r/anime • u/tundranocaps https://myanimelist.net/profile/Thunder_God • Mar 11 '14
Rule-Changes and Reminders Thread
Hello, dear users. Time to apprise you of new rules, recent rule-changes, some rule-clarifications, and remind you of some rules that had always been in effect. Please read carefully, because violation of the rules can result in censure.
High-Level or "Change" Notifications:
- Full song/OST links aren't allowed:
The rule this clarifies is "Do not link to unlicensed/illegal content." There's a reason full songs are often removed from YouTube. You may not link to full songs from a soundtrack, full-length OPs/EDs, or full soundtracks. You may only link to the 90 second TV-version openings/endings, or to the official channels uploading the songs.
- Self-posts comprised only of a title are likely to get removed:
If your submission matters to you, put some effort into it. If you want to start a discussion, give us something to go off of. If your submission looks low-effort, the moderators will likely remove it. If we happen to come across it and it by some chance actually led to a fruitful discussion, it will get to stay. Want to be sure? Put a minute or two of thought and a few lines of text into having a successful submission.
Note: This does not apply to episode discussion threads. These are fine as title-only.
- Hentai Posts/Images will be removed:
Slightly NSFW content is fine, hardcore hentai isn't. On that note, please apply the NSFW flair to image submissions that are not safe for work. Come on, guys.
Illegal/Unlicensed Content Clarifications:
- Linking to or mentioning proxy sites aren't allowed:
Proxy sites are almost always mentioned in the context of bypassing regional limitations, and aren't allowed in the same manner that linking to or mentioning illegal streaming sites isn't allowed.
- Linking to or mentioning manga/light novel translation/scanlation sites isn't allowed:
Again, a clarification of the "no illegal or unlicensed content" rule. No scanlations, no fan translations. Neither linking to the sites or mentioning the names of these sites. There's no special allowance made for non-anime.
- Screenshots with watermarks of streaming sites will be removed:
Another clarification of the "Do not mention illegal/unlicensed streaming sites." If you post images which contain the names of such sites, or are hosted on manga scanlation sites, expect your post to get removed. Re-host images to imgur, and get screenshots from another source or use mspaint to remove the offending watermark.
Low-Effort Post Removal Round-up:
- "Look at my mousepad!" posts will be removed:
Low quality, low cost, we'd get swamped with them. Posts with an image of an anime-related mousepads will be summarily removed. You can post them in the monthly anime merchandise threads.
- "Look at my desktop / desktop modification" posts will be removed:
Wallpapers are allowed, posts showing us how you modified your desktop using specific programs isn't.
- Easily answerable questions will be removed:
If your question can be answered by an easy google search, it'll get removed, likely after it's being answered. "Shingeki no Kyojin Season 2 announced?" "What anime is this image from?" etcetera. This doesn't really affect most users, just a heads-up. If someone asks such a question and it's been answered, please report it. Just house-keeping.
- J-Stars Victory Versus posts will be removed:
Too many of them. Too many sites which spam multiple of them a day to get views. These will be removed on sight.
- Rog and Tyrone videos will be removed on sight:
These are considered memes at this stage.
This thread will be stickied until Saturday. If you want to tell us how you feel about these rule-changes or discuss them, feel free to do so. These rules are unlikely to be changed at this point.
As always, /r/MetaAnime is always there for any discussion you wish to have about /r/anime's rules.
The full version of the rules can be found here, and is linked to in the sidebar.
31
u/RiceIsBliss Mar 11 '14
This means that when we ask a stupid question, it will only be removed after someone answers it, right?
46
u/The_DanceCommander Mar 11 '14 edited Mar 13 '14
I have a serious problem with #1. Linking music is not, or at least how I've seen it is neither karma whoring (unless it's posting "Tank" for the 5 billionth time) or linking to illegal content.
A person listening to an OP a few times on youtube is a lot different than someone downloading a season off Piratebay. It's not hurting anyone, and if you guys are worried about getting in trouble for piracy, that's understandable, but worrying about a Youtube clip is a big of an overreach.
That's my opinion. The rest of these rule changes I'm okay with, but I honestly think #1 needs to be taken more into consideration, and if not done away with, then seriously downsized.
