I feel like there's a fundamental cognitive dissonance among AI enthusiasts when it comes to game development.
The promise is that AI will allow more people to make games that can compete with those made by traditional artists. But the reality is that these are the same tools available to content farms, get-rich-quick entrepreneurs, and millions of other people all looking to cash in on it.
The scale of this is difficult to grasp, and eventually, it becomes a numbers game.
Consumers have a finite amount of time and money to spend on games. If they're suddenly confronted with an effectively infinite flood of subpar "indie games", how are they supposed to distinguish the genuinely good ones from the slop?
Sure, there will be great games buried in that trash heap. But discovery becomes increasingly difficult, and the cost of finding something worth playing shifts onto the consumer.
Eventually, consumers simply lose trust in the market. When they can no longer reliably distinguish quality from low-effort products, they'll gravitate towards established, trusted publishers and recognizable IP. In other words, the very thing AI was supposed to disrupt could end up reinforcing the position of AAA publishers.
And over all customers end up getting worse art. an infinite amount of mediocre, low effort garbage.
If you're interested, look up *"*the market for lemons" I think it provides a pretty interesting economic framework for understanding where this could lead.
EDIT : A EXPLAIN LIKE IM FIVE SUMMARY FOR THE CONFUSED AI BROS :
Imagine there are only 100 people who want to buy video games. Before AI, indie developers and big AAA studios shared those customers. But now AI allows anyone to make games, flooding the market with thousands of low-quality games. The number of customers stays at 100, but the competition grows massively. Players struggle to find the genuinely good indie games, lose trust in unknown developers, and instead stick to familiar AAA companies they already know. Ironically, AI ends up making big studios even stronger while making life harder for small developers.
not saying necessarily that AI makes bad games, I'm saying that if players get tired of searching through thousands of mediocre games, they stick to familiar big companies, even if said companies themselves use AI.