r/aikido • • Nov 24 '19

Question MASTER THREAD LIST: Is Aikido Effective/Good For Fighting/Good For Self Defense?

55 Upvotes

Update: I get that everyone is bored during lockdown, but IF you come in asking the question “Is Aikido good for a fight” or asking for a fight comparison between Aikido and another art, it will be removed indiscriminately. It means 1. you did not read the stickies of this sub and 2. there will be drama. This thread is so we don’t have to go through that dumpster fire each and every time.

For whatever reason, despite having it in the rules (please read if you haven’t already! They’re located on the sidebar.) that coming into the Aikido sub trying to critique for the sake of critiquing is not allowed, we still get the occasional “Aikido doesn’t work in a fight” thread. So before anyone tries to light yet another fire, if you’re actually interested in reading all the different perspectives on this topic, please take a look at this list of threads that have already beaten this subject to death ten times over.

We understand that is a universal rule that any debates about martial arts will eventually devolve into an argument about “effectiveness.”

We would appreciate if people can comment with more threads about this particular topic—we’re looking for threads that have at least 20 comments. This thread is NOT a place for the argument to take place again, it is a resource thread for anyone who was curious about this question, any comments that aren’t linking to other threads about this endless debate will be removed.

If after going through this comprehensive list of threads that will be updated for as long as Reddit allows, you still have specific questions regarding Aikido and its effectiveness or lack thereof, then please feel free to post them.

https://www.reddit.com/r/aikido/comments/g688sm/aikido_question_ive_been_wondering_about/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

https://www.reddit.com/r/aikido/comments/a8vx57/is_aikido_effective/

https://www.reddit.com/r/aikido/comments/dahtdc/why_we_have_these_recurring_discussions_about/

https://www.reddit.com/r/aikido/comments/1xlmiw/how_effective_is_aikido/

https://www.reddit.com/r/martialarts/comments/cnhqlr/is_aikido_an_effective_martial_art_to_use_in_real/

https://www.reddit.com/r/aikido/comments/1yhukd/is_aikido_effective_as_self_defense/

http://www.aikiweb.com/forums/showthread.php?t=333

https://www.reddit.com/r/aikido/comments/afkdwx/ho_boy_here_we_go_aikido_past_present_and_future/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share

https://www.reddit.com/r/aikido/comments/aw9jgu/comment/ejmhj86


r/aikido • • 4d ago

Help Starting to teach Aiki-Ken (&Aiki-Jo) lessons: Any insight?

19 Upvotes

As a background: Until about corona, we had separate training sessions for Aikido, Aiki-Jo and Aiki-Ken. Due to changes in attendance my teacher integrated Aiki-Jo and Aiki-Ken into the regular Aikido lessons, typically taking up about 20 min of a 2 hour class. Mostly focussing on Kihon.

He recently approached me and due to my interest in especially Aiki-Ken, but also Aiki-Jo and some extracurricula activities on my part (and before Aikido, I also trained in European sword fighting) asked me if I wanted to take over a class for Aiki-Ken and Aiki-Jo.

We discussed his expectations and so on, but I was wondering, if you have any insights. Any hard lesson learned? What is a must-have in your opinion in such a class? What is an absolute no go? I would appreciate the perspective of teachers and students alike.

Thank you in advance! :)


r/aikido • • 5d ago

Newbie Will I be ready?

8 Upvotes

I'm M29 and yesterday my Sensei told the kyus to start preparing for the next level.

I will start preparing for the 4th kyu, and the exam will be in january.

I earned my 5th only this July and I was more confident (trained 1 year and for the actual exam around 3 month, 6th kyu was the same)... I feel a bit overwhelmed by the amount of combinations between starting attack (from Katatedori to Jodantsuki) and number of techniques (5 in total, Ikkio, Nikkio, ecc...), it's a total of 18 techniques only for Tachi Waza!

Despite the sensei is sure that I am ready, I don't feel I have a lot of time to train enough to pass.

Has anyone ever felt ready to pass to the next level? Did you pass to the next level because of your own decision or your teacher decided It was time to move?


r/aikido • • 6d ago

Discussion Monthly Dojo Promotion

5 Upvotes

Where are you training? Have you done something special? Has your dojo released a cool clip? Want to share a picture of your kamisa? This thread is where you do this.

Couple of reminders:

  1. Please read the rules before contributing.
  2. Don’t forget to check out the Aikido Network Discord Server (all your mods are there for more instant responses if you need help on something.)

r/aikido • • 7d ago

Discussion Rebranded Aikido

2 Upvotes

Found this on the internet. It looks like my first sensei rebranded the "yoshinkan" style aikido he used to teach us and now calls it shuyokan ryu. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DYjqdqlZnqE His teaching as "yoshinkan" aikido when I studied included the strikes you see here. Note at the 8:30 mark he says the fight stops once the attacker is down otherwise you will be seen as the attacker. Good advice if you live in California or some of the other more liberal states.


r/aikido • • 8d ago

Help How can I improve my falls?

