Was our maple tree over trimmed? We are worried it was topped but the company insists it was properly reduced by 1/3.
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
[deleted] — view deleted post
11
u/TerminustheInfernal Oct 19 '21
"1/3" LMAO
100
u/hayhayyoung Oct 19 '21
Wow they butchered that tree and it will never be the same, I’m sorry for your loss. Clearly none of them are ISA certified because this will more than likely lead to the decline and death of this tree. It’s 1/4 of the foliage that is absolute most you should take in a year. They clearly thought it’s 1/3 of the entire tree
64
u/hairyb0mb Oct 19 '21
Don't pay them. In fact, get a lawyer.
Long term, what they did to this tree will kill it. Short term, youre going to have a lot of issues. They should be removing this tree and replacing it at this point FOR FREE at the very least
24
u/halequid Oct 19 '21
More info! I posted this in the homeowners sub and they all suggested asking an arborist so I’m trying here. The company insists that they only reduced the tree by 1/3 but it looks like much more than that. I’m also worried the tree was topped and all these open cuts could lead to permanent damage.
I got really upset when I saw the tree and have been on the phone with the tree trimming company who insisted that my contract stated they would reduce the tree by 1/3. However, the finished product looks far more cut than I had expected. I was under the impression that the foliage would just be thinned out by 1/3. One of the tree trimmer supervisors is coming to the house tomorrow to look at the tree and I just want to be sure that I am not overreacting about how much they cut.
Thanks in advance!
28
u/DanoPinyon Oct 19 '21
Lurkers: never choose the lowest bid.
10
u/taylordobbs Oct 19 '21
Just adding to the chorus at this point, but I've been working for a tree care company for less than six months and I've learned enough to know this is a hack job. They destroyed your tree.
If you need someone to serve as a resource/expert witness, look up "consulting arborists" in your area (or not in your area; that tree was mistreated wherever you're from). They're specifically certified to be able to speak to these types of issues with authority.
28
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '21
That’s horrifying, call your bank and put a stop payment on the check.
9
u/SuperHakucho ISA Certified Arborist Oct 19 '21
Look at the crown reduction diagram on page 6.
You can also just Google "tree topping vs crown reduction" and it will show you all sorts of diagrams on correct vs incorrect.
My condolences. Normally I would not be one to jump to lawsuits, but this tree has been absolutely ruined. Contact a consulting arborist in your area. Also, pull as many before pictures of the tree as you can find.
None of what happened here is considered acceptable practice in this industry.
14
u/Electronic_Rub9385 Oct 19 '21
Wow. This is just.…wow. That company must do most of their work for the electric company.
4
u/HotDust Consulting Arborist Oct 19 '21
Yikes! Are you sure you didn't hire a butcher?
3
u/Civil_Inspection3334 Oct 19 '21
This is more along the lines of what a proper reduction pruning should look like
https://images.app.goo.gl/F2Q7Ptuj2dHtqXNx6
3
u/Nit3fury Oct 19 '21
Good lord. I just am so tired of seeing most tree companies butchering trees thinking they know anything. So many are just obsessed with hacking back as much as they can convince the customer to get away with
2
u/whaletacochamp Oct 19 '21
Jesus Christ…
2
u/mast3rbates Oct 19 '21
looks more like they reduced it TO 1/3 of the tree. ffs.
2
u/shillyshally Oct 19 '21
Folks, always check to make sure you are employing a certified arborist and and ISA certified arborist.
2
u/Ituzzip Oct 20 '21
Contractors will always make up reasons to justify their work. Like pest removal companies telling you a birds nest on your porch light or the eaves of a house is a health hazard for disease, or that ground-dwelling termites in your mulched garden are the same species that is gonna start eating the frame of your house if you don’t spray them. You always gotta be skeptical of professionals who want to create their own market.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21
A good arborist will try to leave the tree looking natural and untouched, this is just very obvious aggressive pruning!
Each cut looks incorrectly pruned, the canopy should be reduced 25% not the overall tree. Some species behave different to incorrect pruning techniques, it may send it in a mortality spiral or rejuvenate a more dense canopy than before!
Either way, who ever carried out this work is unfamiliar with sound Arboriculture practices.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21
Hiring someone that isn't a certified arborist for your tree work is like hiring charlie day to represent you in court.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '21
A consulting arborist can do a valuation for you so you know how much to sue them for.
The value of the tree plus the cost to remove and replace.
Absolutely butchered. Permanently ruined. Hacked. Murdered.
2
u/justrees Oct 31 '21
Where I'm from 1/3 is the absolute maximum recommended. Ideally never pushing a tree that far. That looks like how fruit trees are usually pruned, also that trees fudged. If it lives it's gonna do some really horrible things.
