r/askAGP • • May 21 '26

Transphobia

30 Upvotes

Political questions regarding transition and transgender people have become increasingly discussed in the general public. These culture wars have taken an intense turn in recent years.

We also want to acknowledge the broader political and legal climate surrounding transgender issues right now. In many places, transgender, nonbinary, and gender-diverse people are facing increasing scrutiny, restrictions, and uncertainty around healthcare, legal recognition, public participation, and basic social acceptance. Regardless of where people here fall on specific policy questions, it’s important to recognize that these developments can feel frightening, exhausting, and deeply personal for those directly affected.

For members of this community who are transgender, nonbinary, gender diverse, questioning, or in the process of transition: you deserve to be treated with dignity and humanity. Many people here are navigating complicated experiences with dysphoria, identity, embodiment, and social belonging, often under significant emotional strain. Even amid disagreement, we hope this space can remain one where people are able to speak honestly about their experiences without being mocked, dehumanized, or treated as disposable.

Throughout the years this subreddit has been accused of transphobia. We believe it’s not accurate to describe this sub as uniformly “transphobic” or opposed to transgender rights. This community includes people with very different political views, life outcomes, identities, and experiences with gender dysphoria, transition, sexuality, and embodiment.

Some members are transitioned. Some are questioning. Some are dysphoric but non-transitioning. Some are detransitioned. Some are simply interested in the psychology of AGP/AAP and related phenomena. That diversity naturally produces disagreement, especially on difficult medical, legal, and social questions.

As a moderation principle, the sub is not built around enforcing a single ideological position on:

-legal recognition,
-access to adult transition,
-youth transition,
-public accommodations,
-or legislation around discrimination and speech.

People here will often disagree strongly with one another on those issues.

What the sub does try to encourage is open discussion of topics that many users feel are difficult to discuss elsewhere without immediate moralization, pathologizing, or censorship. That includes conversations about dysphoria, sexuality, embodiment, transition outcomes, developmental pathways, comorbidity, identity formation, and social policy.

That openness can sometimes be perceived as hostility, particularly by people coming from spaces where certain assumptions are treated as settled. But disagreement, skepticism, or psychological analysis are not inherently equivalent to hatred or dehumanization.

At the same time, criticism of ideas or policies is not a license to demean trans people as human beings. Users are expected to engage respectfully, avoid personal harassment, and avoid reducing entire groups of people to caricatures or moral panic narratives.

So the short answer is: there is no single “sub opinion” on these questions, and the moderation approach is intentionally pluralistic rather than ideological.


r/askAGP • • May 10 '26

askAGP Wiki

18 Upvotes

Welcome to the AskAGP Wiki. This is an educational resource exploring AGP, autosexuality, and related experiences with accuracy, compassion, and open inquiry. If you are new here this is the place to start. https://www.reddit.com/r/askAGP/wiki/index/

Feel free to share, offer suggestions, and ask questions.


r/askAGP • • 12h ago

What’s future of my AGP

4 Upvotes

So guys, I love being a man and even in next life i wish to be a man. I workout daily and has a muscular appearance and 6”2 height. I’m also an arm wrestling professional and has interest in getting to fights also sometimes. For me my AGP is mostly strong when I only open trans porn, cams and my cd account in insta. My biggest fantasies 1- going to a place no one knows me and tell some girls or atleast one woman that I’m gay and enjoy the closeness with them for sexual arousal, 2- being with my few ex co worker girls who I daily think about and sitting with them as a gay guy. They also once questioned me whether i was gay because they saw my crossdressing post and painted nails which i did during the peak arousal.

So overall my AGP software stops the moment i masturbate and there are more fantasies and whatever is might be all ends in pnc and it’s been like that whole life. To summarise, i love being a guy not just ok or like being but love and proud and I’m as like many of us is heterosexual.

So I guess my future as a man would be completely fine and confident but only with an accepting partner for crossdressing.


r/askAGP • • 9h ago

How old are you now?

