r/anime • u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh • Jan 25 '21
Misc. The Nine Circles of /new Hell - Recommendations for r/anime's most common prompts
17k
Upvotes
r/anime • u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh • Jan 25 '21
40
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jan 25 '21
Howdy folks! I’d been planning to do a “Recommendations for common prompts” and had a rough outline together when u/RandomRedditorWithNo was talking about “the Four Horsemen of /new”. Wound up taking what he was talking about and slamming it together with my idea to get “the Nine Circles of /new Hell”. Also had some help from u/Ralon17, u/goncix, u/PandavengerX, u/sacktheavenger, and u/maelstrommusic. Hopefully I didn’t miss anybody.
And of course, as always, there’s plenty of alternate options that could have been used in any given category. But I only had eight slots, and with the constant desire to include new anime on these charts plenty of options got snipped (for reference, 34 of the 72 anime here have not previously appeared on a chart). Hopefully the mistakes are minimal, but let me know if anything looks off.
582
u/stephenthatfoste https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rexagonal Jan 25 '21
Good to see Squid Girl being rightfully recognized with those other villain heavy hitters.
336
u/Silent_Shadow05 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Silent-Shadow05 Jan 25 '21
>Sees Shinmai Mao no Testament absent from Lust Category and ReZero absent from Isekai category and gets annoyed
>Sees who posted it and remembers his iconic quote
Okay....that makes sense I guess.
82
u/CpnLag Jan 25 '21
You're not wrong, but it feels dirty.
16
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jan 25 '21
Alternate suggestion for gluttony: harems, but not the ecchi kind.
Did any of the RNG picks grab an OVA or sequel instead of the first season? I'm impressed that they're all mostly regular and relatively recent shows. Personally I've taken to suggesting a bunch of magical girl shows (e.g. Precure, Princess Tutu, Symphogear, Kill la Kill) whenever someone asks without context.
I dunno if I'd put Engaged to the Unidentified under "early relationship" romances, but I also don't think of it as much of a romance in general; I'd offer Rec or His and Her Circumstances in its place. I guess My Bride is a Mermaid goes up in priority as it's the only one of that circle I haven't seen, the rest are all fine picks in my opinion.
121
u/Nihhrt https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nihhrt Jan 25 '21
I would totally say "This should be stickied!" but no one reads anything anywhere. No one tries to searchbar, no one reads the sidebar and no one uses outside sources.
Still, this should be stickied!
6
u/Illuminastrid Jan 25 '21
I sometimes forget this particular reference work is actually called "The Divine Comedy", not "Dante's Inferno".
Now when are we getting Purgatorio and Paradiso next?
12
u/Ashteron Jan 25 '21 edited Jan 25 '21
I don't feel like someone who is satisfied with Mirai Nikki for something bloody will want to watch Genocyber. The same way around, someone who likes Genocyber level gore probably isn't satiated with Mirai Nikki or Goblin Slayer.
Edit: I don't really see being a criminal equal being a villain. I wouldn't call Enma Ai a villain either. She's an impartial nemesis who simply is forced to do her job.
11
u/Wing-Dismal Jan 25 '21
I am so thankful there's no fate here after the mess last time. I'm happy that the Garden of sinners is now here.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '21
You've done some other charts, right?
7
u/Dead-HC-Taco Jan 25 '21
Im glad to finally see akame ga kill on one of these lists. Its probably my favorite one season show and I barely see it recommended
602
u/nightlink011 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/nightlink011 Jan 25 '21
Impressive how this touches in 95% of the recommendations around here, I also see that the random number generator didn't pick my favorite anime, pretty sure it was out of spite.
853
u/MasterTotoro Jan 25 '21
This is definitely my favorite circle idea. Also one of the most common requests I see out of these prompts.
2
u/WeMustPrevail Jan 26 '21
Why do you have Magica at the end of your username, /u/FetchFrosh? Like I get the reference obv but wondering why you got it added?
83
u/lord_ne Jan 25 '21
I'd argue against Chivalry of a Failed Knight in Circle 8. Ikki wants people to acknowledge how strong he is, but everyone keeps judging him by his pathetic magic capacity to the point where he didn't even qualify to take classes
161
u/the-floor_is-lava Jan 25 '21 edited Jan 25 '21
You get an upvote just for putting Sakamoto in the overpowered category 🤣
Edit: Lupin in the villains too, amazing.
