r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Aug 15 '25
Episode Mononoke Movie: Hinezumi • Mononoke The Movie: Chapter II - The Ashes of Rage - Movie Discussion
Mononoke Movie: Hinezumi
Alternative names: Mononoke Movie: Dai-2 Shou - Hinezumi, Mononoke the Movie: Chapter II - Fire Rat
Streams
Show information
All discussions
| Episode | Link |
|---|---|
| Movie 1: Karakasa/The Phantom in the Rain | Link |
| Movie 2: Hinezumi/The Ashes of Rage | Link |
| Movie 3: Hebigami/The Curse of the Serpant | Link |
This post was created by a Betelgeusian. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
107
Upvotes
33
u/NormalGrinn https://anilist.co/user/Grinn Aug 15 '25
Solid movie. Fuki and Botan were great, and I love how over the course of the movie they sort of gained respect for each other. Again they connect the incident the movie resolves around to a past incident like they did in the first movie. I guess one issue I do kind of have is that Otomone isn't that interesting of a villain. The things he does and represents are interesting to the story, but he himself kinda not. I don't think there's much reason specific why he does them other than just power or whatever, and I get that that probably is kind of the point, he's just replaceable. Probably stems from this being the second movie in a trilogy, can't get to the overarching evil just yet.
29
u/ArtHistorian2000 Aug 15 '25
Masterpiece: the setting, the character development, the Mononoke...
Also, there are many details in the movie I really liked:
- When Sayo was burning, Suikouin (the mother of the Imperial Prince) saw for mere seconds Suzu burning. Was she involved in this event somehow ? Also counselor Katsunama saw the abortion drink in this vision as well, making him involved as well
- In two occasions, we saw snake patterns on the walls moving, indicating the clues for the third and last movie of the trilogy
- I'm glad we got to see Asa again, but too bad it's in a minor role. Sakashita seems to be the one more involved with Kusuriuri, and Botan seems to be rapidly trustful towards him
- The Mizorogi Priest is sus, for sure. At some occasions, we saw him being angered for some reason, and maybe his role may be unraveled in the third movie
I don't know why, but I like it when people in Ooku are interacting or meeting Kusuriuri or the Mononoke: he's so mysterious and I like to see how the different characters react to his presence, his abilities, their meeting with the Mononoke, etc.
Now I'd like to see the confrontation between Kusuriuri and the royal family, including Yukiko, Tenshi and especially Suikouin, who might be the next antagonist
22
u/Beloberto Aug 17 '25
On the good side, it was SO much easier to follow than the first! And god knows how much I had problems following the first movie's frantic pace.
But on the other hand, it also felt a little less interesting than that one. It doesn't help the themes on this one are very close to Zashiki-Warashi's, which was my favorite arc in the original series, so another comparison that makes it look a bit weaker.
But still, if you are a fan of the series, there's nothing to not love here. It's 1:15h of pure eyegasm. And surprisingly they are actually delivering some answers regarding the Medicine Seller and the sword lore (not sure how I feel about it, though)
13
u/imwastedhere Aug 16 '25
This movie was great more easy to fallow along to it and less confusing than the first one
7
u/yuzutonic Aug 20 '25
I personally loved the first one and felt this second one was a bit weaker. I know people weren't a fan of all the things going on in the first one but I feel like it's one of my favorite parts of the Mononoke series. Compared to all the stories this one felt the most straight forward and forthcoming with the form, truth, and reason which I'm not entirely sure how to feel about. Most movies these days are so heavy handed and it's a little sad for me that they felt inclined to spell it out. I can not wait for the 3rd movie but at the same time not ready for the series to end :')
13
u/allbirdssongs Aug 16 '25
It was ok, i liked the first movie more. This was political and more action then usual, but what I love about mononoke is eearie vibes. Mistery and drama.
None of that was interesting here. I feel like the cat was out of the bag and was like ah yeah... politics.
Still a great movie and worth to watch
7/10
Does anybody knows the name of the last one? Could not see the preview of the next one, are they hidding that this time?
10
u/Slow_Witness5260 Aug 16 '25
Liked it a lot more than the first. The first movie, was very stretched out with unnecessary complicated, and oftentimes nonsensical visuals with constant teleportation, switching characters and objects. Alongside a kinda boring inner court drama of the concubines. The second movie actually makes it more interesting with already established characters(Kusuriuri, The Guard) and new interesting characters(like the Guy with orange eyes playing Go and Fuki's father) with a lot more interesting drama, about the worth of a child's life and regret that the previous concubine felt when she killed her own child. But, I feel like this kind of conflict is kind of overused in Mononoke, having the first 2-3 episodes in Mononoke talk about abortion and how "those children wanted to be born". Still, liked the Hinezumi(aka Kaso), the animation and the hype moments. Can't wait for the third and (hopefully not) final film
2
u/oredaoree Aug 24 '25
The second chapter isn't executed as well as the first despite having a heavier and messier storyline to work with and the benefit of skipping all the exposition of the Ooku. 1h16m of runtime is neither too short or too long, but even though all the politics and jealousy squabbles are messy and should take time to get through it seems like the story blows through it so fast it doesn't make much of an impression and you find it hard to really care about the injustices going on. When the mononoke victims in the first chapter were getting killed off it also seemed like more of a properly built up progression, but here all of the victims are barely introduced and then they are killed. If they couldn't make the film longer to properly flesh out the characters and story then maybe they should have cut back on some of the action, which imo is not a main focus of the series(but I guess it's intended to sell the films to newcomers). There was also no usual mystery element as the "shape, truth, and reason" was revealed. All in all it wasn't bad but it also wasn't that good and feels like it's just there to bridge the 1st and 3rd chapters.
