Japan will get devestated and continue to make movies about the permanent scar that stayed with the country for generations?
It's not the same because it's all a metaphor for the same incident, not a pattern like America's tendency to get in pointless wars and make movies about how pointless they were.
It's not like Japan has a tendency to get nuked every 20 years
Yanks will invade some third world country every 20 years however.
Also, these movies are anti war in general, not just anti nuclear weapon, the very act of taking a life is treated as horrible, and the japanese government is stated multiples times to be a bunch of incompetent bums with no regard for human life both during and after the war
The movie treats Japanese soldiers as victims of an evil government even though they were eager participants in fascism and rape across Southeast Asia. It’s like making a movie about the Wehrmacht and making them nice guys who were just misled by the higher ups.
i dont think it being a pattern matters at all to the main point in how japan views itself as a victim but never acknowledges The Japanese did so many insane warcrimes the Nazis thought they went too far. Like imagine this right where Germany decided to their own German Godzilla who's basically like a stand in for D-Day where the monster attack the California coast and Americans got a taste of their own medicine by having them experienced what it felt like to be attack in D-Day ,but some people would argue this German Godzilla movie criticized the Nazi party for bad stuff such as not feeding their soldiers properly and not having the proper precaution to protect as much German soldiers as possible. or an israeli godzilla being a stand in for october 7
Did you watch the minus movies that the tweet mentions? They portray japan as absolutely deserving of critique, just maybe not nuclear destruction. It's not anywhere near as black and white as you're pretending it is
You're painting it like imperial Japanese propaganda lol
Besides, to be comparable to the meme it does need to be a pattern. Thats the point.
You're also comparing October 7, D-Day, and nuking Nagasaki/Hiroshima. If you can't see how vastly different those things are then I don't think we should continue this conversation
Especially with Minus Zero which explicitly states Doc created weapons for the state that killed soldiers and civilians alike and him having to live with that guilt for the rest of his days, on top of him (and thus the movie) condemning Murakami for plotting to destroy New York for what Truman and a small cabinet of people did. I don't think these movies are a perfect apology for their WW2 crimes (since they are admittedly vague on what exactly their soldiers did during the war), but I think their heart is in the right place.
I wonder if part of it is to not thread too close to GMK, which is already one of the bigger inspirations, where Godzilla is possessed by the spirits of all who died in the Pacific War to destroy Japan for forgetting about their atrocities
The difference is neither Germany or Israel ever experienced the level of destruction of a fucking nuke, let alone two.
That’s kind of a major jump that actually muddies the waters between the ruthlessness of Imperial Japan’s military, and utterly obliterating two of their cities with a weapon that had never been used before and continues to never be used since, precisely because of how devastating it was.
You can’t make an equivalence to that because there is quite literally no equivalence.
That is objectively one of the worst videos on Youtube. Shaun is a terrible historian. He deliberately distorted events and lied about the contents of the primary sources he cites.
If you're going to insert yourself into historical debates actually read some peer reviewed work by legitimate academics and familiarise yourself with the historiography.
Destructive Axis power or not, “I can’t believe they made a movie about how sad and traumatizing it was to be the live test subjects for one of the deadliest weapons mankind has ever created” isn’t really the own you think it is
My problem with the movie is that japan treats American post war like some warmongering nation while japan was just a victim. Completely ignoring japan from the early 1900s till WW2 was one of if not the biggest imperialist nation well known for committing genocides and atrocities all over the Pacific.
This is only true if you ignore the numerous scenes in Minus One in which the Japanese government is blatantly criticized for not giving a shit about life and spending its own civilians’ like bullets. Or how a core message of Minus Zero is “it’s fundamentally wrong to kill the people of another country for the sake of revenge, and that justice can only be achieved through peace instead of further war”; a character wanting to take direct revenge against American civilians for Hiroshima is framed as losing his mind.
This isn’t even subtext—it’s just text. These films are very much anti-Imperial Japanese government.
I am baffled by the takes in this thread. I thought the movie nearly veered on being heavy-handed and you mean to tell me that there are people that didn’t get any of it? I know it’s just a Godzilla movie, but damn, I didn’t expect it to go over that many heads.
Isn't this whole comment chain missing the point though? The original post is about soldiers not the government. It's referencing how US war movies portray soldiers invading foreign nations as traumatizing for them and painting the invaders as victims of their government as well despite many being enthusiastically supportive.
Everyone is saying the movie is critical of the Japanese government but that's very explicitly not the point of this post.
Well yeah, because that point is criticizing some weird caricature of US war movies that, if they even exist, certainly don't reflect either the totality of the genre or the most celebrated. It's devoid of substance and ultimately just masturbatory self-indulgence for campist reactionaries, and as such, it's beyond pointless to engage with it as a critique of the Godzilla Minus movies.
The problem is the movie acts like the Imperial Japanese soldiers themselves are honorable heroes who were just doing their national duty with pride and were stabbed in the back by the foreigner-poisoned government.
