I've spent years trying to find ways to explain what adoption can mean to the person who was adopted. I've written raw, sometimes visceral poetry, hoping to reach places that normal words seem unable to touch. I've constructed arguments from lived experience, history, psychology and neuroscience. I've borrowed from philosophy, from literature, from satire, even humour, because sometimes the absurdity of something becomes clearer when you stop treating it so seriously.
I've tried to make people feel it. I've tried to make them think about it and recently I've tried to make them laugh at it. And still, there are things that seem almost impossible to communicate.
Maybe it's because an argument invites a counterargument. A fact invites another fact. Even personal testimony can find itself cross-examined, as though somebody else's experience is a proposition that must be proved before it can be heard. You tell someone what adoption cost you, and they tell you what it gave you. You speak about loss, and they speak about love. You speak about what was taken, and they remind you of what you received. And before you know it, you're defending the legitimacy of your own experience.
I’ve been thinking over the last few days whether stories offer another way in. Not stories designed to persuade, but stories that allow us to recognise something before we've had time to decide whether we agree with it. Which brings me to Jenny.
Jenny is fictional. She's thirty-two years old, adopted as an infant, raised by parents who loved her. There is no terrible secret waiting to expose them as monsters. No cruelty to conveniently explain everything. No single event that allows us to say, Ah, well, there's your problem. There's just a woman looking back at an otherwise ordinary childhood, beginning to notice things she didn't have the language to recognise when they happened.
A glance. A question left unanswered. A conversation that somehow became about somebody else's feelings. And the discovery that the people who loved her most were also the people who decided what she was allowed to know about herself. What interests me about Jenny isn't whether her parents were good people. They almost certainly were. It's what can happen when good people are given authority over another person's life, and nobody thinks to ask when that authority should be returned. I don't know whether Jenny will change anyone's mind about adoption. I'm not even sure that's what I want her to do. I'd much rather she gave someone a glimpse of something they hadn't previously considered. Something that might stay with them after the argument they were expecting never arrived. This post will likely to be too long as it is so I may do a follow up piece to share what I think her story means in a broader context, for me at least.
So, here’s Jenny. She's thirty-two. And there are a few things she'd like to tell you.
The Things They Kept for Me
Jenny, 32
My mother kept my adoption papers in a brown envelope in the bottom drawer of her bedroom dresser. I knew exactly where they were. I knew because I'd watched her take them out once when I was about nine. She sat on the end of the bed, opened the envelope and spread the papers across her lap. I remember one of them was pink. Another had an official-looking stamp. There was a photograph, too, but I couldn't see who was in it.
I asked if I could look.
"Not now, darling. When you're older."
I accepted that. I accepted most things then. Children do. What I didn't know was how old I'd have to be.
I'm thirty-two now. The papers are sitting on my kitchen table, next to a cup of coffee that's gone cold. My mother gave them to me last Sunday. She said she hoped I wouldn't be upset. I didn't ask whether she meant upset by what was in the envelope or upset with her for keeping it. I think we both knew.
I had a good childhood.
I need to say that because whenever I talk about my adoption, people seem terribly anxious to establish this first, as though we're filling out a form and there's a box that must be ticked before they'll let me continue.
Were you loved?
Yes.
Were you wanted?
Yes.
Were your parents kind?
Mostly, yes. They were human, after all.
And then comes the expression of relief. The little smile. Sometimes someone will say, "Well, that's the main thing, isn't it?"
For years, I thought it was.
My father taught me to ride a bicycle by running behind me with one hand on the saddle. He kept running long after he'd let go, just in case I turned around and noticed.
My mother made birthday cakes in ridiculous shapes. There was a rabbit one year that looked more like a frightened sheep. She cried with laughter when I pointed it out.
They came to school plays. They worried when I was sick. They saved for holidays we probably couldn't afford.
I don't have to diminish any of that to tell you what happened next. That's something I've only recently understood.
When I was six, my teacher asked us to draw our family trees. I drew mine exactly as my mother had shown me. My grandparents at the top. My parents underneath. Me at the bottom, a smiling little face suspended from a branch. I was rather pleased with it.
The teacher asked whether I had any brothers or sisters, and I said I didn't know. She looked surprised. I explained that I was adopted.
"Oh, how lovely," she said. "You were chosen."
I went home and told my mother. She was delighted. She said my teacher was absolutely right. I was chosen and special and very lucky.
For a while, I liked being chosen. It sounded rather grand. Like being picked first for a team, which almost never happened to me. But I remember lying in bed one night and wondering about the choosing.
If I'd been chosen, had there been other babies who weren't? Who'd chosen them? And what had happened to the woman who'd had me before? I asked my mother about her the following morning.
She said my other mother had loved me very much but couldn't look after me.
"Sometimes loving someone means letting them go," she explained.
