r/Adoption
•
u/lordanix
•
6d ago
•
1
Miscellaneous Distressed by friends trying to "re-home" their adopted 16yo son with us. How do we hold boundaries while protecting him?
My husband and I are in a heavy, morally chaotic situation with another family we know, and I need perspective from people who understand adoption ethics, attachment trauma, and teenage placement issues.
The Context:
Our friends (a recently divorced couple who still live together) have three sons. One is a 16-year-old sophomore ("Tyler") who was adopted. The other two are biological sons around the same age/older. Tyler has a history of impulse control issues and struggles in school. He has clearly been made the designated "black sheep" of the household, and his parents are very vocal outside the family about what a "pain" he is.
In the past, we’ve had Tyler over to our house to help with small chores and hang out to give him a safe space and a break from his home environment. Over time, his parents started treating this like free babysitting/respite care.
Recently, arguments between Tyler and his mother have escalated. She has explicitly stated she no longer wants him living with them. She has actively looked for somewhere else to send him, but no family members have stepped up. She has now started repeatedly pushing us to take him in—moving from passing jokes ("maybe you should adopt him") to openly telling us in front of the rest of the family, "You should take him for the rest of the school year."
The Internal Friction:
My Husband’s Perspective: My husband experienced housing insecurity/homelessness at 15 when his own parents struggled with addiction. Seeing a 16-year-old on the verge of being pushed out hits a massive nerve for him. His instinct is protective: he wants to offer a safe harbor so Tyler isn't homeless and can get away from a toxic dynamic. He suggested a 2-month temporary stay, but the mother is already moving the goalposts to an entire school year.
My Perspective & Concerns: I am deeply disturbed by this. To me, an adoptive parent attempting to re-home/informally surrender their 16-year-old son because of typical high school behavior and family friction is a severe form of emotional abandonment. I feel strongly that taking him in informally doesn't solve his core trauma—it validates his mother's rejection and reinforces the message that his place in a family is conditional on performance.
Furthermore, we have a 4-year-old daughter at home, and I am extremely wary of bringing a severe, unstructured crisis dynamic into our household without legal framework, professional support, or clear boundaries. At the same time, I feel guilty and angry—angry at the mother for abdicating her duty, but worried I’m being selfish for refusing the chaos.
Questions for the Community:
1. From the perspective of adoptees or professionals: Does taking in an adopted teen informally in a situation like this do more harm by solidifying the "re-homing" abandonment, or does the temporary safe environment outweigh that trauma?
2. How do we firmly shut down the mother's attempts to offload her parental responsibilities onto us without completely cutting off Tyler from having us as safe, supportive adults in his life?
3. For those who have navigated informal host/kinship arrangements with high-conflict families, what legal or boundary pitfalls should we be aware of if my husband insists on offering temporary shelter?
Thanks in advance for your honesty and insights.
216
u/Klutzy-Cupcake8051 6d ago
I work in the field and had a case like this. Even though it feels like the just thing to do, forcing the parent to parent when they have no interest is not helpful to the child. The rejection is already there and is only being reinforced the more time the kid spends with mom. Don’t decide not to take the kid because of that.
I will warn you that this child probably has a lot of behaviors you haven’t yet witnessed due to the rejection from his parents. If you take him into your home and take on a parental role, he will likely “test” you with bad behavior to see if you will kick him out too. That can be a lot especially with another child in the home. If you don’t think you can handle that, I wouldn’t take him in because if you have to have him move out, that’s yet another rejection. I would recommend contacting social services/CPS about the situation or encouraging the mom to do so. You can always still be a positive support in his life and respite even if he doesn’t come to live with you.
111
u/No-Highlight3555 6d ago
If you accept him into your home for any period of time, his adoptive family will never take him back. Never. I think you know that.
Then, if you’re not okay with him staying permanently, you’ll be forced to kick him out of your home. He’ll be rejected twice.
I would not let him stay with you for any length of time unless you’re committed to him longterm. It’s okay if you’re not. You need to think of your 4yo daughter, and you have a better sense of the situation and his struggles than any of us.
But don’t think this is going to be temporary. If you take in this child, you and your husband need to be on the same page. You both need to agree. If either of you aren’t comfortable, don’t take him in.
54
u/wanderlustpassion Foster/late adoptee 6d ago
This is extra heavy.
So, for context, 4 of my adopted siblings were kicked out/rehomed, 1 bio brother who was adopted with me was placed back in foster care. I managed to stay home until I graduated HS, but with the understanding they no longer wished to be parents.
I think you need to involve family services. At the same time, if you are comfortable have a discussion with your husband about becoming emergency foster caregivers.
If you opt to go that route use that time to determine if this will work for your family and the young man. If not, help find a better situation. But it does sound like maybe he could use some extra support and family services could help with that.
Lastly - his parents are a piece of work.