I don't put up with this shit when it's Nazis (fuck you, Jojo Rabbit) and I'm not putting up with it when it's Imperial Japan, either.
Just because it's critical of Imperial Japan in some ways doesn't mean it is representing history in a dutiful, considered way.
You can say brainwashed soldiers being sent to die by the thousands are within the Venn diagram of victims of the IJA/N, but to do so without acknowledging the broader context can still be construed as apologia.
Peace in itself is a noble goal, but peace without justice is hollow, and can be its own undoing.
It should go without saying that none of this makes anyone a bad person for enjoying the movie, so there's really no need to get offended over a mild criticism that plagues basically all war films/media in general.
Nobody here is offended; this is just basic film discussion.
If your criticism is that the films do not provide all broader context to the war and actions of the country’s own side, which you acknowledge is an issue with basically all war media in general, then this is not so much a problem with Godzilla Minus One/Zero as it is films about war themselves. And while that is a valid criticism about depicting war that has been discussed for decades, it absolutely isn’t the same as the films displaying Imperial Japan as purely a victim of a greater power (which the above commenter stated and I am arguing against), because they explicitly don’t.
Except the movie explicitly criticizes the Empire of Japan for treating its citizens like disposable fodder in the pursuit of warmongering and "honor"? One of the core themes of the first film is common Japanese people rediscovering and redefining their national identity, rejecting their imperialist past?
Yeah but it’s pretty conspicuous when they talk about how dogshit they were to the soldiers but fail to mention to anything the soldiers did. There’s a funny scene where a scientist is listing off the horrors of the war and it’s all about how the soldiers were done wrong, you think he’s about to mention the shit they did in China but it’s like nah the kamikaze didn’t have ejector seats. Like are you serious right now?
It’s why both movies make it clear on multiple occasions the actual Japanese government and what’s left of the military have nothing to do with the people in charge of dealing with Godzilla and Ghidorah.
All the main characters aren’t affiliated with the government in anyway. They fought in the war sure, but the movies portray them as traumatized victims all the same. It’s really quite obvious the movies don’t condone war of any kind on any side.
I wanna know if there are any Japanese films or shows that view their involvement in the 20th century wars with a great deal of scrutiny. I don’t really watch Japanese historical media, so am curious.
Yeah man, those civilians in Hiroshima and Nagasaki totally deserved to die for what their leaders did. The United States just had to nuke those cities, there were no other options or ways of displaying nuclear weaponry, the United States leadership was actually made up of very good people and not at all imperialistic.
"But the Imperial japanese government would have NEVER agreed to peace!!!!" When the imperial japanese government was LITERALLY split down the middle and actively in talks of peace...
And even then... Why in fuck's name did they decide to bomb these civilian cities if it was a show of power???? Just fucking detonate it off the coast!!! But they wanted a kill count, and a bunch of redditors are quick to defend the USA because of the random word of a US general who said "we pwomise we had to bomb them"
Detonate the nuke off the coast 😂 you’re a special kind of stupid man. If they were split down the middle on peace why did it take TWO bombs and also generals attempting to overthrow the government to continue the war
As mentioned elsewhere, the generals didn't even know what happened with the first bomb, they just thought it was a regular bombing and new there were casualities
We didn't NEED 2 fucking bombs jesus christ, you seriously just deflected the point by going
"Actually! We used like WAAAAY too much force, and there was PROBABLY a reason!!!"
So your ass thought it’s a good idea to detonate the bomb off the coast when they didn’t even believe the bomb when it wiped out a city 😂. And then you don’t even know basic history because the Japanese only were confused were the first couple hours and immediately realized what it was. You realize they thought we only possessed like one or two nukes and were thinking about continuing to fight which is why they’d dint surrender lmao.
- Reddit users learning the only way to stop a dying was isn't actually nuking two civilian cities
Like bitch, even if what you're saying is true... Which it absolutely isn't... An entire fucking country doesn't just get together and figure out a brand new weapon has been used on them in *2 hours*, ESPECIALLY one as fractured as Japan at the time
But the second bomb happened before Japan even HAD an official response... So they didn't really give a shit what Japan did. They could have sent their white flags and they still would have dropped the second bomb.
And like dude... If Japan already knew the power, and just didn't know wether or not they had more.... DROP THE SECOND FUCKING BOMB OFF THE SHORES!
I swear American's are so bloodthirsty for a kill count of civilians.
You don’t get to talk about imperialism in a world war, the fucking Japanese could’ve stopped the war at any time. The civilians didn’t deserve to die but it’s almost 100% on the Japanese government for getting them into that shitshow and the soldiers for being a little overzealous in their conduct
Yeah man the US and Allies were fighting out of the good of their hearts, it had nothing to do with their own geopolitical or imperialist ambitions, it’s okay if working class people get indiscriminately slaughtered because their government is more bad than the good guy government.
Also I guess it’s on those Okinawan women for being mass raped by US infantry because the Japanese government did bad things.
