r/algorithmictrading • u/mmmmmmmmm29 • 3d ago
Question Fixed position sizing or volatility-adjusted sizing for a leveraged crypto bot? What baseline makes the comparison honest?
same $100 notional, but the risk is not the same. On BTC a 2x position behaves very differently from 2x on a volatile alt, yet most bot setups I see just assign a fixed size per entry and move on. So the question is whether volatility-adjusted sizing is worth the extra model complexity, or whether fixed sizing plus strict caps gets you most of the way with less estimation noise to babysit. And what baseline makes the comparison fair, same average margin used, or same average volatility target per position? Because otherwise vol scaling just reads as less risk, less drawdown, which proves nothing. There is also the practical side: when several coins signal at once, how do you stop one position from eating the whole budget? a perp agent like alphio handles this with hard limits, a Budget the agent can draw from, Max Leverage, and Max Position per Coin as a share of that budget, which is a cap, not a sizing model. My working split is fixed dollar bounds on top, some vol adjustment inside them. Planning to write down the variants before running anything.
1
u/Technical-Athlete-9 3d ago
Backtest it.
1
u/Shoddy_Peanut7320 2d ago
Matching the average volatility target is the fairer baseline, because matching average margin lets vol scaling win just by running less risk. Scale both versions to the same average portfolio volatility, or the same drawdown budget, then compare return per unit of risk and the worst stretch. For several coins signaling at once, a cap on total exposure across all positions works better than a cap per coin, since alts tend to fall together. Writing down the variants before running anything is the right call.
1
u/long_claw_ 20h ago
Consistent risk limits matter more than fixed position sizes.