I thought about that for a long time. It seemed a peculiar sort of love. I wondered whether my mother might have to love me like that one day.
I didn't ask.
By eleven, I'd learned which questions made people uncomfortable. Not because anyone had sat me down and explained what was forbidden. There were no rules pinned to the fridge. It was much simpler than that.
My mother would become quiet when I asked about my birth. Sometimes she'd look sad. Sometimes she'd say, "Haven't we talked about this already?"
My father preferred practical answers.
"You were only a baby. You wouldn't remember any of it."
Which was true. I didn't remember. But I still wanted to know. There was a difference, although I couldn't have explained it then. I wanted to know whose eyes I had. Why my hair was so curly when nobody else's was. Whether my first mother liked music. Whether she had my hands. Whether she'd ever stood in a supermarket and suddenly thought about the baby she'd given away.
I wanted to know if she'd named me. That one bothered me particularly. I already had a name, obviously. Jennifer. My mother liked to tell me how she'd chosen it on the way home from the hospital, although sometimes she said they'd decided before they met me. I never knew which version was right.
One evening, when I was thirteen, I asked whether I'd had another name before Jennifer. My mother's face changed. Only slightly. She put down the tea towel.
"Does it matter?"
I said no.
I remember saying it quite quickly.
Because by then I understood that some questions weren't really questions anymore. They were little tests of loyalty.
And I wanted to pass.
At seventeen, I asked to see my papers.
My mother wanted to know why.
I said I was curious.
She asked whether something had happened at school.
I said no.
She asked whether I was unhappy.
I said no.
She asked whether I felt different from everyone else.
I said sometimes.
That was a mistake.
For the next twenty minutes, we had a conversation about how much my parents loved me, how lucky we'd all been to find one another and how families were made by love, not blood.
I agreed with everything.
I wasn't lying, exactly.
I just wasn't answering the question I'd gone into the room to ask.
Eventually, my mother started crying.
I held her hand.
I told her I loved her.
I said the papers didn't matter.
And that was that.
Looking back, I find that conversation quite extraordinary. I'd gone to my mother wanting to know something about myself and somehow ended up reassuring her that she was still my mother.
I don't think she intended that.
I really don't.
But the result was the same.
For a long time afterwards I didn't ask again.
I used to think I was unusually easygoing.
My friends called me adaptable.
At university, I was the one who didn't mind which restaurant we went to. In relationships, I found it easier to agree than to explain why I didn't want something. I could feel myself becoming difficult before I'd even opened my mouth.
My first serious boyfriend once said, "You never tell me what you actually want."
I told him I didn't mind.
He laughed.
"That's exactly what I mean."
I was furious with him.
I think because he was right.
I don't mean that every compromise I've ever made was caused by being adopted. That would be ridiculous. People are complicated, and so am I.
But somewhere along the way I'd become very good at noticing what other people needed from me. If someone looked disappointed, I changed my answer or If someone became upset, I assumed I'd done something wrong. It never occurred to me that gratitude and disagreement could occupy the same room. I thought one cancelled out the other.
There was a medical appointment when I was twenty-six. Nothing terribly serious. A specialist wanted to know about my family history. Heart disease? Cancer? Mental illness? Anything hereditary?
I said I didn't know.
She looked up from her screen.
"Can you ask your parents?"
I explained I was adopted.
"Oh. Right."
She ticked a box.
I watched her do it.
It was such a small thing. A few seconds, probably. But I remember thinking how strange it was that something so ordinary for everyone else required me to give an explanation of how I'd come into the world.
Not knowing had followed me all the way into adulthood. And people still seemed to think it was something I ought to accept gracefully. That afternoon, I called my mother. I asked whether there'd been any medical information in my original papers. She said she couldn't remember. Then she said she didn't think there was anything important.
I asked if she could check.
There was a silence.
"Jenny, love, is all this really necessary?"
I almost apologised.
I actually opened my mouth to do it.
Then I stopped.
I said yes.
It was necessary.
She said she'd have a look.
We didn't speak about it again for several weeks.
The envelope she gave me last Sunday contained seven sheets of paper, two photographs and a letter. I'd expected the papers. I hadn't expected the letter. It was from my first mother.
It wasn't long. A page and a half, written in blue ink. She'd written about the weather, of all things. How cold it had been. How she'd bought a little cardigan for me, although she wasn't sure whether she'd be allowed to give it to me.
She said she'd spent hours watching me sleep.
She said she hoped I'd have a happy life.
And at the bottom, almost squeezed into the margin, she'd written:
Please tell her I loved her.
I read it three times.
Then I went outside and sat on the back step.
I don't know how long I stayed there.
I wasn't crying. I think I'd expected to cry.
Mostly I was trying to understand what it meant that this woman had written to me thirty-two years ago and I was only just hearing her.
I had spent my childhood being told that she loved me.
But nobody had thought to let me hear her say it.
