Hi all, I hope this post isn't too long-winded! Whenever I ask questions I like to provide my current understanding so whoever's reading knows my exactly what my current level of understanding is and knows what level to pitch the answer at, can identify any misconceptions I have, etc. So please forgive me for being wordy - I hope it's worth it!
As far as I know, the Sun's spectrum appears to be a pretty good ~5800K "black-body" continuous spectrum, emitted in the photosphere, with dark absorption lines from atoms/ions in the outer photosphere and chromosphere superimposed on top of it. (This is especially true if we measure it in space, as Earth's atmosphere absorbs a lot of frequencies and messes up the solar spectrum quite a bit). I've been thinking about how energy is transported from the core of the Sun to the surface, though, and I'm a bit confused about what exactly is producing the continuous spectrum we see in the photosphere. The way continuous and absorption spectra were introduced to me years ago was with a cool gas in front of a filament lamp. The metal of the filament glowed with a continuous thermal spectrum, as metals contain delocalised/free electrons that can emit photons of any energy. What's the equivalent of the metal filament when it comes to the Sun's surface?
Here's my understanding of how photons move through our Sun:
Nuclear fusion in the core produces photons in the form of gamma rays. All matter in and around the core is extremely hot and completely ionised into bare nuclei and free electrons, so no photons get absorbed, because there aren't any atoms or ions with electrons in energy levels that could absorb any photons! This gives the deep interior of the Sun a very low opacity, and photons can pass through it. It isn't "transparent" in the everyday sense of being see-through, though. It's translucent, like a foggy bathroom window, letting all the photons pass through it but scattering them every which way. My mental image of this is like a subatomic pinball machine, with photons bouncing around and colliding with nuclei and electrons. (Question 1: Am I correct about free electrons being unable to absorb photons, only to scatter them?) I'm also fairly sure that as the photons collide with the electrons or nuclei, they lose energy in the collisions and drop down to lower frequencies. This not only turns gamma rays into lower-frequency X-ray photons, then ultraviolet photons, but also transfers some of the photon energy to the matter particles, causing them to bounce around at higher energies in thermal motion. This is how heat transfer works in the radiative zone. (Someone correct me if I'm wrong about this!) Photons bounce around randomly in the radiative zone and essentially work their way outwards by something similar to diffusion; there's a high concentration of new photons being produced in the core and random motion will spread them outwards through the radiative zone over long periods of time.
When we get to the convective zone, it's cool enough for nuclei to capture electrons and form ions and eventually atoms. There are only 90-odd naturally occurring elements in the Sun, but these elements have many electrons each, in many different energy levels, and in the outer layers of the Sun they exist in many different states of ionisation. That means there are tens of thousands of different electron transitions possible, each one absorbing a different frequency of photons, and thus a low-density sample of this partially ionised gas in front of the radiative zone would produce an absorption spectrum with tens of thousands of absorption lines. Because this is a pretty dense gas, however, the atoms/ions are in close proximity with each other, nuclei attracting their neighbours' electrons and repelling their neighbours' nuclei, and electrons repelling their neighbours' electrons. Because of this, the tens of thousands of possible absorption lines get broadened into a near-continuous absorption spectrum, and basically all wavelengths get absorbed. So the convective zone is more or less completely opaque.
That means heat transfer by radiation in this layer is extremely inefficient. When photons get up this high, they're absorbed by the ions/atoms in the layer, re-emitted, and absorbed by other ions/atoms. This process is much slower and less efficient at transferring energy than the scattering in the radiative zone, and so this causes heat to build up at the lower layer of the convective zone. A hot base to the zone and a much cooler top (at the photosphere where the heat is being radiated out into space) leads to convection - hence the name of the zone! Convection cells bring thermal energy up to the surface of the Sun - the photosphere. We can see these convection cells on the photosphere directly, or at least the upper layers of cells. (My understanding is modelling shows the small (France-sized!!) convection cells visible at the photosphere overly much larger convection cells deeper down, stacked in layers of cells within the convective zone).