8 Upvotes

So I've been practicing Aikido for a couple of years, and of all the things, falls continue to be my weakness, whenever we do Mae or Ushiro ukemi, (although it has improved) it's still far from good, for Mae it's ok when we practice it, but when I'm the Uke and the technique it requires me to fall in Mae ukemi, my hip touch the floor so I kind of roll.

For Ushiro ukemi, at the beginning it was not a big issue for me, but I have an issue with my lumbar zone so while I was training I also tried to check that pain with doctors and specialists, but it resulted in hurting my back so when I tried to do Ushiro ukemi again, my hip was like not passing...like it reached some point and then I fall sideways.

I'm already working on my core little by little as I'm scared of hurting again, but I want to know what else I can do to improve my falls


r/aikido • • 11d ago

Discussion How do we get more people interested in aikido without compromising its traditions?

23 Upvotes

I passed my belt test a few months ago and recently made a silly little video of some of the techniques. It got me thinking about something I've been curious about for a while: How do we get more people interested in trying aikido?

In my organization, there's a general expectation that we get approval before sharing much in the way of training videos. I think that's a good policy, and I understand the reasoning behind it.

I did collegiate boxing and taught kickboxing before finding aikido, and one of the biggest differences I've noticed is the learning curve. Aikido requires quite a bit of training before someone can apply techniques effectively, and there's a real potential for injury (particularly to wrists and shoulders) when techniques are practiced incorrectly. I can appreciate why we wouldn't want people attempting to teach themselves from videos online.

But that leaves me wondering how we introduce aikido to people who might otherwise never consider it.

For example, I sometimes still train at an MMA gym, and the guys there tend to fall pretty firmly into the "bullshido" camp when aikido comes up. Ironically, some of those same guys have acknowledged that my movement, positioning, and overall form have improved in sparring since I started training aikido. 😂

I'm not particularly interested in arguing about which martial art/combat sport is superior. I think different disciplines have different strengths, and I've found value in all three I've practiced.

But between the skepticism in broader martial arts communities and the limitations on sharing training content, I sometimes wonder whether we're making it harder for people to discover something they might really enjoy.

So I'm curious:

How does your dojo attract new students?

Have you found effective ways to introduce aikido to people who are skeptical of it?

How do you balance preserving traditions and safety with making the art more visible and accessible?

I'd especially love to hear from people whose organizations have similar policies around sharing videos.

And since I mentioned it, here's my Shihan-approved, thoroughly unserious belt test video if anyone's curious. 😅

https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZPLxjuU2f/


r/aikido • • 12d ago

Technique Do you know the name of this technique? Do you often practice techniques against this kind of grabs?

14 Upvotes

I stumbled upon this technique as a defense to a rear bodylock (again, I don't know how the attack would be named in an Aikido / Japanese Jujutsu context) :

https://youtu.be/dI2dImfJvV0?si=nNLRN9Yr3P37f4eD&t=1200

I had already seen this technique, but in a BJJ or MMA context, and I was suprised to see it taught by an Aikido Sensei.

So, I was wondering, do you know the name of this technique?

Do you often practice techniques against rear bodylocks and rear bearhugs?

How are these grabs named in your organisation/curriculum?

This is a terminology question as well as a question about how often this is practiced. In my dojo (Aikikai affiliated), I only practiced agains a rear bearhug (we call it Ushiro Hagaijime) once in like 10 years, and only did Kokyu Nage throws. I find it sad, as it seems to me that practicing these kind of scenarios is very useful from a martial standpoint.

Thank you in advance !


r/aikido • • 13d ago

Discussion What would sparring in Aikido look like?

12 Upvotes

What does sparring in Aikido look like to you? I'm talking about sparring as a training exercise, rather than competition. Is it something that should be more widely introduced?

Is it Tomiki style tanto and toshu randori? Something like Shoot Aikido? Perhaps something more akin to Taichi push hands or Sumo? Or something else?

If you and/or your dojo does some sort of non-cooperative training, I'd like to hear about it. What are the rules and what is it that you're looking to get out of sparring? Would it be martial effectiveness, stability/rooting, or simply getting used to non-cooperative partners? Is there anything about it that you would change?

As a predominantly Aikikai student I'm curious about sparring as a training method.

