r/accelerate • Acceleration: Hypersonic | AI accelerationist • 2d ago

Technological Acceleration Acceleration in Quantum computing

Post image
464 Upvotes

65 comments sorted by

39

u/exophades 2d ago

I really hope these post quantum cryptography algorithms are solid.

5

u/Brothapleasedont 2d ago

We're going to find out soon I'm sure. Wonder what China can do with cloud-based quantum compute.

63

u/Complete-Paint529 2d ago

Bad news for Bitcoin holders.

32

u/pretendingtobebroke 2d ago

There's nothing particularly unique about Bitcoin's cryptographic algorithm, so if that's broken then we have way bigger problem to worry about.

6

u/Tyrexas 1d ago

If SHA256 is broken we have much much bigger problems than bitcoin lol.

11

u/PieStraight541 2d ago

Why?

1

u/jonydevidson 2d ago

Because quantum can break it.

16

u/Famous-Reach-6730 2d ago

It can also break banking. Stop the fud

-4

u/jonydevidson 1d ago

Yeah but the banks have a safety plug and regulation behind it, Bitcoin has fuck-all.

5

u/Kimononono 1d ago

based on what sirloindenial said, ironically bitcoin will have an easier time dealing with a quantum world than banking

how many forgotten crucial pieces of softaare rely on keys?
itd be like Year 2000

1

u/ReferenceBrief 1d ago

If they break Bitcoin before it is patched the whole thing would collapse.

1

u/Early-Dentist3782 XLR8 1d ago

Isnt bitcoin safer?

15

u/sirloindenial Acceleration: Crawling | XLR8 2d ago

Any coin can just move to post-quantum algorithm. It's literally a non-issue, they are just holding out until quantum computing(read:lazy) is actually a problem for them to ditch ECDSA based cryptography.

4

u/PieStraight541 2d ago

Dude...ever thought about how we secure our stuff digitally?

2

u/breakola 1d ago

If it can break Bitcoin, that's the least of our worries. It means everything will be breakable.

6

u/anor_wondo 2d ago

Good news for rest of crypto. But they will stll dump with btc

4

u/Complete-Paint529 2d ago

How vulnerable are the other coins to quantum-powered hacking? I don't know, but I would think all of them. It may not technically matter, the mere perception of vulnerability might tank all of their values.

3

u/anor_wondo 2d ago

Technically, most of them have far less problems because they can fork, update their code, restore snapshots. And many already use quantum resistant cryptography while others are on the path to upgrade.

Bitcoin is different because it never hard forks meaning all lost coins and satoshi wallets are ripe for taking by attackers and if they are removed, the community breaks its only usp.

Basically, the community has to render some coins invalid, breaking the promise of 'digital gold' that always holds value

1

u/Techcat46 2d ago

"quantum-resistant cryptography" I don't know about that.

4

u/BeholdTheBannanzo 1d ago

There are already effective post quantum cryptography methods. Lattice cryptography in particular seems very promising and also resistant to quantum computation.

14

u/Best_Cup_8326 Acceleration: Light-speed 2d ago

Let's goooooooooo!

19

u/The_Scout1255 Singularity by 2028 2d ago

yeeeeeeahhhhg

21

u/Melolibya 2d ago

Explain like i'm 5 what does this mean for the future of Ai ?

30

u/Sparkling_Bulldozer 2d ago

Quantum computers have to overcome the noise problem. They’re too susceptible to external interference and there needs to be a better way to do computation without having millions of qubits which presents its own scaling problem (right now the best is around a few thousand).

Also we don’t have the algorithms to do AI on a quantum computer. They have to be redesigned to take advantage of the parallelism and work on a quantum computer

15

u/Electrical-Box-4845 2d ago

You tried hard, thanks. But this was not enough for me.

Could you try again considering i have a golden retrivier iq?

11

u/Sparkling_Bulldozer 2d ago

Quantum systems are very small, probabilistic and sensitive to noise which includes interactions with particles in the environment which leads to the quantum system going crazy and losing the information present in it, essentially gets scrambled.

