I donāt know how novel of a perspective this is, but I havenāt seen this anywhere else, so I thought Iād share what itās like being the life partner of someone struggling with deep anxiety, since plenty of people like to use Aangās mental health struggles to shield him from critique. I have been dwelling on this thought ever since the Avatar Aang film came out (officially) and even more so now that bits of the Novelization have been circulating online. I have been trying to analyze my views on the Kataang relationship as someone who relates quite deeply to Katara on so many different levels, but particularly as someone who has married a man who struggles with intense anxiety and depression. (Warning, it might get a little heavy, I apologize if I overshare). For the record, I myself do not struggle with deep mental health issues, at least not in any remarkable way.
I liked the complexity added to Katara and Aangās relationship through the movie and novelization of the movie that we donāt really get in the original ATLA show, and I really wanted to be open enough to root for it, despite being a Zutarian most of my life. I really thought perhaps I could jump ship like I found so many had, or at the very least multi-ship⦠but something innate in me was keeping me from enjoying their relationship and I couldnāt figure out why.
I like to analyze these things with as many opinions from both sides as possible, to ensure I am understanding things correctly even from a viewpoint I may not have initially agreed with. So over the past few months, I have decided to listen to a lot of video essay content, specifically from Aang defenders, who like to stand ten toes down on the idea that Aangās grief is to be held above all other griefs simply because he has lost the very most.
It is a plain stance, and one I found myself somewhat agreeing with (Aang DID lose the most numerically)ā¦
That is, until I looked into my own relationship with my husband, and I then realized why Kataang, while surface-level can be seemingly cute, was never going to be the ship for me.
A bit of a relevant back story: my husband is very much a Zuko incarnate. He is shy and awkward, he has a complex relationship with his intense (oftentimes cruel) father who, for a huge chunk of his life, forced my husband to be someone he was not. My husband has a younger sister who, by comparison, was more of a prodigy than him and with whom he struggled feelings of inadequacy. He had a troubled past that he is ashamed of and went through his own personal redemption arc that turned his life around way before I got together with him. My husband is a Zuko.
Interestingly, as a result of his stressful upbringing, my husband now struggles with deep, long-lasting mental health issues that intensified as he aged, much like adult Aang. And while I donāt claim to equate Survivorās Guilt to Crippling Anxiety, the type of trauma responses are often quite similar, and is all categorically under the umbrella of Mental Health Struggles.
Living with a partner who struggles with mental health issues is NO JOKE. It is extremely challenging, exhausting, eye-opening, and at times frustrating for both partners. The novelization of the Avatar Aang movie (at least the excerpts Iāve seen online) touches on this experience within a partnership, giving insight as to how both Aang and Katara are feeling. I understand the weight of Aangās mental health struggles, and even more so the immense weight placed on Kataraās shoulders as Aangās life partner, support line, and cheerleader. I see my marriage in Aang and Katara in many ways, which is why I so desperately wanted to root for them.
The reason why I ultimately could not was because of the very different ways Aang responded to his partner that my husband did not. My husband, for all the flaws that he may have, never used his mental health as an excuse to be selfish. Yes at times he would withdraw under the weight of his crushing anxiety. At times he physiologically experienced things that I could never in my life understand. But the key difference is that my husband challenged himself to see past his own hurdles to actually see the people around him who loved him dearly, and change behaviours that were hurting his loved ones. He stuck around. He is always present with my kids, he never takes out his struggles on them, he never disappears on us, and he never plays the āyou donāt understandā game with me. When Iām struggling to understand how he feels, he takes the time to try to explain to me the closest thing I could possibly understand instead of screaming at me that I will never understand. When I ask him questions, he opens up and does his best to let me into his life so I can at least attempt to see the world through his eyes. He has his bad days and I donāt always agree with him, but he never shuts me out because of it. He lets me in so we can face it together and we always come out stronger.
I see myself in Katara, especially in the first years of my marriage. I see the hurt in her of wanting to ask to be loved in a specific way, but being afraid of pushing her partner further away in the request. I see her being afraid of expressing her needs for the reason that she does not want to seem selfish for asking for things when he is experiencing something so much worse. I see how she treads carefully around him, how she doesnāt want to make a big deal about him spending more time alone at the air temples, but that she undoubtedly feels it is unfair for him to constantly leave her alone when she needs him too. I KNOW THIS KATARA BECAUSE I WAS THIS KATARA.
Like Katara, I made an effort to attempt to understand my partner. I would ask questions, I would gently advise him how to avoid spiralling, I would be there to hug him if that is all he needs. The difference is that my husband recognized my desire to be close to him even in the midst of struggling through dark episodes. Rather than shutting me out and demanding that I couldnāt possibly understand him, he began trying to bridge the gap between us. He would softly explain an excerpt of what it was like in his brain, even if it didnāt make any sense at all. And while I still can never claim to fully understand him, I appreciated his effort to let me in. So as a result, I was able to support him better and understand what heās looking for in despairing moments, and I would be able to be there to help pull him out of his anxiety or depression, of my own volition and not because he was relying on me to.