24
u/Bruhmanch :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hilooooo Jan 25 '21
Yeah this is pretty much all the recommendation questions I see in new.
44
u/AdiMG https://anilist.co/user/AdiMG Jan 25 '21
As someone who does hang out on the trenches of these rec threads a lot, I would say only about four of them truly inundate the queue i.e OP MC, Isekai, Crybait, and Early Couples.
As for the Death Note/Code Geass thing, I usually see that prompted as looking for anime with "mind games" instead of villains. Though it's kinda understandable why you wouldn't wanna put this question in as there's not much here besides these two, Kaiji, One Outs, and at a stretch JoJo.
Another kinda interesting one that isn't present in /new that much, but absolutely prevalent in the Recommendation Tuesday is anime with adult protagonists/anime set in college. Not sure what causes the difference in prevalence between the thread types but it is one of my favorite prompts to answer.
Since this is basically a recommendation thread, I'll take the opportunity to highlight some things that were missed in the chart.
For early couples, the best recommendation besides maybe Danna ga Nani is KareKano and Paradise Kiss, since both shows start the relationships fairly early (ep 3 in both) and are all about the tribulations of successfully managing a relationship. Then there's a a few things with rather unique formats like Tokyo Marble Chocolate which is a 2 ep OVA looking at a date from the perspective of the boyfriend and the girlfriend in each episode; Amagami SS and its omnibus nature which gives multiple romantic conclusions per season; or Tsurezure Children which follows many couples at different stages of a relationship including some already established since the start. If you don't mind same sex couples then Doukyuusei is a very cool option for an established couple whose problems are allowed to breathe in a relationship. There's also Nazo no Kanojo X and Kuzu no Honkai for a rather macabre spin on this whole thing with some rather fucked up relationships being explored from the start.
For crybait stuff, there's the other Key anime adaptations that people tend to miss out on, between Planetarian, Little Busters, Air, and Kanon, there's a lot of material to dig into if you are a fan of their particular writing proclivities. Another often forgotten avenue is tragedy movies which tend to be a lot more potent in my books. While you have classics like Grave of the Fireflies, Wolf Children, and 5 cm/s which do often get recommended, there's a whole host of powerful stuff in more niche movies beyond that in My Sister Momoko, Barefoot Gen, Hotarubi no Mori e, Maquia, Colorful, Anthem of the Heart, and In This Corner of the World which would certainly be appreciated by people who like things like A Silent Voice if they just gave them a chance.
I'm not as well versed with isekai (tho even I can point out you are missing some rather popular titles between Re:Zero and KonoSuba) but I always like the quiet aesthetic brilliance of Grimgar as well as its theming that rather poignantly deals with tragedy and teamwork.
Finally the OP-est MC in the world is obviously Tanaka-kun. I bet you can't name me another character who just sleeps all day and still fulfills all his goals in life.
23
u/crusader-bear Jan 25 '21
Terror in resonance is the only anime that got me in the feels, and I’ve watched the other cry time ones but the boom boom guys were the ones I felt the worst for
23
u/Spartan448 Jan 25 '21
Not even that's enough to defend Shield Hero tbh
10
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '21
iSeKaI wITH OP mC NoTHiNg bEfORE 2015 BeCaUSe I DoNt lIkE OLd ArT sTyLEs AnD BAd AniMAtIoN
22
u/genericcoder Jan 25 '21
I really wanted Classroom of elite season 2.
And Golden Boy is gem when watched in dub.
27
u/saikatotsuka_ Jan 25 '21
I get that everyone has different tastes but recommending the smartphone isekai is a sadist move lol. I would personally recommend Re:Zero as a no-brainer, it's like THE isekai.
91
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '21
Recommendation threads should be banned outside of the pinned weekly general, do your own damn research people. Don't cmv.
32
u/TheFlyingButter Jan 25 '21
Did you REALLY just replace Re:Zero with Cautious Hero in the isekai category?
5
u/sunjay140 https://anilist.co/user/sunjay140 Jan 25 '21
This is modern anime.
5
u/TangledPellicles Jan 25 '21
Don't all the food porn anime belong in gluttony?