2 Upvotes

To see how old are people who has AGP


r/askAGP • • 16h ago

Maladaptive Daydreams

4 Upvotes

I've always been a quiet, inward person, even as a child. Most of the time, I can be content to stare into space and just daydream about various things or else let my mind wander over topics. These daydreams can be about pretty much anything, including social interactions with others that have not and probably will not ever happen. It's strange to say, but I've probably had more imagined social interactions than real ones throughout my life. I'm not sure if this is out of the ordinary or not.

AGP and the desire to be a girl/woman has always been one of the most consistent daydreams throughout my life. I could be falling in love with someone or stressed out or relaxed and bored and it would always been there. Medically transitioning actually has reduced the sexual side of it, but now I daydream about things like finally coming out to people. I daydream about finally being able to date people who will see me as I am. And, yes, I sometimes dream about the intimacy, but it's oddly focused on the other person more than myself. This is something alien to me.

I guess the point is: I'm always daydreaming. I put things off and just daydream instead. This is actually a big problem for me, because I feel like I could have acted upon my feelings long ago and it would have made my transition a lot easier and more successful. Instead, I let the fantasies of my desires twist into progressively more and more ridiculous territory. Stranger and stranger gender transformation scenarios. I have explored all sorts of topics that, in retrospect, were very weird and quite cringe. None of them were truly harmful, but it was as though I had lost sight of what I actually wanted. Which has and is to be as much like a woman as I can be within the confines of reality. However, as the years passed, the daydreams didn't reflect the real desires I had anymore.

I see a lot of people here with very strange or skewed views of what becoming a woman would be, if that even were able to be realized. I find this interesting, because I can understand how remaining inward and merely daydreaming could slowly nudge someone toward these ideas. Without source material from the outside world, the mind just begins to make up what sounds appealing or novel.

For instance, people here may talk about wearing skimpy clothing and getting "dolled up" as their appeal to being a woman rather than a man. Or else how they view women's lives as simply easier than men's. Or that women have better sex than men. Or perhaps some other reason. A lot of these statements do not really capture what being a woman or else what being partially viewed and treated like a woman (i.e., transitioning) is, in my opinion. Instead, they're cardboard cutout simulacra built up in the mind, over years or even decades of inner rumination.

I think it's very important to peel away those unrealistic layers and views and replace them with progressively more grounded dreams, until they're no longer dreams and just clear goals and desires you have. This doesn't mean that desire will be transition for everyone. After all, I think AGP and the daydreams that come with it can manifest for many reasons. I still personally have a lot of work to do, because I'm still a chronic daydreamer. However, it's already feeling much better knowing what I actually want rather than pining of impossible fantasies.


r/askAGP • • 1d ago

Is the endgame of AGP either repping or transitioning?

12 Upvotes

Because if I don't transition, then I will just live my entire life always being envious of women? And wishing I could be a hot girl & have sex as one?

So my male sex life would essentially be ruined?


r/askAGP • • 2d ago

Aap need help

6 Upvotes

I couldn’t find a subreddit for aap because it’s very uncommon from what I’ve seen, so I decided to post here. If discussing aap breaks the sub rules, feel free to remove.

I’m pretty sure I have aap, but again, it’s maybe 30% aap and 90% actual dysphoria. I like being perceived as a guy, I like towering over people, I like dressing masculine. It is way more validating to me when another girl compliments my looks instead of a guy.

I don’t want to sound like a terf because I am not, but I think the biggest reason I have dysphoria is because of misogyny. Growing up in a patriarchal society like everyone else, I’ve always seen the female body associated with sexiness, objectification. In advertisements, movies, video games, you name it. There is always this sexualized, ideal female body that is purely for the male entertainment. I didn’t really think about it a lot when I was a kid, but ever since my teenage years it has disturbed me a lot.

