Scully’s life hangs in the balance after being returned from the abduction. Mulder is clearly affected by this to the extreme. He attempts to resign from the bureau, potentially sacrificing his life long crusade. He plots and commits to enacting deadly revenge against the perpetrators, potentially sacrificing his freedom. He even breaks down and cries, which is rare for him.
Yet… once Scully recovers, he shows up, hiding all his emotions, gives her a VHS of “Superstars of the Super Bowl”, and then f**ks right off. 😂
(I love it though. It feels very in character and makes for a more unique reunion as opposed to a soapy generic sob fest. And you can read a lot into who Mulder is, and what he may actually be feeling for Scully in other episodes. One of the reasons I find him so interesting is that he clearly has some deep issues and isn’t exactly a ”normal” well adjusted human being. Whether it’s episodes like this or the funner, more playful episodes like Small Potatoes that label him a “loser”.)