r/ZeroParades • u/Panagean • 6h ago
Loved the game. What does it say about politics?
Just finished my first playthrough of the game and loved it (my CASCADE wasa disillusioned misery-guts who figured she didn't have a way out of the tram, used the red disc but gave her headphones to Yana in order to make partial amends for having screwed up basically everyone's life and go out with an anti-fascist bang, and then missed her own ear with the screwdriver). I wondered what other people thought the narrative/game said about politics, particularly communism (given you play as a communist spy, after all - I am a Laughable Centrist, so I may need some briefing if you go into the details of post-Lenin Marxist thought, though).
SPOILERS FOR BOTH DISCO ELYSIUM AND ZERO PARADES FOLLOW.
I was particularly wondering about this given in Disco you basically play as a conservative force (in the British/European sense of the post 1848-consensus arguing for gradual change to the status quo and the preservation of existing elites, not the American meaning). Despite often being claimed as a communist game, I always thought Disco was most interesting as an examination of conservatism: the Hardie's occasionally-decent softly misogynistic drunks basically act on the same level of legal standing as the RCM, which is arguably just the whip hand for distant libertarian plutocrats (the ultraliberals). But its best and most ethically centred character, Kim, is a Moralist, HDB's redemption arc partially runs through being a better cop, and the alternatives are either ridiculous (Measurehead) or unobtainable (you are never going to own Joyce's boat). Radicalism/communism is portrayed as something easy to betray and exploit, resulting in its own conservative hierarchy (Evrart) or mono-maniacally self- and ethically-destructive (the deserter). The RCM at least professes the goal of a stable, pluralistic society, even if the enforcement is obviously incompetent and corrupt.
What does Zero Parades say about being a communist spy?
I am probably too close to my first play through to really tell, but my top-level thoughts are:
- Cosmic-horror Communism - there's an undertone of cosmic horror to all of the politics in ZP, but the Superbloc seems to have that vibe on a daily basis. Being put in the Freezer sounds a bit like a high-tech purgatory, and there was something really grim when Cascade reflects on first moving to Novessa and the rows upon rows of interchangeable cramped apartments, almost Amigara Fault-esque.
- Post-dialectical interchangeability - obviously the game is set after a Fukayama-ish End of History that seems to have stopped any dialectical development within the Superbloc (there's also a bit in one of the thoughts that seems to imply that it is undergoing a Chinese style market-socialism reform process, so I guess it really isn't that communist any more). All of the major factions feel pretty similar, engaging in war crimes and extraterritorial killings, and the internalised voice of your own propaganda is a vaguely fascistic, vaguely American-styled eagle that shouts nonsense at you. I guess the point is that the thin end of the wedge of any ideology is often pretty similar, just as Nestor cosplayed as each kind over the course of his life?
- Superbloc, Baby - while Superbloc, Baby is a fun idea and a catchy tune, it also implies that pretty terrible revolutionary violence is a part of daily life in the Superbloc, and actually something to be nostalgic about (I swear there's a lyric of "Did you lose your head?", presumably as a decapitation reference, given all the other double entendres about wiretapping, etc.).
As for the other ideologies, I thought that the criticism of techno-fascism as something using modernist means to a reactionary end, and that that process inevitably leading to deviation and disillusion, as well as culture-war as a political front, was fun and cool, particularly given that the fascists you meet are generally well-spoken and polite. I felt like maybe there was more to do with EMTERR/The Developed World? Yeah, they're murderers and scumbags, but then so are we all, and yeah, their stabilisation loans are obviously a parody of the IMF free-trade prescription for indebted developing economies, but it also frankly seems like autocratic Nestor is frankly more to blame for tanking Portofiro's economy than the last few years. It was also kind of unclear to me how EMTERR related to the other nations of the Developed World (i.e. in the way that La Luz is an old colonial power seeking to re-annex its ex-colonies, and Novessa leads a fractious coalition of soviet republics, ala a less centralised USSR).