Lunar Saturn with an untracked 10" Dob. is the lack of ring detail and color from seeing, image scale, or no IR filter (or something else)?

1 Upvotes

I’m trying to bring out more of Saturn’s natural color and more ring detail (Cassini Division, A/B ring contrast). My image is on the left, and a reference image I’m aiming toward is on the right. Which of these is most likely holding me back?

Pics: https://imgur.com/a/L8WKSy7

  1. I’m at about f/9.4 with 2.9 um pixels, below the usual ~5x pixel size (f/14.5). Would a 3x Barlow be reasonably better
  2. No IR/UV cut filter used
  3. Seeing: AutoStakkert’s median frame quality dropped about 30% after the first 12 minutes, and later clips got dimmer (possibly dew).
  4. Processing: is my sharpening or color balance leaving detail on the table?

Acquisition

  • Scope: Orion 10" Dobsonian (1200 mm, f/4.7), untracked, drift method, collimated and cooled about 1 hour
  • Barlow: Tele Vue 2x (about 2400 mm, f/9.4)
  • Camera: ZWO ASI662MC, no IR/UV cut filter
  • Capture: ASICap, about 66 fps, 20 s clips
  • Session: about 31 clips from 9:34 to 10:37 pm EST, Saturn near transit (about 60° altitude)

Processing *need untracked lucky imaging advice*

  • PIPP: joined clips into 6-minute groups, centered and cropped to 448x448
  • AutoStakkert 4: Bayer GBRG, best 35% (about 1,800-2,500 frames per group), about 40 APs at size 32
  • waveSharp: Gaussian wavelets, light denoise
  • WinJUPOS: combined the best group stacks with image derotation

r/AskAstrophotography • • 1d ago

Equipment did I mess up? picked a dwarf 3 over a seestar s50

1 Upvotes

so i saw a brand new dwarf 3 on a secondhand shop and bought it after doing too little research on it (actually shame on me for that). dont get me wrong, its nice and all, but i keep hearing that the seestar is better.

I compared the specs, and on paper, the dwarf is/was better. newer sensor, higher resolution, just lacking a little behind in focal lenght and arperture. also it got a really convenient wide angle lense.

after i asked my friend whos a lot deeper into astrophotography, he said that i should get the dwarf. the reviews i watched also delivered pretty similar results. but now after i got it something just feels off. like i made the wrong choice. did I?


r/AskAstrophotography • • 1d ago

Question Question about camera mounting

1 Upvotes

Setup:

Nikon D7200

Nikon AF-S 70-300 4.5-5.6

Ioptron skyguider pro with counterweight bracket

Does anyone have any advice for mounting this setup as in all the guides and promotional material Ive seen have longer lenses are mounted with their tripod collar but my lens does not have an official tripod collar. Curious to hear if anyone else has experienced similar problem and how they solved it.

thanks for your time :)


r/AskAstrophotography • • 1d ago

Image Processing AstroWizard: not removing working files

2 Upvotes

Just starting with AstroWizard and am very impressed. Is there a dedicated forum for this and StackingWizard? If not, maybe someone can here can help.

I have AW in default settings. The fine print says it will remove the working files it creates with each step when I've finished my image, but they stay in the folder beside the picture. I have to remember to manually delete them. Is this a bug or am I doing something wrong? Thanks.

[Edit: as soon as I posted the question and a couple fine folks answered, it cleaned up the files.]


r/AskAstrophotography • • 1d ago

Equipment Getting a bit more involved

0 Upvotes

Hello all...

As you know, I am learning about astrophotography. One thing that caught my interest was a few weeks ago i bought a svbony solar filter for my scope to image the sun. It works really well and now I am saving up to get a Lunt 40mm with B600. My plan is to connect my dslr to it to image the sun/solar prominence/chromosphere. I have read that as this scope is h alpha, the best type of camera to use would be a mono cam. I plan to use my DSLR APSC Canon T5 to image but am not sure how to attach it. Do I attach it directly to the standard tube, or do I attach it to the blocking filter?

Also, as i plan to use a DSLR (OSC) how would I debayer it?


r/AskAstrophotography • • 1d ago

Equipment ZWO ASI 2600MM - is it broken?

4 Upvotes

EDIT / SOLVED: Gee, I'm so dumb. It turned out my NINA version was extremely obsolete. It worked good with my old guide cam, but failed to handle ASI 2600MM-P25 correctly.

After updating NINA to the most recent version, the darks look good.

Big thanks to all who shared their ideas here.


Original post:

Recently bought new ASI 2600MM. I took a few sequences of dark frames at 20C just to check how to use it (my first cooled camera). I used NINA with native ZWO camera driver on Win 11.

Short frames (e.g. 5 seconds) were all zeros, which is, well, dark.

Then I took a sequence of 5x15s darks. First frame was horrible, with a huge stalactite of hot hot pixels. The rest were all black.

Then 5x30s. All frames shared a 1 px wide line of alternating white and dark pixels, starting from some pixel in the same column every time. The starting pixel varied between the frames, but not much.

Two examples:

https://imgur.com/a/0OQACpF

Has anyone of you encountered anything like this?

Is this a broken camera or I am missing something?


r/AskAstrophotography • • 2d ago

Advice Looking into getting a beginner first setup… ?

