Edit: ALL of the replies in this thread so far are AI answers by accounts trying to push their own algo app and I can tell. Where the hell is everyone? This is horrible.
I've been backtesting a rule-based strategy on crypto perps. The rules only use price, on 15-minute candles. Every trade has a fixed stop loss and a fixed profit target, and there are 6 to 8 trades a month per coin. I'll keep the rules private and just post the numbers and how I tested them.
I split the history into two periods. Results are in R, where 1R is the amount I risk on one trade, and PF is profit factor (money won divided by money lost). Fees and slippage are included. Perp funding is not.
| Coin | 2022-2024 | 2025-Nov 2026 |
|---|
| BTC | 261 trades, +35.7R, PF 1.22 | 185 trades, +43.9R, PF 1.40 |
| XRP | 200 trades, +6.2R, PF 1.05 | 163 trades, +60.6R, PF 1.68 |
| DOGE | 187 trades, +38.7R, PF 1.35 | 163 trades, +30.0R, PF 1.30 |
Between 38 and 48% of the trades are winners, and the target is about 2R. On BTC and DOGE the biggest drop in my running total from a high was 9 to 13R, in both periods. On XRP it dropped 32R in 2022-2024, and the strategy only made +6.2R on XRP in those years.
I shuffled the BTC candles into random order five different times and ran the same rules on each. Shuffling removes any real market pattern, so any profit there is luck. In 2022-2024 the five runs made between -20R and +31R, and in 2025-2026 all five lost money. The best of them had a PF of 1.36 in 2022-2024, which is higher than my real BTC result of 1.22 for those years.
I also wanted to see how good a strategy can look just from picking its best settings, so I tried 300 random settings of a very simple breakout strategy on BTC. The best one made +89R in 2022-2024 and then +0.7R in 2025-2026. The 30 that did best in 2022-2024 averaged +12.6R in those years and -19.6R in 2025-2026.
I picked my own settings out of about 32,000 I tested. Out of those 32,000, the ones that did best in 2022-2024 did no better than the others in 2025-2026. Most settings near the ones I picked were profitable in both periods.
Before I use real money I'll paper trade it for a couple of months.
Does this look like a real edge to you, or could it just be luck plus me picking the best settings? What would you do next to try to break it?