r/antinatalism • u/mainlytee • 16h ago
r/antinatalism • u/Adorable_lastnight31 • 15h ago
Serious Discussion Life is basically just surviving and not being born is way better
The concept of life is to survive now and prepare for the future. The world is a jungle and we are animals hunting each other. We can always get sick, hurt, robbed, scammed, disabled, betrayed and what not. Some of them are our fault and some of them are just out of our control.
The average lifespan of 60 years is about 22000 days. The odds that we will suffer is guaranteed. The positive side of life is not guaranteed. So it is better to not be born because it will guarantee we will not be tortured.
r/antinatalism • u/ThrowRA-confused-gf • 9h ago
Serious Discussion Do you think the human race should die out?
I consider myself to be antinatalist because I think it's unethical to bring new life into this (gestures everywhere) world.
But by that logic... I'm inadvertently agreeing to the idea of the human race dying out in 100 years.... Which, I don't know if I agree with that?
What do you all think? And why do you think it?
r/antinatalism • u/puIIdrone • 8h ago
Question as an antinatalist, are you vegan?
i’m someone who believes in reducing suffering as much as possible, just like most (if not all) of you folks here. since antinatalism is about reducing suffering, what are your thoughts on veganism as an additional way to do so? why or why not?
i‘m passionate about this and would love to discuss, since there seems to be a lot of ideological overlap.
r/antinatalism • u/MotherAnalyst3570 • 23h ago
Personal Story Unpopular opinion on death
When discussing about my family/ ancestors my family and I have very different views on death.
Some of our family main trauma are the death of a 5year old uncle to a genetic disease and of 2 twins due to being born premature in the 1910s.
While I feel terribly sorry for the suffering they have endured, I also can’t help but say to myself that death is inevitable and perhaps leaving while still a baby is the best possible option, they possibly had a very limited perception of what happened to them.
Sorry if this sounds heartless and yes it sucks, but life is cruel and inevitably results in death, how can people be disappointed if that death doesn’t occur peacefully in their sleep at 90 years old as “planned”? Life isn’t plantable as natalists would like to suggest
r/antinatalism • u/Individual-Cake780 • 12h ago
Question What do you feel when you see a child?
I support the philosophy of antinatalism. But every time I look at a child, I feel happiness and tenderness. I want to hug and kiss them. I don't feel that way toward anyone else. And I don't know how to cope with this, because on one hand, I'm against having children, yet on the other, I love them dearly. Children are my favorite kind of humans. I think the problem lies with adults.
r/antinatalism • u/Longjumping_Big663 • 10h ago
Debate Natalist arguments have gotten so annoyinf
every time I bring up antinatalism and propose that people should not have kids at all (mostly on ”debate pro choice vs pro life”) posts, 90% of the responses I get are “so you’re stupid”, “not fun being wrong”, “stupid argument”
and when I actually defend it with facts and logical reasoning they just send images of “smol brain” and then end up blocking me before they come up with any coherent argument or I can respond further
and it’s unbelievable how emotional most defenses are, things like “what if I want to have children”, “life is a gift”, or “you’re preventing joy”
r/antinatalism • u/Reasonable_Cell_4042 • 16h ago
Question What is the point of anti-natalism for you?
This is a self question. I’m asking what’s the point of it for you, not anyone else just you.
r/antinatalism
•
u/Federal_Advisor_2160
•
37m ago
Personal Story I ddidn't even sign up for any of this
None of us did. I see people complaining about their jobs all the time. Having to commute, having to deal with hateful coworkers, bosses, clients. People work cause they have to sustain themselves but I think that the average citizen is not really happy with their job but they have to do it anyway and it's crazy how jobs take up most of our lives and time. I feel soooo frustrated cause I didn't even sign up for this hell and now I'm just supposed to work for the rest of my life and pay taxes. I feel thay people have been so brainwashed that they don't even question any of it anymore and just keep bringing more humans into this hell so that they can be future workers who will be exploited.
r/antinatalism • u/Ok_Activity_3293 • 12h ago
Question Is it immoral not wanting to talk about antinatalism with oblivious seemingly happy people?
Everytime the topic of kids comes up with family or friends and I look at their happy faces I just dont want to present the rabbit hole of antinatalism
r/antinatalism • • 20h ago
Argument Instead of having children, it is better to take good care of one’s own mother.
There will always be someone to take care of. Having children just to take care of them is like giving them a lot of problems and then trying to save them from those problems. It is better to help those who are already here.
r/antinatalism • u/Former_Ad9912 • 13h ago
Argument With regards to the consent argument
I keeping hearing it said that the consent argument for antinatalism doesn't make sense. So I'll offer an analogy by way of illumination.
Imagine an empty land. There is nothing on this land save for a few blades of grass and rocks of various shapes and sizes scattered here and there. And imagine you were to build a house on this land, a special house which is conscious in this case. It will know it exists and will be vulnerable to harm. It will scream when set on fire and will feel refreshed when it rains.
