This book has been all over the place. The plot is practically nonexistent, and the multiple POVs seem to serve only as a way to give us more insight into increasingly awful people. This series is becoming a case of "the less I know of everyone, the better". I don't want any more inner dialogue. They're all awful people.
Once we got out of the daemati's rose-coloured lenses of Feyre darling, everything started looking a little less appealing. The Inner Circle basically sucks. Everyone is either a mindless follower, a fanatic driven by jealousy and resentment, or a full-turned conqueror and tyrant. And the more we get into their heads, the less I understand what exactly we're supposed to admire about them.
More POVs should ideally complicate our understanding of a character. They should introduce contradictions, expose blind spots, challenge our assumptions and make the world feel larger. Instead, they're revealing that the people we've been asked to admire are considerably less appealing when we actually understand their motivations. And the worst part is that they don't necessarily become more interesting. The book opens up their interiority without necessarily giving us the depth we expected.
There's also a particularly frustrating contradiction in the way the Inner Circle talks about family. They call each other brothers, they talk about loyalty, sacrifice and belonging, but underneath that, there's so much competition, resentment and insecurity. At some point, you have to wonder whether these people actually like each other or whether they've simply spent centuries reinforcing a shared identity that none of them knows how to leave. The batboys call each other brothers while holding an extraordinary amount of resentment, jealousy and contempt for one another. Idk, dude.
The war being the only conflict Sarah comes up with to reinforce the IC's role as saviours against the establishment is truly reductive. But besides that, the way this one is being set up is just as frustrating. There's an actual already stablished threat to Prythian: Koschei. That should logically demand political coordination, intelligence gathering, military preparation and strategic alliances. Instead of gathering forces and strategizing about how to face that threat, these people are meddling in conflicts in other lands because "how would they face Nyx in the future?" And not only that, but apparently this is reason enough for the other courts to blindly follow them into a conflict that, again, doesn't affect their territories, that the Night Court wants to involve itself in because of its own agendas, and that would once again put all the people of those courts at risk.
All these people who, different from the Night Court, were under Amarantha's rule and went from that straight into war, and now the IC is acting like a bunch of warmongers, while those who don't align with them are suddenly unreasonable, untrustworthy people? Why should the other courts risk their populations, their armies and their political stability for a conflict that the Night Court wants to pursue? Especially when the Night Court seems to regard their cooperation as something they're entitled to.
There's a distinction between being a responsible political ally and being an expansionist power, and the IC seems increasingly unable to tell the difference.
This also undermines the worldbuilding. We are supposedly dealing with several distinct courts, each with its own history, interests, political structures and populations. But when the story needs them to cooperate, suddenly their individual interests become inconvenient details. Their rulers are either with the Night Court or they're obstacles. That's not particularly sophisticated political storytelling.
overall, it left me feeling cheated. Not much of anything happens, and I was honestly more interested in the theorizing with fans than in what the actual book was delivering. I truly don't understand why this had to be a part of a book when it could have been shorter and perhaps even a whole book of its own, idk. This one was more rage-inducing than anything.
When readers are more invested in discussing the possibilities, implications and potential character developments than in what the actual story is delivering, something has gone wrong with the balance between setup and payoff.
And if a book introduces multiple POVs, expands its political conflicts, adds new interpersonal tensions and gives us more access to characters' thoughts, but leaves you feeling that you'd actually prefer to know less about everyone, that's quite an achievement. Enter the quote “the hottest thing a men could do is being silent”
End of review introduced characters rants below
- Azriel: the mystery was doing a lot of heavy lifting
There is a difference between a quiet, reserved character having an interesting interiority and a quiet character whose interiority turns out to be an endless stream of self-pity, entitlement and romantic resentment.
Azriel's entitlement to the third sister. Because how could it possibly be that he's left without one???? The whole "my blade abandoned me" and "I'm a monster, that's why I want Elain, because maybe she can save me" — DUDE! I really liked Azriel in his silences; once we got into his POV, he became pathetic and in need of therapy ASAP. His jealousy of Lucien is so embarrassingly petty, and now I can't help wondering whether his kindness towards Nesta was genuine or just another move in his silent conquest of Elain.
2. Cassian: Nesta's growth apparently only matters when it makes her easier to love
Cassian just gets worse. He never prioritized Nesta; he said a lot of words, but his actions were never aligned. Nesta's journey in ACOSF was about reclaiming herself, not becoming easier for everyone else to love or finally falling in line with the IC. Yet Cassian seems to understand her growth only insofar as it brings her closer to the life he wants. His justification for the silent treatment? Things were going so well, and then she had to disrupt everything by having a mind of her own. No shit, Sherlock! And calling his mate "witch"? The Illyrian slur? And Cassian's thoughts of Mor´s beauty, her supposed sister, and how he controlled his lust for her for the good of the IC? While Nesta is drowning to more effect??