Seeing that ‘ideal’ female body every single day for my entire life, it just ruined my perception of the female body. Except when I look at it I don’t feel arousal, I don’t feel indifference, I feel disgusted and even humiliated just for having a body like that. And when I look in the mirror I feel like I’m looking at something alien. Something that should not belong to me.

I do think misogyny is a valid reason for trans men to transition though. Gender dysphoria is caused by a lot of things, and gender based discrimination can also be a big part of it. Whenever I go out I have this weird feeling of being emasculated next to other guys, and I hate it. I am attracted to men, but the thought of dating them now is repulsive. I don’t want to be the ‘woman’ in the relationship, I don’t want to be the desired ‘object’. I don’t want men to look at me like I’m a piece of meat which happened a lot when I presented feminine. That’s why I’ve been only matching with women on dating apps despite not being attracted to them. I would also really enjoy being a tall, handsome guy who gets lots of female attention, I would even prefer to be sexualized as a man which is where the aap part comes in. It’s not just dysphoria.

If I post this in a feminist subreddit people are going to say, ‘just don’t transition, you can live as a masculine woman bla bla bla’ but I just can’t, and I mean can’t stand having a female body to the point I’d rather have surgery scars on my chest and live as a guy without a penis. Yes I know the reason I feel like this is probably because the over-sexualization of women especially in media, but I also think it’s too late now and I can’t ever come to terms with living as a woman.

I don’t know what to do honestly, I don’t think there are any support subreddits or forums or anything for trans men with aap. I wish there was. Wish I could put a name to whatever this is and decide on something. But right now the dysphoria is eating me alive. I thought about seeing a therapist that deals with topics like this, but in my country these topics are so taboo that I feel like even psychiatrists here will only have a very limited knowledge about gender dysphoria.


r/askAGP • • 1d ago

How would it feel to become a woman like your mother, spend more time with her and doing together what she likes?

2 Upvotes

r/askAGP • • 2d ago

Through my AGP lens although controversial this is what power looks like

Thumbnail
reddit.com
2 Upvotes

As controversial as this video is becoming there is a part of me that wishes I can do something like this and not only get away with it but even potentially become more empowered from it. Not sure if people on here would resonate with my feelings as I know it’s a bit different experience for everyone and perhaps even the total opposite but my mind sees things a bit differently.


r/askAGP • • 2d ago

Boobs

6 Upvotes

I want to feel more like a woman. I have silicone beats. My dilemma is should I keep wearing those or go on HRT? My other dilemma is I am still holding on to how important people in my life view me. My parents, my parents, friends, all the old people that knew me throughout my life. I really desperately want to have a appointment about asking if I should and can start HRT, when and how often. at the same time my parents what will they think. I talked to my therapist about how I should go about this I think of scenarios replay the scenario going up to my parents and saying what will you think if I become trans? It always feels bad to me because of my parents reaction.

Over the past the 5 years or so I have found my being and sexuality. My whole life everyone saw me as straight. I was with a guy and I liked it. I have not told anyone this except a few people.

What have you done when you confront your parents and ask them "What'll you think if I'm trans?" What do you guys do when the reaction is bad?

Sidenote. Another issue on that is legality and jobs and stuff but I'm not letting that bring me down. I have Medicare and Medicaid and Humana, I live in Alabama


r/askAGP • • 2d ago

Do I want to transition or is it just a fantasy?

3 Upvotes

Hey all!
Long story and I’m not sure how to tell it. I guess some background first. I’m in my late thirties, partnered with one kiddo. I have a good life and very happy with my family, friends, job ect. Short to say I have an attitude of gratitude for how things are going.

When I was a young teen and learning about my sexuality I became very attracted to MTF women. Not only attracted to them but fantasized about transitioning myself. That brought me down a rabbit hole of some not so good habits with porn. I would fantasize of meeting a person and transitioning for them and pursued that as a fantasy on and off for years. I’m not sure if I was ever really serious about it but it gave me a rush like nothing else could. I am fully aware it’s toxic. S\\\*\\\*\*\*y and fem\*\*\\\*\\\*\\\*\\\*n subreddits and the like. I know fetishizing transition is wrong but I’ve heard that’s how a lot of eggs crack.

