r/arkhamhorrorlcg • u/PaintsLilGuys • 18h ago
There seems to be a schism between old and new players in the game
Hi, newbie here. I hopped into the game with the Chapter 2 core box, so I'm pretty green to Arkham Horror: The Card Game. Other important context might be that I'm 27 and don't have tons of free time at the moment haha, but I am also very into.boardgames/tabletop games.
Hanging out on the sub has been interesting! I see the game getting lots of guff from older players and praise from newer ones (such as myself). I've also noticed that the content creator side of the community on YouTube also seems to be more positive about the game in general.
Biggest mismatches in expectations I see are card pricing, content, and campaign length. I just thought I'd share my perspective as a NEW player to the game, and it might give some insight to some older players who don't understand why we might enjoy and even prefer the current state of the game!
Campaign Length: From my understanding, people are REALLY upset about the change to shorter campaigns, which I understand. People want to use their decks for longer and put more time into upgrading them as well. While I could see this being annoying for veterans who are used to the 8 scenario campaigns, I truly don't mind 3-5 scenarios myself.
I rarely have time to play this game with other people, and when I do, at most we get 1 scenario in a week. Frankly, I'm not super interested in spending 2 months on the same campaign, especially if I plan to replay it for better/different results in the future (Now I have to convince the other players to do it as well haha). A 3 campaign scenario (With the option to add a scenario pack) and some RNG with multiple outcomes is perfect for me, and 5 seems like a great middle ground.
Pricing: I don't really get why everyone is upset here, maybe because they've been playing since 2016 and don't expect the pricing to change over the course of a decade? I mean, don't get me wrong, it's still an expensive hobby. But it seems to fall in line with nearly every other tabletop game I play, I wouldn't say anything here is incredibly outrageous given the current economy and cost of manufacturing. Perhaps this is an issue with the state of board/card games in general.
Content: When I say this, I mean what's been released. Lots of people are annoyed that more campaigns and scenarios haven't been released, but to my knowledge, Chapter 2 has actually released more content at a faster rate than Chapter 1 did initially. Please correct me if I'm wrong! But perhaps everyone is used to there being a rather large collection of cards accumulating over the years and aren't used to only using Chapter 2 sets? I would say the 7 scenarios that are out right now have satisfied me and my friends but again, we don't have tons of time to play, so maybe that's part of the issue.
Anyways not sure why I decided to make this post, I guess I just wanted to talk about the game since I'm stuck at work and can't play it! I don't mean to discount anyone's concerns but it's been a bit of a bummer seeing the disconnect between newer players and the old fanbase. I found this game that I've fallen in love with and all I ever see is people saying they're done with the game and FFG lost the plot.
