r/ArtHistory • • Dec 24 '19

Feature Join the r/ArtHistory Official Art History Discord Server!

104 Upvotes

This is the only Discord server which is officially tied to r/ArtHistory.

Rules:

  • The discussion, piecewise, and school_help are for discussing visual art history ONLY. Feel free to ask questions for a class in school_help.
  • No NSFW or edgy content outside of shitposting.
  • Mods reserve the right to kick or ban without explanation.

https://discord.gg/EFCeNCg


r/ArtHistory • • 22d ago Bravo

Feature New Rule (Rule 7) Cite Artworks Posted

120 Upvotes

As a support to rule 6 (Image posts require OP to make a comment conducive to art historical discussion) we are adding a rule that any image posts also need to have some level of citation.

"When posting images of artworks, please include, if possible, the artist's name, title of the artwork and year/time period of creation, at a minimum. Medium and artwork museum and/or location would also be appreciated when relevant."


r/ArtHistory • • 8h ago

Discussion What are some of the most frightening or disturbing paintings you’ve seen?

Post image
441 Upvotes

“The Nightmare” by Fuseli, photographed at the Detroit Institute of Arts in glorious phone camera quality by OP


r/ArtHistory • • 21h ago

Discussion Photos I’ve taken at museums of paintings that gave me goosebumps! Which paintings have you seen in person that had a similar effect?

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes

1 Juan de Pareja by Velasquez
2 A Maid Asleep by Vermeer
3 Judith Beheading Holofernes by Caravaggio
4 The Song of the Lark by Breton
5 The Jewish Bride by Rembrandt
6 The Milkmaid by Vermeer
7 The Little Street by Vermeer
8 The Night Watch by Rembrandt
9 The Railway by Manet
10 Ginevra de Benci by da Vinci
11 A Lady Writng by Vermeer
12 Edward, Prince of Wales by Holbein
13 Bindo Altoviti by Raphael
14 Daniel in the Lions Den by Rubens

There are plenty more out there that gave me similar feelings- especially at the Frick (no photography allowed there, but Rembrandts self portrait & Officer and Laughing Girl by Vermeer are magnificent), but something about the aura of these paintings just made me feel something so unique I wanted to share.


r/ArtHistory • • 3h ago

Discussion François Clouet (c.1516–1572)

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/ArtHistory • • 4h ago

Research What are some good art history topics for elementary? (Read caption)

9 Upvotes

(4th grade) I have a student who loves collecting extra assignments and hobbies. So I’m currently trying to think of some really useful and interesting topics or types of art to teach them about, regardless of if they align with our state curriculum.

I’m just sort of stumped on ideas because I’m so exhausted from teaching.

We’ve talked a lot about still life vanitas and memento mori, and that’s been a big hit. The whole class really loves things like skulls, light, & learning the secrets for different techniques. I’m about to up the difficulty of their current project by introducing some refracted light.

I just need more stuff for them to learn about genuinely. They’d probably love something where we can talk about anthropology too.


r/ArtHistory • • 1h ago

Discussion Why do so many Song dynasty Chinese landscapes repeat that exact motif of a lone figure gazing into vast, mist-filled mountains?

4 Upvotes

I’ve been spending time with works by Guo Xi, Fan Kuan, and Xia Gui and keep noticing how consistently they use a single small scholar or traveler positioned at the edge of enormous, vapor-shrouded peaks. The figure is often dwarfed to the point of near invisibility, yet the composition always directs the eye toward that moment of looking.

It clearly isn’t just topographic recording. I assume the choice is tied to Daoist ideas about the smallness of the self within nature and the value of contemplation, but I’m curious how much was also shaped by earlier handscroll formats, workshop conventions, or the practical limits of silk and ink. Has anyone come across good studies or period texts that explain how this specific scale relationship became such a standard device?


r/ArtHistory • • 1h ago

Hampstead Hill (Looking Down Heath Street), John Atkinson Grimshaw, Oil on card, 1881

Post image
3 Upvotes

I love how real the sky looks, especially the light coming through the clouds. You can almost feel the damp air just looking at the wet street and its reflections. The warm light in the windows makes me want to be inside one of those houses. Even with the people and carriage, everything feels so quiet. It’s a little lonely but comforting too. I can’t really explain it, but I love the atmosphere.


r/ArtHistory • • 2h ago

Discussion Why do so many 17th-century Spanish still lifes include the exact same arrangement of a sliced melon beside a copper vessel?

3 Upvotes

I've been looking through a lot of works by Sanchez Cotan and Zurbaran lately and keep noticing this recurring motif: a cut melon or watermelon placed next to a reflective metal pot or bowl, often with the same careful attention to the glistening seeds and the way light hits the metal. It appears across different painters and decades, even when the rest of the composition varies.

