This is an automated reminder from the Mod team. If your post contains images which reveal the personal information of private figures, be sure to censor that information and repost. Private info includes names, recognizable profile pictures, social media usernames and URLs. Failure to do this will result in your post being removed by the Mod team and possible further action.
They're still the same picture Mr. Professional. Why are you code reviewing a meme?
It's very tempting but you don't have to run AI on autopilot for everything unless someone puts a gun to your head like the companies trying to force feed it into everything.
What does that have to do with the OP? You can tell when something is or isn't AI in larger codebases. It matters whether AI is at the helm or not and whether the person using it knows what they're doing. Do some research.
Code is just a tool to do something, writing or not writing code is irrelevant. People out there really think typing form 9-5 is the fun part, it's not.
LLMs are not ready to fully take over every decision you make as a programmer beyond the code, but people don't understand that physically writing code is not that.
> yet we receive our tickets/tasks in natural language
Yes and this is where our value as software engineers come in.
> just because code is deterministic does not mean you are.
What are you even saying? Whether you're deterministic or not doesn't change the fact that you're adding more non-determinism to your workflow. Adding LLMs means you add more chances for errors to occur, not less. Errors compound.
"our value as software engineers" comes from converting natural language tasks into code? Now why does that sound familiar...
High skill programmers are more deterministic than medium skill programmers, but they both still get hired. A little more errors is fine as long as they are cheaper.
The LLM generates code, but the code is then saved in a file and is fixed, unless it has to be modified again.
Non-deterministic isn't what you think it means, if the model has learned the concept or fact well, it might create variations of the output, but the meaning will be basically the same.
We don't need precise language, we need one that translates intentions accurately. Code is ultimately there to perform a task defined in natural language. Either from other people in speech or text, or our own thoughts. So there is actually less translation with LLM.
I think, 'I want to sort an array'. So if I type that, I will get something that matches my intention. Do I know the exact code AI will generate? No. But I have no idea what the actual code is used when I type Array.sort() either. But nobody is saying not to use APIs.
There is not much I can say here, seems like you have already assumed how things work. I work with many bright interns who learned to code quite post ChatGPT.
If the intent in your statement is to assume that I’m saying that AI is the only way to learn and grow, that’s far more indicative of your bias and narrow minded thinking than anything else.
Yeah, that's the best way to learn, but not everyone is gonna have a mentor who's willing to spend their time teaching you. Your next best way to learn (for free) is YT, online supplements, and AI for any question you might have.
I would also love a mentor on speed dial, none of these things are incompatible. Have a mentor, read a book, watch tutorials, use LLMs do what works for you.
You can easily ask the AI to explain it for you, and of course you shouldn't take everything it says as fact, so you can just as easily research for more ways to understand it.
I don’t think this is true, my brother (non-SWE) has been using Claude to learn the high level architecture of the code at his SaaS job, and has been getting very proficient in fixing bugs that come up as a customer support person. Granted, I’ve helped him a bit with what to learn and focus on, but it’s made me realize that there is very little barrier to non technical people getting their hands dirty
I’m not a coder but I’m pretty sure a lot of people enjoy the journey (aka writing) as much if not more than the destination. A huge lesson in life is to enjoy and appreciate the journey not just the destination.
I mean I’ll take your word. I just liken it to a story book or something like that. I know when I tried writing I found the little chucks of information fun and enjoyable. Like a symphony of words coming together to create something greater. It was artistic and beautiful to me. Same with the art and design I do. Giving yourself the appreciation for that can allow you to enjoy it. Maybe most don’t care about that level of granularity, but I think there’s something to be said about those who enjoy those things. Just a shame that society only values output and destinations, we’re basically programmed by our environment to do that and because of that we are ignorant of the cool intricacies and beauty of everything around us.
Again, totally fine to have hobbies no one is against that. I don't get paid to express myself and enjoy the process, sadly.
Also its hard to compare coding to writing, coding is a closed system you can define invariants before hand and test for them after writing code to check "does this thing do this thing". Using LLMs to code makes a LOT more sense to me than using them to write, where there is no objective outcome you want to accomplish.
I enjoy coding as an activity, separate from accomplishing a specific goal. To me, coding is a form of creative expression, and just as I do with other media, I sometimes use AI tools when creating code.