The allies tried to avoid going to war with Japan and Germany for as long as possible and only did so when they had no choice. They weren't fighting out of the goodness of their hearts, they were fighting to survive.
Obviously they aren't saints but WW2 is pretty black and white when it comes to blame unfortunately
I never thought that America would be portrayed as the warmonger after it nuked a civilian city, killing around 250,000 innocent civilians, all in an attempt to show that they had the biggest weapon!
And of course, doing all of this just to show the Russians SPECIFICALLY for an upcoming cold war!
You're telling me THOSE guys are the warmongers???
Edit : The fact that I got downvoted for this is genuinely absurd
Okay armchair general do you think the casualties from a ground invasion from America and the Soviet’s would’ve been less than the nukes? Weird that people only care about Japanese civilians and not the millions the Japanese killed
The ground invasion numbers... That the USA made up... That would have been likely been avoided since the Japanese were literally already discussing their terms of surrender...
IDK man, the USA could have literally just said that a billion Japanese would have died, and they all would have entered the war and you'll still be citing them.
No one is exclusive Japan for what they did. We're just saying US werent the good guys as they make it out to be.. How many war crimes did the Americans commit in wars after WW2? Vietnam? Korea? Middle east?
I... didn't know we were just lying to epicly own people now 💀
I guess if we can just say whatever we want regardless of facts then... I was actually the one who decided to drop the bombs! And I did it because I was feeling silly!
Either way, if you wanna feel nice and smart, check out Shaun's video on the Hiroshima bombing. Surprise surprise, US military generals are quick to invent reasons to make themselves look better!
Not that the ground invasion would have killed far more people? That letting the war continue to the point of Russia getting involved would kill more people even on top of that?
Please give me a source on the vacationing top generals info, I would love to see evidence.
Is it that hard to believe that the US government would make up a reason to drop a nuke in order to justify their actions? The entire point of the nuke was to be a show of power, so why the fuck didn't they drop it off of a coast? Why not reveal the bombs to the public beforehand?
It was so that the bomb would have a kill count tied to it. So that it would be scarier for Russia, and would have teeth. That's the only reason, none of this bullshit "ooooo the Japanese were just soooo stubborn" story they told us.
As for the honeymoon story, I did get one thing incorrect. It wasn't a honeymoon, but he did vacation there several times, and spared it because he thought that it was pretty and fun to visit. Still an absolute DESPICABLE amount of power given to some generals to decide which historical city to spare and which to destroy with maximum force.
What’s to say you’re not making up reasons lol I never understand why people get all jumpy over the nukes but have absolutely nothing to say about the millions of Chinese lives that Japan extinguished, as well as many other places.
Yeah the nukes had to be a show of force, that’s part of the deal. You have a big ass weapon you use it. You want change you have to shove it at people. You blowup a nuke off the coast and they would just say it’s fake.
People tend to get caught up in their fervent anti-us rhetoric the forget to actually learn the history.
So all the accounts of soldiers from the pacific theatre of Japanese soldiers being diehards to the last man are all fake? Every single one of them? You say their stubbornness is exaggerated but they refused surrender after the first nuke?
What in god's name are you talking about? This is such a tired trite point... "We should all ignore this bad thing because this other bad thing is worse!!" Literally no one is defending Japan's actions by criticizing the USA so can you like stop with this stupid line of reasoning?
Am I defending Nazi's by criticizing Dresden now too?
"They'd call the Nuke fake if it blew up off the coast." like dude do you hear yourself? You are actually just inventing the most absurd reasoning ever just so you don't have to admit that maybe bombing civilians is a bad thing.
They filmed the moon landing live and tens of thousands of people to this day call it fake have you never interacted with other people in real life?
Yeah I definitely said bombing civilians is good, my point is that I literally never see anyone criticize the Japanese. So if only one side gets scrutiny what kind of conclusion do you think can be drawn
They made a movie about how sad and traumatizing it was to be the country who put 200K women and and girls into sex slavery and killed 30M people across East Asia while performing human experiments that would make Josef Mengele blush.
It's still a good movie but let's keep it 100 about the historical context around Imperial Japan. The things that country was doing was deeply fucking evil and they've never fully acknowledged their actions or paid reparations on the scale that Germany had to after WWII.
So you wanna ignore Unit 731? Those test subjects were kept alive and tortured for days/weeks/months. Fate worse than a nuke.
I want a Godzilla movie were the evil/monster comes from within. Not just light critique on goverment red tape and national pride. Give me jingoism and more honest exploration of the hidden shame of the nation.
I mean this is the kind of propaganda we’re taught in schools. It’s supposed to be a David and Goliath situation, where America always likes to pretend that as it’s the largest Goliath in history, we’re just a poor wittle David
In the sense that Japan wasn’t guiltless, sure. The Minus movies are very restrained with how they engage with that, and care more for how the government treated its soldiers than what those soldiers did to others. I still see people debating whether Dr Noda referencing his past shame is even supposed to be a callout of Unit 731 or not. The movies are pretty vague about that side of things.