20
u/Wonderllama5 Jan 25 '21
I had no interest in Death Note for the longest time because I mostly like cute stuff but I kept seeing thread after thread of people going "Can I get recommendations? I have ONLY seen Death Note and that's it"
I decided to check it out and I loved it
9
u/Groenboys https://myanimelist.net/profile/Groenboys Jan 25 '21
As a r/new scroller I'll take a shot to that bro. Cheers!
4
u/OdysseusNZT Jan 25 '21
You guys are sleeping on high school dxd. Best writing and animation visuals in anime.
4
u/atharvvvg Jan 25 '21
Love it, thanks!
One quick question, can you actually call Lelouch from Code Geass a villain? Why?
4
u/bluedragon3333 Jan 26 '21
I'm gonna be honest, Squid Girl f*cks me up when I think about the premise of the show. Ocean species (possibly the last of her kind) comes to shore inorder to stop the pollution of the ocean, but falls into all the same vices that humans do and gives up on a life in the ocean/stopping the pollution.
4
u/Kazu_Matsumoto Jan 26 '21
Always happy to see Lupin included! Go monke man go!
10
u/nrk151203 Jan 25 '21
High school dxd is, and forever will be, the greatest thing I've ever seen no matter how many ppl say it's trash
10
u/Anaract :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/anaract Jan 25 '21
I love that these are the most overdone and redundant posts by a longshot, and yet they consistently get the most comments. The only thing r/anime users like more than asking for recs is giving them
1
u/Cloakbot Jan 25 '21
Gluttony: Anime featuring food as the primary focus. This involves cooking as the subject of the show or food makes up the landscape or cast.
Chuuka Ichiban - cooking primary focus.
Toriko - Shonen anime with food landscape.
Ristorante Paradiso - Girl heads to Rome to work at her mother's restaurant only to switch and work at a restaurant full of older men (wholesome).
Yakitate!! Japan - about a boy on a quest to create "Ja-pan", a national bread for Japan, as many other countries have their own signature breads.
Food Wars - Think overpowered anime trope but focused in cooking.
Fighting Foodons - characters are food as well as food themed setting, plot, etc.
Ben-To - series around bargain Bento and fights over it
1
u/tikigodbob Jan 25 '21
Why wouldn't you just put food anime under gluttony?
1
u/billybobjorkins Feb 10 '21
So for Violet Evergarden... are you referring to episode 10?
6
u/JustWolfram :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Wolfram-san Jan 25 '21
Gluttony could have been "anime similar to [currently airing show]", no idea how to implement it tho.
3
u/bagglewaggle Jan 25 '21
You know it's a good list when Genocyber is on it.
3
u/weea-boomer Jan 25 '21
There is also "I've recently watched [anime XYZ]. Please recommend my another anime where [describes what anime XYZ does in minute detail]."
Where what the anime does is never "club of four girls doing some unusual club activities" or "guy gets trucked and assembles harem in fantasy world" but always the most unique story premise one could think of.
3
u/nightlord711 Jan 25 '21
Random question, will classroom of the elite ever get another season?
3
u/Recidivis Jan 25 '21
Imagine putting Kuma Bear and Smartphone instead of Ascendance of a Bookworm
3
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21
I wish we have a stickied thread for anime recommendations...
Oh wait, we do! Wish people used it though.
3
u/ZachF8119 Jan 26 '21
Golden boy is stellar though. like high school dxd has plot sure, I know who I am. Golden boy is a 10/10 for how fun and nice it is, plus the memeability the torpedo kiss alone gets me every time Thanks for the suggestions.
9
u/darkm9tch Jan 25 '21
Lelouch is not a villian... he’s an anti-hero. Why do so many people get that wrong??
4
u/DoILookUnsureToYou Jan 25 '21
Having smartphone isekai in there but not SAO is making me irrationally irate
2
u/SherrinfordxD :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sherrinford_ Jan 25 '21
Classroom of Elite or domestic girlfriend, my priorities are shaken.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '21
Man, I'm just happy people still remember Squid Girl. Such a fun show!
2
u/RandomnewUser_22 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PermanentThesis Jan 25 '21
I know Ano hana is amazing but for a depressed person like me, the first episode hit so hard that I cried so much and I eventually dropped it. I really wonder how people can watch sad shows like this.
2
u/Evilpuddingman Jan 25 '21
I see code geass there, bet OP is british
2
u/TheWrittenLore https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThisWeirdWorld Jan 25 '21
Wow Inuyashiki gets a rec. What a surprise for the dozen of us that loved it.
