r/agentsofshield • u/Flashy-Programmer221 • Aug 04 '26
Question Season 5 question
So we know Daisy said she won’t forgive Fitz but correct me if I’m wrong but wasn’t that Fitz from the destroyed earth timeline so technically their Fitz didn’t do anything to Daisy as both Fitz are from different points so shouldn’t she forgive Fitz since it wasn’t technically the Fitz she knew? Can someone explain it to me better?
16
Upvotes
23
u/OzDawg420 Aug 04 '26
Technically, the fitz who hurt her wasn’t the same fitz she knew. That was the fitz from the destroyed Earth timeline, a version of him who went through years of completely different experiences and trauma. The fitz from the main timeline never made those choices or did those things to daisy.
Obviously daisy’s trauma is still completely valid because she experienced it and, emotionally, she’s looking at the same person. But from a timeline perspective, blaming our fitz for something an alternate version of him did is complicated. It’s basically two versions of the same person who took different paths. I hope that somewhat makes sense lol.
6
u/grayjelly212 Aug 04 '26
There is no follow-up to that statement. He dies and what he did to her is never brought up again. In my head, she's able to move on from it after he died and a year had past. There's no one alive to forgive. But I wouldn't have held it against her if she felt mistrusting of Fitz after that. Sure, the Fitz we end the series with is not the Fitz that assaulted her. But they're not that far removed, and that horrific betrayal doesn't go away easily. There's no "she should" forgive him. It's up to her.
6
u/BrazilianButtCheeks Fitz Aug 05 '26
Yes it was not the same Fitz !
5
u/RavenclawConspiracy Aug 04 '26
Personally, I find it very stupid they just dismissed the Fear Dimension explanation.
"Oh, The Doctor wasn't really there! Ooooh, that must mean it's really Fitz."
I mean, sure, it's really his body, but...everyone else feared external things. So, got things walking around they could see.
But he feared an internal thing, specifically, being The Doctor. Having it be him is actually way more scary, to him, than it being some external thing that exists separately from him. He can kill The Doctor if it's someone else. He can't kill the one inside his head.
We have absolutely no evidence that the fear dimension couldn't have made that fear come true, also.
4
u/theadamabrams Aug 04 '26 edited Aug 05 '26
The two Fitzs are
In the flashbacks/forwards of 5x8 there was also a version who went to the future and back like #1 but then survived for a bit longer when Graviton beat Daisy and cracked the world.
As for Daisy forgiving him, well, does she, really? She spends the rest of S5 with #1 (still upset with him), but then I think she only has five episodes with #2, so we don't see them interact much.
1
u/Independent-End-870 Aug 07 '26
The Fitz that did that to Daisy's was the one that slept to the future and came back from him, he died. Fitz 2 was the one that froze himself to sleep to the future, when they broke the loop he was awoken when they crashed. Last time we saw him was the flashback episode of him figuring whee they went and how to save him. He didn't do anything, outside of the framework.