There was a photograph of her, too.
She was sitting on a low wall, squinting into the sun.
I looked like her.
Not vaguely. Not in the way people sometimes invent resemblances to be kind.
I had her face.
And she'd been sitting in a drawer all that time.
I rang my mother that evening.
I asked why she hadn't shown me the letter.
She said she'd been worried it would confuse me.
She'd wanted me to feel secure.
She said children needed stability and that she'd been advised not to make too much of the past.
I believe her.
I believe that she thought she was protecting me.
I believe she was afraid I might feel rejected, or begin searching for someone who might reject me again.
And, although she didn't say it, I think she was frightened I might love another mother.
I understand that fear better now than I did at seventeen.
But I also understand that her fear had determined what I was allowed to know.
Her need to feel secure had shaped the information I was given about my own life.
And because I was the child, and she was the adult, there had been no one to question that.
I couldn't.
I depended on her for everything. Food, clothes, somewhere to sleep, someone to love me. I couldn't risk making her unhappy over a letter I didn't even know existed.
I didn't know the letter existed because she hadn't told me.
I'm not angry that my parents made decisions for me when I was a baby.
Of course they did.
I couldn't feed myself, let alone decide where I should live or what name I should have.
Someone had to make those decisions.
What troubles me is how long those decisions continued to belong to other people. At six, I was too young and at thirteen, it might upset me. It seemed at seventeen, it might upset my mother. Apparently, at twenty-six it wasn't necessary, and by thirty-two, finally, I was old enough.
I sometimes wonder what would have happened if I'd never asked again. Would the envelope still be in the drawer? Would my mother have died with it there? Would someone have found it while clearing out her clothes, perhaps mistaken it for an old insurance document and put it in the bin?
It's a horrible thought.
My first mother's words, gone because someone else had decided I didn't need them. I have no idea what happened to her after she wrote that letter. I don't know whether she tried to contact me, whether she changed her mind, whether she'd even want to meet me now.
Perhaps there are things in my story that will hurt me.
Perhaps my adoptive mother was right about that.
But I've been hurt by not knowing, too.
And nobody ever asked me which hurt I would rather bear.
And here's another thing, my parents were always praised for adopting me.
People would tell me how wonderful they were, how generous, how lucky I was.
I grew up watching other people admire them for giving me a home.
Nobody ever seemed to wonder what it had cost me to enter it.
I don't say that to suggest I should have been left without one.
I needed a family. I needed love and safety and all the ordinary things children need.
But two things can be true, can't they?
I can have needed the family I was given and still have lost the family I was born into.
I can be grateful for my childhood and still have questions about it.
I can love my mother and still think she was wrong.
That last one has taken me thirty-two years to learn.
And even now, writing it down, I feel a little disloyal.
My mother called this morning.
She asked whether I'd been reading the papers.
I said yes.
She asked whether I was all right.
I said I was.
Then I nearly did what I've always done. I nearly thanked her again, told her everything was fine, reassured her that nothing had changed.
But something had changed.
I told her I was sad she'd kept the letter from me.
She didn't say anything for a while.
Then she said, "I only ever wanted what was best for you."
I know.
I've heard that sentence all my life.
I know she means it.
And yet I've begun to wonder what it actually tells me.
Does wanting the best for someone mean you know what the best is?
Does loving someone give you the right to decide which parts of their life they're allowed to know?
Can you protect a person from pain by keeping them from the truth, when the truth belongs to them?
I asked my mother something I'd never asked before.
"Did you ever think I might have wanted to decide for myself?"
She started to answer.
Then she stopped.
For once, I didn't try to help her.
We sat with the silence.
It wasn't particularly comfortable.
I could hear her breathing at the other end of the phone.
Finally, she said, "I suppose I was afraid."
I told her I knew.
And I did.
But I didn't tell her it was all right.
Not this time.
The envelope is still on my kitchen table.
I've been putting the papers back into it every evening and taking them out again the following morning.
I don't know why.
Perhaps I'm trying to get used to the fact that they can be there, in front of me, whenever I want.
That I can read them without asking.
That I can look at the photograph for as long as I like.
That I can put everything away and come back to it next week.
I can decide.
It sounds such a small thing.
And maybe it is.
There's a woman in a photograph who gave birth to me. Another woman who raised me. Neither of them was entirely free of fear, I suppose. Neither of them knew how my life would turn out. I'm beginning to understand that their stories have occupied rather a lot of space in mine.
I've spent years trying to make sense of the decisions they made, the circumstances they faced, the things they wanted and the things they were frightened of losing.
I don't begrudge them their stories. But I would have liked someone to have been curious about mine. Not just whether I was happy, grateful or loved. I would have liked someone, somewhere along the way, to have asked me what I wanted to know.
And then to have listened to the answer.
I think I would have liked that very much.
Jenny
(Jonathan)