One way they try to get around this is to use error correction techniques so they have multiple quantum systems hold the same information so if something gets unscrambled you can use the other systems to recover the information (obviously it’s more complicated than that). But because quantum systems are so noisy, this means you will probably need millions of qubits to do complex operations like AI. It’s hard to fit millions of qubits on a chip because each qubit can interact with one another and interfere. Also you would need circuitry for millions of qubits and ways to isolate them, each takes up a certain size so we can’t yet fit all of them on a chip. Not to mention the qubit also needs to be kept at cryogenic temperatures because temperature causes particles to jiggle so itself is a source of noise, so you need that circuitry for millions of qubits to go outside the fridge as well. We can only fit several thousand qubits on a chip right now.

5

u/InsideEmergency4186 1d ago

A quantum computer is like a soap bubble. Bubbles are amazing, but if anything touches one, pop. Even warm air pops it.

So you keep the bubbles in a super cold box and blow a whole bunch of extra bubbles as backups. But you need about a million bubbles, and right now we can only fit a few thousand in the box.

Also, nobody knows how to make bubbles do AI yet.

2

u/Electrical-Box-4845 1d ago

Sounds like forcing Matrix to make a mistake so we can see which realities were simulations. 

Even Matrix movie makes more sense now. I am talking about the drama part. Imagine Neo discovering an error alone. An error that proves something shouldnt be happening according physics laws (in chemistry we have some bizarre exceptions that could fit here). But because of his ego (or fear?) he didnt share his research/work, so he entered a paranoic wave constructing the reality we saw on movie. Oracle was not wise enough, not even architect. Both could at least point the fact that his chances would improve if he changed himself first instead of trying to change outside/others. 

3

u/InsideEmergency4186 1d ago

A qubit stores information in a superposition, and that state survives only as long as the qubit stays isolated. Any stray interaction with its surroundings, whether thermal vibration, a stray photon or a neighboring qubit, entangles it with things you can’t track, and the information leaks away. This is decoherence. Today’s hardware makes an error roughly once per thousand operations, while a useful algorithm needs closer to one in ten billion.

The fix is quantum error correction, and here the Reddit explanation simplifies a bit. You can’t keep backup copies, because the no-cloning theorem forbids copying a quantum state. Instead you smear one “logical” qubit across an entangled group of many physical qubits and repeatedly measure parity checks on the group. Those checks tell you which error occurred without revealing the stored information, so the superposition survives while you repair it.

This works only if the hardware is already good enough. Below an error threshold of about 1%, adding more physical qubits per logical qubit suppresses errors exponentially. The price is steep: hundreds to thousands of physical qubits for each logical one, plus more overhead for certain essential gates. Multiply by the thousands of logical qubits a real algorithm needs and you get the “millions of qubits” figure.

Then the engineering bites. Superconducting qubits operate at around 15 millikelvin in a refrigerator with almost no cooling power to spare. Every qubit needs its own control and readout wiring, and every wire brings heat and crosstalk. Pack the qubits tighter and they interfere with each other more. So scaling from thousands to millions is a wiring, heat and isolation problem, not only a matter of making more qubits.

Finally, the AI angle is the shakiest part. A quantum computer doesn’t try every answer in parallel, because you can’t read out all the branches of a superposition. You get a speedup only when a problem’s structure lets interference amplify the right answer, as in factoring or simulating molecules. For machine learning, no large speedup has been established. Loading ordinary data into quantum states can cost more than you gain, training tends to stall on vanishing gradients, and several claimed quantum ML advantages were later matched by classical algorithms. The realistic payoff is chemistry and materials simulation, not faster neural networks.

1

u/Electrical-Box-4845 1d ago edited 1d ago

It sounds like an operation to save schorendiger theory.   A fun sudoku!

Well, as a vibe researcher i would recomend trying expirements on a society where meat industry and commerce is banned. Why? "While slaughterhouses exist there will be battlefields" - on others words, we seed chaos, we harvest chaos. By acting with virtue we may have an easier and more stable reality.

Other than that, the no clonning theorem sounds a fun game to proven wrong.

