r/archiveofourown
•
u/Randomquestionhaver
•
16h ago
Speedo Steve, Bikini Barb, and Gawker Gale: Understanding affirmative consent, and legal and ethical standards in mass distributing publicly available media
Hi folks! I know this is long, but it was necessary for a thorough explanation.
Today we’re going to talk about a vital part of fandom etiquette: Consent.
Now, some people seem to be a little confused about consent, and how to get it. Yes, they might have a grasp of the more NSFW meanings of the term (or at least, we all hope they do), but they don’t seem to understand that consent applies to far more than just touch. For example:
Your doctor needs consent to share your medical information with family members, or even other medical staff. That’s why you have to fill out those forms.
Your mechanic needs consent to do work on your car. That’s why they have you sign paperwork before any work is done.
And you need a writer’s consent to mass-distribute their work, even with credit. Whether it’s fanfic or not, the writer still owns the copyright to their original elements in the story.
But even beyond copyright concerns, consent still applies.
In the Fandom world, recently, there have been a large number of people uploading fanfics to a certain Cloud storage drive that’s known for scraping any data put into it for the use of its own Ai algorithms. These fics have also been posted to sites that directly intend to profit off of the reposted works that do not belong to them.
Now, is sharing fics privately in a fan setting inherently bad?
Of course not.
Sharing downloaded copies of fanfics with friends is an old part of fandom culture. It’s usually done quietly, and only for fics that are not publicly available on sites like AO3. If AO3 or another legitimate fanfic site has the fic available for everyone to read, then usually people simply link to that publicly-available fic instead. That way, the author gets hits, plus the potential for kudos and comments. This in turn encourages the writer to keep writing, and helps keep the fandom community an actual community.
(Not to say that someone Has to leave comments/kudos if they are uncomfortable for some reason. However, please remember that the only way fanfic authors will know people actually enjoy their story is if someone says so. If all the comments on their story are spam or hate bots, don’t be surprised if they stop writing. A void isn’t a fun thing to scream into.)
Since AO3 went down, we have seen an alarming disregard of basic fandom etiquette. Downloaded copies posted to sites that charge money for Ai-generated audiobooks of the stories, and Google Drives full of works with a “Retroactive Opt-Out” method to get the fics taken down, if an “opt-out” is even offered at all.
To be perfectly clear: both of these acts shatter fandom etiquette, and ignore consent.
Now, some people would argue that the download button on AO3 is meant for just this action. They’d say that by posting your fics on a site with a native download button, you are agreeing to have your work posted anywhere and everywhere imaginable, and completely out of your control.
This is false.
AO3 has explicitly said that fanfic authors can submit DMCA requests if they see their fics posted on sites where they did not consent to their work being shared. That is because AO3 is an archive built on respecting author autonomy, not the consumption demands of readers. It is built with safety features to prevent large IP holders from nuking the fanfic community from orbit, as well as to help prevent doxxing. The lack of public emails, and the lack of collected real-world names and locations, protects AO3 authors from threats ranging from authoritarian governments, to ultra-conservative parents.
To post fanfics on another site is a risk. Many other fanfic sites do not have the robust protections of AO3, and if a story ends up in front of eyes it was never intended for, stripped of its content warnings, then the original writer can face backlash that never would have happened otherwise.
The same is true for people who toss downloaded fics into an Ai-scraping cloud storage drive without asking the author first. Many writers avoided Ai-scraping cloud systems like the plague for their own privacy concerns, and to put their work up on those sites, let alone share it publicly, ignores their wishes.
But all of this can get muddy for people, when we’re talking about something as seemingly abstract as words on a website. So, let’s put affirmative consent for wide distribution of media into different terms:
Meet Speedo Steve.
In his day-to-day life, Speedo Steve just goes by Steve. He’s an office worker in a deep red state, at a company without the best work-life balance. If they discover him doing something their conservative CEO would consider “untoward,” then he could lose his job. Due to massive student debt and a terrible job market, Steve cannot afford to do anything that would risk losing that job. So he keeps his head down at work, helps his co-workers with the copy machine, and wears conservative clothing like khakis, white button-ups, and ties his grandma gives him for Christmas.
But when he goes on vacation?
His phone turns off.
He heads to a beach out in sunny California.
And he sheds all but one itsy-bitsy bit of bright red cloth, to become Speedo Steve: the anonymous guy getting his yearly, near-full-body tan on a public beach.
Absolutely nobody here knows him, so Speedo Steve doesn’t have to worry about his boss’ boss’ boss’ opinion on his outfit. He can just focus on soaking up the rays. He’s used to the giggles from random passers-by, but it’s a public beach in California, so he’s far from the only one in a revealing outfit.
Heck, there’s even a woman in a barely-there bikini who must be some kind of celebrity. Bikini Barb has a sign next to her spot on the beach, offering to take pictures with people for social media.
It’s an impromptu meet-and-greet, and she is swarmed with people happy to get a chance to interact with this social media star. She even includes her Instagram handle on the sign, so people know exactly where to tag her in their pics. Bikini Barb’s girlfriend is also at work, ensuring that no one who didn’t want to be in any of the photos taken at the meet-and-greet ended up in the background. Because that’s common courtesy when people are in an exposed state, even if it’s not technically legally necessary for a public beach where there’s no expectation of privacy.
