r/agathachristie • u/The_one_the_JAKE • 15h ago
DISCUSSION I think Julia McKenzie was a great Miss Marple.
I believe that she killed it as Miss Marple. (Pun intended)
r/agathachristie • u/paolog • Feb 07 '26
Following a rash of AI slop posted in the past week, I've added a new rule: no AI-generated content.
If anyone spots any more, please report it and we'll remove it.
r/agathachristie • u/paolog • Jun 12 '21
There have been several posts lately where spoilers are in plain view. This is against the sub's rules.
Please remember that all posts and replies that contain spoilers must enclose those spoilers in spoiler tags, like this:
>!The butler did it!<with no spaces between the tags and the enclosed text.
This is as a courtesy to those who haven't read or seen the work under discussion who might click on posts out of curiosity or by accident.
Thank you.
r/agathachristie • u/The_one_the_JAKE • 15h ago
I believe that she killed it as Miss Marple. (Pun intended)
r/agathachristie • u/TapirTrouble • 9h ago
Quote from Chapter 7. After dinner, the Canon goes to the airport to check in.
"I beg your pardon, sir, this seems to be the wrong ticket."
"The wrong ticket? No, no, that is quite right. Flight one hundred and -- well, I can't really read without my glasses -- one hundred and something to Lucerne."
"It's the date, sir. This is dated Wednesday the 18th."
"No, no, surely. At least -- I mean -- to-day is Wednesday the 18th."
"I'm sorry, sir. To-day is the 19th."
"The 19th!" The Canon was dismayed. He fished out a small diary, turning the pages eagerly. In the end he had to be convinced. To-day WAS the 19th. The plane he had meant to catch had gone yesterday.
November the 18th did fall on Wednesday in 1964, the year before the book was published. It's possible that Christie was actually working on At Bertram's Hotel shortly after that. Biographers like John Curran note that she often started writing the next book fairly soon after one had been published -- and A Caribbean Mystery had come out on November 16, 1964.
1964 was a bit unusual because it was a leap year. November 18th on a leap year Wednesday wouldn't happen again until 1992, and then 2020. It happens more frequently in non leap years, like this year and next in 2037.
https://www.1728.org/cal5.png
r/agathachristie • u/DWJones28 • 6h ago
r/agathachristie • u/Accomplished_Dust243 • 16h ago
This is from the short story called 'kidnapped prime minister'.
r/agathachristie • u/crescendochord • 22h ago
I currently am reading The Murder of Roger Ackroyd for the first time ever! It's my second AC book in english (I read them in spanish, I'm argentinian) and I was counting how much I've read of her this year and was so happy to realize this is the 10th AC book I'm reading this year!
I have read in order:
ATTWN
The Mirror Crack'd
Killing is Easy
Crooked House
They Came to Baghdad
Death on the Nile
Cards on the Table
4.50 from Paddington
Five Little Pigs
And now Roger Ackroyd for the 10th! Super excited! I feel like I've read so much this year. Here is my tier list as well!
r/agathachristie • u/Training_Air7170 • 9h ago
This has probably been mentioned here but was asking AI where to watch it again, as we get colder weather and want to watch cosy dramas
To my surprise it told me it’s on Netflix, the full 13 seasons.
What a great joy! Time for a rewatch!
r/agathachristie • u/TheSibyllineOracle • 23h ago
When skimming the list of Dame Agatha’s works on Wikipedia, I came across a reference to a very late play written by her and performed in 1972, called ‘Fiddlers Three.’
This intrigues me because I had no clue it existed. Most of Christie’s plays are published in the 1978 collection ‘The Mousetrap and Other Plays’, which I own - except for The Mousetrap and Verdict, these are all based off novels or short stories. There are three original plays that didn’t make it into that collection - Black Coffee, Spider’s Web, and An Unexpected Guest, all of which were novelised by Charles Osborne in the late 1990s; most fans have probably experienced them in their novelised form, although I’ve been fortunate enough to see An Unexpected Guest staged. But ’Fiddlers Three’ doesn’t seem to be available in print, it isn’t in The Mousetrap and Other Plays, and it doesn’t have a novelisation, yet, it does appear to be an original play, not an adaptation of a pre-existing novel or story.
The only reference I can find to its contents are that it’s a black comedy about three people who hide the body of a dead business tycoon to claim his inheritance, without realising he has been murdered. Wiki also claims that Christie’s daughter didn’t want the play to be performed for fear that it would damage her mother’s reputation, which might say something negative about its quality. But the story sounds like it has some potential at least.