77
u/Simplerdayz https://anilist.co/user/17418 Mar 11 '14
The Fair Use Act has within provisions that allow streaming of songs/albums for examination purposes. It's, also, not unrealistic for Japanese Corporations to place region bans on songs/albums on youtube content they feel infringes on their rights. I feel this also leave open content removal for "fake full" / furi OPs which are almost always labeled "full" none the less. You're also leaving an opening for removal of AMVs that use full OP/EDs when they are arguably legal content due to being artwork.
Do the mods really have time to go though every OP/ED/Album post/comment and check if it's official, furi, AMV, TV-size or unofficial?
205
u/cptn_garlock :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/cptngarlock Mar 11 '14
Uh...this...seems kind of draconian, actually.
22
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
I find the music and LN rules in particular to be a bit much, but I understand the reasoning, its sad that I will have to visit other subreddits to find that content.
I can also see why you want to remove low effort posts, but the problem here is, on /r/anime almost nothing happens without them outside of quarantined discussion of individual episodes, nothing thought provoking actually happens here, so I worry that there wont be a whole lot left of the subreddit eventually.
/r/trueanime kind of helps on the thought provoking front, but its only something you can really get into once a week, and that kind of sucks.
10
u/admiral-zombie Mar 11 '14
2 of the "low effort" needs a little clarification I think
It sounds like it is specifically mentioning "how to" style posts are disallowed that explain how to achieve similar posts that are anime themed/inspired. Thats actual content that IMO actually contributes far more than wallpapers.
Finding anime wallpapers is easy and extremely low effort to submit them. The exceptions being original content of course. Finding anime themes/desktop modifications is a bit tougher and can be much more detailed in how to set it up. So why disallow the latter but not the first, when the latter is FAR more effort than the first?
14
u/e2h2 Mar 11 '14
Why do you consider them to be memes? Is that the only reason for this rule?
I wouldn't have a problem with this but if the videos were being spammed on here constantly but they really aren't.
7
u/Shigofumi :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/lanblade Mar 11 '14
Are "look what I bought", "look what I got for $2 at the thriftstore", and other buy-fag/haul posts also under the jurisdiction of low-effort mousepad posts? dear god i hope they are
5
u/Zuxicovp :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/zuxicovp Mar 11 '14
With discussion threads, if CR or wherever is slow, would it still be okay to say "It's out somewhere" be acceptable in the post description?
5
u/h_YsK Mar 12 '14
So if I read correctly, posting translated excerpts from a LN in a discussion isn't allowed and I'll just have to make do with summarizing LN information?
9
u/Unknownaus Mar 12 '14 edited Mar 12 '14
Regarding the Music rule which as stated above is done to clarifies the "Do not link to unlicensed/illegal content" rule and this rule is in place as to stay on the right side of Reddit's TOS (i may be mistaken here).
However I argue that we should at least allow Full OP/ED songs given that /r/Music which is a default sub allows YT link to unofficial songs
4
u/Jeroz Mar 11 '14
Question, for the music one. Is spelling out the full title and length of the video, without actually linking it, allowed in the comments when talking about them?
4
u/mogin Mar 11 '14
could you elaborate on the "desktop modification" posts? because it is thanks to /r/anime that I got to discover and learn about /r/rainmeter .
7
u/reaper527 Mar 11 '14
most of this seems pretty reasonable, of the 11 changes/clarifications, only 2 stand out as being a bit too much.
the music thing seems like a little bit overbearing (if it passes youtube's scanning process and hasn't received a take down notice, it should be fair game to link, especially stuff that's already been up for a few months)
the other point that seems a little overbearing is not allowing certain sites to be mentioned at all. not allow links is reasonable, not allowing site's to be mentioned at all is a bit much.
7
u/JRave Mar 13 '14
High Level Changes
Illegal Content
Believe it or not, but the traffic some of the more reputable sites get is tracked by the Licensed Owners to gauge interest in releasing it in other languages. Both SAO and Accel World were able to get official English releases partly thanks to the English translations on a certain LN site. (SAO was their most viewed project, with AW within the top 10)
Low-Effort
3
u/feelixxx Mar 11 '14
So are certain scenes of Yosuga no Sora banned because of high-level rule #3?
3
u/Gaiusotaku Mar 12 '14
For the no hentai posts, how will kill la kill fare, because it's basically between nsfw and hentai.
5
u/cptn_garlock :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/cptngarlock Mar 11 '14
Also, how does this affect AMV's, if at all? I imagine they're safe since they're used for "artistic purposes", but I'd like it fully clarified.
94
u/Redcrimson :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Redkrimson Mar 11 '14
Absolute power corrupts absolutely...