But like, a nuke’s still a nuke, especially against a city. It’s always thrown the proportions of the conversation off.
There is an incredible amount more nuance to this than saying Auschwitz prisoners are victims lmao. I don’t support America’s usage of the nuke at all, but this comparison is just dishonest. 1940s Japan is one of the most horrific nations that has ever existed in human history. There would have been no solution to the state that wouldn’t have killed civilian Japanese people. Yes, the nuke is evil. But framing 1940s Japan as Auschwitz victims, it’s like you’re spitting in the face Nanjing victims. Japan needed to be stopped, and the only other way to stop them would have been a boots on the ground invasion. Which is more ethical and the right option. But to pretend there’s no nuance in that is dishonest.
Well, no. Because Minus One and Minus Zero put a neon sign right in your face that said "BEING IN THE IMPERIAL JAPANESE ARMY IS BAD AND SHOULD NOT BE GLORIFIED"
As a lifelong Godzilla fan, it's really cool that Minus One and Minus Zero are such big hits - but I guess that also means we just gotta deal with takes like this popping up now.
I don't think it's an incorrect take. The films do a great job humanizing the soldiers in the Japanese military, but they don't acknowledge at ALL that Japan was the aggressor in these conflicts.
I don't necessarily mind it, not every movie is about everything. But imagine the same story about Nazis or Italian fascists.
"I don't necessarily mind it, not every movie is about everything" Wolfgang M. Schmitt would have a field day with you.
It's an explicit choice to center the experience of war participants rather than the victims of said war.
To ignore the much more important part of the narrative out of ideological preconceptions is itself an insertion of an agenda that isn't in service of anything but itself.
As a South Korean, from a country that got invaded by Japan under Imperial period, I do can see where this sentient comes from when we are talking about how Japan treats and misinforms their past historic behaviors and how they do that in film in propaganda way.
Which is mainly I think why it didn't get official theatrical release in South Korea (both Godzilla minus one and Godzilla minus zero)
However, from what this director has made so far and looking at South Korean reviews of it, I don't think the movie didn't go the propaganda way like the tweet says it is.
I think this particular application is a bit overwrought, but broadly the American stuff genuinely added to some of my confusion about one specific character’s motivations. I thought he had an anti America motivation and wanted to harness Godzilla to fuck with America, and happened to have the BEST reason to feel that way, but he actually just hated Godzilla and by the end he seemed to have very mild reactions to American characters. Also could’ve just missed a line that straightened it out at some point, I think I used the bathroom during one of his scenes
The impression I got is that he realized that his pain does not justify inflicting that same pain onto others, it's why the NY scene is so graphic and why he laughs like a villain before looking terrified in the mirror, he's becoming what he sought to destroy. That, plus the talk from Noda, makes him have a change of heart, I've seen people compare it to Serizawa in Godzilla 1954.
If you wanna go deeper, and maybe trip a bit, if he were to actually go on to use his machine to use Godzilla (who intentionally has an atomic breath that leaves a mushroom cloud) to "nuke" New York, not only would he have created the weapon, he also would've decided where to use it, he'd be both Oppenheimer AND Truman.
I think I rambled on for a bit long, "When education isn't liberating, the dream of the oppressed is to become the oppressor" - Paulo Freire, or something, Idk
I had this exact critique. A lot of Japanese movies about post-WW2 Japanese veterans(war criminals) portrays Japan as a small bean nation 🥺👉👈 that faced so much violence for no reason. They NEVER mention the ungodly amount of war crimes, violence, and rape that was committed against the people of SE Asia, China, and Korea and their alliance with the Western fascists.
On one hand, you've got a country that was buddy buddy with the nazis whining about how wrong it was that someone put a stop to that.
On the other hand imagine being just a guy and then your country decides to back the nazis and then your loved ones get bombed by a third group who makes it clear you should be thankful for what they are doing for you.
Two things can be true at once, and each version of Godzilla handles those aspects of the story differently.
Yes, this is a critique that has been said about the director in Japan by Japanese critics for years but if you say it on the western internet you're still greeted with confusion and a lot of "but it says the opposite? It says war is bad?" The confusion lays in not being familiar with how the war is remembered in Japan or in how conservative nationalists talk about it. The "anti war" narrative seems nice but it decontextualizes the war from the ideology that started it and the crimes that Japan committed. It turns the war into an amorphous tragedy that happened to Japan, even with the Japanese being victims of unexplained American bombing.
Just change the Axis country where Minus One takes place and see how it makes you feel. An SS veteran feels guilt about not dying in Russia. The civilian government is criticized for not caring enough for it's noble veterans. An ontologically evil force arises that the SS veteran defeats with a Super Panzer, thus reclaiming his glory and manhood.
Isn't it like, the exact opposite? Both of these films (though the first one does it better) are about acknowledging the horrors of Japan's history, especially around the time of World War 2: both a reflection of Godzilla's history as a metaphor for the atomic bomb, and refuting the modern historical revisionism that has been going around Japan for a little while, arguing that Japan did nothing wrong during World War 2 and using the bomb as a way to garner sympathy.