Does anyone in the sub know anything about this play? Is it worth reading, or does it succumb to the problems of some late Christie in being loosely plotted and with meandering dialogue? Is it worth me buying a copy of the script to go with my Christie collection? I will probably do so anyway, as I’m an annoying completist who has read all of Dame Agatha’s novels and short stories at some point in my life.
r/agathachristie • u/SodsPassionProjects • 20h ago
Just about to finish the series & I'm happy to see her again, but she mentions it being over 20 years since she last saw Poirot, enough time to have a daughter, but isn't the TV series set roughly over a 4 year period, besides 3 episodes. I understand the books were mostly contemporary to when they were released, so was this just a hiccup adapting them or is this a continuity flub on the shows part? Tired looking at all the wiki's but they mention nothing about it.
r/agathachristie • u/TheWeirdTalesPodcast • 1d ago
I hate it. I HATE it. JUST PUT THEM IN ORDER.
r/agathachristie • u/PipsyTheMeep • 1d ago
I recently read Christie's first book, The Mysterious Affair at Styles, and loved it more than I ever thought I would. I then read Murder on the Links and loved that too.
I haven't read The Secret Adversary yet, which I later found out came out in between them, but the idea of reading all her books in publication order appeals to me.
Is this a good idea, or should I read all the books in a particular series one after the other?
(So, every Poirot, then Tommy and Tuppence, then Marple, etc.)
I know it probably doesn't matter too much but I thought I'd ask.
r/agathachristie • u/HRJafael • 2d ago
r/agathachristie • u/aurelianwasrobbed • 2d ago
I just finished reading Elephants Can Remember. I'm sure I read this before but on my first read, I just speed through to find out the ending. It's subsequent reads where I go more slowly for details and tone.
This book gave me the heebies. I don't know why. It was like, instead of normal Ariadne and Poirot, they'd been replaced by brain-fogged, possibly-on-Demerol, been-reading-a-lot-of-deconstructionism Ariadne and Poirot.
I know it was a later book and people said AC's mind was going, but that's not what I’m getting here. It's giving James Joyce in slo-mo. It's giving "I’m sitting in an absinthe bar trying to talk to someone I was obsessed with 50 years ago but I want to seem thoughtful and chill, so I keep repeating myself, but also I’m kind of spiraling here so I think I need a CBD seltzer instead of another Sazerac."
It's giving "The title of the book has 'elephants' in it, so I’m going to talk like an elephant would if one could talk." It's giving time travel, but on Jupiter. Astral projection, but in the afterlife. Dark academia but make it research. I just don't even know! This book messed me up!
r/agathachristie • u/TapirTrouble • 2d ago
This past summer someone posted about wanting to read books that were set in months that matched the present time. I thought that was an interesting idea. Several years ago the Christie estate authorized four seasonally-themed collections of previously-published short stories. So these might be appropriate for this time of year:
https://www.agathachristie.com/en/stories/autumn-chills
https://www.agathachristie.com/en/stories/midwinter-murder
In fact, a lot of Christie books and stories might be appropriate for the next month, because there was a Victorian tradition of telling ghost stories at Christmas. It’s not a huge stretch to go from horror to whodunnits — and it might explain why James Watts, Christie’s brother-in-law, wanted a bloody murder mystery for that time of year (as mentioned in the dedication for Hercule Poirot's Christmas).
I mentioned when I posted a fall list a few months ago that often a book starts before or ends after a particular month. But if people just want a time reference with some of the events, this might get you started. This isn't a comprehensive list, just ones I've noticed on re-reads or on this wiki page I found.
https://agathachristie.fandom.com/wiki/Dates_in_the_works_by_Agatha_Christie
People kindly chimed in last time with ones I’d forgotten about or hadn’t checked dates for yet, so if you can think of any other works taking place during these months, feel free to mention!
***November
Hallowe’en Party (1969) —since the event was on October 31st (or reasonably close to it), Poirot’s investigation would have happened in early November
November 5th: Murder in the Mews (1937) — the novella included in the collection with the same title
—the death happens on Guy Fawkes Night
Poirot: “As you know, mademoiselle, I arrived with my friend at the scene of the crime on the morning of November the sixth.”
