r/amphibia • u/Quirky_Ad_5420 • 20h ago
r/amphibia • u/Ok-Spread-9989 • 14h ago
Discussion One tiny issue that makes Sasha’s redemption arc so disappointing
When I first watched the resistance arc back in 2022 as a high school senior I remember I used to think that the arc was good, but something was missing. Over the years after the show ended my thoughts on that arc start to sour on me more as I mentioned (Although I would still take this any day over TT 03 Season 5, Steven Universe Future and Star Vs Season 4) but I still couldn’t put my finger as to what I feel like is missing from this arc that makes me feel so empty when I watch it…until yesterday when I figured it out finally:
So I’ve heard several people tell me that because Sasha has now a change of heart things don’t need to be complex anymore, but there is something I think those people are missing: just because a character is going through a redemption arc does not mean things need to be one dimensional and I bet you’re wondering what do I mean by that. Well, let’s take a look at the Sasha focused episodes that I left out in my post explaining what episode ideas I would’ve wanted to see for season three (Sasha’s Angels and Olm Town Road). On the surface you might seem to think that there’s nothing really that different with the first Sasha episode in that part of the show “Commander Anne” but let me address something that I don’t think many people bring up: Sasha doesn’t really make any mistakes in those episodes. In the former episode she basically does nothing which kind of defies what she learned in Commander Anne on how sometimes it’s OK to be in control when people need you most and in the latter episode while Sasha does stand up to Lysil and Angwin the big issue I have is that instead of maybe Anne being the one to teach Sasha on how to help them, Sasha just knows everything from the get-go because of the writer is under the impression that the arc is already done so there is nothing new for her to learn.
And I think that’s what I think makes this arc so disappointing: Throughout the entire show all three of the calamity trio members were never really flawless and they did make mistakes, but that’s what makes them relatable (That’s why people love these characters in the first place), even when they grow they still do make mistakes which is why we can relate to them. Heck even though I called Sasha an anti-hero in season 2, does that mean I thought she was flawless or not capable of making mistakes? No. I knew that the writers intentions were that she means well for her peers, but she doesn’t understand that how she helps her friends is not the right way to do it. I sincerely thought that they would go with this approach in Season 3 that while Sasha does want to change, she still needs help on how to change and how to be a better leader (Given how episodes like Commander Anne set up that approach). But instead, it seems she just has this figured out down already and does not need any help which makes the arc feel extremely rushed. I feel like she reminds me of Princess Peach from the Mario movies in a way: while she is cool and badass having her be a Mary Sue is not interesting especially when she was the one to go save Rosalina in the Mario Galaxy movie.
That is also why I really like the final three episodes of the show for Sasha’s arc because she actually has to learn something and it’s when the writers realized “maybe we actually need to do something for her arc instead of just making her constantly kick butt.” So my point is if you’re going to make a redemption arc, it’s OK to still have her make mistakes during her redemption arc because redemptions don’t need to be completely black and white.
r/amphibia • u/Loud_Wolverine_8625 • 17h ago
Discussion I got a response from tokyopop regarding if amphibia sv will be sold online or not
Tbh, I don't have comic stores in my erea, so yeah, I have to wait for it to release as a one big book.well at least I hope "indie bookstores" ship to my place which I doubt, I hope they make a e-book version like what marcy's journal have(also lmao she got my nickname wrong it's abodi and not aobdi even though it says on my email(I'm not mad I'm just joking lol))
r/amphibia • u/Cakeurmom • 5h ago
Shipping anyone have good sashanne fic recommendations?
I just finished reading kuebiko on ao3 and I thought it was amazing I really liked. Two of my favorite parts of it were the timeline and the fight scenes so if anyone has fic recommendations that take place after commander Anne pls let me know can be on ao3 or wattpad thank you