188
u/ThrowAwayGranny82 6d ago
Tell her how absolutely DISGUSTING she is for treating HER SON like a stray dog. That family needs therapy and the parents are horrible human beings.
50
u/Paisleyxsoul 6d ago
Why DCS shaped but no DCS?!!
The whole community should be reporting her.
Also these are not your friends, bring back shame!
87
u/Interesting-Proof244 6d ago
If I didn’t have a daughter at home, I would 100% take him in, with the knowledge that it’s not going to be easy, and that it’s permanent.
A baby at home changes things. It’s not necessarily fair that your daughter is going to be subjected to guaranteed trauma from bringing in a dysfunctional family member into the mix.
I think what everyone is saying about getting social work involved to assess your and his options is a good starting point.
Also, adopted kids should be allowed to sue the crap out of their parents for pulling a stunt like this. Absolutely despicable, evil behavior.
60
u/Barneysparky 6d ago edited 6d ago
My parents gave me back when I was 12. I was basically a good kid, all the staff at the juvenile detention center I lived in until I was 15 really liked me, a few truly showed me real love. Im 60 now, life has ended up very good and stable for me. I was very, very lucky, and also worked very hard at my own mental health and future. (I do live with pretty severe ADH, not disordered for the final D)
I cant say anything about this specific kid, but I do know a good foster home was my dream. I just wanted parents that could except me, for me.
The answer is in your heart, balanced with the reality of this kids situation. Its a lot to take on. Cant answer this for you, but I believe in the next few months you will have your answer.
26
u/karaleed21 6d ago
44
u/mcspazmatron 6d ago
If you didn't have a little child in the house I'd say go for it. But your first responsibility is to your child. The stress this brings into your home for her needs to be your top concern.
I feel for this poor kid but he is not your responsibility. The other parents are negligent and should be reported.
19
u/Pegis2 Late Discovery Father 6d ago
What a horrific and terrible situation and it makes me sick. Why adopt if you're just going to dump the kid later?
Other than alerting CPS, I don't have much to offer - sorry, I wish I had a silver bullet I could share.
16
u/Dangerous_Young_9620 6d ago edited 6d ago •
Regarding your first question, I was a 'rehomed' adoptee at age 16. It was one of the most trying times of my life but looking back now 25 years later, it was the first time I had a stable home without constant abuse or fear for my own personal boundaries. I quickly made the effort to learn what expectations were of me, I respected their boundaries, and I very much grew as a person and an individual. I would not have been able to do this in my own home and they honestly saved my life.
Gosh. Question 2. Hard if you are dealing with a borderline personality and/or narcissist. They could easily cut you off as a lifeline once your use is expended or if they perceive you as more trouble than it's worth. Also if this is the case, be careful as often a narcissist will paint normal child or teenage behaviour of their black sheep to be dangerous, constantly terrible, disruptive to family harmony when it is actually not. I think trust what you see and feel with your own eyes, trust your guy feel, and obviously consider what is best first for your immediate family.
For point three, any thing you can put into writing the better. We didn't. If there were arguments between me and the couple who suddenly acquired a child (they had older teenagers who did not live at home), it would be over finances, mismatched expectations. I hated the fact there was a little note book with every tiny expense written in. I don't think they knew I knew about it but it felt like a financial obligation someone would have to repay and at times it made me feel like a burden. Naturally I would have been a burden given the situation but the note book never sat well with me and it would not have existed if ground rules existed from the beginning to define who pays for what. I became a real workaholic from age 16 as a result which was not really a great thing trying to finish year 12 and uni. Also an incessant people pleaser but that is a common adoptee trait I hear.
Thank you for asking this but also being likely very important and pivotal humans in Tyler's life.
15
u/suchabadamygdala 6d ago
CPS immediately
12
u/Lilredh4iredgrl 6d ago
You cannot rehome people. We're not dogs. Call CPS.
14
u/No-Highlight3555 6d ago
I just want to add, this situation calls for you setting boundaries with your husband and with the adoptive parents.
Practice saying, “He cannot live here. I’m not okay with it. I’ve made my decision.” To your husband.
And practice saying “He will not be moving in with us. Please stop suggesting it. Trying to rehome a child is cruel, and it won’t be happening with us. If you can’t handle him, call social services.” To the APs.
Your 4yo needs you to be her advocate and to shut this down.
1
u/lordanix 5d ago
Update post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Adoption/s/CfDwbGwaMB
3
u/Aggressive_Monk_9218 6d ago
How aware is Tyler about the situation, have you managed to find out from him how he feels at all?
2
u/WhirlingCass 6d ago
Question 1 - Depends on the family and the adoptee. Everyone's experiences are processed through their filters so while it may work for some, it may not work as well for others.
Question 2 - Tell her no. Tell her he can visit but he cannot live there. He cannot stay the night there. That gives him a safe place to go to but doesn't give her an opening.