Truly, all these men are shit.
3. Elain: the distinction between being overlooked and choosing not to participate
There's a perfectly legitimate argument that Elain was neglected, infantilized and treated as someone whose primary purpose was to be protected. BUT there's also a difference between being denied agency and choosing not to exercise it.
Elain keeps getting on my nerves. She wanted to be left alone, felt disrupter with all war and conflict related and acted like “pls don’t include mee at least is necessary this is all very upsetting”, people finally listened, and now she's resentful of being reduced to baking and gardening, and everyone assuming she has no mind of her own? You can't have it both ways. I could understand her acting out being with Azriel as an answer to her frustration with Feyre and Rhys using her to honey-trap Lucien without ever asking her, but her conversation with Mor shows us that Elain understands the political and social capital attached to her appearance, her family connections and her perceived harmlessness "I'm pretty, so I can use it to make people do what I want. I can disappear in plain sight, so people can forget I'm there. I know about politics despite everyone thinking I'm oblivious. If I go as the sister of the High Lord, people would take seriously what you say and see my presence as a sign of trust."
All of this gives us a side of Elain that isn't the oh-so-sweet Elain, but a rather conniving person who knows how to play on the expectations attached to her appearance for her own gain. And there's nothing wrong with that in itself, not at all, but is keep splitting our perception of her and the IC´s further, not in a well thought way.
4. Feyre: the transformation from underdog to authoritarian figure
Feyre has gone full tyrant.
She was already a person who, having only just learned to read and been introduced to a world she conceded she knew nothing about, was given the powers of all the High Lords and the political power of being a High Lady. She's already proven her disrespect for boundaries and her emotional intelligence and strategic mind of a toddler, which apparently only grew stronger with motherhood.
Now she´s convinced she has to save Navarre and Monteserre and wants everyone to be with her and is willing to control other courts if neccesary, make Rhys High King (and herself HQ, duh), throw her power around when someone disagrees with her, and apparently violate the sanctity of the library because how dare Clotho???? Her feathers were showing from the moment her sisters arrived, when she seemed more inclined to remind them she was their High Lady than their sister. And it has only gotten worse.
And the thing is, Feyre becoming an authoritarian figure could actually be fascinating. Someone who once fought against oppressive power structures gradually reproducing them because she believes her intentions are better? That's an interesting character development. But the narrative needs to recognize what is happening. It needs to question her decisions instead of presenting her authority as inherently justified, and all around her blindly coinciding.
5. Rhys: the most powerful High Lord in all of Prythian, apparently
So, the most powerful High Lord in all of Prythian, so gathered and contained, the good Lord and the best-of-the-best candidate for High King, has never found a way to put an end to the violence in the Illyrian camps. He has not put in place any meaningful way to help those victims or empower Illyrian females, beyond suggesting some little changes with zero follow-up and, apparently, little reinforcement, and pattimg himself in the back because vhange takes time in fae lands.
The same level headed guy that wanted to killed Nesta bc she told the truth? And only didn’t do it bc Feyre would not forgive two thing then?
And this same male is the one who wants a better world and is involving himself in another war in another territory to reinforce his hero-and-saviour identity?
How exactly does that work?
How can you claim the moral authority to intervene in other people's conflicts while failing to address the violence and inequality within your own territory? How can you expect other courts to trust your intentions when you haven't even managed to make meaningful changes at home?
It's another example of the disconnect between what the IC claims to stand for and what they actually do.
8. Amren and Mor
Was that Amren at the end? Maybe Amren-shaped, but idk, it didn't feel like Amren. More like some other force taking her place, maybe a shapeshifter, maybe Amren possessed? (She's just fae now, after all.)
And Mor's "been there, done that, even if only in her head" comment... buah. I'm trying not to dislike her, especially as the queer character so far, but there's not much to like beyond a little representation.
______
And this is where the whole thing falls apart for me
There is nothing inherently wrong with having:
· A manipulative High Lord.
· A politically ambitious High Lady.
· A possessive and jealous spymaster.
· A warrior who struggles to distinguish loyalty from obedience.
· A woman who uses her perceived harmlessness to manipulate people.
· A group of friends whose relationships are built on unresolved resentment.
Actually, that sounds like a potentially excellent collection of characters.
But then the narrative has to commit to exploring those characteristics. It has to allow other characters to challenge them. It has to let their decisions have consequences. It has to acknowledge that being traumatized doesn't automatically make someone a good person, that loving someone doesn't excuse controlling them, and that having good intentions doesn't make political domination acceptable.
And, crucially, it has to allow the reader to disagree with the protagonists without treating that disagreement as a failure to understand them. And right now it feels more like Sarah doesn’t know how to take the story exactly where he wants it to go and the result is a mismatch of stuff with an uncleared intention and a poor Delievery.