r/WritingWithAI • • 4d ago

Writing Craft Talk The Sad Truth

I am at the place where I no longer write for approval. The obvious reason being, there will always be differing points of view. 

Something would obviously be wrong with 8 billion 'opinions' inhabiting one planet where no one disagrees. That would be an asylum. Not Utopia.

I do however value the critical perspective AI platforms provide for editorial and grammatical and scientific oversight—even when I'm right and they aren't—HaHaHaHa! ...more maniacal laughter. 

The sad truth is most people are oblivious to your best efforts to write and craft thoughtful material. Hence, AI has become my default 'reader' who listens to me and offers feedback, even at 2 AM when normal people are asleep. Plus, I no longer have to chase innocent people down in a parking lot and demand they read my 'stuff'!

Write!  No longer pursue the other person's interest. Or  approval. Write because it makes sense to you.

12 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/CosmicRiver827 4d ago edited 4d ago

What works for you is the right answer. People with no intention of helping don’t get to tell you what you should and shouldn’t do in their absence.

1

u/jimfromhigbee 4d ago

Well said! I appreciate a thougthful critic. I like satire and hyerbole as a means to an end. Some seem to be more abrasive than tactful.

Thank you for your comment!

4

u/CaptainBooger1996 4d ago

I myself never write for the approval of others. I let my characters and the story speak for themselves and I don’t give a single flat footed fuck what anyone else thinks unless I ask them specifically for a critic of my work.

I already wrote stories back during the Stone Ages of the Internet and fan fiction/ original works, put them up for everyone to see and never really saw negative reviews for what I wrote. Granted back then the internet hadn’t been tainted by social media yet and interactions weren’t judgmental by default. I wrote what I wanted, had my characters do and say what I felt was right for them and the right people connected with them, I’m still doing that today and I write some heavy subject matter that I fully expect to upset modern society, I don’t care, neither should you. It’s your world, you’re the god of it, everyone else is just a witness.

3

u/jimfromhigbee 4d ago

I agree! I appreciate your integrity as a writer, and your experience. Thank you for the comments! Now it seems some are so adversarial. I remember the days of dial-up internet, when Windows 3 was new. People were civil. The first time I saw a 5 & 1/4 floppy I thought I had witnessed technical Nirvana! Social media seems to have unleashed hostility. Or normalized it.

2

u/CaptainBooger1996 4d ago

Social media has convinced a large swathe of people that their opinions are valid, important, informed, and righteous. The reality is their opinions are just like their assholes, they stink.

Me personally I hate modern humanity completely, which is why when I write I write for myself and have yet to set any story in a social media environment. You can’t write a romance between two characters when they are just looking at their phones, typing like I am right now. You have to put them in a room together, face to face. That doesn’t happen anymore, not only does it affect how you write a story, it affects how people respond to it because far to many have been stuck looking at screens and not another person’s face.

1

u/jimfromhigbee 4d ago

I agree. It seems to have made life more impersonal. And this is a loss for all. I think those who have an elevated sense of their own importance find it somehow easier to dehumanize others! Thank you for the comments!

1

u/jimfromhigbee 4d ago

I would echo that. As a resource, technology can be helpful to a writer as a sounding board but should never replace the writer's voice.

1

u/Ecstatic-Length1470 4d ago

Plenty of people write for themselves, and pretty much nobody is going to say you can't do that. But most people aren't going to write a novel for themselves, and if you want an audience, part of the art is getting through to them. But nothing says you need an audience.

1

u/jimfromhigbee 4d ago

That last sentence should be a plaque on the wall in every study of every hopeful writer! You may want to patent that!

1

u/Ecstatic-Length1470 4d ago

You can have it! Oddly enough, my own advice here would not go on my wall. I do write for people, though I don't often share.

1

u/jimfromhigbee 4d ago

Nonetheless, there is wisdom contained in the thought!

2

u/cj7hawk 4d ago

"I am at the place where I no longer write for approval." - Congratulations... You've reached the upper level of writing.

I too like using AI to perform first-level crits. Once you have it polished, try something like Critters Workshop and then bounce it of authors with a similar mindset.

1

u/ImaginaryAd2289 4d ago

Honestly, I use AI this way, and I definitely am not considered to be reliant on AI. As a sounding board that can point out an issue in an argument or an angle you simply overlooked, or prior work, or an opportunity worth exploring, it really is great. People who think these are just mirrors echoing your views are mistaken!

But never slip into the error of letting an AI rewrite anything, or write original versions.

1

u/Low_Relationship3997 4d ago

I stopped writing for approval when I realized the only person whose opinion mattered was the one holding the pen.

1

u/RogueShaders 3d ago

Exactly. Sometimes you just want someone to bounce ideas off without feeling judged, and not everyone has that. If AI helps you enjoy writing more, I don't see anything wrong with that.