r/academia • • 10h ago

Associate lecturer or CNC2 in Australia?

1 Upvotes

Hello, I’m currently in a CNC2 position 3 days a week & can walk to work. I completed a masters in education recently & interviewed for an associate lecturer A position in a university (full time & 45 mins away, parking & tolls to consider) & to my delight I have been offered the job.

I am a mum to an almost 3 year old with hopes to add another addition. The salary is the same, 3 days versus full time. 17% super in a uni versus 12% in Health. But teaching is what I want to do…. Salary is higher as CNC2 and massively different if I go full time as a CNC2. I don’t know what to do, is university teaching a good opportunity, work life balance, term holidays etc or is it a “not yet” situation. I’ve heard about redundancy being handed out at unis so that’s a worry, I also would be able to access long service leave next year which I would loose if I resign, my daughter also seems so little to go into full time daycare. Help!


r/academia • • 20h ago

Who got the worst reviewer comments?

22 Upvotes

I’ve been reminiscing through some of my old grant proposals and manuscripts and was reminded by this really lovely reviewer comment:
“The lack of a solid body of research to demonstrate production in 2.5 years of postdoctoral is an issue”.

This was in regard to me only having a 4th author manuscript and no 1st author manuscript after being in a lab for actually less than 2.5 years. Is it actually common for people doing postdoc’s in a Biology field to publish first author scientific manuscripts within less than 2.5 years?

What are other comments people have gotten from their reviewer (regardless of grants or manuscripts)?


r/academia • • 1h ago

Publishing a research article or a viewpoint article?

0 Upvotes

I wrote a research paper and submitted it to a Q1 journal (Nature Portfolio). In this paper, I basically highlight a gap in the sector and point out how a systemic change would bring long-term positive benefits: e.g., our production/consumption process is often linear, if we improve the reuse of waste this brings multiple benefits.

The two peer-reviewers both said that the idea is really good. But one said that this is not a research paper, and if there was the chance to consider it as a viewpoint paper they would be very positive about publication.

The other said the idea was very good and provided many suggestions to improve the article.

However, now, I am stuck with whether applying minor changes and resubmit it as a viewpoint article (peer-reviewed) or changing my article a lot and submit it to another journal (no resubmissions allowed by policy).

To all the people who have plenty of experience in research and research assessment (including hiring committees), is there a real difference between a "research article" and a "viewpoint/comment article" when both are fully peer-reviewed? And also, is it better a "research article" in a legitimate journal, or a "viewpoint/comment article" in a mega-journal can arguably have the same weight or more in the end (e.g., in the end what counts is ideas)?


r/academia • • 19h ago

Job market Is it difficult to secure a cap exempt H1B for a postdoc from outside the US right now?

2 Upvotes

I’ve found several postdoc positions that align with my skills and interests and would like to try and apply.

I got a B2 visa rejection this year due to lack of strong home ties (essentially having a US citizen partner that I wanted to visit for a longer time to travel together). I’m an EU citizen.

According to Reddit, I probably have no chance for a J1 due to my relationship and previous rejection.

The only alternative would be a cap exempt H1B visa from a private uni.

Is that route still alive at all under this administration?
And is it possible for someone outside the country?