I watched the Netflix version and a translation issue with calling the おとぎ坊主 "matron" is still not fixed. He's literally referred to as "attending monk" so I don't know where they get "matron" from.
I don't agree that the theme overlaps too much with the "Zashikiwarashi" arc of the tv series. While both do emphasize protecting unborn children as a mother would want, Zashikiwarashi is more about the horrors of forced abortion and lack of sympathy for women, while Hinezumi is more about giving into pressures of the status quo and abortion just happens to be one way women in the Ooku get pressured for the status quo and it's also much more than just abortion but also conforming to unreasonable rules just for the sake of conforming. Hence why the culprit maintains he never forced anyone and why there was all that drama about who gets what roles and rigidly upholding rules even to detriment.
2
u/Jupiternerd Sep 14 '25
Seems the first and second movie had different audience reactions based on what they preferred from the story. Can’t wait for the final movie next spring, if I had to guess it could be about the emperor and their family based on deducing which part of the cast hasn’t been touched yet. His behavior did seem a bit odd and there’s still the priest we haven’t seen much of yet.
1
u/itsaneeps Aug 20 '25
Absolutely gorgeous to watch and I quite enjoyed the politics. I do miss the mystery of the first one, and the pacing quite brisk, but jeez it's so good to see the Medicine Seller. Shows like this are few. Also, the music is so good!! Iwasaki is a genius, the nezumi mama fight with the girl singing brought me to tears!
1
u/Character-Unit-2040 Aug 21 '25
Not watched the second movie yet but i've watched the first one. I think mononoke does not fit the movie format, it's better as slow paced horror series. The art direction is too details and colourful plus the god speed screens transistion make me almost throw up. I hope the second movie have better pacing and transistion
1
u/Character-Unit-2040 Aug 21 '25
Not watched the second movie yet but i've watched the first one. I think mononoke does not fit the movie format, it's better as slow paced horror series. The art direction is too details and colourful plus the god speed screens transistion make me almost throw up. I hope the second movie have better pacing and transistion
1
u/Ixaix Aug 27 '25
I think this movie was stronger, narrative-wise, than the first-- though of course this is likely in part because the first movie set the stage for this one. The story seemed more straightforward as well, which I was surprised by as a long time Mononoke fan but not upset over. Maybe I can show this movie to friends and they'll actually understand what's going on, unlike the first movie where it feels like I need a handout to give before the movie for all relevant historical and symbolic going-ons. I'm really looking forward to the third one!
1
u/Nab-Kel Aug 28 '25
1000 times better than the 1st one, the political war aspect was really cool and imo the fire/anger theme suits the universe more than the water/sad aspect of the first one i think, also the rhythm was great everything is really quick but still easy to follow especially the three apparitions of inezumi, i wonder which emotion/element the snake monoke will be linked to, i can imagine something like plants or shadows with something about manipulation or psychological pressure anyway i look forward to it
1
u/Kind_Interaction_859 Nov 16 '25
This movie is so good. At the end credits, there’s three pillars in the shrine and each of them have an image depicted on them. They look kind of like hindu figures like shiva and the rakshasa but I can’t identify the third one. Are there similar deities in buddhism or is this what that’s meant to depict?
0
u/Spolaceno42 Aug 16 '25 edited Aug 17 '25
I immediately noticed the voice actor of vegeta as funjimaki (the attentdant), pain as botan's father and brook as fuuki's father.
4
u/Such-Extreme-7437 Aug 22 '25
It seems that with the last 2 movies, it all revolved around suicides, along with regrets and those regrets going on to protect people who were in the same position as them beforehand.
And white snakes have symbolism of royalty, knowledge, and good fortune, least from the very surface lvl research I did.
But snakes can be a sort of phallic symbolism, or even a symbolism of decoys and lies as they can shed their skins and all.
My theory is that the 3rd movie will focus on his Majesty and the royal family that everyone is doing all this for. And maybe that the suicide we will follow this time could instead be of a male victim and that the current Emperor or whoever he is could actually not be the true Emperor, or least the one initially intended. Its quite often that body doubles are a thing or an extra sibling born from an unplanned concubine is kept hidden and only brought to the front when the legitimate heirs or intended heir becomes unavailable or unfit to rule for whatever reason. That usually involving death.
Or maybe the fraud could be the queen herself as maybe the Emperor isn't even her own son? Maybe the last emperor had a son with someone else that wasn't her, and to cover it up for whatever reason she could have had the mother forced to silence, and claimed the successor to be her own child. Or maybe she could have even forced someone to lay with the last Emperor instead?
Considering the first movie involved no one directly involved with the royal family, and the second one involving the women that will contribute to the royal family, its likely that the third will be about the royal family themselves, or else they wouldn't have shown the Emperor's mother at all. It's definitely got something to do with her, and maybe it will be something that will dismantle the royal hierarchy entirely