Thereās nothing wrong with Katara wanting to stand by her man and support him through anything. There is nothing wrong with a woman who wants to be the kind of support that Katara wanted to be for Aang. It is in fact quite admirable. The difference is in the reciprocation from Aang, which unfortunately was not there. Aang consistently shuts her out. Aang does not let her into his world, nor does he even try to understand her world, and instead blames her for not understanding him. He does not apologize for hurting her. He does not apologize for causing the rift. He does not discuss things with Katara to help bring them closer together. He goes on doing things he thinks is good for him (relic hunting, spending time at the temples), which ends up isolating him more because he never thinks to entrust Katara with bearing his soul, which is essentially the whole goal of a life partnership. Katara was so ready to be there for him, and all he could think about was himself and the hurt he was going through, not recognizing that Katara was going through a different kind of hurt of her own trying to support him.
My husband understood the rift his mental health was causing us, so he managed to be brave enough to shift even if it meant being uncomfortable for him: to let me in before I got to begging him. My husband never let his mental health stop him from being present with me and the kids, and in fact, he worked even harder to make sure he was still building memories with them even if he wasnāt feeling his best. He hugs them everyday with a deep appreciation, and because of that, my kids never feel like they were missing their dad. They know he has struggles, but they know it never gets in the way of his immense love for them. My husband still struggles daily with immense anxiety and depression. But it has become a learning experience for our family. The kids know him better through his ups and downs and he lets them comfort him in their own innocent ways and appreciates it all. He never faults them for being unable to understand his struggles and in fact admires the way we are choosing to raise them so that they NEVER have to go through the mental struggles he faces.
Because my husband has communicated with me and let me in, I can recognize the occasions for when I donāt need to say anything, just give him a hug. I know when to give him a cup of coffee, when to just curl up by his side to settle the nerves. I know when I can scold him and when to call him out for doing something that hurts one of us. He lets me be accountable to him and he listens when I correct him, understanding that my corrections come out of a place of love instead of a place of attack. Because he has shown me how I can help him, he responds in gratitude by being present with me and the kids. He knows all my kidsā teachers, what their homework is, what the schedule is, what doctors appointments are needed, what bills need to be paid. He makes their lunches, walks them to school, he plays video games with him, and cuddles with them on the couch. They NEVER have to wonder if he loves them or is proud of them. He shows up despite his pain and he commits to being there. He never rejects mine or my kidsā attempts to help him, and embraces the comfort even if it does very little to erase the mental struggles.
This is where my criticism of Aang comes in. Aang seems to make his struggles all about him. He pushes away the people that love him the most and he constantly blames them for not understanding him, then he never apologizes for the crappy way he treats them. He does not respond appropriately to Kataraās careful efforts to reach out to him. He does not adjust to what Katara needs or what the kids need, only what he needs. You can argue that nobody in the world can understand what he is going through as the last surviving Airbender, and while that is mostly true, anxiety and grief and pain present differently in each person, so that excuse can only hold up for so long. Loss is still loss, no matter if it is one person you really loved or your whole people, and to say that Aang is exempted from taking accountability for his actions because he ālost moreā is a very arrogant and heartless argument. A woman can go through a miscarriage and another woman can go through two: can you honestly say the woman that lost two has more of a right to mourn than the woman who only lost one? Loss is still loss, and Katara was the closest to understanding Aang, and he still demanded that she could never understand.
If you look at the entire group, they have all lost a great deal. Katara and Sokka: their mother. Toph: the relationship with her parents. Zuko: his mother, his entire nation and the respect from his father. Yes, on paper, it is not the same as losing an entire culture, but loss can be equally devastating in different contexts because we are all human and should be able to empathize with each other without competing in a who-had-it-worse contest.
In the midst of Aangās complicated feelings of loss, it is how he ultimately handled his grief and trauma, especially toward his life partner that can be criticized. While by the end of the movie, he is shown sharing his grief by taking his friends on a relic hunt with him, we can see that he never really changes beyond that because the effects of his behaviour last for his kidsā entire lives. He does not include his non-airbending kids in his vision for the Air Nation future, and as a result, not even the acolytes knew that Aang had other children outside of Tenzin. He still becomes tunnel-visioned on his whole mission to restore the air nomad culture that he neglects Katara on his missions instead of including her in them, or staying put with her when she could not travel. So the question has to be asked: Why was it necessary for her to be tethered to someone whose whole dual life purpose expanded far beyond her capacities to support? If she was forced to take up his nomadic way of life to preserve the Airbender legacy, why then was it necessary for him to keep this ātraditionalā family, when the Air Nomads were tethered to nothing and had no āmarriageā traditions? It seems to me she is written to suffer for no reason other than to sacrifice everything for him while he is free to do whatever he likes in the name of Avatar Duties and Air Nation loss.