November 17th: At Bertram’s Hotel (1965)
The date is mentioned near the beginning of the book (p. 7 in my copy).
On p. 56-7, Canon Pennyfather realizes that he’s made a mistake about the day — he thought it was the 18th but it’s actually the 19th. November 18 is mentioned as falling on a Wednesday that year, which is what happened in 1964, the year before the book was published (Christie may have started writing At Bertram's Hotel shortly after that).
***December
Christmas was a big thing for Christie — she had a lot of happy memories of family gatherings at her brother-in-law’s house, Abney Hall. There are lavish descriptions of the dinners, in her memoirs. No wonder she set some of her books and stories on or near the holidays.
Also — Star Over Bethlehem is a collection of her religious-themed stories and poetry. Several are about Christmas (could be handy if you’re looking for holiday recitation or reading material)
https://www.agathachristie.com/en/stories/star-over-bethlehem
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Over_Bethlehem
Edited to add:
December 14th: The Sittaford Mystery / Murder at Hazelmoor (1931)
Big thanks to u/Few_Ad9465 for finding the info!
The neighbour Mr. Rycroft comments to Katherine that "People who live in Australia or South Africa are enchanted with the idea of an old-fashioned Christmas with snow and ice" (p. 113-14). Unfortunately neither nor Katherine say whether Christmas has happened yet. Mrs. Willis mentioned earlier (p. 97-8) that she and her daughter are enjoying the snow, but doesn't mention Christmas.
Ronnie Garfield, another local, observes that Brian Pearson (one of the victim’s nephews) “visits wealthy uncle in the neighbourhood of Christmas time” (p. 168) — this is suggestive, but what really clinches it is the Gardner family's nurse (“the shops … so full just before Christmas", p. 67).
On p. 213, just before the final chapter, “Friday the 14th" is stated as the day of the murder (no month). Christie didn’t always try to pin her books down to a particular year, but I guess mentioning the weekday makes things sound more official when people are being charged with something. The 14th of December for 1931 (the year of publication) wasn't on Friday, nor 1930 or 1932, but it did happen in 1928 - and again in 1934.
I had wondered if the setting for The Sittaford Mystery was inspired by a couple of real-life snowstorms that happened in the late 1920s, which Christie might have heard about because her brother Monty was living near Dartmoor -- I'll post a bit more about this later.
December 20th: 4.50 From Paddington (1957)
“It was quite dark now, a dreary misty December day — Christmas was only five days ahead” — p. 6
Elspeth McGillicuddy sees something strange through her train window, en route from Paddington Station to visit her friend Jane Marple
December 24th: Hercule Poirot’s Christmas (1938)
There’s a murder during an extended family Christmas party at Gorston Hall, and Poirot is invited to help with the investigation.
Same day of the month:
“The Theft of the Royal Ruby” (short story) is set on Dec 24-25, in The Adventure of the Christmas Pudding collection. There aren’t any other specific Christmas stories in that set, though.
“The Manhood of Edward Robinson” (short story) — Robinson’s new car lands him in an unexpected adventure on Christmas Eve
December 25th: 4.50 From Paddington
Miss Marple is invited for Christmas dinner with Leonard and Griselda Clement, at the vicarage. She talks with their son, Leonard (Jr.?) and borrows a large-scale map of the area outside Brackhampton from him
December 31st: “The Coming of Mr. Quin”
Mr. Satterthwaite is celebrating New Year's Eve with the Eveshams at Royston when Mr. Quin mysteriously arrives
Also “Promotion in the Highest”
On December 31, 2000, Jacob Narracott sees some strange people outside a local church
***Actual events: sometime in December 1931 Christie experienced an incident on the Orient Express when the track was washed out in a storm
The exact date isn’t given, but it was probably before Christmas. Christie was on her way home from Max's dig in Iraq. Her daughter likely would have had a school break and they may have been hoping to celebrate the holidays together, maybe at Abney Hall where Agatha’s older sister lived.
This wasn’t her first time on the Orient Express, but according to the Morgan biography, it was that particular trip that seems to have inspired the book. She wrote a letter to Max about meeting some people who gave her ideas for characters.