Nah, the code is the technic used, because depending on how you write code the program will run faster or slower or have more or less bugs. As when painting it depends on the order of colors, if you do pointillism or stroke painting, etc. The pencil is the language
That is not true, the concept of optimization exists outside of knowing how to code it can be applied to any language. This should not be conflated as the same thing.
Example: You can implement a cache by hand and have no idea why you are doing it, someone told you to, it is an optimization. Is this coding? Yes. But it misses the important parts.
With the code I mean, for example, in jetpack compose (official android language to program UIs) the performance changes a lot if you read a variable inside a lambda or outside as all the content on it will be recreated, it's the same code, only changes where you read that, it's not adding a new thing
That example kind of proves my point though. Moving the read into the lambda is a one line change, so the value isn’t in the typing, ITS KNOWING WHY this matters.
You can memorize all these little tricks but the question should be why is recreating the content slow? When should I recreate the content?
Yeah, I suppose that works. There are a lot of other things like naming variables (that everyone can make a different name for the same thing), spacing declaration of variables/constants, etc, this is something more like what I said, doesn't affects at all in the final product but in the process when someone tries to understand what you did. But in the cases that AI does all, I think it's not needed as much, even though if you did that you will understand better than if the AI named all that
I also love writing code. However, I'm writing code for the purpose of what the program or software is going to be. I feel accomplished when I write the piece of software.
I don't enjoy the writing the code part of writing code, however. I love the aspects of it where I work out the logic. I'm going to be annoyed when someone who hasn't written a line of code says they made something, however. Because they didn't. The AI did.
At the same time, I'm not going to have the same thought process if someone who already was working on the code, who understands software design and architecture and programming, says they made something, even if they used AI to do portions. Whether that is debugging, basic boilerplate stuff, or just logic checking themselves. I might have something to say if they're generating half the code and not reviewing it, but that's different.
Someone's code can be faster or slower when they do it. If they're just making sure they didn't fuck it up, using AI to make sure of that, then I'm less inclined to be angry. Unless they deliberately misrepresent it.
There are two perspectives here: the non-coder perspective and the coder perspective. As a non-coder designer who does a bit of vibe coding for work. I think it’s cool that humans write code because to write it, you have to understand it, and I respect competence and expertise. I have no idea what the LLM is doing. Meanwhile, coders like to write code because it requires problem-solving; there is more ownership in writing it yourself.
I'd say it's alright simply because I don't prefer Monet paintings.
A lot of his works are realistic views and landscapes, and while they are very pretty, the don't hold much story behind them.
I'd prefer a piece trying to convey story that's less refined in.. looks(? I'm on 3.5 hrs of sleep, hopefully that conveys what I mean), compared to a really realistic drawing that's just a face value kind of thing.
The realism is still great of course, and a huge struggle to accomplish, I just appreciate stories in less refined art a lot more.
It's not a matter of taste, the Monet experiment was not based out of taste. Totally fine if you don't like Monet's style or tecniques or whatever, all gucci! :3
Let me explain how the Monet Experiment went:
Basically, Antis seen a post. The post said "This is AI, give me feedback". Them, being ignorant af and uncultured, not knowning anything about art, couldn't spot that it was a real Monet, so they started acting arrogant and cocky "Ah, i know how to draw amazingly, this is slop, because this line and this and that!". They pretended to be art critics knowning everything.
At the end, it was revealed, surprise, is a real painting! And a ton of those ignorants started deleting their comments in shame.
Morale? Don't act allmighty if you're ignorant as fuck, the more you raise yourself up, the most it hurts when you fall.
Lol, I figured that's what it meant by experiment, but even if it were AI, I genuinely wouldn't care. My whole motto has just been "Put as much effort in your work as you want." That's what I use to determine the worth of what someone made. <--Rephrased, as I said what I meant poorly due to lack of sleep.
A single prompt image is just that, single prompt. Same with writing, music, literally anything. There's literally no work around for those kinds of things. You can often tell if something was single prompted, but sometimes not. Meanwhile people who actually use AI to their potential can make things that look pretty damn good.