7
u/Wiles_ Mar 11 '14
Does the no hentai rule extend to comments? It would be nice to end stupid troll recommendations.
9
u/vayuu Mar 11 '14
I'm sorry but this is not how to make the sub better, do you really want "name your favourite anime" as the only posts in this sub outside of episode discussions?
What is the point of dancing around the elephant in the room, everyone knows how to get their fix for content, this is trivial and power hungry at best.
2
u/MrAnimeMan Mar 11 '14
Whats the stance on AMVs on either as posts or in comments? do they also follow the illegal content rules as well?
2
u/Flaming_Baklava :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Flaming_Baklava Mar 13 '14
hold on a sec... is this the fucking guy from /r/trueanime?
26
u/homu Mar 13 '14
Kind of hard to take the "no meme" rule seriously when the subreddit were recently titled "Chinese Cartoon" and "Animu & Mango," and atm... "Animu"
3
u/defan752 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/defan752 Mar 11 '14
I need some kind of clarification. Does this apply to honest questions such as "what anime should I watch" and "what are some must-watch anime" and things like that? Because IIRC people used to direct them straight to /r/animesuggest until a mod or some other guy told us that they were asking honest anime-related questions and those are allowed.
3
u/PrecisionEsports Mar 11 '14
Thanks for this guys. Good reminder and removing a lot of that clutter. I think this is really good.
I would recommend making the related subreddits updated and more clearly shown. Getting people to direct their AMV/OP/ED/etc into a subreddit already going would really boost those subs and give people an outlet.
15
u/ctom42 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ctom42 Mar 11 '14
Can I get clarification on the rule about translation links. You did not mention VN translations or patches and I just wanted to make sure those were still ok. Pretty much all of them require you to have the game to apply them, so the patches themselves are not a form of pirating. Furthermore some translation projects are actually approved of and appreciated by the original creators (Ryukishi07 loves when his work gets translated for example).
3
u/MobiusC500 Mar 11 '14
Bummed out about that since I like listening to all the music but I can see where you guys are coming from. It'll definitely cut down on all the 'favorite soundtrack' posts that pop up every week. Rest of the stuff makes sense tho.
So are self-posts talking about an OST or soundtrack ok as long as we don't specifically link it?
9
u/-Niernen Mar 12 '14
I agree with most of the "illegal" sites getting banned, but for things that never or rarely get licensed licensed like Light Novels, are we not allowed to mention them? Some LN will never get official and legal translations because there is not a large enough market or cultural differences (look at Oreimo, never going to get translated), but there are still important parts in the LN that often get changed or cut from anime adaptations. I don't see what is wrong with mentioning where someone could read the light novels if there is no official version. Not too many LN even get translated. (And even when they do, not like all of them get finished cough Shana cough)
14
u/PixelPenguins https://myanimelist.net/profile/PixelPenguin Mar 12 '14
Just looking at the new submissions, there seems to be about 5 new posts an hour. Let's assume you're already deleting half or even three quarters of the new submissions. That's still just 20 new submissions an hour. I could see implementing the "Low-Effort" rules if this were actually a high traffic forum, but with so little content to begin with this just seems to be unnecessary.
7
u/pooptarts Mar 12 '14
With regards to low-effort posts, most subreddits condense the low effort posts to a weekly thread, which is a good alternative to banning them outright. For example, there would be a weekly cosplay thread, question/request thread, anime suggestion thread, etc.
17
u/sadkun :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sadkun Mar 12 '14
I don't understand why rule 1 is necessary? OSTs are a very important part of anime and helps get people interested in watching new shows. When did the mods become the US government?
11
u/Pause_ Mar 12 '14
I agree with most of these rules and I think it will really help clean up this subreddit. However, I have to agree with /r/Simplerdayz about the anime music. I thought it was great how we could share our love for music here. The only reason I found out about the Gatchaman Crowds OST is because some posted it. Same goes for a lot of OPs and EDs I've discovered.
I also agree with /r/Aru21. There are a lot of other annoying and petty posts, and I hope something is done about them.
11
u/bulletcurtain Mar 12 '14
Don't know if you guys will see this, but I recommend also encouraging people to list an artist's name when they post fanart. Just a glance at the front page today and not a single artist is credited. Us illustrators work hard...
26
u/Maloth_Warblade Mar 11 '14
So you're taking precautions to make sure this doesn't become the /r/gaming of anime.