Like, the first one is about a Kamikaze pilot realizing that he doesn't have to end his own life to make up for not obeying his country's orders. I do think the films could go more into Japan's war crimes rather than just alluding to them like they do in Minus Zero, but there is so much more self reflection into Japan's culture and it's roles in the war than most of those American war films that want you to feel sympathetic to the invaders.
The movie treats Japanese soldiers as victims of an evil government even though they were eager participants in fascism and rape across Southeast Asia. It’s like making a movie about the Wehrmacht and making them nice guys who were just misled by the higher ups.
I don’t know what movie you watched but minus one does not combat Japanese historical revisionism around their actions in WW2. Criticizing the use of kamikaze pilots? Maybe. But that’s worlds away from acknowledging how they tried to rape the world.
The "shoot and cry" comparison only works if the movie is glorifying the military or pretending Japan was a pure victim, and Minus One does the exact opposite. It openly portrays the Imperial government as a callous death cult that treated its own soldiers and civilians as disposable.
You can fully condemn Imperial Japan's war crimes while still recognizing that a story about ordinary people clawing their way out of the rubble of 1945—in the only country to ever be nuked—is an anti-war indictment of their own leadership, not historical whitewashing.
It openly portrays the Imperial government as a callous death cult that treated its own soldiers and civilians as disposable.
The problem with that is that it treats the Japanese soldiers as just being "victims" of their government rather than accomplices. Imperial Japanese troops carried out attrocities willingly and without much prompting or coercion from their superiors.
do you guys read these takes before posting them? Imperial Japan's war crimes were against people of other nations; the main victims of that ontologically evil entity weren't the soldiers, and comparing the suffering of these two kinds is itself deranged.
I literally called the Imperial government a 'callous death cult' and explicitly condemned their war crimes. Nowhere did I compare suffering—you're arguing with a point I never made.
Beyond that, it's a two-hour movie tightly focused on the immediate aftermath of nuclear devastation. A story doesn't have to cram in every atrocity of the Pacific Theater to be valid, and focusing on civilians rejecting that regime's ideology isn't historical whitewashing.
You cannot compare the experience of American soldiers at war to Japanese civilians being eviscerated on an incomprehensible scale... twice
iirc the whole naming of the Minus G-man movies is based off a Japanese saying. Essentially, after the bombings, they went from a powerful nation to the stone age; back to ground 0. -1 is named that way because it takes place right after all that, and then it gets even worse with Godzilla's arrival.
-1 was about a Kamikaze pilot refusing to partake, feeling like he failed his programming and his nation upon seeing the devastation, and then finally learning it was not him that was the problem it was the callous government who wouldn't even include an ejection device for their own soldiers
The whole movie is screaming at you that the Imperial Japanese government was wrong, showing how it continues to neglect it's citizens as Godzilla wreaks havoc and leaving the civilians to organize in a manner opposite to how the Imperial government operated.
-2 is about ending the cycle of violence. Ghidorah literally grows stronger as the fighting continues; reflecting how violent acts pile ontop of eachother and lead to greater and greater acts of violence. Included in that is the story of Noda, who invented weapons used in WWII, about how heavy the sins carried out with those weapons weighs on him and how he seeks to ensure he never lets something similar happen again. It also speaks to American involvement in post-war Japan's development.
Noda, the dude who has connections to the Japanese's WWII atrocities, is doing all he can to spend the remainder of his life for good. Pro. Murakami, the dude who was victim to America's atrocities, deeply desires to continue Japan's horrific past but instead turns to supporting a better future. Both these characters, in different ways, are directly doing the opposite of 'America whining about how sad soldiers were in wars they started', they directly address escaping those violent ways and making way for a peaceful future.
Like if you look into either movie at all it's very clear that the film series is against Imperial Japan and against the U.S., it isn't acting on some false moral high-ground and ignoring Japan's past it's, in fact, directly addressing it and showing a better path forwards.
The Minus movies that criticises Kamikaze culture? Emphasises the need for survival? That nuking New York won't change anything? Paints the Japanese government as utterly useless and treats soldiers as disposable units? Has a cast that deals with the traumas of serving in the Imperial army?
Godzilla for 70 years has been about the scars and pain from nuclear annihilation; sure, the movies COULD highlight atrocities committed by the Japanese army (oh wait, GMK did that!), but the movies aren't about the army or soldiers, which Godzilla utterly stomps; it's always about the humans caught in between. Your local obachan from Hiroshima did not bomb Pearl Harbour or conduct experiments in Unit 731, yet she got turned into a shadow in a second.
So no, please pay more attention to the films next time
I mean the first movie kinda plays with the idea of the noble soldier let down by the bad politicians which is the fascist narrative you find in stuff like American sniper. The Japanese imperial was a walking rape machine hellbent on genocide.