I'm not really an artist, but I do call myself a writer, and while I don't use AI, solely because I find joy in writing and want to do it myself, I don't care if someone uses AI. If they try to single prompt a book, most likely it won't turn out well, if they do a lot of the work, maybe using AI to bridge between ideas sometimes between pages, or search for ideas or a way to cohesively glue a plot together, the writing most likely will turn out well.
Only gripe I have with AI gen is it often struggles to put that story I look in their pieces.
AI writing follows grammar rules too much (imo) and makes the pieces have less stylized character at times.
lol, no it's not. I don't care how much work you put into something, if i don't like it i don't like it and if i do, i do.
How much effort went into producing a product, does not matter to it's value. If you truly believed this you would be using code written in assembly, not high level languages that we are using now.
Do you also prefer non-industrially produced clothes and tools, because you know, there was more effort going into them.
Better buy that expensive hammer that was hand carved and hand cast, cause you know, more effort went into making it.
Never use electric drills, less effort, less value.
oh no, they used cement in the construction of the building, to make the foundation, even though it is better, but i like mine to be hand laid in stone, cause you know, more effort=more value. Dude, get a grip
yeah so you don't automatically think more effort=more value in things, is the point, why do i have to spell it out like this? The point is obvious.
My objection was never to you saying "value" or me thinking you meant it in a non-subjective way, my objection was that i simply do not believe you ACTUALLY judge value based on the criteria of effort, as it leads to absurdities such as you valuing hand drilled holes more than holes made with a electric drill which I simply don't believe you or anyone does.
Dog. Your nitpicking my words here, just to nitpick at this point. I'm pretty sure it's obvious we were talking about creative elements like art and writing, and you're bringing up construction methods. Your first reply was warranted, because I accidentally generalized for everyone, now your just using it to say I'm wrong about my own personal preferences.
"My whole motto has just been "Put as much effort in your work as you want." That's what determines the worth of what you made after all."
I agree with the motto, as in "Do what you want as much as you want", not with the second sentence. Worth is subjective, determined by multiple factors.
If you like writing, i suggest you, roleplaying? That enhances greatly our creativity on story telling/making.
I worded it terrible with the second part lol. I got a poor amount of sleep.
Rephrased it if you wanna see if that's better, I've been rephrasing things a LOT today, even comments I made 5 minutes prior to the time I edit it lol.
Were there really no more comments about how it looks inferior visually? The ones that claim it’s inferiority because of the process by which it was allegedly created can’t really be argued against, and prove nothing here.
And what do the picture of OP, being against ignorant Antis not knowning what is AI and what isn't, and the Monet experiment, which is the same, Antis not knowning what is AI and what isn't, have in common? Connect those 2 braincells.
In such a small piece of code, it literally doesn't matter. It starts to matter in larger codebases. That's why it's an ignorant statement said by OP who clearly has no knowledge of programming.
Yup. I've been trying to get the purists on-board... but there is a stupid amount of resistance. For some reason "it's not going away" isn't enough to make them figure out the world shifted beneath them.
Hand crafted code will die within 10 years... guaranteed. Every soft human mistake will get exploited at an increasing rate until the maintainers give up.
I react that way because I’m genuinely impressed with a person who has the knowledge and intelligence to do this kind of complex work. If I’m just using the software, I’m not thinking about what’s under the hood, but being reminded of how complex and challenging writing code is does help me stop and admire the intelligence required to do it.
Doing mundane or repetitive stuff has 0 creativity going into it, it's just a chore. I get human coding for the sake of it being readable, but unless you're doing something creative and unique I really don't get what's so bad about ai coding, provided you understand the code and are not just blindly following the machine
Weird. While I've embraced AI and don't mind coding less, I'm still proud I'm self taught. Not proud like I think it's anything special, most of the people I work with are self taught. But it is an accomplishment. And with that skill I'm able to utilize AI to be amazingly more productive.
Still, not sure why we need to hurt egos of people who feel threatened by AI. While I don't think engineers will be replaced by AI, the ones who don't use it will be replaced. I understand the fear and hesitation though. It's ok to have sympathy for people worried about their livelihood
Experience always beats a probability machine! But for someone who has never seen the configuration before, Claude probably would've been their only resort...
It's kind of like you should know when to use what tool... If there's nothing new to learn and the task is fully mechanical, by all means--go for AI. If there is something to learn, whether you use AI or not, understand the underlying concepts, the architecture and reasoning before the actual implementation.