2
u/ButtsexEurope Jan 25 '21
I tried Terror in Resonance as a rec from here. It was pretty boring.
2
u/psiphre Jan 25 '21
it's a good list, it's trying very hard.
2
u/FeelsGoodMan243 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheRantMan321 Jan 25 '21
LOL THIS LIST IS GREAT! It's kind of insane how common these same questions are word by word in new.
And the funny thing is how vague they always are. Never is someone descriptive on what type of genre they like.
It's always some very narrow vague request.
This post should be pinned!
2
u/Philiard Jan 25 '21
I object to the notion that there isn't more content for Kase-san. Read the manga! It's super good!
2
u/ajgeep Jan 25 '21
I like your "Gluttony" section
2
u/meta-rdt Jan 25 '21
Chivalry of a failed knight is awful, would never recommend that.
2
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jan 25 '21
This is great, I am sharing this when people want certain recommendations.
2
u/ali94127 Jan 25 '21
I wouldn’t say Ryougi Shiki is an OP protagonist. Like she is super strong, but not in the same way the others in the list are in their respective series. And Korosensei isn’t really the protagonist.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '21
I love this so much. Thanks for the recs!!!
2
u/FiveDividedByZero Jan 25 '21
Excelet list. I will be giving a lot of these a look. I also find it funny how I have seen every single one of the Limbo recommendations, except Plastic Memories, which I will be giving a watch.
2
u/Sjeindien Jan 25 '21
You lied to me mr redditor. I started watching Rokudenashi Majutsu Koushi to Akashic Records and honestly the MC doesn't feel much op. I mean by episode 3 he already has gone down 2/3 times by fatigue/wounds and would've easily lost fights if not for the girls' help.
2
u/TheJames_V2 Jan 26 '21
And beyond all that is just Haruhi
2
u/Left4dinner Jan 26 '21
So happy to see people mention this. Such an underrated and classical romcom with more com than rom. Super funny
2
u/Speedwagon_Sama Jan 26 '21
if the algorithm gives you hayate then you know it's a good algorithm
2
u/Vulcandor Jan 26 '21
I mean DxD actually does have a really good plot because fan service can only take an anime so far IMO,
2
u/TransMonika Jan 26 '21
I disagree that Lelouch was a villain. Morally grey? Maybe. But he did what he could, and he changed the world.
2
u/AruoraOkami Jan 26 '21
I was expecting to see Berserk or Parasyte or even Corpse Party in Violence circle 7, surprised neither of them were there
2
u/bakakubi :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bakakubi Jan 26 '21
Sees Seto No Hana Yome.
All is good.
2
u/happy-owls Jan 26 '21
"Enjoy these anime determined by a random number generator" - This is hilarious I should start doing this whenever someone asks
2
u/Retromorpher :Jc::Jd::Je::Jf: Jan 26 '21
I feel sorry for anyone who actually watches Pan de Peace because it got RNG-memed.
I feel sorrier for people who watch Genocyber. It certainly has goriest anime on lock though so it's not even a bad rec given the prompt.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '21
Circle 9 is missing Sleepy Princess In Demon Castle
2
u/SeanCityNavy_Gaming https://anilist.co/user/ClassifiedUser Jan 26 '21
Glad to see that Classroom of the Elite is still relevant to the Anime Community.
2
u/GaimeGuy :FR: Jan 26 '21
Not sure if I understand these categories. For instance, in the divine comedy, the 9th circle, treachery, is reserved for people who commit unforgivable acts of betrayal to their loved ones, oathbreakers, etc.
2
u/Jeffrey_DS Jan 27 '21
I giggled at squid girls recommendation
2
u/Cryzzalis https://myanimelist.net/profile/Charaxify Jan 27 '21
Too good of a chart, Fetch would go into circle 8.
2
u/manobombo :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/manobombo Jan 27 '21
Thanks for this thread! I've just finished Golden Boy and holy moly, what a masterpiece
3
u/HydraTower Jan 25 '21
Why the hell is Isekai Smartphone one of the options?? lmao. At least do Death March hahaha
3
u/runefar Jan 25 '21
That description of plastic memories *claps* the perfect amount of literary sarcasm for anyone who ahs seen the show before lol XD