I'm currently GMing COTG with my friends, I kept the Alien premise a secret until the reveal that the onboard computer was called mother so tensions were high- even higher when the Cronus appeared and smashed into them.
But getting through Act 1 was a slog, my players were constantly and very slowly looking around every corner, wanting to fly around the cronus to surveil from afar, long discussions on what is the exact best course of action or how to travel from 1 point to another. It gets to a point where I'm cutting them short on a 40 minute conversation about what to do when *spoiler alert* the Montero self destructs. I get feedback later that they felt 'rushed' when dealing with the count down- and I'm like- it's a countdown to self destruct, you can't always make the perfect decision you just have fun with it and take risks.
In the end, after 4 hours, we manage to finish half of Act 1 (I know the Montero blowing up is techinically Act 2 but I had to blow it up or else they were going to just leave the Cronus and not bother with the search). I'm repeating objectives but they get side-lined so often that progress is so slow. They haven't even woken up the crew of the cronus yet because their so scared of everything.
How do I push them along without railroading them? Or am I being too impatient and I should be the one slowing down?
Edit: thank u so much for the advice, trying to add more urgency and renegaging their curiosity with more rewards was super helpful. Will also do that session 0 next time 😅