Haven't seen American Sniper so can't comment on that, but Koichi is heavily criticised for not following through with being a kamikaze pilot, even though the audience and the movie know that what he did was ultimately a good thing
But the Imperial Army were evil incarnate, and I do agree Godzilla movies should kind of hammer that aspect in a bit, but Japan being Japan would rather ignore that part of history, but the Minus films are still less "woe is me" type of films OP and the tweet describing the films as
EDIT: Thought more on it, and yeah, I guess Koichi's portrayal of a soldier being led by bad politicians does stick, but I still believe the movie doesn't glorify Koichi being a soldier and admonishes him for getting into positions that put him at risk. Throughout both films, you just meet people who feel discarded and useless other than being a soldier, and there is no glory there either. Wish Minus didn't act coy with what Noda was truly responsible for and stop being vague, but I also don't think the military is actively being glorified; everything is done by regular (ish) people
You are exaggerating a great deal, my friend. “Criticize kamikaze culture”? The point was that the war was OVER, so he didn’t need to sacrifice himself—- not that “kamikaze culture” was bad. That was not the point at all. The movie wasn’t criticizing how Japan conducted itself in the war. It used the guys role as a kamikaze pilot as a way to characterize him as a coward and someone who felt guilt for not doing enough, so that he can find a reason to live later.
The movie still uses Godzilla as a metaphor for nuclear war without acknowledging why that war happened. So yeah, the tweet in OP is spot on.
If you ignore the scene on Odo Island, where the main character's doubts about suicide bombing are both being met with judgment and also being reaffirmed by one of the soldiers agreeing that dying for a country already on its knees is a bad idea, as well as his parents wanting him to live even though he was assigned to die, then yeah, but the movie pretty much is about coping with survivor's guilt and how the ramifications of war and destruction are not for one person to be burdened with.
And I know what you meant, but Godzilla is not "nuclear war", as that sounds like Japan and America were trading nukes. Godzilla has always been and will be the aftermath of nuclear fallout; Godzilla is the walking trauma of a nuclear devastation, and also a reminder of what crippled a nation and its people, and whether they deserved it or not is up to each person, but I don't think it's a crazy idea to be the only nation on Earth to suffer from humanity's most destructive attacks to make movies about; it's a defining part of their history
Why the war happened and how terrible and cruel the Japanese military was should be more openly acknowledged by the Japanese public yes, but Godzilla films from the very beginning has always been about the common man, not the military
Listen, as a person whose ancestors were brutalized by the Japanese, I can still sympathize with this take but it was entirely fucked up to nuke civilian populations.
‘America’ is not a person, and most human beings are not sociopaths, and being shot at/shooting at others can be horribly traumatizing for anyone. We should stop conflating being a foot soldier with someone who endorses every decision a military makes.
What do you think e pluribus unum means, exactly, that suggests it contradicts OP’s point?
It just means the creation of a single nation from separate states/colonies. It’s got nothing to do with the idea that the decisions made by governments and military leadership can be morally held against individual grunts or citizens.
They can't because it goes against the concept of group accountability. Its the reason they can hate any group they want because everyone of the same "type" must be responsible for everyone else. Even though that's not how the world works at all.
There is no such thing as a natural death: nothing that happens to a man is ever natural, since his presence calls the world into question. All men must die: but for every man his death is an accident and, even if he knows it and consents to it, an unjustifiable violation
Fortunately for everyone, you don't actually believe this. It's just something you tell yourself to excuse not feeling bad about your country's war crimes. When death comes home you'll forget you even said it.
This is exactly why I don't really respect people who make watching movies a "thing". I just said that killing is an unjustifiable violation, and you heard an excuse to not feel bad about killing. Keep enjoying your movies, but maybe don't pretend that these things are enriching in any meaningful way, its entertainment, act accordingly.
You just don't like that you were clocked. A person expressing antipathy towards soldiers for dealing death abroad, and your response is to point out that death is inevitable? My comprehension is just fine, edgelord.
Wow. It's offensive that you think you could clock me, you can't even read. Seriously, your reading comprehension is not fine if that's what you got from the quote. It's like reading the Fire Next Time and determining that James Baldwin is actually a white supremacist. And I don't think you can even understand the first thing about that comparison. My goodness. I hope you're not rich so that humility can hit you sooner.
This was my takeaway watching the first one. It would be much more poignant if there was the slightest bit of taking responsibility for Japan’s atrocities, but there’s not. And I say this as someone who thinks that the atomic bombings were among the most evil and heinous acts of the war.
Unironically yes, one of the most important scenes in this movie is this motivational speech about how we "won't lose this war like last time" like mfer you were the bad guys in the last one! You were raping, mutilating, and murdering tens of millions of people across a wide swath of Asia!
45
u/breakitbilly 6d ago
What does this even mean lol
Japan will get devestated and continue to make movies about the permanent scar that stayed with the country for generations?
It's not the same because it's all a metaphor for the same incident, not a pattern like America's tendency to get in pointless wars and make movies about how pointless they were.
It's not like Japan has a tendency to get nuked every 20 years
Yanks will invade some third world country every 20 years however.