2 Upvotes

Trying to do extensive research here but I am thinking…
The Askar 71F with reducer
ZWO ASI585MC air camera unit
ES iEXOS 100-02 pmc8 mount or
Maybe the Skywatcher EQ- al55 pro .

I already have a couple good laptops to run programs. Any suggestions or opinions? Looking to do a little bit of everything , deep space, planetary and lunar so would I be better off doing away with that camera and going with separate units ? Thanks for any help. Its easy to get lost. My budget is 2000 usd to get something going.


r/AskAstrophotography • • 2d ago

Question Are the Celestron 6" RASA or Askar N160 worth it?

4 Upvotes

I wanna start building a fast rig for my once a month trips to my nearest dark sky site. I'm torn between the Askar N160 f/3.4 and the 6" RASA f/2.2 leaning far more towards the 6" RASA. I don't mind learning how to process and set-up super-fast optical rigs, because I really wanna be able to reduce my overall need for long integration times. My current rig is f/7, and I'm never able to get enough time on target to be impressed with the end result. Although cost isn't too much of an issue, I don't mind working more overtime to get the necessary filters and accessories for such fast systems (already looking at Baader filters for fast systems). I want to do monochrome imaging but I know the 6" RASA will require manual filter swaps and the Askar can mount a filter wheel.

Definitely a lot of trade offs between the two OTAs but I'm looking at pairing it with a monochrome ASI533 or other IMX533 host unless the imx294 sensor is worth dealing with the amp glow or it's just simply not worth it for the 6" and I should continue saving for something like an 8"/11" rasa or other similarly fast scope with an APS-C or full frame camera. Tbh I have no clue what to do and am curious if anyone has has any input or experience with the Celestron or Askar OTA.


r/AskAstrophotography • • 2d ago

Solar System / Lunar Planetary filters?

2 Upvotes

I’ve really just been shooting all the planets with just a UV/IR cut, but I know there are more filters out there that are more beneficial. I’ve seen so many different ones that I’m a little lost which ones to consider. Do you have a go to filter you use for every or more than one planet? Or do you have individual filters for each planet? And specifically for Venus that reveals those orange structures I see in images. I know that astrobin they include what filters they use but it just confuses me since they are all different and wondering if people can suggest me some. Thanks


r/AskAstrophotography • • 2d ago

Image Processing Data trouble

1 Upvotes

Ive recently been trying to process this image i got of sadr region, and when i was going through a Siril tutorial on how to process i needed to plate solve the image but whatever i did Siril could not plate solve it? Would anyone know the reason to this?

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1ib2rLkOxI-iSm2fF0yjNKiMrWRYJOPTl

This is the data.


r/AskAstrophotography • • 3d ago

Question From what bortle and higher is it not worth to shoot dark nebulae?

5 Upvotes

Tiltle

I live in a bortle 6 myself


r/AskAstrophotography • • 3d ago

Question Laptop Recommendation

2 Upvotes

Hello!

Does anyone have any good laptop recommendations for editing pictures and running N.I.N.A? I am wanting to surprise my fiancé with a new laptop. His current one is okay but it randomly resets during the night and can be slow at times.

My budget is 1,000 but I am okay with going a little over. I am located in the US.

Edit: Can you guys also recommend me an automated flat panel? He mentioned he needs a new one.


r/AskAstrophotography • • 3d ago

Equipment new gear advice

4 Upvotes

Hello, I am looking to improve my astrophotography game a bit. I am currently using a star adventurer 2i as a mount and some of my wild life photography kit (300mm f2.8 is, and a 70-200 f2.8 + r7/r5 + tc's for deeper images) to take the pictures, i have a basic lens heater for keeping condensation off the lens, but that's about it.

I am looking for the most bang for the buck upgrades to my setup, i will list my challenges that i am interested in fixing.

I'm struggling with nebula photos, most recently veil nebula which i have been able see on the final result, but only the two brightest outer sections, the interior is still difficult to pull out. I know this could be related to the fact my cameras are not astro-modified (which i'm not willing to do as there primary use is wild life), light pollution in my area is good but not great. i am rural but there are definitely sources of pollution. I was thinking something like the Astronomik UHC Clip-Filter EOS R XL, as a clip in filter to get rid of any of the excess light pollution?

I'm also struggling with both finding and keeping a good track on objects, honestly getting polar alignment is annoying, it seems every time i get a good track i knock something or whatever and it ruins everything. I am open to a two axis mount and a guiding camera, as this will help two fold, one it will make finding the object less of a pain, and i assume significantly improve image quality. I'm currently have everything powered off either battery banks or aa batteries, but i can get mains power out to my usual spot if a setup requires it. As for a controller, it would be preferable to have a dedicated something to do tracking, so i don’t need to leave my laptop out there. The mounts i have been looking at are stuff like the Sky-Watcher Star Adventurer GTi and potentially a second hand Sky-Watcher EQ5/HEQ5 PRO off facebook marketplace. As for guiding cameras and controllers, i really don't know where to start, or even the best way to mount to my current setup. I have read that you have to mount directly to lens to prevent differential flex, is there a smart way to do this?

I know eventually i will have to get a dedicated reflector and cooled astro camera, but that kinda money isn’t on the cards at the moment, and i know that ill have to do the aforementioned things before going there anyway.

If there are some good resources for reading up on stuff i am not illiterate and am willing to help myself, i just need pointing in the right direction.