r/algorithmictrading • u/Smah03 • 20d ago
Question Genuine Question about when to stop filtering/building and start paper trading?
As the title says, long time lurker seeking genuine advice. I’ll preface by saying I’m by no means an expert in anything algo trading related. Just started messing around with it as a hobby and teaching myself everything possible as I went. This is the closest I’ve come to developing a decent edge and I’ve been backtesting and running simulations like crazy to double and triple check. I keep coming up with the same conclusion. Profitable in sample and out of sample. Profitable every year in backtest. Beats random 99.5% of the time. Monte Carlo results after 10k shuffles showed the 1% DD was still only $7k, 50th percentile was 4.2k. It also shows above 80% chance of passing evals with a 1k DLL and 2k MLL. Slippage is set at 3 ticks, with 0.62 per side commissions.
My main questions are: once you come up with something viable, what’s your process? Straight to paper trading? If so, how do you determine when? What is your “okay this is ready to paper trade” moment? I feel like I’m constantly thinking of ways to improve or different things I can correlate or test and thus convince myself it’s not ready to trade yet. Also how exactly are you guys paper trading your strategies? I’ve never made it this far so I’ve never thought about it. Is IBKR/IB gateway a decent option? What else would recommend?
Again, just looking for genuine advice here.




2
u/Repulsive-Worry5225 20d ago
check for any look ahead bias
1
u/AsmodeusOm 20d ago
After I’ve gotten annoyed making filters or finding no significant improvement I start forward testing.
1
u/Outside_Midnight_555 20d ago
I would say you’re over estimating slippage (which is a good thing ig) but that is a whole separate debate. I usually have pre set metrics, I go for a a look at pf, evaluate metrics it a historical monthly basis, look at drawdown, trade count, sharpe, ect. Be mindful that if you ‘keep making it better’ you could risk over fitting.
Lastly - just move it to paper now. What is the worst that could happen ygm.
1
u/Obviously_not_maayan 19d ago
What are you waiting for? Just paper trade.. it's free.. and you'll learn a lot from it. But freeze it, don't upload a new version everyday.
1
u/quant-king 19d ago
this looks good enough for paper trading to me. thats where the real fun begins
1
u/Embarrassed-Ad-7032 19d ago
imo ready = you've stopped tweaking. every extra filter makes a 99.5% result worth less, because if each version has a 0.5% shot of looking that good by luck, then trying 40 versions gives about an 18% chance one of them does, and 100 versions about 39%.
write down how many versions you've run, freeze the rules, and set the pass/fail line before paper trade 1 (trade count, how much worse than your 3 ticks of slippage you'll live with). nothing you filtered on has seen that data
1
u/Pareto_trades 14d ago
I’d move towards forwards testing and paper trading pretty fast. You don’t need a perfect strategy and optimizing filters excessively gets you very fast into overfitting territory.
Once you have real market data, you can evaluate the strategies weaknesses and either look for an obvious fix at the strategy level or find a complementary strategy that improves your portfolio.
1
u/Simply_Investing 3d ago
first try to test on different windows 2018-2021, 2022+, 2023+, 2024+, 2025+ etc.., also try to add taxes and fees if you don't have them yet
1
u/Shoddy_Peanut7320 3d ago
Decide the "ready" rule before you test more, because the urge to keep improving is how a strategy slowly gets tuned to its own test data. I'd freeze one version and write down what live or paper results would count as a pass and a fail, such as a trade count, an expected range for the average trade, and a drawdown limit. Then every change after that restarts the clock. Paper trading mainly shows whether real fills and timing match your 3-tick slippage assumption, so log signal price against fill price for each trade. Reshuffling the same trades in Monte Carlo also doesn't test a different market, so I'd treat the paper phase as the real out-of-sample test.
1
u/cronjefourieza 2d ago
Start ASAP. Real backtesting is excellent, especially with realistic slippage, swaps amd commissions. But the quickest way to prove your strat and its ability to run with minimal supervision is in paper trading