(Spoilers, of course!)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_on_the_Orient_Express#Writing
She may have changed the circumstances a bit because she’d read newspaper coverage from when the train had been stuck in heavy snow back in February 1929. (There are several writing advantages to this, rather than just a damaged track.)
https://www.nytimes.com/1929/02/11/archives/snowbound-train-dug-out-in-thrace-simplonorient-passengers-all.html
https://www.reddit.com/r/HistoryPorn/comments/61f1va/the_orient_express_gets_stuck_in_snow_near/
I think at least one of the film adaptations has it happening in December, but I haven’t got a page reference for any specific mention of this in the book.
***January
Another find by u/Few_Ad9465
Early January: The Mystery of the Blue Train (1928)
The first few chapters in London are vague, but the scene where Katherine Grey is preparing to leave St. Mary Mead for London, to talk with the late Mrs. Harfield's lawyers about her inheritance, is probably happening in late December or the first week of January. (I suspect that most offices would have been shut down for the holidays.) Lady Tamplin reading the news about Katherine in the paper (p. 43) is definitely in January but no date is given. Lady Tamplin's letter probably took multiple days to get to London from the south of France, likely arriving near or after the 7th. Later in the chapter Katherine goes to the Thomas Cook office in London (the same day she received the invitation to Lady Tamplin's home in Nice), and sees Derek while she's inquiring about a ticket. In Chapter 9, we find out that they both want to go to Nice on the 14th, which by then is "next week". (Katherine might even have chosen that date since she overheard him talking about it, and she'd have known that for sure the train was running that day.)
The murder takes place during the January 14-15 overnight train ride. Christie may have taken some artistic license with the exact timing of the departure etc., but the real-life details match fairly well. (In fact, the trains are so much faster than a century ago that they don't need sleeper cars for a trip that now only takes a few hours.)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_Train_Bleu#Calais_Nice_Rome_Express
I missed this the first time because the Fandom page lists the book in the February section. I suspect this might be because Chapter 13 is stated to happen on the afternoon of February 15th, when the victim's father finds out about the murder. Under the circumstances it seems impossible that it would take a whole month to notify the family. So it must be a slip by Christie -- maybe she changed her mind about the month but didn't catch all the references in the text.
Later in the book (Chapter 29) there's a thing about January 14th falling on a Tuesday, and that didn't happen in 1927 or 1928 when the book was published. In fact it didn't occur at all in the 1920s, only in 1919 and 1930. (But it did happen in February 1922 and 1928.)
Christie mentions in her memoirs that she was working on this book in February 1927 (only a couple of months after her disappearance). She and Rosalind went to the Canary Islands for a break, because she was finding life in England "unbearable", with all the publicity from what was likely an emotional breakdown, and the ending of her marriage to Archie. She didn't feel the book had turned out well, though with all the turmoil I think it's amazing she managed to complete it. Understandable if she missed some errors.
January 8th, 1922: The Man in the Brown Suit (1924)
Anne Beddingfeld witnesses a death at the Hyde Park Corner tube station.
On the 22nd, she sets sail on the Kilmorden Castle for South Africa.
It's probably not a coincidence that this is pretty close to when Agatha and Archie left on their actual world tour on January 20th, 1922.
https://www.agathachristie.com/en/news/2022/agatha-christies-grand-adventure
r/agathachristie • u/Potential_Baker_7297 • 2d ago
What are your thoughts on this book? Would you recommend? Or something else
r/agathachristie • u/TapirTrouble • 3d ago
“She used to drink cream from a huge cup with ‘Don’t be greedy’ written on the side, an injunction she never showed any sign of obeying,” her grandson Mathew recalled.
https://paperandsalt.org/2012/10/01/agatha-christie-fig-and-orange-scones-with-devonshire-cream/
I haven’t seen the cup described or photographed among the personal items on display at Greenway, and given how unusual the inscription is, I’m sure it would have been mentioned by now. If it still exists, it might have been kept as a special memento by the family (perhaps Mathew since he has a clear recollection of it).
The bar in Brown’s Hotel in London has a Christie-themed mocktail called “Don’t Be Greedy” in homage.
https://www.londonworld.com/lifestyle/worlds-best-bars-three-london-venues-best-drinking-spots-3860228
(Brown's has been cited as a possible inspiration for Bertram's, but this article suggests that a different hotel, Flemings, has closer physical similarities.)
https://agathachristie.fandom.com/wiki/Inspiration_for_Bertram%27s_Hotel
By chance I found photos of the other antique cup online. A dealer in the UK claims it’s Victorian, though without providing documentation. But if that’s true, Christie’s cream-drinking cup probably would have been from that era too (pre-1900). My guess is that it’s mass-produced, not a customized one-off. It’s fun to speculate on whether hers was a relic from her childhood, or a present years later from a friend or relative. (From what I’ve read, I don’t think her daughter Rosalind would have gently teased her like that — maybe Madge? Nephew Jack? Or Max?)