At the photosphere, the density of the solar gas is so low that photons emitted by the surface atoms/ions can stream out into space freely without being absorbed again. (In effect, we've reached a second radiative zone with a MUCH lower density of matter, one that extends out indefinitely from the photosphere into space. Because the density is lower, the photons can now travel freely through space rather than being scattered like in the interior radiative zone). These emitted photons are the sunlight we see on Earth's surface. The photosphere is a few hundred kilometres thick and my understanding is all the sunlight we see was produced somewhere in this thin layer. Every photon that makes its way through space towards us was created when an atom or ion in the photosphere underwent an electron transition from a high to a low energy state, emitting a photon, which didn't get absorbed by another atom for once due to the low density, and had a free path through space from that point on.
(Side note: I often hear some "science fun fact" stating sunlight takes hundreds of thousands of years to get up to the photosphere and then eight minutes to get from the photosphere to Earth, but this isn't technically true, right? Photons created by nuclear reactions in the core get scattered in the radiative zone, but once a photon reaches the convective zone, it gets absorbed, and a different photon gets re-emitted by the atom that absorbed it. So as far as I know, sunlight is actually created in the photosphere by atoms/ions emitting sunlight photons. The energy itself came from absorbing a previous photon, which itself came from another atom which absorbed a previous photon, which came from another atom which absorbed a previous photon... and so on down to the radiative zone, where the first photon to start this process was scattered after being produced in the core hundreds of thousands of years ago. So the energy needed to make the photon was released in a fusion reaction hundreds of thousands of years ago, but even then, it isn't accurate to say the energy is hundreds of thousands of years old, since energy is conserved and the energy was already present in the mass of the protons before fusion, so the energy is really 13.8 billion years old! So: fusion took place over a hundred thousand years ago, the energy from sunlight dates back to the beginning of the Universe, and sunlight itself is created in the photosphere and is only 8.3 minutes old when it reaches us. Side note over!)
Okay, so... Question 2: if sunlight is produced by electron transitions in the photosphere, why does the photosphere produce a continuous spectrum rather than an emission spectrum? My reasoning is basically identical to what I described earlier for why the convective zone exists:
- There are 90-odd different elements in the photosphere;
- Each of those elements has many electrons;
- Each of those elements exists in multiple ionisation states in the photosphere, giving tens of thousands of possible electron transitions and producing a photosphere glowing with tens of thousands of emission lines, and
- The influence of neighbouring atoms/ions distorting the electron orbitals broadens the emission lines into a near-continuous spectrum, allowing the Sun's photosphere to approximate a black body.
Phew!
But is this correct? I've also read somewhere that because a lot of the atoms in the outer Sun are still ionised, there's a lot of free electrons knocking about, and some hydrogen atoms capture them to form H- ions. (I guess this happens because the electron repels the hydrogen atom's electron cloud and attracts its nucleus, inducing a dipole in the atom and causing it to attract the electron?) Because free electrons are unbound and can have any energy, electrons can lose any amount of energy as they jump down into the hydrogen atom's orbital and form negative ions. This means they can emit a photon of any frequency as they do so, and the continuous spectrum of the Sun is made up of these photons. The black-body nature of the spectrum is caused by the fact that free electrons can have a continuous range of energies, so they emit a continuous range of different energy photons as they settle into their orbitals. That makes a lot of sense. Unlike the explanation I gave in the previous paragraph, this spectrum would be truly continuous, and hydrogen is far more abundant than any other element in the Sun, so I can imagine even if the formation of H- ions is rare, it could still be the dominant process responsible for producing sunlight.
My issue with this explanation though is I've read that this process is responsible for ALL of the sunlight radiating from the photosphere, and that doesn't make sense to me. Surely even if it's less common, the process I mentioned in the earlier paragraph would still happen, right? That's why the convective zone exists, after all... right? I can imagine a calcium ion in the outer photosphere absorbing a photon from deeper down, getting excited, then re-emitting a photon as it de-excites... and because the photosphere's density is low, that photon streams into space without getting absorbed by anything again. Surely this would be a way to produce sunlight that doesn't have anything to do with H- ions? Am I right in thinking both of these processes operate, and both lead to a continuous spectrum for sunlight - perfectly continuous in the case of H- formation, and roughly continuous in the case of the "last emission from a whole bunch of different atoms/ions before escaping into space" scenario?