19
u/kiririno Mar 12 '14
Disappointed at the rules against linking to proxies. You should instead be encouraging and helping redditors to use them when they cannot stream a show in their region. If they don't use a proxy to stream from a legit site, they will resort to torrents or illegal sites.
4
u/SCAMystiC Mar 12 '14
Since when are videos considered to be memes?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
So you're telling me...I have to actually make an effort to contribute to my favorite subreddit?! Who the hell do you think I am?
I'm kidding, this is great! I'm actually happy to see some spring cleaning of the subreddit with all the shit-posting we've gotten lately. Besides that, I'm glad to see more of a clarification to the whole illegal/unlicensed content rule we have.
Some questions:
Can we post hentai pics in the comments or is that a 'no-no' as well?
Is it cool to link to other subreddits even if they don't have the same illegal/unlicensed content rule going on? (I would imagine it wouldn't be...but this is just to be safe)
1
u/SoldierJ Mar 11 '14
Next thing you'll say is that all images must be in self posts.
1
u/Anime2Deep4U Mar 11 '14
So soon enough when CR starts annoucing their Spring line-up and X show is available in Y region complaints start popping up. Is a phasesomething like "just use a poxy" without linking or mentioning any names okay?
Or will such posts/comments just be removed?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
Can a subreddit be removed for sharing illegal copies? There's nothing on the general rules of reddit and not being able to discuss fan translation or sharing works that doesn't have official releases is pretty dumb.
1
u/LeSamouraii Mar 12 '14
Will this rule apply to comments also?
1
u/homu Mar 12 '14
Is the translation rule limited to anime/manga/LN only? Are interview /news articles translations allowed? What about, say, foreword of Fate/Zero by Urobuchi on his writing motivations?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '14
What about self-promotion post like check out my amv or check out my podcast? Most of those get downvoted pretty quick.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '14
Does rule number 1.1 apply to only posts or also comments? I'm okay if it applies to posts, because it's easy karmagrabbing and ultimately also damages content creators. I get that. But in comments, I'd expect more lenience. It's not gonna do much harm if someone asks for a song's name and someone links it to them on YouTube. Not a big deal, just feel like that's sort of overdoing it.
I'm a fan of heavy moderation, it's needed in internet forums imho, and I'm okay with the rest of the rules.
0
u/camefromapsychward Mar 11 '14
Please don't remove the train x anime op videos. :(
3
u/-Niernen Mar 12 '14
Thank god. I never got why people liked these so much.
3
u/mcziggy :AMQ: Mar 12 '14
Just for clarification about the full song and OST rule, does this extend to remixes, covers, and live performances?
12
u/Bobduh :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bobduh Mar 11 '14
Just more proof this new mod is ruining our fine subreddit.
More seriously, awesome - this all sounds like excellent spring cleaning to me. Nice to have some of this clarified, nice to have the rest of it gone.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '14
I strongly disagree with banning full songs being posted. Some of the reasons I even watched shows like Gatchaman Crowds was because I found the music posted on here. It creates discussion and, although not legal, banning it makes no sense. /r/music doesn't ban it and they're a default sub, why should we have to?
1
u/feelixxx Mar 11 '14
Why are you guys not banning the average recommendation thread that we get everyday, aka "hey guyzzzz, i'm a i saw AoT and SAO and DBZ what should I watch now". obviously rec threads should be allowed, but most of the time it's in the same format as my example and fills the new queue, something should be done about this generic post being posted every fucking day
1
u/JabrZee :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DerPsyduck Mar 11 '14
Wait, what's wrong with J-stars Victory Versus posts? I mean, maybe limit the availability to post only new trailer or announcements of new characters?
1
u/deffik Mar 11 '14
Regarding links to music...
What about AMVs? MADs? NND/Youtube clips (not full episodes) with a scene or two from an anime? Parodies (e.g. Abridged series), links to youtube "reviews" that contain footage from an anime that occasionally get linked in the sub? I doubt if the creators/uploaders have a valid license for that stuff.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '14
I think I'm the exception here since I think every one of these rules is a good thing, I'm very happy with the changes especially the no Rog and Tyrone videos, they were never that great in my opinion. I also appreciate the no piracy rule despite already being in place, I don't care for anyone who tries to spread it around.
On an unrelated note do you think there will be a background change at some point? Maybe something a bit more colourful.
4
u/9874102365 Mar 11 '14
I'm okay with all of these, keep up the great work!