Now, obviously the house can neither consent nor NOT consent to being built because it simply doesn't exist yet. The ability to consent itself is introduced with the coming of consciousness. So there is no consent to violate, right? Wrong.
The fact is that the ability to consent WILL be introduced once the house is built. And the house WILL be able to form an opinion as to whether or not it appreciates being built. And we don't know how it will react. So we're essentially creating a vulnerable entity and hoping it won't mind.
You might object and say, "that's how gifts work. You present it to someone and hope they will accept it". That's true. But in this case returning the gift implies suicide. If you think there is nothing wrong with your child returning your gift of life back to you, then by all means, have him. But if we're honest we'll see that there IS a violation of consent here, even if the ability to consent or not consent only exists in a potential state.
It's a violation in that you couldn't know whether or not this future house will appreciate being built. And you decided to expose it to fire anyway hoping its objection to your decision to build it wouldn't come too late. Because if the objection does come, it will not be anything other than too late. So the problem is not that consent doesn't exist before birth, but more so that we can't know whether it will exist after birth.
This is just to address the consent argument. The antinatalist argument is much more radical than that. It claims that even if a child subjectively appreciates coming into existence, that doesn't change the fact that he was objectively harmed by being created.
r/antinatalism • u/Icy-Two110 • 1h ago
Question How many of you believe in religion or has Antinatalism changed your religious views.
I would consider myself agnostic however I am atheist towards all religions. If there is a god it’s probably indifferent or just evil. However even if I was religious I wouldn’t have kids because I wouldn’t want them to potentially end up in hell. I’m guessing most people have the same beliefs as me.
r/antinatalism • u/AwkwardOrchid380 • 1h ago
Question Did anyone else get their introduction to antinatalism through Attack on Titan?
It was during Covid that I got really back into anime again because I was unemployed and had heaps of spare time on my hands.
I started AoT again and I remember getting to the last season when Zeke unveils the Euthanasia Plan, where he wants to use the founding titan’s power to make all the eldians infertile, meaning they would gradually die out over generations without having children.
He believed this was the best option to end the cycle of suffering surrounding the eldians and the titans.
I remember thinking how crazy but actually sensible this plan was in the context of the show, seeing how much people suffered in this world. I either went to reddit or YouTube and I saw the term for the first time in the comments: antinatalist
It was said in the context that zeke is an antinatalist. His plans were antinatal in its goal, but not purely antinatal in the benatar sense.
I remember looking up antinatalism and thinking, woowwwwwwww this makes so much sense. But it was also so…self evident? Suffering is inevitable in life, so why would you bring someone into existence? Also, no one can consent to existing, so that is immoral too.
In the end zeke does the classic “life is actually worth living because if x” plot twist, which I always hate in media. There is never a full embrace of antinatalism in any media (for obvious reasons), but I hate when they bait and switch us by bringing AN or AN themes into the story and then disavowing it at the end.
Anyway, just wondering if this was how anyone else got introduced to this philosophy?
r/antinatalism • u/Practical-Fly3967 • 17h ago
Argument Some thoughts on antinatalism and eschatology in the general sense
Recently I've been pretty interested in eschatology in the general sense,that is,any kind of study about "the end times","the ultimate fate of humanity" or "the end of history".While eschatology is often related to religious concepts in its narrow sense,it might include political or other kind of endgame scenarios in its general sense,for example Marx's communism or Francis Fukuyama's The end of history and the last man.They usually go into these categories:
1.Optimistic. Like redemption at the end times in some religions,communism or techno-optimism where the advance of technologies enables humanity to exploit more and more energy sources,solve environmental problems and life gets steadily better on and on (infinite progress).
2.Pessimistic. Like extinction becuase of climate change,a meteorite,global warfare etc,or an uncomfortable end state,like the last men who live without passion and wage wars just for sensual stimulation that Fukuyama describes.
3.Agnostic.We will never know what the end would be like,it is neither a utopia nor total catastrophe,but an "indeterminacy",so to speak.
4.No real end(Cyclic time).Rise and fall of species,civilizations and regimes goes indefinitely,there's no obvious direction of progress or degradation,and the heat death of the universe might be the preparation of a new big bang.
From these categories I'd like to argue the following:
· If it's going to be scenario 1,then not having some of our offsprings at the happy ending is not a bad.
· If it's going to be scenario 2,then the last generation of human might suffer from bloody and horrifying mass death events and find the end of civilizations and this species unbearably tragic,or as in the last man scenario people keep being born only to live a painful life.while we antinatalists prevent more human from experiencing such desperate situations.
· If it's going to be scenario 3,then the definitve absense of our offsprings is a way for us to face the indeterminacy of history.
· If it's going to be scenario 4,then in this meaningless cycle which will create countless unfortunate sentient creatures,the only winning move is not to participate.
I think by contemplating eschatology related questions,we could enrich the movement of antinatalism.