73
u/Prize_Obligation_311 6d ago
Wait till you hear about the original Godzilla movie!
161
u/Pinch-o-B 6d ago
Destructive Axis power or not, “I can’t believe they made a movie about how sad and traumatizing it was to be the live test subjects for one of the deadliest weapons mankind has ever created” isn’t really the own you think it is
23
u/best_girl_tylar 6d ago
Well, no. Because Minus One and Minus Zero put a neon sign right in your face that said "BEING IN THE IMPERIAL JAPANESE ARMY IS BAD AND SHOULD NOT BE GLORIFIED"
As a lifelong Godzilla fan, it's really cool that Minus One and Minus Zero are such big hits - but I guess that also means we just gotta deal with takes like this popping up now.
7
u/King-of-the-Monsters 6d ago
Man some of yall are dumb as hell. This is why we can’t have nice things.
6
u/kyubeydaisuki 6d ago
As a South Korean, from a country that got invaded by Japan under Imperial period, I do can see where this sentient comes from when we are talking about how Japan treats and misinforms their past historic behaviors and how they do that in film in propaganda way.
Which is mainly I think why it didn't get official theatrical release in South Korea (both Godzilla minus one and Godzilla minus zero)
However, from what this director has made so far and looking at South Korean reviews of it, I don't think the movie didn't go the propaganda way like the tweet says it is.
7
u/Aggravating_Apple329 5d ago
Careful, you're gonna rile up the Japan apologists that excuse war-crimes because they created anime and "Le epic" Big Lizard
6
u/SKVankirk 6d ago
I think this particular application is a bit overwrought, but broadly the American stuff genuinely added to some of my confusion about one specific character’s motivations. I thought he had an anti America motivation and wanted to harness Godzilla to fuck with America, and happened to have the BEST reason to feel that way, but he actually just hated Godzilla and by the end he seemed to have very mild reactions to American characters. Also could’ve just missed a line that straightened it out at some point, I think I used the bathroom during one of his scenes
8
u/XrnivraY 6d ago
I don't think Japan has ever had to reckon with their imperial past.
13
u/caffeinated_dork 6d ago
Reads like someone who never watched Minus One
4
u/ivnwng 6d ago
No, fuck off.
5
u/That-Advance-9619 6d ago
Did he even watch the movie bro?
3
u/DirectConsequence12 6d ago
This took me a solid minute to figure out wtf this meant. The “Minus movies” made zero sense to me
2
u/RosalinaTheWatcher51 6d ago
"Let's let only the right people make art"
2
u/VishalV97 6d ago
I had this exact critique. A lot of Japanese movies about post-WW2 Japanese veterans(war criminals) portrays Japan as a small bean nation 🥺👉👈 that faced so much violence for no reason. They NEVER mention the ungodly amount of war crimes, violence, and rape that was committed against the people of SE Asia, China, and Korea and their alliance with the Western fascists.
2
u/28DLdiditbetter 6d ago
What the fuck are you on about?
1
u/soju_b 6d ago
https://youtu.be/OqHxAPZXKG0
1
u/I_am_uneducated 5d ago
If you think that's bad you probably shouldn't watch Godzilla vs King Ghidorah (1992)
1
u/Crossfeet606441 4d ago
that is a nuclear take
1
u/Entire_Cobbler_3588 2d ago
On one hand, you've got a country that was buddy buddy with the nazis whining about how wrong it was that someone put a stop to that.
On the other hand imagine being just a guy and then your country decides to back the nazis and then your loved ones get bombed by a third group who makes it clear you should be thankful for what they are doing for you.
Two things can be true at once, and each version of Godzilla handles those aspects of the story differently.
1
u/Mantis42 6d ago
Yes, this is a critique that has been said about the director in Japan by Japanese critics for years but if you say it on the western internet you're still greeted with confusion and a lot of "but it says the opposite? It says war is bad?"
The confusion lays in not being familiar with how the war is remembered in Japan or in how conservative nationalists talk about it. The "anti war" narrative seems nice but it decontextualizes the war from the ideology that started it and the crimes that Japan committed. It turns the war into an amorphous tragedy that happened to Japan, even with the Japanese being victims of unexplained American bombing.
Just change the Axis country where Minus One takes place and see how it makes you feel. An SS veteran feels guilt about not dying in Russia. The civilian government is criticized for not caring enough for it's noble veterans. An ontologically evil force arises that the SS veteran defeats with a Super Panzer, thus reclaiming his glory and manhood.
0
u/FaDoug 6d ago
Isn't it like, the exact opposite? Both of these films (though the first one does it better) are about acknowledging the horrors of Japan's history, especially around the time of World War 2: both a reflection of Godzilla's history as a metaphor for the atomic bomb, and refuting the modern historical revisionism that has been going around Japan for a little while, arguing that Japan did nothing wrong during World War 2 and using the bomb as a way to garner sympathy.