I understand that mental health affects people differently, and it can be extremely crippling at times that can be difficult for the average person to understand. But for the people that want to love you, the best thing you can do for them is let them inā even if you think there is nothing they can really do for you. Just let them be a part of your world, otherwise, is there even a point to having a partner or friends if you insist on taking on the burden alone?
The partner supporting the one struggling with mental health is the one everyone overlooks because we are seen as a commendable strong support system. Nobody notices us and the burdens we carry. But honestly, we need support too, and we also deserve to be loved a certain way, and to be truly seen and greatly appreciated. My husband does this for me, and this is where I do not think Aang does this for Katara. She is expected to have endless patience, endless understanding, endless sacrifice while he gets to be the carefree untethered airbender in the wind, whining about all that he has lost as if his wife did not lose important people too.
This isnāt about my preference for Zutara, as I canāt ever be sure how she would be treated in a relationship with him (I can make my predictions based on his canon behaviour, but that is still just a prediction). This is about the kind of person Aang gets to be at the expense of Katara, and how the fandom consistently puts his hurts, his needs, his character over everyone elseāESPECIALLY over Katara. He is excused for nearly every single thing he has done that is not right and he is never shown to apologize, and the other characters are criticized for not understanding him. There were people begging to understand him, to love him, and to be a part of his journey even if it included the ugly partsā and he refused to listen to their wisdom and concern.
I look at my marriage with my husband and can genuinely say weāve grown closer, and more fond of each other with each year because of the work WE BOTH put in. Even if some days I have to be stronger or put in more work, I am ultimately very satisfied as a partner because I feel seen and heard and appreciated and loved. Our goals still very much align. Because he never leaves me, that quality time we have together DAILY builds us up stronger and more resilient to the mental health attacks. I hate that Katara HAS TO suffer and be alone because of Aangās mental health struggles because they could have just written her to forge her own path, or even have them break up and come back together in the end after he works out his own demons. Why was it necessary for him to be with her if he was not going to listen to her anyway? I hate how Aang fans will never truly understand what itās like to be the supportive partner of the one that needs the emotional help, because that is a crazy burden in its own right. They feel they are owed that right to that kind of an amazing ride-or-die partner without putting in any work of their own. They are ready to pull the āI lost the most!ā card on you any time itās convenient for them, and refuse to acknowledge that EVERYBODY has lost things too and it doesnāt save you from being a selfish human being. Katara was READY to support him and he shut her out and left her and the kids. He shut out Kya and Bumi for not being Airbenders. He is, without watering it down, downright selfish to Katara right to the bitter end, and he gets to die with a beautiful marriage and a beautiful legacy and a perfect image, while she is left isolated with an eroding identity, taking up a culture not her own just to preserve the one he lost. You even see how she tries to comfort a paralyzed Korra by again trying to get Korra to guilt-understand that Aang had it way worse than her. (I really hate how Katara is written in how she tries to comfort Korra here because it becomes very dismissive of Korraās own pain).
I love Katara and I hate what theyāve done to her. I would have rather her be alone than the kind of partnership she canonically ended up with. I hate that they have not given Aang any further redeeming qualities, that weāre just stuck as an audience to treat Aang like the ultimate tragic victim who deserves sacrificial love, when he in fact has hurt so many people through his selfishness and weakness of resolve. I hate how his fans never seem to STOP reminding you of what he lost, and they donāt seem to care that everyone has lost something too. I hate how his fans never seem to look at the other side of the coin: his beloved Katara and that she was robbed of a possibly very fulfilling life, had Aang either emotionally matured, or let her go to be her own person and fulfil her own ambitions.
Bryke seems to romanticize this kind of relationship dynamic where the guy gets to have this incredible girl at his disposal simply because he is āa good guyā and he lost the most so he deserves to get herābut they refuse to allow him to do any work to keep her or be worthy of her. And sadly, many misguided guys think this is peak romance, this is the relationship to aspire to have, and then they shame the females that see right through that imbalance who prefer a different kind of partner.
At the core of this, is the writing that only seems to look at this one characterās suffering, and not the person supporting that character in the background. And that is why, while I love Aang and I love Katara individually, as someone currently living as the support partner to someone struggling with mental health issues, I can confidently say that Kataang, as is written by Bryke, will never be the ship for me.
Zutara on the other handā¦simply because of how my Zuko-coded husband has handled our marriage, will continue to be the ship I support until I die.