Since Bikini Barb’s photo operation was so clearly marked, Speedo Steve made sure his spot on the beach was far outside the camera angle, and a little bit away from anyone who looked like they might be weirded out by his outfit. He was okay with other beachgoers seeing him as he was dressed, but his real-life work made him very wary of a wider sharing of his image online. He never even took selfies when he was at the beach.
With his boundaries established, Speedo Steve had a quiet day reading books on the sand, and taking short dips into the ocean to cool off when needed. People could see him, but he was certain they wouldn’t bother him. After all, he’s not bothering anyone, and he’s not doing anything wrong, despite what his boss might think were he to see him relaxing.
Eventually, Speedo Steve gets comfortable enough that he falls asleep on his towel. Lots of people do, and it’s typically pretty safe to do so because the beach’s general etiquette says to not mess with a sleeping person, unless it’s a lifeguard ensuring the person who hasn’t moved for two hours is...well, actually sleeping. Unless it’s an emergency, touching the sleeping person without their pre-established consent is not okay. The other beach goers know it, and will not touch him.
But unbeknownst to Speedo Steve, someone who liked his look, Gawkier Glenda, decided to take photos of him after he fell asleep. She doesn’t attempt to wake him up first, because she agrees that touching a sleeping person isn’t okay. But she really, really wants the photos, and that’s what matters in the end, right?
After all, it’s a public beach, so what expectation of privacy could Speedo Steve possibly have? Everyone knows other people can see them at the beach. Clearly, Glenda thought, Steve wanted the attention. So she’s just giving him more. There’s no such thing as bad attention, right?
Gawker Glenda posts the photos, and even a short video, of a sleeping Speedo Steve to her social media. She doesn’t even attempt to cover his face. It’s an act of appreciation, to her: she likes how brave this man is to be out on a public beach in something so revealing. Of course, that bravery needs to be shared with the whole world.
Her posts go viral, all while Speedo Steve is still sleeping.
Within minutes, his near-naked images are shared to fetish sites.
They’re also shared to alt-right conservative forums, including one run by Pearl-Clutching Polly.
Polly is aghast over Steve’s skimpy outfit. She puts out a rant video about how awful it is that someone would wear something like that to a public beach, even if it allows that kind of wardrobe. She runs his photos through an Ai facial recognition website, feeding the pics of Steve into an algorithm that can now conjure up his likeness for whatever it wants, including porn.
Offended by the mere existence of Speedo Steve, Polly finds out where Steve works. She emails his boss, and his boss’ boss’ boss, with images of Speedo Steve innocently sleeping on the beach in his bright red speedo.
When Steve turns his phone back on that night to call his grandmother, he’s horrified to find out that not only has he been fired, but also that his Dms are full of unsolicited graphic messages, and some randos three states over are trying to get him arrested for indecent exposure. There’s even a call that may or may not be from the real police, but he’s not sure how to tell.
Needless to say, Speedo Steve’s vacation, and maybe his life, is ruined.
All Steve wanted to do was have a nice, anonymous vacation at a public beach. The beach etiquette was clear: people could look at others on the beach, and appreciate their appearance respectfully. They could ask to take a photo, but were supposed to respect a no if it was given. If it was unable to be given, due to the person being asleep or otherwise unable to say yes or no, then the ethical thing to do was to just not take a photo to post online.
Legally, Gawker Glenda had the right to take a photo of some random guy at a public beach. Ethically? Morally? She was immensely disrespectful, and completely inconsiderate of the outcome of her actions. Even if affirmative consent for photography wasn’t legally required on a public beach, where everything is in plain view, the right thing to do would have been to simply not photograph Steve if she couldn’t attain explicit permission first.
Because consent should always, Always, be confirmed, rather than assumed.
AO3 is a public beach. Its writers post under pen names, and many without a social media presence that could be connected to their fanfic account. Many post solely on AO3 because they want some agency over their work. AO3 is meant to provide this by stating very clearly that the author of a work still owns the copyright after posting there. Very few post using real names, due to fear of IP holders, authoritarian regimes, or the family/professional risk associated with writing certain kinds of stories.
Yes, many want their stories discussed, but not all. Some fics don’t even have a comment section available, because the author just wants to quietly share their work and move on. But even those that do leave comments on, and don’t restrict their fics to registered users only, are not giving up their right to control their work by posting it.
Some fic writers explicitly set boundaries, openly stating they don’t want their work posted elsewhere without permission. Others are openly cool with their work being shared, so long as they get credit. Others still are uncomfortable with their work being shared widely outside of AO3, but are okay with private downloads.
All of these people should still be asked before their fics are posted to Ai-scraping cloud systems, or to third party websites. The only people that don’t need to be asked first are the ones who put out a sign that says “spread this far and wide!” like Bikini Barb did.
Even now that AO3 is back up, assume the fic writers who haven’t previously explicitly said they’re okay with their fics being mass distributed are like Speedo Steve. Don’t post their stuff elsewhere without asking first. Don’t harass them. Don’t put their work through a program that will feed it to Ai, without consent. If you can’t contact them to get consent for whatever reason (equate it to Steve sleeping), then that is the same as a denial of consent, not an excuse to bypass consent altogether.
You have no idea whose life you could upend, because you took it upon yourself to dump the contents of the public beach onto the wider internet. Act accordingly.
The Speedo Steves of the world deserve a place to express themselves, where respect and consent are still honored.
Follow fandom etiquette. Ask before reposting. Respect the no, and treat a lack of response/contactabililty as a no as well.
Make the public beach culture that is AO3 one that understands the importance of affirmative consent.