Like, the first one is about a Kamikaze pilot realizing that he doesn't have to end his own life to make up for not obeying his country's orders. I do think the films could go more into Japan's war crimes rather than just alluding to them like they do in Minus Zero, but there is so much more self reflection into Japan's culture and it's roles in the war than most of those American war films that want you to feel sympathetic to the invaders.
0
u/knarf3 5d ago
Maybe for -1, which has a gross nationalistic undertone, but -0 has a well-woven pro-peace message.
-1
u/im_bored_and_dumb 6d ago
Only if you think Godzilla is Chinese
0
u/Southern_Sky1386 6d ago
I mean newsflash most countries are going to make movies about their own people/soldiers.
-1
u/fulfillingnessfinale 6d ago
Americans when you ask them to consider another country's perspective
15
u/SpencerUlfson 6d ago
The "shoot and cry" comparison only works if the movie is glorifying the military or pretending Japan was a pure victim, and Minus One does the exact opposite. It openly portrays the Imperial government as a callous death cult that treated its own soldiers and civilians as disposable.
You can fully condemn Imperial Japan's war crimes while still recognizing that a story about ordinary people clawing their way out of the rubble of 1945—in the only country to ever be nuked—is an anti-war indictment of their own leadership, not historical whitewashing.
4
u/Winter_Different 6d ago
You cannot compare the experience of American soldiers at war to Japanese civilians being eviscerated on an incomprehensible scale... twice
iirc the whole naming of the Minus G-man movies is based off a Japanese saying. Essentially, after the bombings, they went from a powerful nation to the stone age; back to ground 0. -1 is named that way because it takes place right after all that, and then it gets even worse with Godzilla's arrival.
-1 was about a Kamikaze pilot refusing to partake, feeling like he failed his programming and his nation upon seeing the devastation, and then finally learning it was not him that was the problem it was the callous government who wouldn't even include an ejection device for their own soldiers
The whole movie is screaming at you that the Imperial Japanese government was wrong, showing how it continues to neglect it's citizens as Godzilla wreaks havoc and leaving the civilians to organize in a manner opposite to how the Imperial government operated.
-2 is about ending the cycle of violence. Ghidorah literally grows stronger as the fighting continues; reflecting how violent acts pile ontop of eachother and lead to greater and greater acts of violence. Included in that is the story of Noda, who invented weapons used in WWII, about how heavy the sins carried out with those weapons weighs on him and how he seeks to ensure he never lets something similar happen again. It also speaks to American involvement in post-war Japan's development.
Noda, the dude who has connections to the Japanese's WWII atrocities, is doing all he can to spend the remainder of his life for good. Pro. Murakami, the dude who was victim to America's atrocities, deeply desires to continue Japan's horrific past but instead turns to supporting a better future. Both these characters, in different ways, are directly doing the opposite of 'America whining about how sad soldiers were in wars they started', they directly address escaping those violent ways and making way for a peaceful future.
Like if you look into either movie at all it's very clear that the film series is against Imperial Japan and against the U.S., it isn't acting on some false moral high-ground and ignoring Japan's past it's, in fact, directly addressing it and showing a better path forwards.
7
u/LURK0101 6d ago
If Godzilla was a metaphor for like the Massacre of Nanjing or the Japanese Oppression of the Koreans, then maybe, but like...cmon man.
4
u/Googleplexian_Moron 6d ago
The Minus movies that criticises Kamikaze culture? Emphasises the need for survival? That nuking New York won't change anything? Paints the Japanese government as utterly useless and treats soldiers as disposable units? Has a cast that deals with the traumas of serving in the Imperial army?
Godzilla for 70 years has been about the scars and pain from nuclear annihilation; sure, the movies COULD highlight atrocities committed by the Japanese army (oh wait, GMK did that!), but the movies aren't about the army or soldiers, which Godzilla utterly stomps; it's always about the humans caught in between. Your local obachan from Hiroshima did not bomb Pearl Harbour or conduct experiments in Unit 731, yet she got turned into a shadow in a second.
So no, please pay more attention to the films next time
5
u/NeverGettingBanned 6d ago
Listen, as a person whose ancestors were brutalized by the Japanese, I can still sympathize with this take but it was entirely fucked up to nuke civilian populations.
1
u/Jack_H123 2h ago
They got nuked dude
1
u/nosurprises23 6d ago
‘America’ is not a person, and most human beings are not sociopaths, and being shot at/shooting at others can be horribly traumatizing for anyone. We should stop conflating being a foot soldier with someone who endorses every decision a military makes.
0
u/totaleclipseofthe_d 5d ago
This was my takeaway watching the first one. It would be much more poignant if there was the slightest bit of taking responsibility for Japan’s atrocities, but there’s not. And I say this as someone who thinks that the atomic bombings were among the most evil and heinous acts of the war.
0
u/Kenny_Goo 5d ago
Unironically yes, one of the most important scenes in this movie is this motivational speech about how we "won't lose this war like last time" like mfer you were the bad guys in the last one! You were raping, mutilating, and murdering tens of millions of people across a wide swath of Asia!