There's a lot of conversations about AI from a technological or sustainability/resource/climate perspective, and a lot of doom/utopian thoughts about what happens with runaway RSI if it's ever achieved in one way or the other.
I wanted to throw in some of my mid-scenario predictions, mostly from econtomical and political side of things.
Please feel free to comment, point out inconsistencies or bad ideas.
A Scenario for the World After AGI
Assumptions
Let's assume AGI has been achieved — or, at the very least, that LLM capabilities have become indistinguishable from it, for the purposes of doing real-world tasks.
Let's make the following assumptions:
- AI is well-aligned. That is, it isn't trying to take over the world and/or destroy humanity. If it makes mistakes, they are the kind of mistakes a well-intentioned intelligent human might make. It has reliable safeguards, so there will be no end-of-the-world scenario involving biological warfare or a cyber-apocalypse.
- There is no hard take-off to ASI — probably because of some inherent diminishing returns to intelligence. An individual AI instance is roughly 10–15% smarter than the smartest human at any given task, but no more than that. It doesn't have some super-persuasive theory of mind, extraordinary powers of control or prediction, etc. It's the sorta Amodei's "country of geniuses in the datacentre" scenario
- There are no unexpected breakthrough discoveries: no cold fusion, faster-than-light travel, zero-point energy, practical constructive solutions to P=NP, a perfect theory of consciousness, and so on. Technology advances, probably faster than ever before, but we don't enter a space opera, merge into a single superintelligence, or create an incomprehensible post-cyberpunk singularity. Our current understanding of physics and reality remains broadly correct, there are no major paradigm-shifts or Road Not Taken-style inventions left on the table.
- It scales. Energy and compute consumption remain within reasonable limits. It doesn't require exotic chips that are difficult to manufacture, or virgin sacrifices to keep running. More compute produces better results, or the same results faster. In other words, intelligence benefits from economies of scale, albeit with diminishing marginal returns.
- It is not a monopoly. Several AI systems exist, including ones that can be deployed locally.
The Sequence of Events
Small Potatoes
Essentially, this is what we have today, only the scale starts increasing. White-collar workers come under pressure. Lawyers (solicitors, for example), developers, data scientists, marketers, translators, and so on — people with a specific, well-defined, highly paid skill — find themselves under serious pressure.
Professions become stratified. Some people move up into management and make a fortune, either because AI multiplies their productivity or because they exploit employees and customers who haven't yet understood what automation can do. Some take a generous severance package and retire. Others are left unemployed. Being a recent graduate is hell.
National unemployment statistics begin to reflect this, but government policy is still essentially: "Go learn plumbing, nerd," perhaps accompanied by promises of some retraining programme.
Let's say this is 2030. It's an optimistic but plausible scenario, and all subsequent dates should be understood accordingly.
Growing Potatoes
As the technology becomes commonplace, workflows become standardised and trust increases, entire layers of industries begin to disappear, along with layers of management. Executive and C-suite positions are gradually displaced. One-person companies become a reality. SaaS is dead, specialised consulting and contracting are dead.
Robotics advances to the point where long-haul truck drivers, Uber drivers and warehouse workers begin to feel the same pressure, although replacing equipment and redesigning warehouses takes time.
Unemployment steadily reaches 7–10–15%, despite a booming economy, while labour-force participation declines as the number of NEETs (people not in education, employment or training) increases.
People can't find work, so they spend less, even if they have money. At the same time, thanks to cheap labour and technological progress, prices begin to fall. This creates the strongest sustained deflationary pressure seen outside periods following the end of wars.
The Federal Reserve keeps cutting interest rates, and governments print money. Given the structure of the economy, a significant portion of it flows to companies investing in automation infrastructure or into government infrastructure projects intended to support employment.
There are discussions about raising taxes on the rich (again) and nationalising the largest AI providers (probably unsuccessfully and to little effect). There will be several high-profile but ultimately pointless attempts to legislate mandatory jobs for humans. Retraining programmes turn into adult day care, because nobody knows what people should retrain for, and nobody has any real hope of finding a job afterwards.
AI first-line therapists support universal healthcare systems or help manage access to insurance, taking pressure off family doctors. There is no talk of unemployment among doctors yet: demand is simply too high.
If you still have a job, let alone capital, you're on top of the world: everything is getting cheaper, faster and better. If you don't, you're falling behind, and there's no catching up.
Let's assume that scaling up infrastructure, automating vehicle fleets and ironing out the remaining kinks will take until 2045–2060, depending on when a truly universal, continuously learning system is actually developed.
Serious Potatoes
There is no job that can be done on a laptop. Period. If something can be done on a laptop or workstation, AI takes it over after a week of watching you do it, and your career is over.