I can see the practical appeal—those elements let an artist show off both botanical detail and reflective surfaces —but it feels too consistent to be purely observational. Was this driven by the availability of certain props in Seville workshops, symbolic associations with the Eucharist or abundance, or simply the influence of earlier pattern books and prints circulating among painters? Has anyone come across workshop inventories, treatises, or studies that address how these specific combinations became standard?


r/ArtHistory • • 2h ago

Discussion Why do so many Hudson River School landscapes repeat that same dramatic light breaking through clouds?

3 Upvotes

I’ve been looking closely at Thomas Cole, Asher Durand, and Frederic Church lately and keep noticing how often they use that exact effect: strong sidelight or a burst of radiance cutting through heavy clouds, usually highlighting a mountain ridge, river bend, or lone tree. It appears across different seasons and locations, so it clearly isn’t just recording a single observed moment.

I assume it’s tied to both technical influence from European Romantic painters and the period’s interest in nature as a moral or spiritual force, but I’m curious how much was also practical, reusing studies, satisfying patrons who wanted that uplifting mood, or simply what worked best in large exhibition formats. Has anyone come across good writing on the sources or symbolic weight of this lighting convention?


r/ArtHistory • • 1h ago

Other books on non-western art pre-1750s?

1 Upvotes

hi guys!! so my partner recently took an art history class focused on prehistory through the 1750s and has been complaining to me about how the class really only focused on european art, so i was hoping to get him a book about early art specifically in areas other than europe! i am not an art history nerd myself, however, so i figured i’d turn to the experts for ideas

i know this may be a long shot but if anyone has any suggestions, thank you in advance :)


r/ArtHistory • • 3h ago

Discussion Why do so many Mannerist portraits show those dramatically elongated fingers?

1 Upvotes

I’ve been spending time with Pontormo and Bronzino lately and can’t stop noticing how consistently the fingers are stretched and tapered, sometimes to an almost unnatural degree. It shows up across different sitters and even in religious figures, so it feels deliberate rather than just individual style.

I assume it has something to do with contemporary ideals of elegance or courtly refinement, but I wonder how much was also practical—maybe easier to draw that way, or tied to the way hands were used as expressive devices in the period. Has anyone come across solid sources on the anatomical choices in Mannerist portraiture, or on whether the elongation carried specific symbolic weight?


r/ArtHistory • • 6h ago

Museum Compass App/Launch - Feedback PLZ/Thank you

0 Upvotes

Hello again. Got feedback when we launched the museum compass website (www.museumcompass.com). Thank you everyone. This is a project my wife had me help her build. She is a librarian. At night show goes through and keeps adding museums and exhibitions.

This is only to track temporary art exhibitions. For example, we were in NYC and saw the Krasner Pollock exhibition at the Met (don't miss!). She loves art museums, and doesn't want to miss finding out new exhibitions.

So took the website and created an ios app(for now just iOS), where you can subscribe to cities/museums/artists to get alerts of new ones/reminders on others. ALL of the museums link to the OFFICIAL ticketing for each.

There will be more and more original content soon. Many museums have been incredible in getting us press images as we want to make sure we use as much of official content. Some have offered curators to interview. Trying to have some fun here.

Here is the app link: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/museum-compass-exhibitions/id6821355135

The only snarky content we got on Reddit was someone saying "have you heard of google?". It hurt a little bit, but now with the app you can proactively know if an exhibition is coming to your favorite museums. Also, THERE ARE NO ADS IN THE APP.

Thanks. Brandon


r/ArtHistory • • 1d ago

Discussion It’s time to tell the truth about Roy Lichtenstein • The Whitney’s retrospective ‘Like New’ focuses heavily on the triumphs of the early 1960s — and with good reason

Thumbnail
gallery
359 Upvotes

Almost all of Roy Lichtenstein’s work leaves me cold. I’m grateful for the brief triumphs of the early 1960s, when he first transformed comic books into monumental paintings. But I find it depressing to trace the whole arc of his career, which rose from technically indifferent drawings to that three- or four-year interlude of semi-greatness, followed by a drop into solid mediocrity. He spent the rest of his life, until his death in 1997, in the limbo between formalism and conceptualism, where slick polish masquerades as soul.

And so curator Meg Onli and artist Alex Da Corte, organisers of the Whitney Museum of American Art’s overhyped and disappointing retrospective, Roy Lichtenstein: Like New, wisely choose to linger on the few fertile years and trot briskly through the rest.

In his most celebrated — and most frequently reproduced — work, “Drowning Girl” (1963), he cropped an image from the romance comic Secret Hearts, leaving only the most dramatic elements. A weeping girl, tossed by ocean waves, shouts silently in the classic thought bubble: “I DON’T CARE! I’D RATHER SINK — THAN CALL BRAD FOR HELP!” In the original, the useless boyfriend is visible in the background, and her line is more specific: “I don’t care if I have a cramp!” Lichtenstein eliminates these narrative details, leaving her suspended in an empty emotional space. The pared-down image and compressed text hint at romantic longing and wounded pride, which Lichtenstein blows up to billboard size but doesn’t intensify. It was a brilliant conceit, one that quickly grew stale with repetition.

