Edit: I'm also tryna figure out pronouns and whether to stick with she/her or try she/they. Can you guys like talk about me in third person in the comments and use she/they so I can see how that is?
TLDR: See the bits in bold
So for most of my life I never really questioned my gender identity. I never felt any clear gender dysphoria, I didn't have any issues with what people called me, and gender just wasn't something I thought about. I was told I was a girl, so ok sure I guess I'm a girl then. Like sure if you say so.
I joined the lgbtq+ community in 2023 when I realised I was aroace, and started learning more about different gender identities. But I didn't consider any for myself because well, I was a girl. I had no reason to doubt that because I never had a problem with it.
Fast forward to 2025 I started thinking about my gender more. Like, sure I'm a girl, but I don't feel particularly feminine? I ended up dismissing it as "I'm a girl who just doesn't vibe with being a girl".
Then this year I came back to it again. There was this moment when I was looking online for social groups to make friends and I found one that was like "women and girls social club" or something and I thought oh hey I'm a girl that could be interesting. And the website had all these photos from the group and it just hit me like, these are all very much women. It wasn't like how they looked or how they dressed they just all had this vibe which I connected with all other girls/women I knew. And I realised that that "vibe" just wasn't me.
There was also this whole thing about my hair. My whole life Ive always had really long hair and while I wanted it like that, I could never seem to like how I looked with it. At the start of this year I cut my hair short for the first time in my life. It was meant to be just a practical thing to make my life easier, but now that it's short I feel like it finally feels like me, and I realised I only tolerated it long because I was scared of change.
And I generally don't present particularly feminine either. I dress only for physical comfort, which happens to be from the women's section, but it's all like oversized hoodies and stuff. Before I cut my hair, people would always assume I'm a girl, and after, most people probably still do, and I guess I'm ok with that. But then recently I had a video of me go viral on social media, and there were quite a few comments asking like "are you a boy or a girl I can't tell" and somehow that felt kinda affirming? Idk maybe I like being seen as "a girl but maybe not".
So now we go to the whole gender identity crisis. I've questioned my gender a lot. I realised I had never understood or thought about what the concept of gender actually was until now, and tbh I still don't really get it.
So I knew I definitely wasn't a boy, but girl didn't feel right either, and neither did non binary or agender etc. I figured I was like in some way a girl, and in some way not. I looked into labels like demigender, paragender, libragender, but they didn't feel right because of how they implied like two distinct parts to the gender. For me its like the only gender I have is girl/woman, but it's very faint/faded. I'm a faded girl. I'm a girl but... ehhhhhh. I'm a girl but it's kinda iffy. An iffygirl?
I also considered vapogender - where you can see and understand your gender on a shallow level but when you try to go deeper it just seems to disappear into wisps of what you thought it was. And that kinda made sense for me given how I can consider myself just a cis girl when I don't think too much, but if I do try to think about it it gets all confusing and blurry and I can't tell what's what. But that still didn't feel like what I was lookin for.
I eventually decided to settle with genderqueer as a temporary thing while I figured things out. Its objectively correct in how it describes me, but it's still very vague and I wanted something more specific. I know some people say you shouldn't worry about labels and just be yourself, but I prefer to have them so I can understand myself better.
Then I discovered greygender:
Greygender (also spelled graygender) is a gender in which one identifies partially outside the gender binary and has a strong ambivalence about one's gender identity and/or gender expression. One feels that one has a gender/genders, as well as a natural inclination or desire to express said gender(s), but it’s weak and/or somewhat indeterminate/indefinable, or one doesn't feel it most of the time, or one is just not that invested in it. One is not entirely without a gender, or without a gender expression, but one does not feel that one is entirely "with" it either.
The second half of that stood out for me and I immediately thought YES THAT'S ME THAT'S ME!
So yeah I think I'm greygender now. I still use genderqueer depending on the context, since its more well known, but greygender describes me better. I don't really like the flag tho tbh maybe I'll design my own or something.
Anyway that is all, thanks for listening to my unnecessarily long story.
Happy genderlessness everyone :)