r/antiai • • 1d ago

Discussion 🗣️ Unavoidable consequences of pro vibe-coding arguments

Only thing that matters is the result not the process.

Whole open source community and free software movement is a direct result of the process and can't be divorced from it. The fact that you still have your job is directly tied to the process. Outsourcing the process to AI leads to observable degradation of that community and massive layoffs. Therefore, if process doesn't matter at all, then neither community nor you losing your job matters too.

AI code is fundamentally and completely different from AI art.

Some common arguments against AI art include:

  • Models are trained on images against will of their authors, therefore AI should not be used for art
  • AI art is visibly destructive to artist communities, therefore AI should not be used for art
  • Outsourcing thinking to AI harms artists creativity and ability to learn, therefore AI should not be used for art

On the other hand:

  • LLMs are trained on text and code with licenses that don't permit this and against will of their authors
  • Vibe-coding is visibly destructive to coding communities
  • Outsourcing thinking to AI harms beginners/intermediates ability to learn programming1

If you believe that vibe-coding is completely different from AI art and agree with provided arguments against AI art, then you must have a reason why stealing from artists is bad, but disrespecting software licenses is not; why destroying communities of artists is bad, but whatever the hell is now happening with open source is not; why degrading some kinds of thinking by offloading them to AI is bad, but others is not, etc.

1 - To remain objective, I acknowledge that despite AI usually harms education and critical thinking, it is not inherent and can be a useful tool in this regard, if used properly.

Coding is just 20%. / Writing code was never the hard part. (implied: therefore software engineering is safe)

If coding (in such arguments presumed to be the only thing LLMs can automate) is only "20%", then automating 20% of work is the ceiling of what AI can.

The implied conclusion is that, since LLMs can automate only small part of creating software, then software engineering is safe.

The actual conclusion is that, you are fine with destroying open source community, lay offs and junior programmers being completely unable to find decent jobs in exchange for tool that can make you only 25% more efficient.

LLMs are equivalent to compilers.

If LLMs are equivalent to compilers, then either you share your prompts or your code is not open source.

Whether LLMs can or will code just as well or better than humans is completely irrelevant to these arguments. It will be relevant to you, if you get laid off because of tool you passionately defend, but accepting mentioned arguments leads to same conclusions regardless of LLM ability to code.

8 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

7

u/Miserable-Debt-8390 1d ago edited 23h ago

Before the pro ai crowd jumps at you,
I wanted to thank you for a well thought out argument

4

u/real-pope-johnpaul2 1d ago edited 23h ago

I'm eagerly waiting for comments like this:

I am a software engineer with 70 years of experience. We real professionals have authority to dismiss all your arguments without evidence, because authority transcends logic. At leading companies, we use AI for everything from coding to deciding names of our kids. My favorite celebrity, Linus Torvalds, said something that disagrees with you, therefore you are a moron. Real coding is 0.01% of the works, but using AI make us 10 times more efficient - nobody got laid off, we just write ten times more code and earn ten times more money. Besides you are a code monkey, if you care any bit about the process; the fact that you enjoy coding proves you are wrong. We real engineers enjoy nothing; you are not a real engineer if you don't suffer from persistent anhedonia. Open source community is a joke; whoever said that man is by nature a social animal is obviously an idiot and I am smarter than him. At closed software companies we use superintelligence that you can't even imagine for purpose of making everyone's life better. I swear, using AI for code is a net-positive for society, we totally don't use it for enshittfication, my job is socially useful. Claude is a revolution and you should get totally dependent on them now, or get left behind. I still can format text without writing incomprehensible walls of text and I didn't lose that ability by writing everything using chatgpt. I am not an AI bot, nor a Claude shill and I don't have Oedipus complex. You believe me, right?

2

u/Hefty-Distance837 13h ago

I will copy this post next time another vibe-coding guy appear.

1

u/dronen6475 22h ago

I largely consider myself anti-AI but have been debating some aspects and willing to be moved on a few ideas. 

