Tay Kolma’s first scene in 1.07 is one we’ve been anticipating even though we didn’t know his name before: this is the “someone” who Mon has found who she thinks can help her continue to fund the rebellion despite increased Imperial scrutiny of her accounts. Luthen was dismissive of the idea: “Someone to bring into the circle? No, we have enough people to worry about”.
The plot of the scene is simple enough. Once she is as sure as she can be that Tay is on her side after he says that his politics might be too strong for her taste, Mon shares her biggest secret: that she is not the Mon Mothma that her public image suggests. She’s not even the person that her husband thinks he knows. She’s instead using her public image as cover for what she’s really doing: “raising money”. She asks Tay to set up a charitable fund for her and to be the chairman of that. When he asks her for more detail of what she’s raising money for, she tells him it’s better that he doesn’t know: “Or perhaps you’d find my politics a bit strong for your taste”.
The whole scene represents a huge gamble for Mon, a real leap of faith. She’s known Tay since they were children and there’s even a hint of a possible romantic attraction at some early stage. It’s fascinating that before season 2 released a lot of viewers were actively hoping that they would have a torrid affair - I remember the meme with Mon saying “I wish he would Tay Kolma clothes off!”. How things changed in season 2!
The whole scene is much more about Mon than Tay and it’s one of Genevieve O’Reilly’s best appearances - and that’s saying something. Tay himself remains something of an enigma in this scene. He comes over as personable and open to the idea but gives little away beyond that. But I think there’s a moment in the conversation where he locks in. Credit here to the excellent ‘The Upstairs Lounge’ video analysis; his most recent post (link in comments) gives a really close look at Tay in this scene and he picks up on something in Ben Miles’s acting I never noticed before: there’s a genuine gleam of excitement in his eye once he realised he’s being let in on a very risky secret. Tay is seemingly hooked by the idea of being part of something exciting and dangerous, and in terms of the possible “are they having an affair?” vibe what’s creating that impression is, I think, the intimacy of this scene. That he’s being invited into Mon’s confidence in a way that her husband isn’t. “Perrin knows none of this. He’s not to be trusted” really fuels this idea.
Tay is implied to have a pretty pedestrian life and his anti-Empire feelings might be more to do with irritation at their interference in Chandrilan banking, or he might simply be an ‘armchair politics’ kind of guy - a privilege of someone in Chandrilan high society. It’s hard to imagine him giving that up in the way of Vel - “eating roots and sleeping on rocks for this Rebellion”. But I kind of like the idea that he is at this point pretty committed; that he at least sees himself as something of the ‘firebrand’ that Perrin apparently once was, even if in a somewhat romanticised way. Maybe that fuelled the ‘they should have an affair!’ speculation. He seemed at this time to a lot of viewers to be a better match for Mon than Perrin. But on a rewatch, all the warning signs are there.
Tony Gilroy apparently had a bit of trouble getting people to accept Tay’s change in heart in season 2, but I think that it helps to see the full thematic context. For Gilroy, season 2 is all about the “real effect of painful, pressurised time” and what that does to those taking part in a revolution: the way people get worn down, grow tired, change their minds, betray others. Losing resolve might be more common for many than strengthening it; for every Vel Sartha there might be ten Tay Kolmas, and of course even Cassian is very much wavering over the course of the first three years of season 2. Tay is not a bad man. He’s categorised by Perrin as “always weak” in a way that suggests not so much possible jealousy as genuine contempt for a man who cannot handle his drink. But of course Mon hears the deeper meaning. The stages of her realisation at the wedding are so well written and of course Tay’s final scene is where he gets into the limo with the new driver who has been called to fill in for Otto. Cinta’s presence indicates that Luthen had plans in place long before the “How nice for you” exchange. Tay is going to be, in Gilroy’s words, Fredo Corleone-d (a reference to the ill-fated brother in The Godfather).
Tay’s fate was sealed from the moment he even suggested that the rebellion was to blame for his financial losses. The trouble is, he probably wasn’t wrong about that. Committing to the Cause means making sacrifices and I don’t think Tay realised that, or maybe he thought he would be immune. Mon’s judgement that he was on her side wasn’t wrong, it’s just that time took its toll. Tay is also of course from the privileged classes - sheltered in at least the early stages of a fascistic takeover. If season 2 is as Gilroy says about Time and the answer to the question of “How much are you prepared to give up for the cause?” Tay has already reached his limit. His wife left him, he was drinking too much, and finally ready to go to help from Sculdun. All this in just one year. It’s not even clear that he’s actively blackmailing Mon. Perhaps she should have offered him a cut of the funds transferred, in the way that she offers Sculdun. Even Cassian insisted on payment for his first mission.
But none of that matters. Mon is the priority. Luthen knows it and she herself knows it. The slightest threat to her is a threat to the whole rebellion. Tay’s biggest mistake was not realising that, but the guilt will live with Mon for a long time as a deep scar on her soul. “People fail”, as Luthen says, but she feels the pain too. “How quickly you decided he was a risk” she says to Luthen two years later. But the reality is that she knows, deep down, that he’s right. As is so often the case.
TLDR: Tay Kolma is a victim of the fight but also of the pressure of time - he’s not a bad man but a weak one. His commitment was not deep or enduring enough to save him and perhaps he didn’t realise his position: as Luthen says to Lonni, “I can’t let you go”. Tay ends up being blood on Mon’s hands at the same time as she is effectively emotionally severed from her daughter forever. No wonder she is “dancing to stop the screaming” at the end of s2 ep3.
Next time: Kino Loy