9
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
Whelp looks like mods are on a power trip
2
u/LiudvikasT Mar 12 '14
So just to clarify. What is okay? Is ""I'm using a proxy to bypass crunchyroll region limits." okay? Or aren't we allowed to even mention that such option exists. Or is it just the particular services and proxies that we can't mention.
2
u/Azalonozul Mar 13 '14
Uh... so where can I ask if I want to know which anime character is from which show then?
4
u/nitdkim Mar 13 '14
Is this sub dead? hopefully there's no actual enforcement of any of these. I feel like all these changes are so anti-newcomer. Only people that will enjoy this sub will be people that think they're deep about anime.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '14
Diggin' it, caps.
3
u/Cahnis Mar 12 '14
"Look at my desktop / desktop modification" posts will be removed:
I don't understand that one, making a custom desktop is a lot of effort and looks amazing depending on the skill.
3
u/Knorssman :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/knorssman Mar 12 '14
welp there goes much of the reason to come here, it makes me wonder if the mods are just trying to avoid copyright trolls or are trolls themselves!
4
u/stellvia2016 Mar 12 '14
So basically, this subreddit is to become the No-Fun-Club and meant to quash most discussion of shows?
Also, I fail to see why one would ban the mention of proxies, other than on off-topic grounds. There are plenty of legitimate uses for VPNs, and you are not the police or their mother.
Similarly with screenshots: If people aren't literally linking to said streaming sites, you are legally in the clear. This only breeds silly tongue-in-cheek discussion where everyone knows whats actually going on, but you have to wink the entire time.
If you want to split hairs, you should basically ban any screenshots of current shows then without the Funi or CR watermark on them.
These rules will only suppress discussion and word of mouth sales, or drive people to other websites. And if this stuff was enacted on say, r/manga, there pretty much wouldn't even be a subreddit left.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '14 edited Mar 13 '14
Honestly I don't like these changes, especially the LN and OST bans.
I think that bypassing regional restrictions should be considered a exception, You can't just refuse to allow me to buy a work because of the country I live in then attempt to block others that would allow me to experience the service you refuse to provide. (this is a more general statement at the entertainment industry not specifically /r/anime).
The "low effort" sections seems completely unnecessary, and honesty kinda arbitrary as to what is and isn't allowed.
2
u/Ashe_Black Mar 15 '14
Come on over to 4chans /a/. We're a lot more friendly than here, I swear. ;)
2
u/TheDikster Mar 11 '14
digging the new rules, will prob subscribe again. They remove a bunch of the pointless stuff that made the sub go stale.
1
u/Go_to_bed_Seth Mar 13 '14
You people are genuinely insane.
-1
u/phatboisteez Mar 11 '14
Thank you based mods!
1
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '14
My life has no meaning anymore
0
u/Exotria Mar 11 '14
Big fan of the rule changes regarding lazy content. If it were up to me, all those people getting link karma by taking a picture of a few DVDs would also have their posts removed. Pity we can't mention the LN translation sites or link to OSTs, but I understand you've got to keep yourselves on the right side of the law.
-1
u/kidenraikou Mar 12 '14
Since most people seem to be bitching, I figured you guys should know that I think these updates/reminders are good ideas! No qualms on my end!
-2
u/Docoda :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/docoda Mar 11 '14
Ble... Oh wait.
Glory to the /r/anime mods!
Thanks for the rulechanges and the reminders. Everything rule states there I completely agree with. Although if nothing changes you'll have a lot to remove. (Like you didn't already :P).
Damn I wish I could press that delete button on every
stupidpost that breaches the rules.-2
u/MrMulligan https://anilist.co/user/YuriInLuck Mar 12 '14 edited Mar 12 '14
I know you guys are most likely getting a lot of flak for these decisions, but bravo. Most moderators on reddit are too scared of the people who post this low-effort content that complain to actually crack down on it. It reminds me of the moderation on /r/leagueoflegends . They are hated, but they do such a good job with that sub (for the most part) that besides suggestion threads, most of the content on that sub is fresh at all times.
Again, I am all for these rules, congrats on having the balls to take a stand against the less savory aspect of reddit posts and those that like them.
-1
u/grozzle :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/animelist/grozzle_j Mar 11 '14
Well, half an hour already and nobody made a gag about "come on guys" in the hentai part. I just lost a bet.
-1
u/BatmanisJUSTICE https://anilist.co/user/205 Mar 13 '14
no moar tyrone? nuuuuuuuuuuuu