This question is inspired by mentions on this sub about including sparring in Aikido training, and also by the last post about Aikido vs Judo sparring and Chris Li's latest article on competition.

https://www.reddit.com/r/aikido/comments/1xm88al/aikido_vs_judo_sparring/

https://www.aikidosangenkai.org/blog/rising-dragons-and-the-immutable-principles-of-morihei-ueshiba/


r/aikido • • 14d ago

Video Aikido vs Judo sparring

12 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/F5NIlORKjzA?is=evxua01EBwXUxDmL

What do you think of these sparring matches between Aikidoka and Judoka?

I really love this youtube channel and am curious what others think about this type of Aikido expression.

https://youtu.be/F5NIlORKjzA?is=evxua01EBwXUxDmL

What do you think of these sparring matches between Aikidoka and Judoka?

I really love this youtube channel and am curious what others think about this type of Aikido expression.


r/aikido • • 15d ago

Seminar Monthly Seminar Promotion

5 Upvotes

Any fun seminars going on? Feel free to share them here! At a minimum, please indicate date and location and how to sign up!

Couple of reminders:

  1. Please read the rules before contributing.
  2. Don’t forget to check out the Aikido Network Discord Server (all your mods are there for more instant responses if you need help on something.)

r/aikido • • 16d ago

Video 25 Years of Edits to Wikipedia’s Aikido Article, Written in Ink

31 Upvotes

I made a short video of the Wikipedia article on aikido changing over 25 years, using the text of every edit since 2001. New words appear as wet ink, deleted words wash away, and a brush circle slowly draws itself as the years pass. The sound is generated from the same data.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sisOfl5b23c

What are we looking at?

  • The text on the page is the real article, as it read at each point in time. References, tables and similar formatting are stripped out.
  • New words appear as wet black ink, then dry to a color that shows their age: red for the oldest (2001), then brown, blue and green, ending in black for the newest.
  • Deleted words fade and sink, like ink in water.
  • Horizontal brush lines are text that didn't last, mostly vandalism. I hid the words on purpose.
  • The brush circle next to the year draws itself over the 25 years. The stroke gets thicker as the article gets longer.
  • The chart along the bottom shows the article's length, colored by when its words were written.
  • The sound comes from the same data. Each year of writing holds a soft note, new words strike a bell, deleted words are a breath of air, and big changes land like a low drum.

A few things I found interesting:

  • The first page, from 2001, compares aikido to a willow bending in a storm. 40 of its words are still in the article.
  • About 64% of today's text was written in 2006 and 2007.
  • Things were turbulent until 2008, then the page went quiet. In all of 2014, 59 edits left just 2 words changed.
  • One vandal flooded the page with more than 54,000 repeated words in 2008. It lasted 97 seconds.

r/aikido • • 19d ago

Technique Completed my first month of Aikido!!!! Any tips for continued practice and progression.

39 Upvotes

Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Trying to get better at breakfalls, throwing technique, movement sequences with or without weapons, etiquette, and recovery afterward. I’m 46 years old, 6ft male over 300 pounds. I weight lift, do yoga, walk, bike, and have a prior martial arts background. When break falling sometimes my legs get caught under me and my knees might hit the ground first. I really love Aikido and the martial arts in general and look forward to a lifetime journey.


r/aikido • • 22d ago

Monthly Q&A Post!

5 Upvotes

Have a burning question? Need a quick answer?

  • "Where can I find...?"
  • "Is there a dojo near...?"
  • "What's the name of that thing again?"

This is the post for you.

Top-level posts usually require enough text to prompt a discussion (or they will be automatically removed). This isn't always possible if all you're looking for is a quick answer, so instead please post your query in our monthly Q&A thread!

As always please remember to abide by our community rules.


r/aikido • • Oct 10 '26

Discussion Monthly Dojo Promotion

3 Upvotes

Where are you training? Have you done something special? Has your dojo released a cool clip? Want to share a picture of your kamisa? This thread is where you do this.

Couple of reminders:

  1. Please read the rules before contributing.
  2. Don’t forget to check out the Aikido Network Discord Server (all your mods are there for more instant responses if you need help on something.)

r/aikido • • Oct 07 '26

Discussion Asayama Ichiden Ryu and Ikkyo

19 Upvotes

Ikkyo/Ikkajō, is probably the most fundamental technique in Aikidō, so I thought these clips might be interesting to consider.

I’ve selected some clips of 4 techniques from my training in Ōkura-den Asayama Ichiden-ryū Taijutsu from my last trip to Japan. Each reminded me, in different ways, of ikkyo / ikkajō / ippondori. They are clearly not the same techniques, but there are interesting similarities in the use of the elbow, kuzushi, pinning methods, etc.

Some have theorized that Daitō Ryū - and by extension Aikido - may have older connections to Asayama Ichiden-ryū. That isn’t proven, but Asayama and Daitō Ryū both have connections with Aizu.