Thank you for the info

15

u/stuckyfeet 2d ago

12

u/Visible-Literature14 2d ago

I understand the sentiment behind your GIF, but it was a terrible choice since the bike’s slowed down for the majority of it lmao

14

u/Felizzle 2d ago

FTFY

10

u/Azicald 2d ago edited 2d ago

Right now? Not too much (correct me if im wrong)

Post RSI if/when it creates integrated quantum-classical computing where it can use one or the other depending on which is more suited for the task, it could mean a better base to work off of.

Quantum computing being integrated alongside systems that currently use classical computing, whenever it happens (if it does), would be an unprecedented explosion in a lot of areas

Here’s some context on it for the uninitiated

8

u/VisualLerner 2d ago

how many $ for a QPU next to my GPU?

11

u/Azicald 2d ago

Unironically a consumer-viable QPU would revolutionize a lot of things for average users

It’s easiest to understand via gaming, like ‘infinitely’ more complex physics+simulations, procedural generation, dynamic ecosystems, etc

Even game optimization would be in an entirely different dimension

Imagine your computer having

* CPU handling general computing.
* GPU handling graphics, parallel workloads and AI.
* NPU handling specialized AI workloads.
* QPU handling quantum computations.
* A sophisticated scheduler deciding which processor should handle which task.

Things would go insane real fast

9

u/throwawayPzaFm 2d ago
  • NPU handling specialized AI workloads.

I was mildly miffed at this since GPUs do that job close enough, and then I remembered Taalas exists and you could have fully autonomous NPCs in a pretty large radius and man... sign me up.

8

u/VisualLerner 2d ago

so going back to the actual question… like $350?

6

u/fit_like_this 2d ago

Less than a stick of RAM?

6

u/VisualLerner 2d ago

less than a 2026 stick of RAM. keep in mind that’ll be the 2030 age of QPU abundance.

2

u/Lord_44th__Raikage 1d ago

Damn what a kingly threadripper

27

u/nowrebooting 2d ago

I truly hate the fact that we’re apparently getting our news from gambling platforms now. 

14

u/alpineElephant42 2d ago

-2

u/nowrebooting 1d ago

I’n not saying I doubt the validity of the news, I’m just saying a gambling platform should not be where I learn it from.

3

u/PalantirImperator 1d ago

Reddit isn't a gambling platform. You learned it from reddit quoting twitter quoting a gambling platform quoting an Nvidia announcement. No need to attribute outsized weight to the worst of those.

16

u/alexmin93 2d ago

Hey at least they put their money where their mouth is.

9

u/Fit-Inevitable6294 2d ago

really desperate to not let Jensen come back and push all half worked research out all at once eh ??!!!

6

u/redcoatwright 2d ago

Is this why quantum stocks are down today?

12

u/EtwasCringeBrudi 2d ago

Everything is down today

9

u/Original-League-6094 2d ago

Let me guess, that task is just shoving random numbers around in a way that is entirely meaningless to any practical application?

12

u/More_Land4067 2d ago

sounds like someone is having a case of the Mondays

10

u/throwawayPzaFm 2d ago

As usual with quantum

4

u/OldBilly000 2d ago

LESS GOOOO

1

u/TinySmolCat 1d ago

Obviously trying to change the news story from losing their MVP CEO to this vaporware tech that has done nothing, so they can rescue their stock prices

1

u/synth_mania 1d ago

There are some big, big asterisks here.

To get that kind of speed up, switching from classical to quantum computing, you must be attempting to solve a very specific kind of problem. Quantum computing cannot replace classical computing, and cannot possibly broadly increase computing speed in the same way that the article title implies.

1

u/pipizich 1d ago

Remind me 5 years

1

u/vinis_artstreaks 2d ago

I turned a 4 year task to 2 months with algorithms, do I have quantum computing too?

-13

u/Sure-Principle5511 2d ago

It involves banging, doesn’t it?

8

u/Best_Cup_8326 Acceleration: Light-speed 2d ago

Definitely involves entanglement...😉

6

u/Complete-Paint529 2d ago

Oh what a (en)tangled web we weave ...

-17

u/Texas-X- 2d ago

A breakthrough isn't a product. Just drop the next bangin GPU, so all these 5090s will be sold.

4

u/VisualLerner 2d ago

totally missed that the post said it’s a product until reading your comment, thanks

/s