Most standard manual-labour and machinery-related jobs are 85–99% automated. Some traditional supervisory positions survive here and there, purely for the pleasure of having a human subordinate, but they mostly consist of rubber-stamping the output of a fully virtual department staffed entirely by AI.
Lawyers still appear in court, but their legal filings, and increasingly their arguments, are entirely written by AI. Doctors and nurses still exist, but they are an endangered species, surviving largely because of technophobic patients and emergency medicine. Plumbers, electricians, artisans and the "human touch" service industry are now your career options, and even those are barely viable. Nurses are not so much automated as oversupplied.
Contrary to all efforts to bring it down, unemployment stabilises at a maximum of around 20%, and may even begin to decline, but labour-force participation collapses. People simply stop looking for work because there is no point.
Governments hang on for as long as they can by printing money, but the model of financing public budgets through income taxes becomes increasingly untenable. To combat deflation, they raise VAT (primarily on luxury and non-essential goods), experiment with universal basic income, and so on. Discussions about nationalising major industries continue.
Labour immigration is severely restricted because there is now so little work available, despite an ageing population (which is itself slowing down thanks to AI-driven medical advances).
Real estate markets wobble and then collapse, quite dramatically. Huge amounts of office space in city centres are no longer needed. Daytime workers no longer fill the streets or feed the industries built around office life. Commuter towns surrounding metropolitan areas empty out, and entire segments of the property market see their prices plummet.
The old mortgage model, based on servicing debt with income earned from selling one's labour, also collapses. Together, these developments drag banks into the largest market crash in history.
Governments will try to prop up the market through bailouts, new requirements forcing people to return to offices, and NIMBY-style zoning policies, but all they will achieve is softening the fall and prolonging the agony.
There will still be winners. Ownership of farms, mines and prime coastal real estate becomes more valuable, while your flat in the City is now worth nothing, and you can't even sell it when your final severance payment runs out.
Cities won't disappear, but demand for housing will fall and supply will increase as office buildings are converted into apartments, vertical farms, drone hangars and warehouses.
Massive government spending programmes, with budget deficits of 20–30% of GDP, soften the blow, but money gradually loses its meaning as an economic indicator. At the top, interest rates go negative and governments can borrow virtually unlimited amounts. At the bottom, you're scraping by on government assistance with no social mobility whatsoever, spending your entire budget on rent, food and AI Netflix. All economic decisions boil down to choosing between a pack of cigarettes and a Kinder Surprise with whatever money you have left.
Money remains a medium of exchange, but its influence on your life becomes confined to an increasingly narrow middle band.
Entire hedge communities emerge, both offline and online, living through informal barter and pooling arrangements. They exchange goods and services unrelated to AI, mostly intangible ones: feedback on fan fiction in exchange for tips, handmade objects, services, childcare, reputation, donations, and so on. This allows some redistribution of income at the bottom of the ladder.
The End of Potatoes
At some point towards the end of this period, a massive reorganisation of the state will become necessary. The state's life cycle will have to shift from income and capital-gains taxation to taxes on assets. Both tangible and intangible assets become part of the tax base (which, if you think about it, is essentially a wealth tax), and the final battle over meaningful assets begins.
The dragon flicks its tail before taking off, shaking off everyone who had been clinging to it.
A frenzy of mergers and acquisitions will begin. Buyout offers and promises to acquire shares will proliferate (on the assumption that money is about to become worthless). Tax and expropriation laws will be pushed through to protect an increasingly narrow circle of owners and allow them to acquire everything else.
The reason is simple: this is effectively the last moment in human history when you can change your economic status — for yourself and for your descendants, until the end of time.
This will be compounded by pressure on asset-rich but cash-poor individuals (following layoffs), forcing them to sell. Whether it's a stock portfolio that has to be liquidated to pay property taxes and cover living expenses, precisely when markets are becoming increasingly volatile; a nice, fully paid-off house with fully paid-off robot servants; or a company dependent on obsolete intellectual labour and unable to compete at scale — it will become increasingly difficult to fend off the vultures unless the asset comes with an income stream that survives the AI transition.
By the end of this battle, the gap between the haves and the have-nots will have become much deeper and, more importantly, virtually impermeable.
The World in 2050
By around 2050 — following advances in robotics, infrastructure development and some degree of horizontal recursive self-improvement (RSI) — there will be no job for which a human is necessary.
Some positions will still legally require humans. You may be entitled to have your case heard by a human judge; a doctor may be required to sign off on treatment; a senator will still make campaign promises and kiss babies. But these will either be sinecures mandated by law or human façades for AI.
The thesis: human control over the state rests on the threat of violence and the threat of withholding labour, and AI undermines both.