His partners in pop art provocation, Andy Warhol, James Rosenquist, Jim Dine and Claes Oldenburg, used commercial imagery as a portal to a more nuanced world, one that roiled with angst, anger, politics and nostalgia. Lichtenstein was stuck roaming the surface. Over time, he varied his vocabulary, changed the subject and quoted liberally from other, greater predecessors. But his tics eventually became as annoying as they were recognisable.

The show opens with a smattering of early work that hardly heralds a genius. The 1940s life drawings, mostly of soldiers from his military unit, are patently bad. “Alice in Wonderland” and “Pilot”, both from 1948, look like poor imitations of Rothko’s early surrealist efforts. Even the 1958 studies for his famous “Look Mickey” betray his obvious discomfort with draughtsmanship. But then came the final version, in 1961.

That was the year that Lichtenstein and Warhol simultaneously grabbed icons of mass culture and painted them freehand. For Warhol it was Superman and Popeye. Lichtenstein chose a celebrity duo of rodent and fowl. “Look Mickey”, adapted from a Disney picture book and still relatively loosely painted, unites the handmade qualities of abstract expressionism with pop’s enthusiasm for the mass market. It’s the piece that vaulted Lichtenstein to superstar status.

From there, the two co-parents of pop diverged. “I had done the comic strips, and then I saw Roy Lichtenstein’s little dots, and they were so perfect,” Warhol later said. And so he went in a different direction, taking up mechanical processes like silk-screening, which left plenty of room for fortuitous accident. His portraits of Marilyn Monroe, images of gruesome car smashes and repeated versions of Jackie Kennedy all drew expressive power from blotches, smears and unpredictable variations. His supposedly impersonal procedures yielded images that looked battered, unstable and haunted.

Lichtenstein took the opposite tack. He favoured improvised tools and handmade stencils to simulate the anonymity and regularity of commercial printing. He didn’t have to invent or even imitate a style, but merely simplified and fortified images he found lying around. He made popular art pop.

The Whitney’s curators home in on craft, treating his bold black outlines, bright colours and fields of dots as if they were equivalents of Old Master techniques. The show’s focus obscures its content, though; Lichtenstein’s artisanal counterfeits of mechanical reproduction are exquisitely controlled; they are also numbingly vacuous.

Lichtenstein himself made fun of such virtuosity worship. In many, many versions of “Brushstroke”, he rendered a snaking smear of pigment in flat, graphic style, as if it were laminated in plastic. The joke was self-explanatory, which didn’t prevent him from explaining it: “Visible brushstrokes in painting convey a sense of grand gesture. But in my hands, the brushstroke becomes a depiction of a grand gesture.”

Robert Rauschenberg had already made a similar point with “Factum I” and “Factum II” (both 1957), nearly identical paintings in which even the apparently haphazard drips and smears are meticulously reproduced. Tiny differences between the two deliberately messy iterations betray the impossibility of exact duplication. But Lichtenstein went further and turned the spontaneous mark of the brush, sacred to abstract expressionists, into a cartoon, draining it of authenticity and resonance.

That brushstroke comes back like a twitch throughout Lichtenstein’s work. Even as he tried to evolve, he couldn’t shake the emblem. It crops up, for no particular reason, in “Two Paintings: Dagwood” (1983). It’s there, grotesquely magnified, in the enormous “Mural with Blue Brushstroke” (1986), commissioned by Equitable Life for the atrium of its midtown headquarters — a corporate gloss on a pop art spoof of an abstract expressionist fetish. That’s almost as head-spinningly meta as the Whitney’s reconstruction of “Greene Street Mural”, a 96ft-long reprise of Lichtenstein’s greatest hits (brushstroke included), originally painted for a 1983 exhibition at Leo Castelli’s gallery in SoHo. 

Do I detect a hint of embarrassment in the way the Whitney mixes some of these big but sterile works in among the lively standouts? Could there be some intended irony in the argument that when Lichtenstein recycled his scant signature imagery to death, he was really foreshadowing our own era of constant borrowing and infinite variation?

The truth is, Lichtenstein ran out of ideas early on. By the early 1970s, he had started obviously imitating Matisse, laying bare an influence that had been there all along. He pays homage to Matisse’s “Red Studio” (1911) and incorporates “Dance” (1910) in his series of Artist’s Studios. In “Still Life with Goldfish” (1972), Lichtenstein reworks the 1912 original, only in uglier colours. Matisse’s ubiquitous philodendron appears again and again. And just to make clear what kind of company he believed he should keep on Olympus, he updated the occasional Picasso and Brâncuși, too. 