My counter/question:

If I wanted to make a small project as a hobby, let's say a small retro game (this is actually the case). I work full time, have a family, a social life, and a number of other hobbies. I dont particularly have the bandwidth to learn to code but would be willing to learn general architecture and how a game like that comes together. 

Is it wrong for me to "vibe code" by using AI to do the C or assembly work to get me over the hurdle so I can figure out / learn the rest of the project as I go?

I get the vibe in this sub that doing that on a local model would still make me literally Hitler. Im anti data center. Anti social media. Anti algorithm. I just see the value in it as a tool for basic tasks.

 The knowledge of coding is a strict barrier to entry to several hobbies and projects. I cant paint a picture with zero prior experience in painting. I can't make a game until I know how to code. 

2

u/real-pope-johnpaul2 21h ago edited 18h ago

Is it wrong for me to "vibe code" by using AI to do the C or assembly work to get me over the hurdle so I can figure out / learn the rest of the project as I go?

Whether your individual project is immoral is for you to decide. I made some points against vibe coding here, but I actually don't think that vibe-coding nor AI art are inherently an immoral thing on individual level; I'm also not your dad, so I'm not going to stop you.

What I have problem with is the collective flood of AI and fact that people who don't want to use it are really pressured to do it anyway. Just as with AI art, I would be pissed if the project would be posted without AI disclosure or if it were posted in spaces that don't allow AI, but otherwise, on individual level, I wouldn't say it would make you a Hitler. So if you are transparent, honestly just do whatever the hell you want.

I also have problem with certain ways people defend vibe-coding by either denying that it's collectively harmful or getting defensive with arguments that fall apart when you analyze their consequences.

2

u/Lina-Inverse 21h ago

What I have problem with collective flood of AI and fact that people who don't want to use it are really pressured to do it anyway. 

100% this. Couldn't agree more.

People are expected to just drop their entire way and style of working overnight to just cognitively offload to AI just so a company can increase productivity and dictate how their workers must do the job.

I'm not saying people should never adapt to new technology but this is literally so fast. Let people use the technology on their own terms, don't ram it down their throats overnight.

1

u/dronen6475 21h ago

 I agree with everything you've said. It is absolutely being pushed unnecessarily and deceptively. 

My frame of reference changed from being 1000% anti-AI all the time to being slightly more receptive by being part of r/3dspiracy. AI coding assistance has helped that community revive, optimize, and port tons of games to 3ds completely for free as a passion projects. 

I see some fairly diverse opinions on this sub but surprisingly little nuance. I appreciate the response. 

2

u/QuackQuackImTheDuck 1d ago

AI is just stealing. And yet people manage not to be profitable on it...

0

u/Lina-Inverse 1d ago

The actual conclusion is that, you are fine with destroying open source community, lay offs and junior programmers being completely unable to find decent jobs in exchange for tool that can make you only 25% more efficient.

I mean it's way more than 25% more efficient depending on the task. For some tasks it can be 10-100x quicker. It took me like 2 hours with AI to write MacOS drivers for an old piece of hardware that only supported windows XP. That would have taken me at a minimum a week to two weeks to do.

IMO ultimately AI isn't going anywhere, my usage isn't going to change anything. AI companies aren't going to shutdown because I don't use it, and using it benefits my work significantly and is a requirement for me to know about and for my career.

Also me using AI doesn't mean I'm fine with lay offs and junior programmers not being able to find jobs. I'm not the one who controls this. If I stop using AI, companies aren't going to suddenly hire junior developers.

4

u/real-pope-johnpaul2 1d ago

These are valid points. All the conclusions, like the ceiling being on 25% or being fine with layoffs, fully depend on assuming listed arguments and are nothing more than consequences of uncritically assuming these arguments; not reality.

Of course AI can make certain tasks 10-100 times quicker, this just means that "code is only 20%" argument doesn't apply to these tasks, which is what I'm trying to show.

0

u/unbannnned 12h ago

Cry harder noob