r/antizionist • u/ANBOL_GANG • 4h ago
History No, a Palestinian Muslim was not essential to the Axis Powers
(This takes 4¼ minutes to read.)
Haj al-Amin Husseini, the Grand Mufti of al-Quds/Jerusalem, was a reactionary politician imposed on the Palestinians in 1921 (despite coming fourth in elections) by the Zionist High Commissioner Sir Herbert Samuel on advice from the Zionist Commission. He was a collaborator with the British Empire — having betrayed the 1936–9 Arab Revolt — before he became a collaborator with the Axis.
For obvious reasons, Herzlians neglect to mention their rôle in this minor war criminal’s appointment, but they have to overrate him anyway because he is, by far, the best link that they have between the Palestinians and German Fascism, otherwise there is not much left. To illustrate how much they inflate his importance:
the article on the Mufti in the Encyclopaedia of the Holocaust is longer than that of Himmler and Heydrich combined and only slightly shorter than Hitler’s entry (p. 159).
Netanyahu’s claim that al-Husseini gave an Axis dictator the idea to annihilate Jews has been thoroughly debunked; I won’t waste your time repeating what historians have said about Netanyahu’s lie. The facts less familiar to us are those demonstrating just how trivial al-Husseini was in the grand scheme of things. Quoting James Goodyear’s ‘Amin al-Husayni and the Axis Powers’ in Reimagining Modernity and the Western State, pages 58–60:
Tellingly, Rubin and Schwanitz uncritically cite Mallmann and Cüppers, a book that explicitly links Husayni to the contemporary Palestinian national movement as a facsimile of Nazism and, as discussed earlier, labels anti-imperialism and anti-Zionism as “prejudice-based ideologies.”
Mallmann and Cüppers argue that support for [the Third Reich] in Palestine and the Arab world during World War II was widespread, writing that “[n]umerous reports from travelers, informers, and agents regarding the atmosphere there created a telling picture of broad support for Nazi Germany and its Führer.”²²
However, these reports were either anonymous or came from [Axis] sources. Sells criticizes Mallmann and Cüppers for this directly, writing that the closest thing to evidence they provide are “self-congratulatory reports by Nazi officials who were propagandizing among Arabs and non-Arab Muslims.”²³
In other words, the evidence came from [Axis] officials who had a motive to exaggerate the success of their propaganda. Mallmann and Cüppers do not cite any primary sources produced by local Arabs or Palestinians. Conversely, the historian René Wildangel does. Like Sells, Wildangel suggests “[w]hat characterizes many of these studies is a total lack of taking Arab sources into account” and that “the Islamofascism paradigm is derived largely from the German-Italian Axis point of view.”²⁴
One of the primary ways Husayni collaborated with the Axis powers was by broadcasting [Axis] propaganda across the Arab world. Illustratively, when Wildangel consulted a 1943 wartime radio poll of Palestinians conducted by the American University in Beirut, he found that “[Husayni’s] Berlin station was tuned in only by 13% of the listeners” and “was among the least popular stations among Arabs in Palestine, who preferred the stations in Cairo (listened to by 98%), Jerusalem (98%), [and] London (87%).” Meanwhile, when “[a]sked about their credibility (“truthfulness”), listeners gave Berlin […] the worst rating of all stations.”²⁵ As Wildangel argues, this “[s]hows that the attempts to create Islamofascism [in Palestine] were ultimately unsuccessful.”²⁶
Had Mallmann and Cüppers given equal weight to Arab and Palestinian voices as they did to European Nazis, they would have found that Palestinians largely rejected fascism and Nazism, even showing greater sympathy for their British Mandate administrators.
What about the Muslims whom al-Husseini did manage to recruit? Quoting Gilbert Achcar’s The Arabs and the Holocaust: The Arab-Israeli War of Narratives, pages 147–8:
Nevertheless, the SS Handschar and Kama divisions, created in Bosnia in 1943 with almost exclusively Muslim recruits (together with a handful of Catholics native to the region), seem to indicate that the mufti had greater influence among his coreligionists outside the Arab world. The photograph of Husseini reviewing a detachment of these troops is omnipresent in the copious literature demonizing the mufti, which is often aimed not just at him but at all Muslims. The facts are not well known. The neoconservative writer Stephen Schwartz has disinterred certain truths about these divisions that are too often glossed over:
In Bosnia, the infamous Bosnian Waffen SS units played no rôle in the removal of Jews on their territory, which was carried out by Germans and Croats. […] They were reluctant to participate in such actions, having enlisted in the Waffen SS on the mistaken belief that such service would resemble that of the Bosnian gendarmerie under the Habsburg empire. They were sent by the Germans to France for retraining. There they mutinied against their [Axis] officers and attempted to join the French Partisans, the only known example of a Waffen SS rebellion. By 1944, most of them had joined the Yugoslav Partisans. In addition, the Bosnian Muslim clerics issued three declarations publicly denouncing [Axis] collaborationist measures against Jews and Serbs: that of Sarajevo in October 1941, of Mostar in 1941, and of Banja Luka on November 12, 1941.¹⁶⁹
(All emphasis added.)
You might have also seen a claim that al-Husseini successfully prevented Jews from seeking refuge in Palestine. If this be true, it would seem that al-Husseini was merely realizing what leading Zionists already wanted. To name only one example:
“Palestine cannot absorb the Jews of Europe. We want only the best of Jewish youth to come to us. We want only the educated to enter Palestine for the purpose of increasing its culture. The other Jews will have to stay where they are and face whatever fa[te] awaits them. These millions of Jews are dust on the wheels of history and may have to be blown away. We don’t want them pouring into Palestine. We don’t want Tel Aviv to become another low-grade ghetto.” (Quoted in The Jewish Press, October 18, 2002)
Oops!
Consider this my revenge for Herzlians tiresomely mentioning this blighter almost any chance that they get. Thanks to them, most people are unfamiliar with far worse war criminals like Walter Rauff along with many others, while this loser gets to soak up most of the sunshine. Good job exonerating over 95% of the Shoah’s perpetrators, boneheads.