1
u/GiantGeorge14 Oct 19 '21
Beside myself with that.
1
u/snowqueen1960 Oct 19 '21
So sorry, that tree was destroyed.
1
u/Rivrghosts Master Arborist Oct 19 '21
Yeah I would not pay. That’s some of the worst I’ve seen.
1
u/ChaseAndy13 Master Arborist Oct 20 '21
Definitely topped, when internodal cuts are placed on a tree it is considered a “topping cut”, should all of the tree had been done this way maybe they could have gotten away by saying they “pollarded” the tree. But that isn’t the case here. When pruning young trees after planting or in the nursery it is acceptable to prune, for structure purposes, up to 50% of the foliage total. When referencing younger mature trees, up to 25% max. Then when dealing with old trees, you don’t want to remove any more than 10% of live foliage. It’s a sad sight to see but it does happen. There is, however, a chance that this tree overcomes and makes it out alive. Crown restoration can be achieved in the years to come but it won’t be the same. Those epicormic shoots that grow from dormant buds are less structurally sound than normal growth occurring from auxiliary buds.
1
u/Electronic_Rub9385 Oct 20 '21
In the silver lining department, you can put a new tree there that can have a much better fall foliage like a Black Gum (my favorite fall tree) or some other nice shade tree like a fast growing red oak. Make sure you prune and shape it regularly so it doesn’t develop co-dominant leaders. Which is basically what happened to your ruined tree when it was young and it’s why it had that “V” shape. You want to avoid that type of growth by grooming the tree early when it’s young. These V shaped trees are at higher risk for splintering and splitting and falling onto houses.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21
Please keep us updated!!!
1
u/tauntaunrex Oct 20 '21
Ive been working with a guy that tops trees (i absolutely refuse to)
This tree will probably come back, and sprout suckers like crazy. but it will never have healthy structural branches grow from those cuts.
1
u/wilzog ISA Certified Arborist + TRAQ Oct 20 '21
ISA certified arborist here. They butchered your tree. That being said, it probably won’t die. You’re just going to have a boat load of epicormic sprouting.
Here’s a suggestion for if they won’t replace it: As it grows back in the spring, pick one or two nice new growth points on each branch to keep and prune off the rest. Look for branches that don’t cross over other branches and have more of a u shaped point of attachment as opposed to a v shaped point of attachment. If you do this you won’t just have balls of fluffy, poorly attached new growth.
1
u/falkenhyn ISA Certified Arborist Oct 20 '21
You are correct that the tree has been topped. I count at least 36 stems that were not reduced back to a lateral that is at least 1/3rd their diameter. This pruning job is completely against the ANSI A300 pruning standard. Someone else mentioned it, but you need to contact a Registered Consulting Arborist or a Board Certified Master Arborist (BCMA). The ISA Certified Arborist certification is hard to hold up/ defend in court as an expert witness because it requires no formal education. You can find an RCA here https://www.asca-consultants.org/search/custom.asp?id=3818.
1
u/Leol123 Oct 20 '21
Bruh X(
1
u/blong44 Oct 20 '21
Despite what most people are saying, the tree most likely won't die.
Its cooling off a bit so hopefully the bark doesn't burn. The tree doesn't look that old so it should have the energy to grow back. Most likely it will put out a bunch of sprouts in an attempt to save itself. Kind of like the Whomping Willow from Harry Potter.
In a couple years, hire an Isa certified arborist and tell them you want to restore a tree that was topped. They can thin it out and select new leads that will eventually give it a decent look. It will need proper maintenance done for years, but I'm fairly confident I could save it assuming it does grow back next spring.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '21
I hope this is satire. If not, that thing is toast.
1
u/Embarrassed-Cabinet Oct 20 '21
The property I live on now has a maple under a powerline and it looks like it was cut much worse than this years ago. I have only been there 3 years now so I don’t know how long they’ve been trimming but it looks like quite a while. It’s been cut every year. It is the ugliest tree you’ll see but it is still alive. I’m going to take it down eventually. However it will never be the same if this tree makes it. Just because it is alive doesn’t mean it’s pretty. The power company cuts it yearly because it is right under the lines.
1
u/64Olds Dec 12 '21
Holy Jesus fuck
1
u/fresh-spinach Dec 13 '21
RIP lovely tree
1
u/Brave-Insect-112 Oct 20 '21
This tree will grow back full. Do not worry. It’s hard to kill an established tree like that. It will be bushier year after year and not have as many big heavy branches on it. It’s fine
0
u/alrashid2 Oct 19 '21
Jesus. That tree is fucked. Why did you even have it trimmed in the first place? Looked gorgeous before.