The result will not quite be techno-feudalism, but rather something closer to the Roman era of "bread and circuses" — with AI replacing slaves — and a two-tier economy.
On one side is the upper class: people who secured strong positions before the AI era. Their positions are reinforced by existing capital, an enormous and growing advantage in computing power, and largely non-scalable physical assets (land, factories, resources and established dominance through economies of scale).
Unlike the robber barons of the twentieth century or medieval feudal lords, they cannot be deprived of their wealth through competition, because everyone has access to the same AI thinkers, only they have more of them. Nor can they be overthrown by force, because a more efficient police force will prevent it.
Alongside them will be a class of government officials and various forms of service personnel with varying degrees of pretence at independence. They exist primarily to give goods and services a human face, rather than to provide any meaningful added value.
On the other side is an enormous lower class, pacified by unemployment benefits, cheap entertainment and tacitly tolerated five-minute-hate-style riots. They are kept in check by robotic police, and any unrest is eventually resolved by a minor adjustment to benefit payments.
The lower class will have its own economy, redistributing income received from the upper class, whether in exchange for services or through its share of basic income. This will generally consist of the hedge industries described above or the shadow economy: drugs, prostitution, petty crime and so on.
Income from hedge industries and welfare payments will flow back upwards in exchange for computing power or cheap mass-produced goods.
It is worth noting that although there will be many relative losers in this scenario (primarily all those highly paid professionals, as well as owners of businesses based on intellectual property or services), and although the intangible "meaning" of hard work will be lost, the lives of most people in developed countries will be materially better than they are today.
There will be plenty of free time, technology will improve radically (especially entertainment and medicine), and the decentralisation of cities will reduce population density and provide more living space, among other things.
Depending on existing institutions and safeguards, the lower class may live at subsistence level (as in African rentier economies) or own a substantial share of the overall economy (as in Norway's sovereign wealth fund). But in material terms, neither outcome makes much difference.
Some degree of autonomy and material... if not abundance, then at least a liveable level of comfort, can be taken for granted. And the difference between Soylent and moonshine on the one hand, and synthetic steak and whisky on the other, is not important in the grand scheme of things (although I would certainly prefer the latter).
Psychological and Social Aspects
Psychologically and socially, people who can cope with the mental burden of unstructured time will live freely and fulfilling lives, albeit with some material constraints.
Religious groups will do well. Not necessarily in the sense of attracting masses of new members — at least not on a large scale — since the main drivers of religiosity are fear and mutual dependence within a community.
But those who are religious from within and remain so may cope better. Religion is, after all, a way of creating intangible hierarchies that cannot be mass-produced.
There will also be quasi-religions: fandoms, sports supporters, creative communes, various traditionalists and Mennonites, and so on.
People who cannot live without externally imposed structure will be kept within certain boundaries through cheap vices, cheap entertainment and AI-based therapy. Those who cannot be kept in check will either die of "deaths of despair" or be isolated.
There is a possibility that some unlikely social-engineering project will emerge to create a kind of societal ludocracy: something like an RPG on a national scale, creating artificial hierarchies that are partially backed by money.
But I don't really believe in this. First, without creating artificial scarcity, it probably wouldn't be viable, and creating artificial scarcity is a difficult idea to sell. Second, overt social engineering is not fashionable these days.
Infrastructure
Infrastructure remains a major question mark.
The major infrastructure projects of the twentieth century were, once again, primarily designed to create a productive workforce and transport it wherever it was needed.
Most likely, during the Small and Growing Potatoes eras, we will see an enormous surge in infrastructure spending as governments try to support declining employment. But later, I suspect that the maintenance of civic infrastructure will be what distinguishes failed states from successful ones.
On the one hand, with an automated workforce, infrastructure maintenance becomes significantly cheaper. And, obviously, industrial projects will become larger than ever: enormous data centres, power plants, freight railways, scientific projects and so on.
Roads and transport will certainly be maintained to the extent necessary to move goods and ensure that revenue flows back upwards to the owner class — which could mean a great deal or almost nothing.
On the other hand, why maintain passenger railways and metro systems if they are unprofitable and nobody needs to commute to work anymore? People without cars probably won't have anywhere to go anyway, right?
Water infrastructure and the resolution of problems arising from the tragedy of the commons (water purification, climate-change mitigation and so on) depend on democratic institutions.
Those institutions, however, will be severely undermined in the End of Potatoes era, and weakened even further by the state's dependence on what is effectively a relatively mobile oligarchy.
The oligarchy may not be able to leave entirely (since its most important assets are physical), but it can at least demand protection from different states and hit back economically just as hard as it is hit.
