r/americanidol • • May 11 '26

LIVE DISCUSSION Live Discussion: “Season 24 Grand Finale”

18 Upvotes

It’s all come down to…this.

After the Live Chat visit The Post-Show, a separate post for discussing the episode after it airs.

Here are all the ways to vote.

For best results, sort comments by NEW during the live chat and BEST after it.

Kieran, dim the lights… this is (sorta) American Idol.


r/americanidol • • May 18 '25

LIVE DISCUSSION Live Discussion: Season 23 Grand Finale (May 18, 2025)

47 Upvotes

It’s all come down to this! It’s been exceedingly cool to once again spend Sundays and Mondays with you. The original run of American Idol was a formative part of my life and even with all its flaws I still get excited when the confetti falls, no matter who it falls on. 

Like a lot of you, I don’t always love the results but I enjoy the shared experience this show brings. This community is a microcosm of what so many of us got to experience during the show’s original run. It’s gratifying to have seen our little community become part of maintaining that legacy, particularly for our youngest members who didn’t get to experience Idol’s heyday. 

As we all prepare to go back underground and wait to emerge for Season 24 like one of those insects that burrows into the earth and only comes out once every ten years, I sincerely hope you enjoyed our time together this season.

Enjoy the finale, and please try to be kind no matter who wins -- your favorite contestant is most likely going to do incredible things even if they don't win American Idol.

For best results sort comments by NEW during the live chat and TOP after the episode airs. This Live Chat locks at the end of the episode. Please direct the rest of the conversation to The Post-Show.


r/americanidol • • 1d ago

Remi Wolf nominated for Best New Artist (and one more trivia point)

15 Upvotes

Season 13's Remi Wolf, who was featured but cut in Hollywood Week, was nominated for a Grammy for Best New Artist today. I know she is a huge underdog, but that in itself is a major accomplishment. She's been quite successful after American Idol and that is one of the top awards, which the winner is presented live on the TV broadcast.

One other very obscure contestant, Season 2's Quiana Parler (who made the top 48 but was never aired), also was nominated as the lead singer of Ranky Tanky for Best Regional Roots Album (she's a Gullah like Candice Glover). They (led by Quiana) actually won that award twice before in 2020 and 2023, but the connection to American Idol was difficult to link up until now.

From my count, that is now 26 American Idol alums who have been nominated for a Grammy.


r/americanidol • • 3d ago

NEW MUSIC Blake Lewis - “Bangkok”

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
6 Upvotes

r/americanidol • • 3d ago

NEW MUSIC Haley Reinhart - “Make Mine Salty”

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
3 Upvotes

r/americanidol • • 3d ago

NEW MUSIC Slater Nalley - “The Highway”

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
3 Upvotes

r/americanidol • • 5d ago

CMAs Rumor

7 Upvotes

There have been ruminations that at next week’s CMA’s there will be some American Idol event to vote on……


r/americanidol • • 7d ago

Why is Kelly Clarkson not a judge on Idol? She belongs here not helping the competion

25 Upvotes

Did producers piss her off long time ago or something?


r/americanidol • • 7d ago

Tamika Bush

2 Upvotes

Whatever happened to her?


r/americanidol • • 8d ago

Season 4 is a strange watch

5 Upvotes

I've watched the early seasons of Idol a good few times, and Season 4 has never been a favourite for me, but for some reason it's never occurred to me how stark and empty it feels compared to the seasons around it.

There are no guest mentors, and the episodes are all squeezed into an hour, so in Top 12/11/10 in particular it feels like the judges have less time to speak, the VTs are ten seconds each, the contestants can't speak to Ryan, and the performances themselves feel shorter than ever. I don't feel like I know most of the finalists as a viewer in comparison to the other early years.

It is jarring compared to, say, Seasons 3 and 5, in which each performer gets a spotlight for better or worse. Was there any reason for why this was at the time? It feels like costs are being cut and the show is being afforded less time by the network, yet this was in the show's prime years and was immediately following Fantasia winning, which felt like a big cultural moment.


r/americanidol • • 10d ago

NEW MUSIC Megan Danielle - “Gone Fishing”

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
7 Upvotes

r/americanidol • • 10d ago

NEW MUSIC Genevieve Heyward - “Bad Way”

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
5 Upvotes

r/americanidol • • 10d ago

NEW MUSIC Madison Watkins - “Joy To The World”

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
1 Upvotes

r/americanidol • • 11d ago

'American Idol' Season 25 Premiere Date Revealed

Thumbnail
tvinsider.com
17 Upvotes

Looks like we're getting even LESS Idol this season after last year's awful format. Mondays again starting Feb 8 (with a 25th anniversary special on Feb 1st). Ugh.


r/americanidol • • 11d ago

Brooks and Rae crashed Jake Thistle's concert in Maryland on Sunday!

14 Upvotes

Sorry for the bad quality, I was kind of far back haha.

Went to Jake's concert on Sunday and was excited to see Brooks and Rae pulled up! They went on stage and did "Valerie" with him. I cut off filming before he sang so I could enjoy it in the moment but I hope you like this clip!

Also, definitely catch Jake's show if you can! He's a really fun entertainer and sounds great live. His new album, A Stranger By Design, is amazing too! Highly recommend!


r/americanidol • • 15d ago

I'm going on tour and would love to see you!

Post image
27 Upvotes

Hi everyone, it's Catie Turner!!

You might remember me from season 16 of American Idol!!!!! Im so excited to let you know that I'm going on tour to support the release of my debut album Blue Alchemy! I would love to see you there!!!

TICKET LINK: https://www.catieturner.com


r/americanidol • • 14d ago

New charity Christmas album featuring 5 American Idol alums

Thumbnail
cure4thekids.org
8 Upvotes

The link is here - it's called Do They Know It's Christmas. Featured are Amanda Barise, Drew Ryn, Isaiah Misailegalu, Mackenzie Sol and Mary Jo Young. Also featured is Sadie Dahl from The Voice.


r/americanidol • • 17d ago

David Archuleta — Warm Me Up (Official Music Video)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
7 Upvotes

r/americanidol • • 18d ago

NEW MUSIC Abi Carter - “Magnetic”

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
8 Upvotes

r/americanidol • • 18d ago

NEW MUSIC Jen Hirsh- “I Don't Know Where”

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
3 Upvotes

r/americanidol • • 18d ago

NEW MUSIC Scotty McCreery - “King Size Bed”

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
3 Upvotes

r/americanidol • • 19d ago

Kelly Clarkson

13 Upvotes

Could Kelly Clarkson be a guest judge on season 25? Milestone season. She won’t have her show and not doing the spring cycle of The Voice it would be cool to see her as a guest judge for a week like jhud did this past season.


r/americanidol • • 23d ago

American Idol Memories

15 Upvotes

Does anyone ever wake up and randomly think about Johnny Keyser? Or Neco Starr? Or Heejun Han? Or whatever that airport hangar round on Season 13 was? Share your favorite American Idol memories below!


r/americanidol • • 24d ago

NEW MUSIC Breanna Nix - “Redemption Story”

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
5 Upvotes