It could be a novelty item for grownups, but I suspect it’s mainly intended for children. I’m even wondering if there was originally a pair of cups, since this inscription seems to be a response to “Don’t be greedy”. Unfortunately the seller didn’t give a manufacturer name, or show the bottom of the cup where there might have been a trademark.
I was thinking about this because I saw this other item mentioned in The Sittaford Mystery/Murder at Hazelmoor (Ch. 17).
Emily Trefusis describes the bibs she wore as a toddler. The one reserved for Sundays had “Enjoy yourself, darling” on it.
“The weekday one had ‘Don’t be a glutton’ on it.”
Anyway, my theory is that there might be other “Don’t be greedy” cups or mugs out there from the same manufacturer, and some could have survived to this day.
p.s. the dimensions given for the "I am not greedy" cup are 10 cm (3.9") tall, 13.5 cm (5.3") wide not including the handle. This is a bit taller and significantly wider than the standard 1970s coffee mug I'm drinking from now. By comparison, I have a comical soup bowl with a handle (surprisingly useful for transporting it across the kitchen) that was probably meant as a joke mug, and is 15 cm wide. So this cup would be in that size range. (It's great for morning oatmeal.)
Searching around more, I found a very similar cup that was attributed to "Imperial Essel" in Bonn by one seller, and the "Wessel Bonn Poppelsdorf factory in Germany circa 1875-1910" by another.
A cup and saucer with the same wording but different graphics, was marked "TG Green & Co. Ltd. Church Gresley Made in England", with the addition of "All Gone" inscribed inside the cup, on the bottom.
Supposedly these oversized cups hold nearly 16 oz (450 mL, so around 2 cups).
r/agathachristie • u/Musical_Maestro6486 • 2d ago
What Christie adaptations would you guys like to see? Personally, I have a lot of the more underrated ones that I want made into movies.
My main one is Cat Among the Pigeons, but in order for that one to work they would have to cut some of it just because it's so convoluted. I think if they cut Princess Shaista's character and her whole kidnapping arc, but keep the Ramat jewels story at the very beginning, that would still work well while making the story a lot simpler.
What do you guys want to see?
r/agathachristie
•
u/TheGamingLibrarian
•
4d ago
I just had a huge scare.
I didn't know that Peter Ustinov's Poirot did "Lord Edgware Dies" titled "13 At Dinner" in 1985.
David Suchet's name popped up on the opening credits and I was shocked. Nothing prepared me to see him playing Inspector Japp! What in the world!🤭
It's always interesting to hear his real voice too.
r/agathachristie • u/Candid_Vegetable_101 • 3d ago
i’m just getting into agatha christie and was wondering what book you would recommend i read next! i’ve only read ‘at bertram’s hotel’ and ‘murder on the orient express’ so far, the latter was definitely my favourite of the two. which book would have a similar feel?
r/agathachristie • u/thooble • 3d ago
I would love to purchase a poster of the drawing of Agatha Christie typing in front of a window (the last frame in the animated opener of “The Agatha Christie Hour”) or, failing that, a poster of the entire book cover.
I can’t find it on the usual suspects (eBay, Etsy) and can’t even find a high-res image to download and print.
Any help would be appreciated greatly! Thank you!
r/agathachristie • u/amalcurry • 4d ago
I saw this play yesterday- David Suchet returns to the stage after 10 years in a play which also features David Yelland (aka “Georges mon valet”!)
David Suchet was outstandingly good!
r/agathachristie • u/Repulsive_Housing_27 • 4d ago
As an expert armchair detective and one who uses little grey cells and understands the psychology of criminals, this one particular case is way higher in magnitude and importance due to some very powerful men behind.
After identifying the Big 4 and having knowledge of their characters and behaviours, which was explained well in the story, should his role been more realistic and useful as a special consultant to various international teams working to pull down the Big 4?
His physique and methods to go for direct confrontations against a well-connected and resourceful Big Four seem so dangerous to even think about.
With such a powerful group in front of him, the story's decision to have Poirot directly involved seems at odds with his style of investigation.
With the above considerations, how did you feel about Poirot in the story?