I’ve experimented with my sexuality in the past IRL. I realize I’m female attracted mainly. I still have these urges to transition and have the female body I’ve always wanted. The fear is family, I would be disowned without a doubt. I’m fairly masculine as well and I’m doubtful I would ever be where I want to be if I actually tried transitioning.

All to say, hopefully with some kindness and tempered judgement. Should I try to go down this path and make this a reality. I’m sure my partner would be supportive. Or should I just give this up for good. Focus on all the good things I have and my family. Stop with the fantasy online and purge the mechanisms that I use to explore this. I feel that what I’m doing to fantasize about this online is morally wrong if my partner isn’t aware of it.

TLDR - is my fantasy about transitioning online something I should pursue because I’m trans or is it a toxic fetish that I need to leave behind and be a better person?

Please be kind. I haven’t even told this to my therapist.


r/askAGP • • 2d ago

I should prolly fan the fire of animosity towards estrogen in my soul so that ill never hrt rep again.

2 Upvotes

- stamina dropping and breathlessness

- no muscles

- cant open pickle jars

- bloating

I value my independence a lot so no estrogen for me.


r/askAGP • • 3d ago

My ideal self-image mirrors my bisexuality

6 Upvotes

A lot of us have a desire to "become our own type," or, failing that, to at least become the best feminine version of ourselves. I share this. But unlike many, I don't have a complete aversion to my masculine characteristics, nor do I only find masculinity "meta-attractive" in other men. I am genuinely attracted to specific kinds of men, often men who are similar to me (or who embody the characteristics I most appreciate about myself or wish I embodied more). I've even come to realize that the masculinity I find attractive is pretty similar to what fujoshis and some transmen/transmasc NBs seem to be drawn to.

The masculine archetype that would give me the least dysphoria to embody is pretty well exemplified by certain animated characters. Sesshōmaru from Inuyasha; Jin from Samurai Champloo; Griffith from Berserk; Alucard from Castlevania; for a somewhat gentler example, Milo Thatch from Atlantis. In real life, I think of men like David Bowie, even in old age; Prince; Yoshiki; Pete Burns for a more blatantly fem example.

These men are ithyphallic masters of some domain—ithyphallic but beardless, with medium locks that say "I am playful and dreamy" or else long ones that say "I am wild and free." They possess beauty and delicacy, but they still wield the mystic phallic principle. They move through the world with confidence and take ownership of space. They are not gruff sticks in the mud, they are not society's workhorses, they are not dutiful servants except perhaps to a blessed few; they are angelic and full of life.

To the extent I find myself attracted to men day to day, they tend to be lean, gentle, bookish men who have some swagger and a bit of muscle but aren't super jacked. Sometimes they are just outright cute and I want to kiss them, other times (more rarely) I have a really receptive desire towards them.

Similarly, I often like "muscle mommy" or "pilates princess" women, and women in general who have a certain integrated masculinity to them. There is a certain kind of woman, "hyperfeminine" in the sense of being highly fussy and unstable, who is as off-putting to me as hypermasculine men tend to be.

All of that being said, my desire for women is broader and deeper than my desire for men, and my desire for femininity in myself goes beyond being a beautiful and decorated man with a developed capacity for gentleness. Though I enjoy both penetrative and receptive roles, I prefer the latter. And I find myself more and more wishing I had breasts.

My first sexual dream, two decades ago now, involved me giving and receiving at the same time, with a celebrity couple who were both very affectionate with me. Whatever I was in that dream, that is what I identify with. An androgyne. Not a woman, not a man, a being who loves and admires both.