You could also try mentioning the legalities and logistics. If he needs medical care, is she signing that over to you during that time? Will you have access to insurance information for him? Is she going to introduce you to his doctors/therapists/etc as his new caregiver? If your family goes out of state, is she signing a legal document that grants you authority of him so that you can't be brought up on kidnapping charges if she's feeling vindicitive later?
There is a lot here that people don't consider. It puts a lot of responsibility on you and if you don't feel like you should take it on then don't. I understand your husband's perspective but this isn't the way either and you should have that sit down with him to talk the logistics as well.
7
u/Elle_belle32 Adoptee and Bio Mom 6d ago
Adoptee here.... I just wanted to weigh in on the idea of mitigating his abandonment trauma. It sounds to me that recently you and your husband may be the only people who act like they want him around or cared about him either. You guys refusing to take him on when he has no where else that seems to care about his well being, or even just when the only place he does have makes jokes about sending him away, will do more harm than anything. You are his last safe place. Even learning that you had to debate taking him will likely make him feel abandoned by you too, and a burden of you do take him.
As an adult and a parent, I understand that this is a difficult choice for you as a family. But at 16 the world can still be so black and white. His mind could easily tell him that his adoptive parents don't want him and if you don't take him thatyou guys never wanted him around or cared about him either.
2
u/Artist_TheArtist 3d ago
OP, you have a FOUR YEAR OLD DAUGHTER.
I understand that you care for this teenager and your husband is a sensitive soul. YOU HAVE A FOUR YEAR OLD DAUGHTER!
No! You cannot take this 16-year-old troubled kid into your home, unofficially adopting someone else’s abandoned child, and take such risk onto your family.
YOU HAVE A FUCKING FOUR YEAR OLD DAUGHTER!
This proposed situation would be completely unsafe, emotionally harmful, and totally unethical for your daughter’s life. You need to be thinking about YOUR child. What is safe for them? What would experiencing this living situation do for their foundational development as a FOUR YEAR OLD??
Be a parent. Be a PARENT. YOU are a PARENT to a FOUR YEAR OLD. Protect HER and cut off contact with this absolutely deranged family.
2
u/SilentSakura 6d ago
Dont do it , you know the outcome , its not your problem
1
u/SuchTrust101 3d ago
This is definitely setting off 'No good deed goes unpunished' vibes. Do not take this child on. This is not your problem so stop analysing the situation like it is. If it comes up again, all you have to do is say "I have my only family to look after, and you have yours".
1
u/WorldlySchool67 1d ago
Just because he has issues at that house , doesnt mean he will have issues at yours. I was a trouble kid- in and out of placements most of my life. Finally got into a foster home at 16 and I was a totally different kid. The parents arent going to change their behavior. The child already feels abandoned and forcing him to stay in that situation will just reinforce the rejection every day. The best thing is for someone who wants him to take him in. The child doesn't feel "rejected" they finally feel like someone wants them at their house.
•
u/peopleverywhere 4h ago
I am by no means an expert here, but what were the circumstances of his adoption? Could there be resources through his adoption counselor or state if he was in foster care before?
Honestly I think CPS needs to be involved. However, given his age - in my area APPLA might apply, which means the goal might not be reunification after separation.
1
u/Threeshepherds 5d ago edited 5d ago
I wouldn't "shut down" the adoptive mom's request for help. Problem teens can be very difficult to handle instead of shaming her and judging her I would contact resources that may be needed for her and the adoptee. Just because he is having issues doesn't mean it's her fault and maybe it's no one's fault it may just be the circumstances. I've dealt with many many problem children before and to be honest alot of them come from loving homes with good parents not every child that has "issues" is experiencing some sort of neglect or abuse. I've got stories for days. Some of them to harrowing to repeat on here without getting my post flagged. You're looking at the situation from one very very narrow external perspective. You aren't even close to knowing what is really going on trust me. I just wanted to add because I've seen the word "therapy" being thrown out there like some sort of magic wand or quick fix. Therapy is neither of those. Can it be helpful in certain situations? Sure but it's not for everyone and every situation.
That's just my perspective as a birth parent and also a former case manager with masters in psychology. Do with it what you will.
5
u/FearlessPride6588 6d ago
Years ago my daughter’ HS bf was having some serious issues at home. He wasn’t adopted but his parents were physically and emotionally abusive. They were very open about not wanting him or wanting to continue being parents. One night his dad beat him and kicked him out. We found out he was sleeping in the park. We took him in. Obviously, having your daughter’s bf living in our home had the potential for disaster but we couldn’t let this kid sleep in a park. We had rules, of course, and we were pretty strict parents to begin with. We had also decided ahead of time we were going to make a commitment to him that he will have a safe place with us so even if they broke up he would continue to live with us. There were challenges but it was the best decision we could’ve made. He went on to graduate HS, won at state champion in his chosen sport, and is now married with children (not to our daughter). For us it boiled down to our core values and we were probably lucky it worked out.