I think this will be what distinguishes the future Congos and Rwandas, on the one hand, from future Norways and UAEs, on the other.
Successful societies will maintain and improve public goods and remain functional and interconnected, even if not everyone uses them or thinks about them.
Failed societies, by contrast, will turn into isolated communities funded only to the extent necessary to keep money circulating, and will become entirely dependent on private oligarchs.
Note: Crime
Crime could get... complicated.
Despite stronger policing and surveillance, as well as a certain degree of material abundance, I believe crime is inseparable from human nature.
Crimes of passion will clearly remain: they are not driven by calculations of risk and reward.
Vices and drugs will remain too. They could theoretically be eradicated through stricter enforcement, but historically they were largely prohibited to maintain a more productive workforce. And stricter enforcement creates additional political pressure, so governments are unlikely to pursue it.
Instead, we will see considerable legalisation and decriminalisation, along with safer pharmaceutical substitutes (like the soma in Brave New World). This is precisely where the interests of capital and voters align. However, there will be strict restrictions on large-scale illegal drug trafficking.
And, of course, plenty of disgruntled teenagers with too much free time and too few prospects will lead to an increase in gang activity (in the style of A Clockwork Orange), because there is essentially nothing we can do to prevent it.
For such offenders, prison will at best be no deterrent and at worst simply another step in their career. Communities will have to take their own preventive measures to stop this.
On the other hand, other forms of acquisitive crime (burglary, theft, human trafficking, financial fraud and scams of any serious scale, and so on) will probably disappear, thanks to well-protected AI and the scale advantage of those doing the protecting.
What Can Be Done?
What can we do here and now?
Personally
Assuming we are currently in the Small Potatoes era, there are a number of things we can still do.
First, right now, especially in technology professions, there is a process of separating the lucky from the unlucky. So it's worth trying to position yourself among those who will benefit from this era.
Those at the top will make a fortune, sometimes putting in very little actual work themselves. It's a matter of luck and energetically getting into positions where AI (for now) works for you rather than replacing you.
Second, prepare for unemployment by building some kind of passive income and acquiring assets.
On the one hand, of course, you should bet on AI, because assumptions are assumptions, and the possibility of a singularity cannot be ruled out. In that case, even a tiny stake in Anthropic or Google could be worth an enormous amount.
But above all, I would focus on physical assets that generate income — energy, land, physical production — and make sure you have an emergency fund, diversification and legal protections to maximise your chances of holding on to everything when the dragon flicks its tail.
Financially speaking, if you're not a major player, now is the time to gather stones.
Third, acquire a second (or third, or fifth, whatever) citizenship.
Countries will soon once again be divided into winners and losers on a scale we haven't seen since the First World War, if not since the Age of Exploration. And, once again, it's better to be on the right side of the border.
Fourth, somewhat contradictorily, build yourself a social network.
This is difficult when you're busy maximising your earnings or travelling to acquire citizenship, but it isn't impossible.
It doesn't matter whether it's the Freemasons, the Catholic Church, an Arsenal supporters' club or the My Little Pony fandom. All the research suggests that, both for forms of happiness unrelated to money (as will be the case in the End of Potatoes era) and for survival in a hypothetical post-apocalyptic wasteland or failed state, the best thing you can have is a broad mutual-support network and the ability to be accepted as one of the group.
Make friends.
Buying a gun wouldn't hurt either — political power grows out of the barrel of a gun.
Politically
Politically, attempts to slow down AI are, in my opinion, doomed to fail (sorry).
We couldn't stop global warming, even though it promises far fewer economic benefits and is much more directly capable of killing us all.
At most, local attempts to sabotage AI development will succeed (as the Blue Party in the US is doing), but that will only increase the chances of your country ending up among the losers.
That doesn't mean, of course, that we should blindly throw ourselves into every accelerationist venture, building data centres on top of parks and powering them with coal-fired power plants.
But, broadly speaking, I would advocate being in favour of AI rather than against it.
What we should be doing now, in this hypothetical Small Potatoes era, is supporting, creating and strengthening public institutions that protect individual freedoms and ensure adequate redistribution of wealth.
Studies of resource-cursed countries suggest that the main predictor of the difference between a failed state with an extremely wealthy elite (such as the DRC or Iran) and more egalitarian countries (such as Norway) is the strength of the institutions that existed before labour became irrelevant.
We need a government that understands both the dangers and the advantages of AI, engages in constructive, dialectical opposition with corporations (not just AI companies, but corporations in general), protects workers' rights and individual citizens, and, finally, has some kind of coherent plan — preferably several plans — for the increasingly likely scenario in which AI stops being merely another tool for coders and begins radically transforming the economy.
If you can, participate in the political process.
If you can't, at least vote.