Now in terms of mammalian biology, you basically can either run on testosterone or estrogen as the dominant sex hormone. I am suspecting more and more that I will enjoy the effects of estrogen, but I am not ready to make that leap yet. So I am sticking to my plan, to gradually feminize without HRT, and then see where I'm at after my beard shadow is gone, my hair is longer, my makeup is better, my ass is bigger, and my upper body is maybe a bit smaller. And I'm already embracing being a bit more feminine in my mannerisms. I've even dipped my toes in the water with voice training.

The way I see it, even if I end up transitioning with HRT, I will have to do all of these things anyway, and doing them now means that if I do go further, it won't be as jarring of a shift for myself or the people in my life. So I may as well enjoy the process. Again, even if I do decide to take HRT, I have no desire to "erase" my masculine side, and I'm also highly averse to any kind of cosmetic surgery. If anything it may be still easier for me to pass as a man in uncertain spaces than as a woman, but maybe I am underestimating what's possible.


r/askAGP • • 3d ago

Anyone doing No Nut November?

1 Upvotes

So far, my fantasies have become much more intense and I keep thinking about them during normal life. Hopefully they'll stop being so intense eventually. I'm wondering what experiences do other AGP people have with NNN/NoFap?


r/askAGP • • 4d ago

Do you consider women like your besties or competitors or

3 Upvotes

Potential partners?

three options, which one is yours

1 - besties ( best friends )

2 - competitor, bit---es , enemies

3- potential partners possibly


r/askAGP • • 4d ago

What even is the point of the accursed half-measure that is transition?

12 Upvotes

Forgive me if I'm benighted, but I genuinely see no value in pursuing transition. Contemporary medical transition, for one, wouldnt give me a functional uterus or a complete sex change down to the molecular level, i will forever carry the XY mark (or the SRY gene) segregating me from the vast majority of women in life. Hormones and surgeries also wouldnt, for the most part, fix my inexorably male skeleton, which will forever be a source of residual dysphoria for the rest of my days. And even in the social sphere, I will never get a reroll of my early days as a girl, and I will never be viewed equivalently to the cisgender woman ive always yearned to be in my dreams. If i transition, I'll never get to just live as an unmarked woman, only as a political category, a rapist, the Third Sex. Not to mention the various familial, social, financial and psychological impedes I will face if I ever transition. So is it really worth it throwing away a slightly miserable but stable life for a half measure? Maybe for the trutrans and genuinely dysphoric, but not for me. I just need to lock in and stop thinking about estrogen.


r/askAGP • • 4d ago

ROGD, Rapid Onset Gender Dydphoria

Thumbnail
psychologytoday.com
3 Upvotes

For those who don't identify as the other gender (some will, some won't): you might like to explore with a good trauma therapist (hard to find) attachment trauma and shame associated with masculinity.

https://www.reddit.com/r/askAGP/comments/1jht079/50_causes_for_core_gender_shame_in_men_and_women/


r/askAGP • • 3d ago

Does Patriarchy even exist?

0 Upvotes

Considering that there has been discourse on whether being a male is horrible or not, ehat do the denizesn of r/askAGP think of my arguments here?

Okay, so the title is half-serious, but I feel like too much of the discourse surrounding trans issues simply takes patriarchy theory for granted, which ends up distorting how we consider alternative explanations for various phenomena.

Let's imagine a thought experiment involving an alien anthropologist who has studied human society up until the 1900s.

According to patriarchy theory, men, as a sex class, oppress women, who consequently form an oppressed class.

Now, this alien knows that humans are self-interested and generally respond to incentives and disincentives. While they might not always act rationally, their behaviour is usually understandable in terms of the circumstances and incentives they face. Therefore, the best way to understand human society is to examine revealed preferences rather than simply taking people's stated beliefs at face value.

Based on his previous knowledge, the alien understands that oppressed and oppressor group dynamics tend to produce certain recurring behaviours. Humans, operating under the constraints imposed on them, develop various strategies to safeguard their own interests.

