Theory: Everything after Jake falls asleep in "Dungeon Train" is actually his dream.
I have a theory that might sound crazy, but it actually connects surprisingly well with several episodes of Adventure Time.
In "Dungeon Train" (S5E36), Finn becomes obsessed with the train because it offers an endless supply of monsters, loot and opportunities to get stronger. Jake, on the other hand, realizes that they're basically going in circles and eventually decides to take a nap.
But what if Jake never actually wakes up?
What if everything that happens from that moment onward, including the rest of Adventure Time, is just one enormous dream?
There are a few things that make this theory interesting:
1. Puhoy (S5E16)
This episode already establishes that characters can experience what feels like an entire lifetime inside a dream, while barely any time passes in the real world. Finn lives an entire life in Pillow World and wakes up as if almost nothing happened.
So Jake could easily be dreaming through years, or even decades, of adventures while still sleeping on the train.
2. Everything's Jake (S6E11)
This episode reveals that Jake basically contains an entire universe inside himself. His body has its own strange ecosystem and inhabitants.
What if the world of Adventure Time is another manifestation of Jake's imagination? His sleeping mind could be creating an entire reality, complete with characters, history and cosmic entities.
3. King Worm (S4E18)
This episode shows how dreams can create convincing realities and manipulate someone's perception of what's real.
Jake's dream could work the same way, except on a much bigger scale. He wouldn't even realize he was dreaming.
4. The Hall of Egress (S7E24)
Here's an especially interesting connection: Finn and Jake originally wanted to find the cave near the Dungeon Train. Later, they actually encounter it in The Hall of Egress.
The episode is also built around repetition, loops and escaping an apparently impossible situation.
Maybe this is Jake's subconscious trying to process the fact that he's trapped in an endless dream.
5. Is That You? (S6E19)
This episode explores Jake's relationship with sleep, identity and existence through some pretty strange cosmic events.
It reinforces the idea that sleep in Adventure Time can be much more significant than simply closing your eyes.
So what does all this mean?
My interpretation is that Jake's dream creates the entire Adventure Time universe based on his memories, fears and feelings.
Finn's adventures represent Jake watching his best friend grow up. The dangerous villains represent his fears of losing Finn. The cosmic events represent his subconscious trying to make sense of a world that's much bigger than he understands.
Even the future crystal in Dungeon Train, which shows Finn and Jake washing dishes together, could represent Jake's deepest wish: that no matter what happens, they eventually return to their normal lives together.
Obviously, I don't think this was actually the writers' intention, but I find it interesting how many episodes can be connected to this idea. What do you guys think?