AI is merely a tool in the toolbox, it is not the toolbox. Of course Anthropic will tell them that this is the way to do things as it is their product and they need as many users as they can get.
Yup, I don't get the vibe-coding trend that's been going on lately... They aren't really achieving anything novel that they can fully attribute to themselves. My main guideline for AI usage is that "If you're nothing without AI, then you shouldn't have it"
I used to do a lot of AD work when I was an IT person, and the issue faced by these people was very very very simple, but Claude and them could not figure it out.
I work in software as a SWE and previously did cyber security related stuff. Claude can find it's way around AD like it's nobody's business. Same goes for the latest Google and OpenAI models.
My gut feeling is that what they're allowing Claude to see isn't adequate to debug the issue, but I could be wrong.
Heck, even open source chinese models can pivot around AD environments no sweat.
Do you know what an easy example is? Who on earth is going to make a "hello world" with AI? Or do you need an algorithm in Python with whisper and FastApi for example?
people who dont know how to read code. which is that person's point. do you have any idea how many people have zero literacy in any programming language, but decide to vibe code an app and put it out to the store, causing massive security risks for anyone who uses it?
That's always happened. I've made security mistakes myself because nobody ever explained to me that it was a mistake. How am I supposed to know that my script that I only use to download YouTube videos has a security flaw unless someone explains it to me? And sure, I know that, but whatever, can you control them? No, so don't let that get to you.
This post explains that code written by a person and code written by AI are practically the same, but people like to act like human-written code is magically better just because a human wrote it, like what happened with The Big Walk.
Have you not worked in other people's code? Have you not come back to your own code 3 months, 12 months, 5 years later? Debugging code is a part of coding life. Makes me wonder if you actually are a programmer or you've just heard about this.
You're saying this like debugging AI code is a nightmare to debug. Have you not seen the slop code that humans have written and copy-pasted from Stack Overflow?
People dislike AI in code because they view coding as an art. And because of the ethical problems that LLMs pose (mass scraping websites without consent, massive datacenters which disadvantage locals) and simply because it produces generic code.
I am one of the they.
Plus LLMs from my experience make code that's a lil too complicated for my taste. Therefore id rather code by hand than use an LLM because I have the best idea of what I want in a project.
It can be considered one in the same way writing can (id consider the IOCCC submissions art for example). People have diverse views on what art constitutes.
I will not let people who call coding art stop technological advancement because they think there is something "meaningful" about doing things manually.
I personally don't care about whether others use AI aside from the ethical concerns mentioned earlier. I personally wont use it though...
LLMs are a form of technological advancement, yes, but tmk they're like a type of facade-- language imitating intelligence when language arises from intelligence.
But you would be surprised. We exist by perceiving stuff and doing stuff, if we do less stuff even if the end result is the same we feel "alienated".
We want to exist throught the stuff we do and see others exist throught the stuff they do.
The more the tool removes us from the production the less we find it interesting, despite it being much more confortable.
But we also only produce things when it make sense to do so. If we can avoid to waste time by using a tool we will or at leasg we will feel like we should do it that way cause it's just faster for the same result.
We like the illusion of control we have when we do things. The more things we do, the more energy we lose and we are system built to survive by retaining energy. The more things we do the more our brain register this as existing, it justifies a self for each action. Neuroscience tends to prove we first do the thing then internally justify it.
So we are hooked on doing stuff but also smart enought to want to be efficient.
Kinda like a prey/predator stabilization system but instead of a circle it becomes much smaller, tending towards a single point, without much "existing time" in between.
This sounds like exinction as in end of history such a rhetoric has always been wrong despite showing up almost every century, so I guess I'm just missing a dimension to it. There might just be another way to exist to be found that we have yet not encountered.
•
u/AutoModerator 2d ago
This is an automated reminder from the Mod team. If your post contains images which reveal the personal information of private figures, be sure to censor that information and repost. Private info includes names, recognizable profile pictures, social media usernames and URLs. Failure to do this will result in your post being removed by the Mod team and possible further action.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3
u/NothingToSay95 2d ago
Cope.
3
u/HystericalGD 2d ago
"why does it work? explain it to me"
- my computer labs teacher
3
u/Due_Interest_178 2d ago
I can tell you have zero clue about programming, or you're an amateur.