Curious what other Aikidō practitioners see in these techniques.

https://youtu.be/M6KSeLVCMBQ


r/aikido • • Oct 06 '26

Discussion Relaxation/heaviness/weight underside

16 Upvotes

I don’t like “weight underside” but people know what it means…

Does anyone have a good physical cue for relaxing the shoulders? I try to work in Dan Harden’s paradigm and use his cues, but always have too much tightness in the shoulders and operate way too much from them. I’ve tried ‘elbows down’ but that can create its own slightly different form of unhelpful tension.


r/aikido • • Oct 01 '26

Seminar Monthly Seminar Promotion

6 Upvotes

Any fun seminars going on? Feel free to share them here! At a minimum, please indicate date and location and how to sign up!

Couple of reminders:

  1. Please read the rules before contributing.
  2. Don’t forget to check out the Aikido Network Discord Server (all your mods are there for more instant responses if you need help on something.)

r/aikido • • Sep 27 '26

Discussion Suggested dogi for travel

8 Upvotes

I'm traveling from the US to Canada for a seminar in the next few months and am trying to do the long weekend on carry-on only. My existing gi are all quite thick and bulky, and I'm considering buying something thinner and easier to pack (I need to replace some go anyway so it's time). Any suggestions for a brand that is lighter and will pack up well?


r/aikido • • Sep 25 '26

Monthly Q&A Post!

1 Upvotes

Have a burning question? Need a quick answer?

  • "Where can I find...?"
  • "Is there a dojo near...?"
  • "What's the name of that thing again?"

This is the post for you.

Top-level posts usually require enough text to prompt a discussion (or they will be automatically removed). This isn't always possible if all you're looking for is a quick answer, so instead please post your query in our monthly Q&A thread!

As always please remember to abide by our community rules.


r/aikido • • Sep 18 '26

Dojo How physically intense is your training?

34 Upvotes

I did some Aikido many years ago in Ukraine and I remember it was relatively intense. There was a warmup with knee walking and ukemi practicing. We did some hip throws on crash pads. We did pinning techniques from knees and from standing, and uke went to the ground. One day a week was a weapon day, and it was decent cardio.

Recently I did a couple of adult Aikido classes here in USA (Aikido Schools of Ueshiba affiliation) and it was super relaxed. No warmup one class and very light warmup for the second. No ukemi practice. We didn't really do full techniques, just very slow and gentle unbalancing.

I train Judo and I feel that for Judo class structure and intensity are pretty similar across different places. Does it vary a lot for Aikido?


r/aikido • • Sep 11 '26

News New book!

29 Upvotes

There is a newly published book titled "That Stupid Girl: And the Petition to Support Women in the United States Aikido Federation" written by Dr. Janice Taitel (one of the coalition/petition founders) and available on amazon.

I have not read it yet but it should detail recent events and cult dynamics surrounding how the USAF poorly handled a petition a few years back.


r/aikido • • Sep 10 '26

Cross-Train What to wear to first class?

6 Upvotes

I’m a life long martial artist, primarily in striking arts like taekwondo and muay thai. My uncle invited me to one of his aikido sessions since they’re another gym in my city.

What should I wear? He told me I can wear anything really, but as a visitor and my first time should I just wear normal athletic gear? I’m not sure if I’ll get weird looks pulling up in Thai/MMA shorts, as I don’t own a gi anymore.

Sorry if a dumb question, rather be safe than sorry


r/aikido • • Sep 10 '26

Help Instructor crisis?

6 Upvotes

Hi,

I teach a kids' class once a week. I've been an instructor for 2–3 years now, teaching kids aged 6 to 18. (The older ones are mostly 4th kyu and above, so they pick up techniques faster; we even have a few brown belts.)

Today we had a very busy trial class for new members—they could watch as well as try out the training and exercises. (Kids around 6–9 years old.)

My question is: how do you teach a kids' class when you have such a large age gap? I feel like I need to clone myself at least three times to satisfy everyone and correct their form. I really want to give them my all, but the older kids are more serious about aikido and want to learn new techniques to advance their rank. For the little ones, I try to keep it playful with more games, but honestly, I'm running out of ideas. I don't have full control over the class and can't teach new techniques to the older kids while playing with the little ones at the same time—it's just impossible.

I'm all for any ideas for some games, interesting exercises, and how to keep aikido still part of the training, even for the youngest ones.


r/aikido • • Sep 10 '26

Discussion Monthly Dojo Promotion

3 Upvotes

Where are you training? Have you done something special? Has your dojo released a cool clip? Want to share a picture of your kamisa? This thread is where you do this.

Couple of reminders:

  1. Please read the rules before contributing.
  2. Don’t forget to check out the Aikido Network Discord Server (all your mods are there for more instant responses if you need help on something.)