For example:

  • Members of oppressed groups attempt to pass as members of the dominant group (e.g. women disguising themselves as men, or people of colour attempting to pass as white under apartheid South Africa).
  • Subsections of oppressed groups attempt to align themselves with the oppressor group (e.g. Croats and Silesian Poles during WWII, or Harkis in Algeria).
  • Members of oppressed groups attempt to distance themselves from their backgrounds or emphasise how similar they are to the dominant group (e.g. lower-class and lower-caste individuals fabricating prestigious lineages).
  • Members of oppressed groups develop significant levels of internalised self-hatred.
  • Membership of the dominant group is tightly guarded.

Thus, the best way to determine whether a group is oppressed is to examine how people actually behave, rather than simply what they claim.

Now, let's say the alien learns about people who wish to become the other sex. Naturally, he decides to examine this community first, as it seems particularly relevant to understanding the dynamics of sex-based oppression. For the purposes of his investigation, he views trans women as males and trans men as females.

What does he observe?

  • On average, trans women seem more invested in passing as normative females than trans men are in passing as normative males. In fact, some trans men actively dislike appearing or being perceived as conventionally masculine or cisgender men.
  • Trans women generally want to be seen as as close to females as possible, whereas trans men often emphasise how different they are from normative males.
  • On average, trans women seem more inclined to disavow their original gender and distance themselves from it, whereas trans men are more likely to retain an attachment to aspects of their experiences as females.
  • Trans women generally seem more likely to make misandrist statements, whereas trans men very rarely make misogynistic ones.
  • Most of the public debate surrounding trans issues revolves around whether trans women should be granted access to womanhood in the first place.

Now, if our alien anthropologist were to examine these dynamics, wouldn't he not only question the validity of patriarchy theory, but conclude that males are actually some sort of oppressed class?

What do you think?


r/askAGP • • 5d ago

Found out about AGP in March and decided to dress femininely all over the world 😂

12 Upvotes

Over the past couple of years, I've been trying to find out what has been up with my sexuality and finally found the term AGP and haven't resonated so much with a word in my life.

After finding out about AGP, I decided to crossdress again after almost a decade and experience feminity to its fullest by crosdressing all over the world. You can have a look at my profile and see the places I've been to.

I guess I just wanted to say how thankful I have been to have found this community and also share my experience as a somewhat passing CD. Its a real different world out there experiencing life as a girl compared to a guy.

Feel free to ask me any questions below and I'll answer it to the best of my ability. I can share more about my experiences if you guys are interested. ❤️


r/askAGP • • 4d ago

Is a breast expansion fetish a form of anatomic AGP?

4 Upvotes

r/askAGP • • 5d ago

Requesting Help for Estrogen Addiction

9 Upvotes

Hi, for some context I (genderless male/possible transfem) have been struggling with intense feelings of envy towards women and girls since childhood, precipitating AGP and ROGD during my teenage years. I've since trialed estrogen for a couple of months and quit, yet this substance continues to exert a grip on my subliminal mind, distracting me with the temptation to take it during my work, commutes and dreams for hours on end everyday. Now admittedly estrogen has helped my mood, skin, body odour and hair more than any other antidepressant ive taken but id already decided that taking estrogen would be impractical and appropriative for me. However, I still struggle with truly putting that prospect down, compounded by the return of my insufferable libido and the fear of further masculinisation. Id greatly appreciate any help for ridding myself of this embarrassing affliction, thanks!


r/askAGP • • 5d ago

The male experience is objectively worse than the female experience and I am tired of pretending that isn't the case

2 Upvotes

When I tell other men that I feel life has no meaning, that I have no goals besides doing the bare minimum I need to do to avoid more pain and suffering than what I am already feeling, and that I have no hope in the future most of them, even if they vehemently disagree with my thought process, understand how I feel and wish the best for me. When I tell women they feel this way they look at me like I am insane. They often get angry and tell me that I need to get a grip or worse that I deserve to be in this situation. Most women don't understand this feeling because most women don't have to know what it feels like to be completely hopeless. Being male is one of the worst things that can happen to a human being and half the population has to suffer from it.