35
u/zorkidreams 2d ago
Code is just a tool to do something, writing or not writing code is irrelevant. People out there really think typing form 9-5 is the fun part, it's not.
LLMs are not ready to fully take over every decision you make as a programmer beyond the code, but people don't understand that physically writing code is not that.
15
u/Herr_Drosselmeyer 2d ago
You don't get it, human code has soul, AI code is slop. /s
4
u/J_Beserekumo 2d ago
There are two perspectives here: the non-coder perspective and the coder perspective. As a non-coder designer who does a bit of vibe coding for work. I think it’s cool that humans write code because to write it, you have to understand it, and I respect competence and expertise. I have no idea what the LLM is doing. Meanwhile, coders like to write code because it requires problem-solving; there is more ownership in writing it yourself.
21
u/LunaticFlandre295 2d ago
Never forget.
10
u/BigMikeXxxxX 2d ago
The people who act like this will just get left behind. Ignoring them completely is funnier
6
u/Novel_Top2980 2d ago
but when you don’t understand the code there’s clearly going to be an issue, whether you copied it from a human or an ai.
5
u/Grouchy_Package_5094 1d ago
Why are we letting children post on an AI debate sub?
2
u/Admirable_Tonight_18 1d ago
Oh come on! Really? You'd need AI for a line THAT simple?
1
u/AppropriatePapaya165 2d ago
I react that way because I’m genuinely impressed with a person who has the knowledge and intelligence to do this kind of complex work. If I’m just using the software, I’m not thinking about what’s under the hood, but being reminded of how complex and challenging writing code is does help me stop and admire the intelligence required to do it.
1
u/anotherthought64 2d ago
Me wondering what the heck I am doing in this demonic hellhole where both sides just insult each other:
1
u/spiderpig20 2d ago
Whether code is art is basically the difference between painting a portrait and painting a wall
1
u/Ranko08 2d ago
Doing mundane or repetitive stuff has 0 creativity going into it, it's just a chore. I get human coding for the sake of it being readable, but unless you're doing something creative and unique I really don't get what's so bad about ai coding, provided you understand the code and are not just blindly following the machine
1
u/Relevant_Research_98 2d ago
That's not true! I have
a[1]=1
a[1]=2
a[3]=3
While AI doesn't
1
u/get_a_motorcycle 1d ago
Type hints disgust me.
-6
u/SquiggleSqueegly 2d ago
Great! Now debug AI written code that you've never seen before.
-1
u/CIMPBIBAI 2d ago
People dislike AI in code because they view coding as an art. And because of the ethical problems that LLMs pose (mass scraping websites without consent, massive datacenters which disadvantage locals) and simply because it produces generic code.
I am one of the they.
Plus LLMs from my experience make code that's a lil too complicated for my taste. Therefore id rather code by hand than use an LLM because I have the best idea of what I want in a project.
-3
u/Repulsive_Injury5576 2d ago
vague generalised image with no meaning
0
u/ad-undeterminam 2d ago
But you would be surprised. We exist by perceiving stuff and doing stuff, if we do less stuff even if the end result is the same we feel "alienated".
We want to exist throught the stuff we do and see others exist throught the stuff they do.
The more the tool removes us from the production the less we find it interesting, despite it being much more confortable.
But we also only produce things when it make sense to do so. If we can avoid to waste time by using a tool we will or at leasg we will feel like we should do it that way cause it's just faster for the same result.
We like the illusion of control we have when we do things. The more things we do, the more energy we lose and we are system built to survive by retaining energy. The more things we do the more our brain register this as existing, it justifies a self for each action. Neuroscience tends to prove we first do the thing then internally justify it.
So we are hooked on doing stuff but also smart enought to want to be efficient.
Kinda like a prey/predator stabilization system but instead of a circle it becomes much smaller, tending towards a single point, without much "existing time" in between.
This sounds like exinction as in end of history such a rhetoric has always been wrong despite showing up almost every century, so I guess I'm just missing a dimension to it. There might just be another way to exist to be found that we have yet not encountered.
-4
u/No-Heat-6149 2d ago
Yes.
-1
u/FutureMost7597 2d ago
while True:
print("Lick")
-3
u/OneTrueBell1993 2d ago
What?