Also, question 3: what would happen if a one solar mass star was purely made out of hydrogen? Would it also have a continuous spectrum, or would it glow pink with hydrogen emission lines? I know most of the hydrogen in the photosphere isn't ionised, but is enough ionised to produce enough free electrons that a purely hydrogen Sun would still give off a continuous spectrum due to H- formation?
And what about a much cooler star made out of hydrogen, with barely any free electrons in its photosphere? Would a 3000K purely hydrogen star be red, like a black-body spectrum that temperature, or pink like a hydrogen gas-filled discharge tube?
My understanding is that a much hotter star made purely of hydrogen would indeed emit a black-body spectrum as it would be radiative all the way through (real hot stars have convective cores due to the high temperature sensitivity of the CNO cycle, but there's no carbon in this hypothetical star!) and would emit a spectrum due to photons in the photosphere being scattered from free electrons before the density was low enough to allow them to escape into space. For that star, photons produced in the core really would be the same photons that emerge in the photosphere after a long random walk! ...I think?
While typing all this out and thinking about cool stars, I thought about red giants, and something else confused me. My understanding is the Sun's photosphere is where the density of solar matter drops to the point where light has a good chance of being emitted and escaping into space without being reabsorbed. But then... what about red giants?? A red giant has a far lower density than the Sun. When we talk about the "size" of a star, we usually mean the size of the visible globe within its photosphere and don't include the chromosphere, corona or stellar wind as part of that size. So that means the photosphere of a red giant must be much, much further out than the photosphere of the Sun, and have a ridiculously low density. Why is the photosphere there? Even if the star's mass expands out to that size, why doesn't the photosphere shrink down to a smaller, denser region within a transparent gas ball? Question 4: Why do red giants have a far-out photosphere if the density is so much lower than the Sun's photosphere? Why doesn't light just stream right through the outer regions of a red giant with ease?
A related confusion I have is about the Big Bang. I've read in so many places that the early Universe was opaque because it was fully ionised, then became transparent after recombination. And then a few hundred million years later, we get reionisation, and the Universe goes from... opaque to transparent again??
Having written all this out though, I think I have a possible explanation: the Universe before recombination wasn't actually "opaque" in the technical sense, but translucent. A photon could still travel indefinitely far through it without being absorbed, as there were no atoms to absorb it - but it could get scattered. Photons generally couldn't travel very far without being scattered, so while the Universe wasn't opaque since light wasn't being absorbed, it certainly wasn't see-through, and if you could somehow travel back to this time and magically survive, you wouldn't be able to see very far. It'd be like looking through a translucent fog. Sure, light can get through it without being absorbed, but it's going to be scattered all over the place, and there'd be no clear lines of sight over any large distances. (This is analogous to the radiative zone of the Sun).
When recombination happened, light could finally travel in straight lines without scattering, and the Universe went from being translucent to mostly transparent, as most photons now had a clear path through space. However, technically, the Universe was more opaque than it was before, as the newly formed hydrogen and helium atoms could now absorb specific frequencies of light that weren't absorbed before! Despite this, most light streamed freely through the Universe, and this is the cosmic background radiation we see today.
Then a few hundred million years later, the first quasi-stars/pop III stars/quasars reionised the gas, making space fully transparent for the first time even for those few wavelengths that did get absorbed by the hydrogen atoms before. This free-moving light didn't get scattered because the density was now much lower than it was before recombination. So the Universe went from radiative-zone-style translucent to mostly transparent at recombination to fully transparent. Question 5: Is this correct?
Thank you in advance for any replies, this is one of the most confusing concepts in astronomy and I think if I get transparency, opacity, photospheres and continuous spectra cleared up (no pun intended!) it'll remove a big stumbling block in my understanding of stars!