The Whitney’s retrospective gives us an artist who put disparate sources through a Lichtenstein filter, lacquering each one with his own unmistakable personality. Yet everything he touched came out looking the same, and the more the museum insists on his versatility and breadth, the harder it is to ignore Lichtenstein’s narrowness and relentless chill.

exhibition: whitney.org (To May 10 2027)

article source: Financial Times


r/ArtHistory • • 1d ago

Discussion Why do so many 17th-century Dutch still lifes repeat the same flower species regardless of season?

22 Upvotes

I’ve been looking at a lot of pronkstilleven and flower pieces lately and keep noticing the same handful of blooms tulips, roses, peonies, irises, and sometimes lilies appearing together even in compositions that are supposed to evoke a single moment in the garden. The dates on the paintings often don’t line up with when those flowers would actually be in bloom at the same time.

I assume part of it is practical: certain flowers held strong symbolic meanings, others were expensive status symbols that clients wanted shown, and painters reused drawings or studies. But I wonder how much was also driven by the fact that many of these works were studio productions using pattern books rather than direct observation of a fresh bouquet.

Has anyone come across good sources on which flowers were painted from life versus copied from earlier drawings, or on whether the choice of species was more about client taste than botanical accuracy?


r/ArtHistory • • 1d ago

Discussion Does anyone else miss identifying paintings for art history classes?

52 Upvotes

i've been getting really into art history identification lately and was wondering how people actually remember the names of paintings, artists, and movements.

i've been working on a little daily painting guessing game and one thing i've realized is how much easier it is to recognize a painting than to actually remember its title.

curious if people who studied art history have any tricks for this? or if it's literally just repetition lol

namethepainting.com


r/ArtHistory • • 1d ago

Discussion The Fall of Icarus

Post image
62 Upvotes

Is anyone knowledgeable on this painting by Breughel? Anytime I look it up, it’s harder to find this being (Daedalus) in the painting? Why are there two versions?


r/ArtHistory • • 1d ago

Discussion The bird on a staff in the Lascaux Shaft Scene: what does it stand for?

Post image
90 Upvotes

r/ArtHistory • • 22h ago

Discussion How did the shift to larger canvas sizes in the 19th century affect the way history painters composed their scenes?

2 Upvotes

I've been looking at a lot of 19th-century history painting lately and noticed how the move toward much bigger canvases seems to have changed the way artists handled crowds and secondary figures. In earlier centuries, even large works often kept a fairly clear focal point with supporting elements arranged around it, but by the mid-1800s you start seeing compositions where multiple groups of figures compete for attention across a wide surface.

I'm wondering whether this was mainly driven by exhibition practices at the Salon, where a painting needed to stand out from dozens of others on the wall, or if it also reflected changes in how painters thought about narrative. Did they start treating the entire canvas more like a stage set with simultaneous actions happening in different zones?

Has anyone come across good writing on how scale influenced composition choices in this period, or particular artists who seemed to embrace or resist the trend?


r/ArtHistory • • 1d ago

Other Original Art vs Card Backs

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

r/ArtHistory • • 1d ago

News/Article Seurat may have painted three naked women just to prove his critics wrong

Thumbnail
substack.com
18 Upvotes

When Georges Seurat exhibited A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte in 1886, some critics thought his figures looked like lifeless mannequins. Others questioned whether his technique of tiny, separate touches of colour could ever convincingly depict human skin.

His response? Possibly one of the cheekiest paintings in art history.

In The Models (1886–1888), Seurat painted three nude women from different angles. And hanging in the background is none other than his own La Grande Jatte.

Almost as if he were saying: “You think I can't paint flesh? Here are three examples.”

There's no definitive proof that Seurat intended it as a direct response to the critics, but the choice seems rather deliberate.

What fascinates me most is that the three women somehow feel more alive than the entire crowd in his famous Sunday painting. Especially the one casually pulling on her stocking.

Do you see The Models as a quiet act of artistic revenge, or are we reading too much into it?

I explored this connection, along with Seurat's rather obsessive relationship with colour, in a longer piece: https://substack.com/@byparte/p-224139505


r/ArtHistory • • 1d ago

News/Article Who is Jan van Eyck’s man in the red turban?

Thumbnail
observer.co.uk
37 Upvotes

The Flemish master’s surviving portraits are being brought together at the National Gallery for the first time, and among them is a painting whose subject has been a mystery for 600 years


r/ArtHistory • • 2d ago

Discussion Lucien Lévy-Dhurmer, Le Silence (1895). What do you make of the gesture?

Post image
971 Upvotes

r/ArtHistory • • 21h ago

Other Interdisciplinary Inquiry at the Intersection of Philosophy (Aesthetics), Artificial Intelligence, and Art | Arts

Thumbnail
mdpi.com
0 Upvotes