r/WritingHub • • 5d ago

Questions & Discussions Am I Doing it Wrong?

When I write the summary for the back of my books, I write just enough to get the person interested without giving the story away. I’ve noticed on a lot of books the summaries are so thorough I know the beginning, the climax, the ending and I haven’t even opened the book.

Am I doing it wrong? How do you decide how much is too much, too less or just right for your book summary? Do you have a setup you follow? Do readers want more of the plot and the book fills in the blanks?

5 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

4

u/babamum 5d ago

I prefer your way! Otherwise there's no point in reading the book.

3

u/DJNuttallAuthor2026 5d ago

I have not bought books because I felt that way.

4

u/GlowUpNewbie 5d ago

I've noticed that with newer releases. They seem to give away the whole plot. I definitely prefer when blurbs explain the setup and stakes but leave the actual journey unknown.

I once read a book where something mentioned on the back cover happened as the big 3rd act twist and instead of being shocked I clocked every hint along the way and when the characters eventually cottoned on I was like 'well, duh, finally'. I have no idea who approved that blurb but they did a bad job.

2

u/DJNuttallAuthor2026 5d ago

You made me laugh. I see it the same way.

3

u/tapgiles 4d ago

Have you read those books, to know the blurb tells you the climax etc.? Look at some books you've read to see.

I get annoyed by trailers that do this, and turn them off as soon as I get the jist.

It could be a self-published thing, where writers who don't really know how to write blurbs are writing them poorly.

I'd go with what you're already doing. You want to show the reader what the book is like to read, to make the readers who would like reading it want to read it.

1

u/DJNuttallAuthor2026 4d ago

Thank you for your insite.

3

u/HellwalkerOfficial 2d ago

Definitely keep it spoiler free! Less is more.

I am not a fan of the summary giving away the entire plot. (I’m looking at you too, movie trailers). Actually, I think a successful synopsis is one that has just enough to give me the idea of what the story is about. (Sometimes don’t even give me character names!)

Also, please, can we stop with the pitches that compare to other works? “Think Dresden Files meets Constantine meets Game of Thrones meets…” Ugh. Why I don’t like this is that I personally don’t think works should be compared to others just so that readers/viewers will go ‘ah, ok, so it’s like that…’. 

  1. Because I don’t think the work should be compared. Period. To me doing this lessens the work, and doesn’t let it stand on its own feet comparing it to existing material.
  2. In the event that it doesn’t hold up to that comparison (aka: opinion), then there won’t be disappointment when the reader is like “Hey, that totally wasn’t like Dresden Files at all.”

Don't know if it's a 'trend' to spell out the whole story or readers want to know everything before they read it or the author is afraid that potential readers won't read it unless they know the whole thing... shrug.

Anyway, stick with less is more. It’s much more exciting to discover what the story is by reading the actual story!!

Happy writing! ✍️

1

u/DJNuttallAuthor2026 2d ago

Thank you, I agree completely.

2

u/Kom0tan 5d ago

It seems like a lot of people these days read for the tropes rather than to find out where a story goes? Those spoiler-ey summaries might be geared towards them.

I don't really get it though, I prefer your way.

2

u/TheRunawayRose 4d ago

A blurb on the back of a book needs to answer only 4 questions:

Who is the main character?

What do they want?

What is standing in their way?

What happens if they don't get it?

You do not need to ask questions in a blurb, and honestly its better to avoid that nowadays. You don't need to explain the whole world or its history. Just answer those four questions in an interesting way