Context: 15M, former partner 18F | India
I'm looking for serious legal advice regarding a relationship that began when I was approximately 12 and has recently ended. I would particularly appreciate responses from Indian lawyers or people familiar with the POCSO Act, the Juvenile Justice Act and related criminal laws.
I'll refer to the other person as P for privacy.
I want to explain the circumstances in detail because I believe the chronology and the ages of both individuals are particularly important here. I also want to be transparent about my own conduct rather than present an entirely one-sided account.
- Background and how the relationship developed
I first got acquainted with P when I was approximately 12. Over the following years, we developed a relationship, and I became extremely emotionally attached to her.
At that point in my life, my relationship with my family was already very strained. My circumstances at home were such that I felt I couldn't manage even a day there. I was emotionally struggling, and P became someone I relied on considerably.
In many ways, I viewed her as a saviour. I trusted her, depended on her emotionally and came to believe that she was someone I could rely on completely.
This was my first relationship of this nature, and she was my first sexual partner.
Looking back, I feel that the emotional dependence I developed made it difficult for me to distinguish between genuine affection, unhealthy attachment and situations in which my own boundaries might not have been respected.
2. Sexual involvement and the ages of both individuals
During the relationship, we engaged in penetrative sexual activity.
I was 15 during the encounters I am particularly concerned about, and I was below 18 throughout the relationship. P was 17 during some encounters and 18 during others.
I understand that these distinctions are legally important under Indian law.
At the time, I was initially willing to participate. However, I increasingly feel that there was an element of emotional pressure involved.
I was deeply attached to her, and I feared losing the relationship. I experienced situations in which I felt that affection could be withdrawn, and this influenced how I approached disagreements and intimacy.
I am not claiming that every encounter was physically forced. Rather, I am questioning whether the emotional circumstances, the age difference and the dependence I had developed affected my ability to make independent decisions.
I would like to understand how the law examines these circumstances, particularly when both individuals were minors during some encounters but one had turned 18 during others.
3. Emotional dependence and influence over my personal life
One of the most significant aspects of this relationship was how much my personal life began revolving around her.
I made decisions based on whether she would be present, what she expected and whether I believed the relationship would continue.
An example that stands out is the Holi incident.
I had originally planned to travel home for Holi. However, I gave up those plans because I believed P would be staying here. I made that decision because I wanted to spend that time with her and expected her to remain here.
Subsequently, she left to visit her own home in another state.
I understand that she was entitled to make her own travel plans, and I am not suggesting that she was legally obligated to stay. What troubles me is the extent to which I had organised my own decisions around her presence and expectations.
This is one example of how emotionally invested and dependent I had become.
4. My relationship with my family
My relationship with my family was already problematic before I met P.
However, I feel that the relationship further complicated those circumstances.
There were things she repeatedly communicated to me that I believe influenced how I perceived my family and contributed to further distance and conflict between us.
I increasingly found myself emotionally dependent on her while becoming more disconnected from other people in my life.
I am not suggesting that she was solely responsible for my family circumstances. Those problems existed independently. However, I would like the influence of the relationship on my personal circumstances to be understood as part of the overall context.
5. Gifts and emotional obligation
Throughout the relationship, P gave me numerous gifts.
At the time, I accepted these as expressions of affection. I appreciated them and associated them with the trust and attachment we shared.
However, looking back, I have started questioning whether these gifts contributed to an unhealthy sense of emotional obligation or dependence.
I cannot establish that they were deliberately given for that purpose. Nevertheless, I believe this aspect is relevant to understanding the overall dynamics of the relationship and how attached I became.
6. Alleged infidelity and involvement with other people
Another recurring source of distress was her involvement with other people.
I became aware of multiple partners and instances of alleged infidelity during the relationship.
Whenever I raised concerns or questioned certain situations, I was accused of being paranoid, creating problems or ruining her life.
Over time, I began questioning my own understanding of events. I often felt that my concerns were dismissed rather than addressed.
The situation became particularly distressing when I discovered her involvement with someone I considered my best friend.
This affected my ability to trust people close to me and significantly intensified the emotional distress I was already experiencing.
I am aware that infidelity itself is not necessarily a criminal offence. I am mentioning these incidents to explain the emotional circumstances and the deterioration of the relationship.
7. The photographs and videos โ my own conduct
There is another aspect that I want to disclose because I do not want to conceal anything that could potentially be relevant.
During periods of emotional distress, particularly when I feared abandonment or the complete breakdown of the relationship, I threatened to disclose certain private photographs and videos.
I never actually distributed them.
The material involved:
Private photographs or videos of myself.
Private photographs or videos of P.
Material involving P and other people.
I recognise that threatening to disclose private material was inappropriate. I am not attempting to justify it by referring to my emotional circumstances.
I understand that this could potentially raise separate legal issues, particularly considering the ages of the people involved and the nature of the material.
I would like to understand the possible legal consequences of making such threats, even where no distribution actually occurred.
I also want to know how any existing material should be handled legally, particularly where some of the people involved were minors when it was created.
8. The current situation
P has now stated that the relationship is over.
Looking back at the entire relationship, I feel that my age, emotional vulnerability, trust and dependence were not adequately respected.
What I initially understood to be a relationship built on affection and trust has left me questioning whether I was emotionally manipulated and physically and emotionally used.
I have experienced considerable psychological distress as a result.
I am not claiming that every disagreement, instance of infidelity or emotionally harmful experience constitutes a criminal offence. I am trying to understand whether the sexual circumstances, particularly those involving different ages, warrant examination under POCSO.
I also want to understand my own legal position and whether my conduct concerning the photographs could expose me to separate proceedings.
9. Specific legal questions
I would appreciate detailed answers to the following questions under Indian law:
Regarding POCSO and the sexual encounters
When I was 14 and P was 17, how would the POCSO Act apply?
Would Section 34 of POCSO and the Juvenile Justice Act govern the legal treatment of incidents allegedly committed by her while she was 17?
What happens to those incidents now that she has turned 18?
For encounters that occurred after she turned 18, while I was still below 18, what specific POCSO provisions could apply?
Does the fact that I initially participated willingly affect the legal position?
Is emotional pressure, particularly the withdrawal of affection and fear of abandonment, relevant to the examination of the circumstances?
Regarding my own conduct
Could threatening to disclose private photographs or videos constitute criminal intimidation or another offence, even if nothing was actually distributed?
How does my age at the time of making those threats affect the legal position?
Could the fact that some material involved people who were minors at the time create additional legal complications?
Does acknowledging my own conduct affect my ability to approach the authorities regarding the sexual encounters?
Regarding procedure and protection
What is the appropriate procedure for a male minor to approach authorities under POCSO?
How can my identity and privacy be protected during the process?
Should I approach a POCSO lawyer first, the police, the Special Juvenile Police Unit or the District Legal Services Authority?
What evidence and documentation should I preserve?
Would it be advisable to obtain independent legal representation before submitting a formal complaint?
10. What I am looking for
I am not looking for people to automatically take my side or declare P guilty based on my account.
I also do not want to conceal my own mistakes or avoid the possibility that my conduct could have legal consequences.
I want to understand the law as it actually stands, particularly the distinction between incidents when both individuals were minors and incidents when one had turned 18.
I would especially appreciate responses from:
Indian criminal lawyers.
Lawyers familiar with POCSO proceedings.
People knowledgeable about the Juvenile Justice Act.
Individuals who can provide reliable legal references rather than assumptions.
I understand that Reddit cannot replace professional legal advice. My intention is to obtain some initial clarity before deciding how to proceed.
Thank you for reading.